Some Descendants of Rev. Leonard Metcalf

Some Descendants of Rev. Leonard Metcalf

25 Feb. 2009

Seventh Generation

1. ⁷Thomas Metcalf, son of Sgt. Samuel Metcalf (son of Ebenezer Metcalf and Margaret Rockwood) and Hannah Richardson (dau. of Thomas Richardson and Jane Downing). Born on 9 Aug. 1764 in Oakham, Worcester County, Massachusetts. Baptized on 26 Aug. 1764 in Rutland, Worcester County, Massachusetts when 17 days old. Died on 16 March 1827 in Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, 62 years old. Buried in Chardon.

Married Sybil Chapin, dau. of Ens. Nathaniel Chapin (son of Nathaniel Chapin and Sarah Abbey) and Sybil Terry (dau. of Maj. Ephraim Terry and Ann Collins), on 26 Nov. 1788 in Enfield, Hartford County, Connecticut when 24 years old (Sybil was 19 years old). Sybil Chapin b. on 6 Dec. 1768 in Enfield; d. on 6 March 1859 in Chardon, 90 years old.

Issue of Thomas Metcalf and Sybil Chapin:
2   i. dau. ⁸Sybil Metcalf b. on 19 July 1789 in Enfield.
3   ii. son Maj. Horace Metcalf b. on 23 March 1791 in Enfield.
      iii. son Samuel Metcalf b. on 16 Jan. 1793 in Enfield.
      iv. dau. Elizabeth Metcalf b. on 27 Jan. 1795 in Enfield; d. on 9 Feb. 1795 in Enfield, 13 days old.
4   v. dau. Elizabeth Metcalf b. on 1 Jan. 1796 in Enfield.
5   vi. son Thomas Metcalf b. on 10 Jan. 1798 in Enfield.
6   vii. son Dr. Asa Baldwin Metcalfe b. on 9 March 1800 near Oakland, on Connecticut-Vermont road, Franklin County, Vermont.
7   viii. son Ebenezer Metcalf b. on 27 Dec. 1801 in Enfield.
8   ix. dau. Sidney Metcalf b. on 16 March 1804 in Enfield.
9   x. dau. Harriet Metcalf b. on 23 Feb. 1806 in Enfield.
10   xi. son George A. Metcalf b. on 26 Feb. 1808 in Enfield.
11   xii. son Oren Metcalfe b. on 28 Jan. 1810 in Enfield.

Notes on Thomas Metcalf:

“Metcalf, Thomas, s. Samuel and _____, Aug. 9, 17__.”¹

“Metcalf, Thomas, s. Samuel, Aug. 26, 1764, bap. C. R.”²

“1788 . . . Novr 26th were joined together in marriage Mr Thomas Metcalf and Miss Sybil Chapin.”³

“Thomas Metcalf and Sibbyl Chapin were joined in marriage together Novr 26th 1788.”⁴

See also Ricker, 8734.²

“1832 March 4, Capt. Ebenr Metcalf’s wife aged 24.”³

_______________
¹ Transcript from Francis Olcott Allen, editor, The History of Enfield, Connecticut, Vol. III (Lancaster, Pennsylvania: The Wickersham Printing Co., 1900), 1429.
² Jacquelyn Ladd Ricker, The Ricker Compilation of Vital Records of Early Connecticut (Baltimore: Genealogical Publishing Company, 2006).
³ Francis Olcott Allen, editor, The History of Enfield, Connecticut, Vol. III (Lancaster, Pennsylvania: The Wickersham Printing Co., 1900), 2627. This may not be the wife of this Ebenezer, being a month and a day different in dates of death, and no other mention has yet been found of this Ebenezer being a Captain.

Notes on Louisa Chapin:

Louisa was enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, in the household of her daughter Catharine s follows:¹

Catharine Pomeroy, head of household, white, femlae, born July 1846, 53, widow, one child, one living, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born Connecticut, reads, writes, speaks English, owns home free of mortgage.
Louis S. Pomeroy, son, white, male, born June 1873, 26, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, printer, reads, writes, speaks English.
Norman C. Pomeroy, stepson, white, male, born June 1866, 34, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, night watchman, reads, writes, speaks English.
Lovisa Metcalf, mother, white, female, born May 1814, 86, widow, seven children, three living, born Connecticut, father born Connecticut, mother born Connecticut, reads, writes, speaks English.

_______________
¹ Catharine Pomeroy household, 1900 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Village, enumeration district 44, supervisor’s district 18, sheet 11A, line 26, dwelling 278, family 289; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 1271.

8. ⁸Sidney Metcalf, dau. of ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1] and Sybil Chapin. Born on 16 March 1804 in Enfield, Hartford County, Connecticut. Died on 9 Feb. 1875 in Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, 70 years old.

Married first Dr. Evert Denton, son of Aaron Denton (son of Solomon Denton and Lydia Husted) and Mary Elizabeth Avery, on 14 Aug. 1824 when 20 years old (Dr. Evert was 35 years old). Dr. Evert Denton b. on 14 Feb. 1789 in Huntsburg, Geauga County, Ohio; d. in 1830, 40 or 41 years old.

Issue of Sidney Metcalf and Dr. Evert Denton:
30 i. son ⁹Richard Evert Denton b. on 10 Sep. 1826 in Huntsburg.
ii. dau. Sybil Evert Denton b. in 1828/9 in Ohio.

Married second Jude Converse, son of Joseph Converse (son of Lt. Joseph Converse and Eleanor Richardson) and Mary Johnson (dau. of Seth Johnson and Mary Edson), on 8 Nov. 1832 when 28 years old (Jude was 27 years old). Jude Converse b. on 21 July 1805 in Randolph, Orange County, Vermont; d. on 4 Feb. 1874, 68 years old.

Issue of Sidney Metcalf and Jude Converse:
31 iii. son ⁹Julius Orrin Converse b. on 1 May 1834 in Chardon.
iv. dau. Mary E. Converse b. in 1847/8 in Chardon.

Notes on Sidney Metcalf:

Chapin¹ said Sidney, daughter of Thomas and Sibyl (Chapin) Metcalf, was born on 16 March 1804 in Enfield, Connecticut. She married first Dr. Evert Denton on 14 August 1824 and they had four [sic, two] children. She married second Jude Converse and they had two children. She died in Chardon, Ohio.

Sydney and her family were enumerated in the 1840 federal census of Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:²

Jude Converse, 1 male 5 and under 10 (Julius Converse), 1 male 10 and under 14 (Richard Denton), 1 male 20 and under 30 (unknown), 1 male 30 and under 40 (Jude), 1 female 10 and under 15 (Sybil Denton), 1 female 30 and under 40 (Sydney).

Sidney and her family were enumerated in the 1850 federal census of Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:³

Jude Converse, 43, male, clerk, born Vermont.
Sidney Converse, 45, female, real property $800, born Connecticut.
R. E. Denton, 23, male, tinner, born Ohio.
Sybil E. Denton, 21, female, born Ohio.
Julius O. Converse, 16, male, printer, born Ohio.
Mary E. Converse, 2, female, born Ohio.

Sidney and her family were enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:⁴

Jude Converse, 64, male, white, retired merchant, born Vermont.
Sidney Converse, 66, female, white, keeping house, born Connecticut.
Julius O. Converse, 36, male, white, editor, real property $4000, personal property $1600, born Ohio.
Julia P. Converse, 35, female, white, born Ohio.
Mary E. Converse, 6, female, white, born Ohio.

Some dates about Sidney, Jude and their descendants are given in OneWorldTree.

_______________
¹ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. I: First Seven Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 804.
² Jude Converse household, 1840 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, Chardon, sheet 164, line 18; National Archives micropublication M704, roll 395.
³ Jude Converse household, 1850 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Township, sheet 234, line 2, dwelling 10, family 11; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 682.
⁴ Jude Converse household, 1870 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Village, page 9, sheet 86, line 29, dwelling 59, family 69; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 1204.

Notes on Dr. Evert Denton:

A history of Geauga County tells of Evert:¹

Dr. Evert Denton, a learned and skillful physician, famous throughout this section of the county, who wore himself out in his practice, and died in 1830, when but forty years of age . . .

_______________
¹ Historical Society of Geauga County, Pioneer and General History of Geauga County, with Sketches of Some of the Pioneers and Prominent Men, 1798–1880 (no place: Historical Society of Geauga County, 1880), 312.

Notes on Jude Converse:

A history of Geauga County tells of Jude:¹

In the olden of Chardon times, just west of the Chardon house, which was built in the earliest of Geauga years, by Norman Canfield, and is still the solid heart and center of the present flourishing hotel of Benton & Co., on the left of Water street, back of its little lawn, was the pleasant cottage of Jude and Sidney Converse. The lawn had young trees and shrubs rising in it, and in their season many beautiful flowers.
Jude Converse was a native of, and reared in, Vermont. An older brother was Governor Julius Converse, of that State. Mrs. French, mother of the late John French, was a sister, as also Mrs. Eleanor Hoyt, of Cleveland. Jude was then a frank, handsome, gay-hearted, young merchant of Chardon. Sidney, a woman of rare endowments, was a Metcalf, a younger sister of the late Mrs. Samuel Smith, of Chardon, with whom she migrated from her native Connecticut in 1817; also of Thomas Metcalf, of Chardon; Orrin Metcalf, of Mississippi, and the late Dr. [Asa] Metcalf. When she was twenty years old, she became the wife of the late Dr. Evert Denton, of Chardon, then in the hey-day of his brilliant career, a widower with four small children, and by whom she became the mother of Mr. R. E. Denton, now of Chardon, also of Sybil, a lovely girl, who died many years ago. She lost her first husband in 1830. In 1832, when she was twenty-eight, and Jude was twenty-six, they were married, and began that life-long union of rare felicity in which each supplied to the other that which secured happiness, spite of the reverses of fortune which overtook, and would have darkened almost any home not made bright by such a woman as Sidney was, and warm by the love to which both so steadily ministered.

_______________
¹ Historical Society of Geauga County, Pioneer and General History of Geauga County, with Sketches of Some of the Pioneers and Prominent Men, 1798–1880 (no place: Historical Society of Geauga County, 1880), 356.

9. ⁸Harriet Metcalf, dau. of ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1] and Sybil Chapin. Born on 23 Feb. 1806 in Enfield, Hartford County, Connecticut. Died on 9 July 1870 in Auburn, Geauga County, Ohio, 64 years old.

Married Dr. Oliver W. Ludlow, son of Francis Ludlow, in Feb. 1827 in Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio when about 21 years old (Dr. Oliver W. was 27 years old). Dr. Oliver W. Ludlow b. on 1 Jan. 1800 in Seneca, Cayuga County, New York; d. on 2 Aug. 1865 in Auburn, 65 years old.

Issue of Harriet Metcalf and Dr. Oliver W. Ludlow:
32   i. dau. ⁹Marie Antoinette Ludlow b. on 9 Feb. 1828 in Chardon.
33   ii. son Linnaeus Charles Ludlow b. on 2 Aug. 1831 in Newbury, Geauga County, Ohio.
34   iii. son Benjamin Franklin Ludlow b. on 12 April 1833 in Newbury.
35   iv. son Washington Irving Ludlow b. on 18 March 1835 in Newbury.
36   v. son Lycurgus C. Ludlow b. on 17 May 1837 in Newbury.
      vi. dau. Louisa Maria Ludlow b. on 8 Oct. 1842 in Auburn; d. on 29 June 1905, 62 years old.
37   vii. dau. Harriet Ella Ludlow b. on 20 Oct. 1847 in Auburn.
38   viii. son Oliver Ellis Ludlow b. on 23 Dec. 1849 in Auburn.

Notes on Harriet Metcalf:

Chapin¹ said Harriet of Newbury and Auburn, Ohio, daughter of Thomas and Sibyl (Chapin) Metcalf, was born on 23 February 1806 in Enfield, Connecticut. She married Dr. Oliver W. Ludlow in Chardon, Ohio, in February 1827. He was born on 1 January 1800. They had eight children. Oliver died on 2 August 1865, and Harriet died on 9 July 1870 in Auburn.

A history of Geauga County tells of Harriet:²

Mrs. Ludlow, wife of the Doctor, was one of the best of women, and was highly respected of every one that knew her. She survived him a number of years, and, after a lingering disease of cancer in the stomach, death came to her relief. She died in 1870.

Harriet and her family were enumerated in the 1850 federal census of Auburn, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:³

Oliver W. Ludlow, 50, male, physician, born New York.
Harriet Ludlow, 44, female, born Connecticut.
Lucius Ludlow, 19, male, born Ohio.
A. Ludlow, 22, female, born Ohio.
Franklin Ludlow, 17, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Irving Ludlow, 16, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Lycurgus Ludlow, 13, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Louisa Ludlow, 18 [sic, 8], female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
H. E. Ludlow, 4, female, born Ohio.
Oliver Ludlow, 6/12, male, born Ohio.

Harriet and her family were enumerated in the 1860 federal census of Auburn, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:⁴

O. Ludlow, 60, male, physician, real property $450, personal property $200, born New York.
H. Ludlow, 54. female, born Connecticut.
I. Ludlow, 25, male, teacher, born Ohio.
L. Ludlow, 23, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
L. Ludlow, 17, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
E. Ludlow, 12, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
O. Ludlow Jr., 10, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.

Harriet was enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Auburn, Geauga County, Ohio, in the household of her son Benjamin Franklin as follows:⁵

Benjamin F. Ludlow, 37, male, white, farmer, real property $1000, personal property $150, born Ohio.
Delia Ludlow, 33, female, white, keeping house, born Ohio.
Evaline Ludlow, 4, female, white, at home, born Ohio.
Harriet Ludlow, 64, female, white, keeping house, born Connecticut.
Oliver Ludlow, 22, male, white, farm laborer, personal property $200, born Ohio.
Louisa Ludlow, 26, female, white, seamstress, born Ohio.

_______________
¹ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. I: First Seven Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 804–805.
² Historical Society of Geauga County, Pioneer and General History of Geauga County, with Sketches of Some of the Pioneers and Prominent Men, 1798–1880 (no place: Historical Society of Geauga County, 1880), 206.
³ Oliver W. Ludlow household, 1850 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Auburn Township, sheet 254 (continued on the next sheet), line 38, dwelling 18, family 18; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 682.
⁴ O. Ludlow household, 1860 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Auburn Township, page 48, line 20, dwelling 389, family 363; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 967.
⁵ Benjamin F. Ludlow household, 1870 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Auburn Township, page 3, sheet 11, line 7, dwelling 20, family 20; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 1204.

Notes on Dr. Oliver W. Ludlow:

A history of Geauga County tells of Oliver:¹

Oliver W. Ludlow, son of Francis Ludlow, was born in Seneca, Cayuga county, New York, in 1800, and moved with his parents to Westfield, New York, in 1807.—At the age of nineteen, with a few shillings in his pocket, he started on foot for Painesville, Ohio, and there engaged in teaching. In 1822 he went to Burton, Ohio, where he taught school with good success until 1824, where he commenced the study of medicine with Dr. Goodwin. In 1825 he went to Chardon, Ohio, where he continued his medical studies with Dr. Denton; also taught school there with much credit to himself. In 1827 he married Miss Harriet Metcalf, of that place. The had eight children—Maria A., Lineus C., Benjamin F., Washington I., Lycurgus, Louisa M., Harriet E. and Oliver E. In the fall of 1829 he went to New York to attend the New York Medical College; during the winter of 1830 he went to Geneva and taught school in order to defray his expenses through college. August 17, 1830, he received his diploma from the New York Medical academy. that fall he returned to Chardon and moved his family to Newbury, Ohio. In 1831 he began the practice of medicine in that and surrounding townships. In 1838 he moved to Auburn corners, where he practiced medicine until his death, which occurred in 1865. He died very suddenly, after having visited several patients on the day of his death. The cause of his death was a rupture of the left ventricle of the heart.

_______________
¹ Historical Society of Geauga County, Pioneer and General History of Geauga County, with Sketches of Some of the Pioneers and Prominent Men, 1798–1880 (no place: Historical Society of Geauga County, 1880), 205.

10. ⁸George A. Metcalf, son of ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1] and Sybil Chapin. Born on 26 Feb. 1808 in Enfield, Hartford County, Connecticut. Died on 27 March 1875 in Seneca County, Ohio, 67 years old.

Married Mary Ann Sikes, dau. of Thaddeus Sikes (son of Amos Sikes and Agnes Austin) and Diantha Rising (dau. of John Rising and Thorinda Hathaway), on 27 June 1830 in Trumbull County when 22 years old (Mary Ann was 20 years old). Mary Ann Sikes b. on 20 April 1810 in Suffield, Hartford County, Connecticut; d. on 6 June 1866 in Seneca County, 56 years old.

Issue of George A. Metcalf and Mary Ann Sikes:
39   i. dau. ⁹Mary Eliza Metcalf b. on 11 Jan. 1832 in Geauga County.
40   ii. dau. Lucretia S. Metcalf b. on 10 Oct. 1833 in Seneca County.
41   iii. son Gilbert A. Metcalf b. on 23 April 1835 in Seneca County.
42   iv. son Orin E. Metcalf b. on 6 Jan. 1837 in Seneca County.
      v. son Jude Metcalf b. on 19 May 1838 in Seneca County; d. on 13 Dec. 1838 in Seneca County, six months old.
43   vi. dau. Martha E. Metcalf b. on 13 May 1840 in Seneca County.
44   vii. dau. Harriet Augusta Metcalf b. on 17 Feb. 1842 in Seneca County.
45   viii. son George M. Metcalf b. on 24 Jan. 1844 in Seneca County.
      ix. dau. Maria Antoinette Metcalf b. on 19 Oct. 1846 in Seneca County; d. in 1875, 28 or 29 years old; m. James Smapsel on 25 Oct. 1866 in Richland County when 20 years old.
46   x. dau. Clara Pauline Metcalf b. in Jan. 1849 in Seneca County.

Notes on George A. Metcalf:

Chapin¹ said George was born on 26 February 1808, married and had ten children.

The extracted record of the marriage of George and Mary Ann is listed in the IGI.

George and his familhy were enumerated in the 1850 federal census of New Haven, Huron County, Ohio, as follows:²

George Metcalf, 42, male, hotel keeper, born Connecticut.
Mary A. Metcalf, 39, female, born Vermont [sic].
Mary E. Metcalf, 19, female, born Ohio.
Lucretia S. Metcalf, 17, female, born Ohio.
Gilbert A. Metcalf, 14, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Orrin Metcalf, 12, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Martha Metcalf, 10, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Harriet A. Metcalf, 8, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
George Metcalf, 6, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Mariah A. Metcalf, 4, female, born Ohio.
Clara Metcalf, 1, female, born Ohio.

George and his family were enumeraed in the 1860 federal census of Venice Township, Seneca County, Ohio, as follows:³

George Metcalf, 52, male, farmer, real property $3200, personal properlty $812, born Connecticut.
Mary A. Metcalf, 49, female, born Connecticut.
George M. Metcalf, 16, male, laborer, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Maria A. Metcalf, 14, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Clara P. Metcalf, 12, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.

George was enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Venice Township, Seneca County, Ohio, with his brother Samuel as follows:⁴

George Metcalf, 62, male, white, farmer, real property $6500, personal property $1000, born Connecticut.
Mana Metcalf, 42, female, white, keeping house, born New York.
Samuel Metcalf, 77, male, white, without occupation, born Connecticut.

Mana has not been identified.

_______________
¹ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. I: First Seven Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 380.
² George Metcalf household, 1850 U.S. census, Huron County, Ohio, population schedule, New Haven Township, hotel, sheet 179 (continued on the next sheet), line 34, dwelling 2436, family 2526; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 697.
³ George Metcalf household, 1860 U.S. census, Seneca County, Ohio, population schedule, Venice Township, Attica Post Office, page 10, sheet 231, line 10, dwelling 71, family 64; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 1035.
⁴ George Metcalf household, 1870 U.S. census, Seneca County, Ohio, population schedule, Venice Township, Bloomville Post Office, page 44, sheet 401, line 24, dwelling 344, family 346; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 1266.

11. ⁸Oren Metcalfe, son of ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1] and Sybil Chapin. Born on 28 Jan. 1810 in Enfield, Hartford County, Connecticut. Died on 20 Nov. 1895 in Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi, 85 years old. Buried in City Cemetery, Natchez.

Married Zuleika Rosalie Lyons, dau. of Dr. Joseph B. Lyons and Aurora Deborah Cox (dau. of Dr. John Coats Cox and Ann Deborah Harper), on 12 April 1838 in Natchez when 28 years old (Zuleika Rosalie was 15 years old). Zuleika Rosalie Lyons b. on 31 May 1822 in Washington, Adams County, Mississippi; d. on 15 May 1870 in Natchez, 47 years old; bur. in City Cemetery.

Issue of Oren Metcalfe and Zuleika Rosalie Lyons:
      i. son ⁹Joseph Albert Metcalfe b. on 12 Nov. 1839 in Natchez; d. on 9 June 1840 in Natchez, six months old; bur. in City Cemetery.
      ii. son Cpl. John Thomas Winn Metcalfe CSA b. on 20 May 1841 in Natchez; bap. on 12 Dec. 1841 in Natchez when six months old; d. on 10 July 1863 near Funkstown, Washington County, Maryland, 22 years old.
      iii. son Pvt. Julius Oren Metcalfe CSA b. on 12 April 1843 in Natchez; bap. on 12 May 1844 in Natchez when a year old; d. on 29 Nov. 1880 in Natchez, 37 years old; bur. in City Cemetery.
47   iv. son Lt. James Bard Metcalfe CSA b. on 15 Jan. 1846 in Natchez.
      v. son Charles Metcalfe b. on 28 Sep. 1848 in Natchez; d. on 6 Aug. 1849 in Natchez, ten months old.
48   vi. son William Lyons Metcalfe b. on 30 Sep. 1849 in Natchez.
      vii. son John Inge Metcalfe b. on 12 Nov. 1853 in Natchez; bap. on 4 June 1854 in Natchez when six months old; d. on 7 Aug. 1863 in Natchez, nine years old; bur. in City Cemetery.
49   viii. dau. Zuleika Rosalie Metcalfe b. on 15 March 1855 in Natchez.
      ix. dau. Medora Metcalfe b. on 8 Jan. 1858 in Natchez; bap. on 25 July 1858 in Natchez when six months old; d. on 5 Sep. 1867 in Natchez, nine years old; bur. in City Cemetery.
50   x. dau. Anna Metcalfe b. on 8 July 1861 in Natchez.
      xi. dau. Belle Metcalfe b. on 1 Oct. 1864 in Natchez; d. on 22 June 1865 in Natchez, eight months old; bur. in City Cemetery.
51   xii. son Richard Inge Metcalfe b. on 29 May 1866 in Natchez.

Notes on Oren Metcalfe:

Oren Metcalfe^{1, 2} was born on 28 January 1810 in Enfield, Hartford County, Connecticut. He moved with his parents to Chardon, Ohio, about 1816 at age six or so. “After leaving the Common School where he received his education, Oren Metcalfe began clerking in a store, a calling he followed for some years, but in 1830 he made a trip to Natchez to visit his brother, Asa Baldwin Metcalfe, who was a practicing physician, but soon after returned to Ohio where he remained for three years longer. Oren then took up his permanent abode in the state of Mississippi (in 1833) and for some time thereafter was engaged in merchandising.”³

Oren married Zuleika Rosalie Lyons in Natchez on 12 April 1838, the ceremony performed by S. G. Winchester, Pastor of the First Presbyterian Church.^{4, 5, 6} Zuleika was born in Washington, Mississippi, on 31 May 1822.⁷

Oren and Zuleika participated in several land transactions in Natchez.⁸

Oren and Zuleika were enumerated in the 1840 federal census of Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi, as follows:⁹

O. Metcalfe, 3 males 20 and under 30, 1 female 15 and under 20. Actually, Oren was 30 years old, and Zuleika was 18.

In 1850 Oren was a merchant in Natchez and he and Zuleika were raising sons John Thomas Winn, Julius Oren, James Bard and William Lyons. (First son Joseph Albert had died in infancy in 1840 and fifth son Charles also had died in infancy in 1849.)

Oren and his family were enumerated in the 1850 federal census of Adams County, Mississippi, as follows:¹⁰

O. Metcalfe, 37 [sic, 40], male, merchant, born Connecticut.
Z. R. Metcalfe, 27 [sic, 28], female, born Mississippi.
Jno. T. Metcalfe, 9, male, born Mississippi, attended school within the year.
Julius O. Metcalfe, 7, male, born Mississippi.
Jas. B. Metcalfe, 5 [sic, 4], male, born Mississippi.
Infant Metcalfe, 6/12, male, born Mississippi.

At this time Oren was also engaged in planting, but in 1851 he was elected county Sheriff. In 1857 Oren and Zuleika purchased Ravenna, a home at 601 South Union Street in Natchez that sits in an informal park facing a large ravine (after which it was named).¹¹ In purely Greek Revival style with Doric columns on the first floor and Ionic columns on the second, it was built in 1835 by William Harris, a Natchez cotton broker, real estate developer and merchant. It passed through the hands of several owners before it was bought by Oren and Zuleika. It stayed in the family for nearly a hundred years, being closed in 1952. It is now the home of Catherine Brandon Morgan. The grounds were described as abounding in dogwood, redbud, huge magnolias and cedars. It is probably best known for its ancient azaleas and camellias set in wandering gardens. Inside the house is an exquisite three-story elliptical stairway that sweeps upward unsupported, in the best ante bellum tradition. Some of the present furnishings belonged to Oren and Zuleika, notably the large dining table, twelve dining chairs and a pair of handblown and embellished hurricane globes.

By 1860 Oren was wealthy ($28,000 in real estate and $45,000 in personal property) and was the Sheriff of Adams County. He and Zuleika were raising three more children: son John Inge¹² and daughters Zuleika Rosalie and Medora.

Oren and his family were enumerated in the 1860 federal census of Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi, as follows:¹³

O. Metcalfe, 49 [sic, 50], male, Sheriff, real property $28,000, personal property $15,000, born Massachusetts [sic].
Zuleka Metcalfe, 38, female, born Mississippi.
Thomas Metcalfe, 18 [sic, 19], male, born Mississippi, attended school within the year.
Julius Metcalfe, 16 [sic, 17], male, born Mississippi, attended school within the yea.
James Metcalfe, 14, male, born Mississippi, attended school within the yea.
William Metcalfe, 10, male, born Mississippi, attended school within the yea.
John Metcalfe, 6, male, born Mississippi.
Zuleka Metcalfe, 4 [sic, 5], female, born Mississippi.
Medora Metcalfe, 2, female, born Mississippi.

Oren was reelected Sheriff for a total of twelve years after which he was appointed for one more year by the Governor. He then returned to merchandising for five years (circa 1865–1870) in which calling he was highly successful.

Oren is said to have served in some capacity during the War Between the States, but no record of his service has been found (and he did serve as County Sheriff during this time). When Natchez was occupied by Union troops, Zuleika was caught using the large ravine in front of her home as a route for smuggling food and supplies to the Confederate troops. Because of her actions, she and her family were forced to leave their home and Zuleika was required to report thereafter to Union officers every day. Ravenna was boarded up until the end of the war, when the Metcalfe family returned to the house.

During the 1860s three more children were born: Anna, Belle and Richard Inge. Daughter Belle died in infancy in 1865. Son John Inge died in 1863 at nine years old, son John Thomas Winn was killed in 1863, a week after Gettysburg, while serving with the Confederate States Army and daughter Medora died in 1867 at nine years old.

In 1870, following the War, Oren was an insurance agent in Natchez with greatly reduced net worth, no doubt due to the aftermath of the War. Zuleika’s young niece, Sallie Medora Lyons, lived with Oren and his six surviving children: Julius Oren, James Bard, William, Zuleika Rosalie, Anna and Richard Inge. Zuleika had just died in Natchez on 15 May of that year (1870), sixteen days short of 48 years old.^{14, 15}

Oren and his family were enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi, as follows:¹⁶

Oren Metcalfe, 56 [sic, 60], male, white, insurance agent, real property $4000, personal property $2000, born Connecticut.
Julius O. Metcalfe, 27, male, white, lawyer, born Mississippi.
James B. Metcalfe, 24, male, white, clerk in bank, born Mississippi.
William L. Metcalfe, 21 [sic, 20], male, white, born Mississippi.
Zuleka B. Metcalfe, 15, female, white, born Mississippi, attended school within the year.
Anna Metcalfe, 9, female, white, born Mississippi, attended school within the year.
Richard I. Metcalfe, 4, male, white, born Mississippi.
Sallie Lyons, 14, female, white born Mississippi, attended school within the year.

In 1880 Oren was still an insurance agent, living with his late wife’s second cousin once removed, Ellen Hibernia Inge (1839–1918), age 40, the widow of Colonel Robert H. Trabue. Son Julius would die later that year. James Bard and William Lyons were living on the west coast.

Oren and his family were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi, as follows:¹⁷

Oren Metcalfe, white, male, 64 [sic, 70], widowed, insurance agent, born Connecticut, father born Massachusetts, mother born Connecticut.
E. H. Trabue, white, female, 40, cousin, widowed, music tacher, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi.
J. O. Metcalfe, white, male, 38 [sic, 37], son, single, lawyer, born Mississippi, father born Connecticut, mother born Mississippi.
Zula Metcalfe, white, female, 25, daughter, single, at home, born Mississippi, father born Connecticut, mother born Mississippi.
Anna Metcalfe, white, female, 18, daughter, single, at school, attended school within the year, born Mississippi, father born Connecticut, mother born Mississippi.`
Richard Metcalfe, white, male, 13 [sic, 14], son, single, at school, attended school within the year, born Mississippi, father born Connecticut, mother born Mississippi.
Ellen Coody, black, female, 69, servant, widowed, servant, cannot read nor write, born Virginia, father born Virginia, mother born Virginia.
Judy Wilkins, black, female, 60, cook, widowed, cook, cannot read nor write, born Virginia, father born Virginia, mother born Virginia.

In 1891 Oren’s business was general life and fire insurance, representing the Queen insurance company of England, the Providence of Washington, Rhode Island, the Security of New Haven, Connecticut, and the Home of Georgia, and he had been an elder of the Presbyterian Church of Natchez for thirty-six years (from June 1855). His insurance office was listed in the 1892 Natchez City Directory at 108 North Pearl Street.

Oren served for forty-five years (from May 1850) as a Trustee of Jefferson College, and was such when he died at 7 p.m. on Wednesday, 20 November 1895, in Natchez, age 85.¹⁸ He was buried there in the City cemetery.¹⁹ A notice appeared in the Natchez Democrat and is given below. Oren and Zuleika had twelve children, three of which served the CSA notably in the War Between the States—John Thomas Winn Metcalfe of the Jeff Davis Legion (killed in action), Julius Oren Metcalfe with the Point Coupee Battery and Lt. James Bard Metcalfe of Breckinridge’s Brigade.

TRIBUTE OF RESPECT
THE FIRST PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH
NATCHEZ, MISS., DEC. 2, 1895
The session of this church, meeting under the shadow of the great grief which has befallen them in the death of Mr. Oren Metcalfe, the patriarch of their body on the evening of the 20th of November last, would, in behalf of themselves and the congregation over which they preside, place on record the following tribute of respect and love to their departed associate.
Mr. Metcalfe had reached the ripe age of nearly eighty-six years. He was born at Enfield, Conn., Jan. 28, 1810, removed with his parents to Ohio when about three years old, and a little later than 1830 came to Natchez, Miss. His connection with this church dates from Aug. 30, 1840, and was formed under the ministry of Rev. Samuel Winchester. He was one of the now sparse band of veteran members who can remember this church in the days of its vigorous youth.
He commenced his life in Mississippi at a time when the opening of new fields of enterprise was inviting multitudes of young men in the Southwest. Happily he brought with him a sound religious faith imbibed in a christian home, and an equipment of moral principle and habit derived from this faith. This was his safeguard in a time of special danger from the prevalence of license, extravagance and dissipation in the country. Hence it happened that Mr. Metcalfe, while sharing in the vicissitudes which have in repeated instances wrecked the fortunes of the leading men in this community, was able always to outride these disastrous periods and maintain a respectable competency and reputation without a blot. The confidence of his fellow-citizens was attested by the fact that for a series of years he was invested by their suffrages with the responsible office of sheriff of Adams county.
He was elected to the eldership of this church on the 29th day of June, 1855, in connection with Messrs. L. M. Patterson, Alexander J. Postlethwaite and Thomas C. Pollock, and was ordained on the 8th of July following. All of these companions had preceded him to the glorified church above. He and they are now united in the ministry of the heavenly temple.
For more than forty years our departed brother with the steady fidelity which marked his discharge of every office has assisted in the government of this church. With the modest estimate of his ability which he entertained, he has shrunk from the post of leadership, and has preferred to contribute his portion to the efficiency of the session by a regular attendance upon its meetings by his wise and conservative counsels and by the credit communicated to it by the lustre of a pure and consistent piety. At one period, in 1858 and onwards, it may be remembered by some of the congregation that his zeal led him to exercise his gifts in a more public form, and that his voice was often heard in the way of speech and prayer at the devotional meetings of the church.
Although a sufferer from certain infirmities, Mr. Metcalfe’s vigor, mental and physical, was retained in an unusual degree to a late day; and it has been only within a few months that a rapid decay gave premonition of the approaching end of the venerable pilgrim. And when the end came it was in beautiful keeping with his character and life.
Suddenly and gently as a sleep comes to the infant rather than as a struggle and shock, death came to him as a peaceful transition. It was simply a change of worlds. “He was not, for God took him.”

Excerpt from Memoirs of Mississippi²⁰

Oren Metcalfe has been a resident of the state of Mississippi since the year 1833, and during the long term of years that he has resided here he has been earnest and able in his advocacy of what he thinks best calculated to promote the best interests of his country. Being a man of indomitable will power he has been the means of pushing many enterprises that have come up before him to a successful issue, and as his leading characteristics are extreme frankness, honesty of purpose and energy, his influence is widespread.
He was born in Connecticut in 1810, the youngest of twelve children born to Thomas and Sybil (Chapin) Metcalfe, the former a native of New Hampshire [actually Thomas was born in Oakham, Massachusetts] and the latter of Connecticut. The paternal grandfather came from England [actually Samuel was born in Rutland, Massachusetts] but his son Thomas afterward moved to [Enfield] Connecticut, where he met and married Miss Chapin. In this state he resided for many years, but in 1819 [or perhaps as early as 1816] he again made a change of residence, this time taking up his abode at Chardon, Ohio; but here he passed from life three years later [actually in 1827], having been one of the honorable, successful and worthy tillers of the soil of the different states in which he resided. His widow, who lived to be ninety-three years of age [actually ninety years old], passed from life in Ohio, having been an affectionate mother and a true Christian.
After leaving the common schools were he received his education, Oren Metcalfe began clerking in a store, a calling he followed for some years, but in 1830 made a trip to Natchez to visit his brother Asa B., who was a practicing physician, but soon after returned to Ohio, where he remained three years longer. He then took up his permanent abode in the state of Mississippi and for some time thereafter was engaged in merchandising.
In 1838 Miss Zuleika, a daughter of Joseph B. and Amora [Aurora] (Cox) Lyons, became his wife, and after a married life of thirty-three [actually thirty-two] years he was called upon to mourn her death, the date of her demise being May, 1871 [actually 1870]. To them a family of twelve children were born, three sons and two daughters of whom are living: Zuleika (wife of George D. Lawrence, who is a resident of Vicksburg, Miss., and is the present superintendent of the southern department of the Louisville, New Orleans & Texas railroad), Anna (wife of James S. Fleming, merchant, a resident of Natchez), Richard Inge (a clerk in a bank), James B. (a lawyer at Seattle, Wash., he being the first attorney-general of that territory and now the head of a well-known legal firm of that city known as Metcalfe, Turner & Burleigh), and William, who is a lawyer of Oregon. The members of the family that are deceased are as follows: Joseph A., Thomas W. who was killed during the war, Julius O., Charles, John Inge, Medora and Belle.
Mr. Metcalfe followed the occupation of merchant until 1850, being also engaged in planting; but in 1851 he was elected to the office of county sheriff, and as the duties of his trial term was discharged in a manner highly satisfactory to all, and very much to his credit, he was reëlected to the position at each succeeding election until he had filled the office for twelve years, at the end of which time he was appointed for one year longer by Governor Sharkey. At the end of this term he once more embarked in mercantile life, and for five years followed an active business life, during which time his efforts to accumulate some worldly goods were highly successful and reflected great credit upon his ability as a financier, his sound judgement and practical views. At the end of this time he engaged in his present business, that of general life and fire insurance, and now represents the Queen insurance company of England, the Providence of Washington, R. I., the Security of New Haven, Conn., and the Home of Georgia. In May 1850, Mr. Metcalfe was appointed trustee of Jefferson college, and four years later was elected treasurer of that institution, which office he has since continuously held, being the oldest trustee and officer. He is an elder in the Presbyterian church of this place, a position he has filled for some thirty-five years, and for his many Christian qualities, his kindness, charity and love for his fellowmen, his friends are numerous and his enemies extremely few.

It is possible that Oren and Zuleika had one other child who died in infancy—there is a tombstone in Plot 3 of the Natchez City Cemetery that reads “Harry Metcalfe, Oct. 23, 1851—Nov. 14, 1851.” Although Harry fits well into the birth order pattern, there is no other evidence which supports him as their child.

_______________
¹ Information provided by Kate Don Brandon (Mrs. George Lawrence Adams) of Natchez, Mississippi, in personal communications, 20 April 1994.
² International Genealogical Index (IGI)—Connecticut lists his birth in Enfield.
³ Biographical and Historical Memoirs of Mississippi, Vol. II (Spartanburg, South Carolina: The Reprint Company, 1978), 432–433. This editon was reproduced from an 1891 edition in the Mississippi Department of Archives and History in Jackson, Mississippi. The complete account is reproduced at the end of this entry.
⁴ Irene S. and Norman E. Gillis, Adams County Mississippi Marriages, 1802–1859 (no imprint), 38, “Oran Metcalfe married Tuleika [sic] R. Lyons 12 Apr 1838 book 6 page 252.”
⁵ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. I: First Seven Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 380: “Orin b. Jan. 28, 1810. m. Zuleika Lyons. 10 [sic] children.”
⁶ International Genealogical Index (IGI)—Mississippi.
⁷ Information provided by Kate Don Brandon (Mrs. George Lawrence Adams) of Natchez, Mississippi, in personal communications, 20 April 1994, including the places and dates of Zuleika’s birth and death as recorded in an affidavit in support of the application of Roane (Fleming) Byrnes (Zuleika’s granddaughter) for membership in The Order of the First Families of Mississippi 1699–1817.
⁸ Direct Index to Land Conveyances, Adams County, Miss., from 1798 Grantors:
Under “Jan 11 1833” and thereafter:
“Oren and Zuleika Metcalfe [to] Francheso Tutiri, Deed, Book GG, Page 271”
“Oren and Zuleika Metcalfe [to] C. Theodore Vennigerhols, Mtg., Book KK, Page 138”
“Oren Metcalfe, Comr. [To] Audley C. Britton, Deed, Book KK, Page 340”
Indirect Index to Land Conveyances, Adams County, Miss., from 1798 Grantees:
Under “Mar 4 1837” and thereafter:
“Zuleika R. Metcalfe [from] Andrew William & Wife, Deed, Book EE, Page 283”
“Zuleika Metcalfe [from] Aurora Lyons, Deed, Book FF, Page 457”
“Zuleika R. Metcalfe [from] Aurora Lyons, Exer., Deed, Book GG, Page 140”
“Zuleika B. [probably R.] Metcalfe [from] C. Theodore Vennigerhols, Deed, Book KK, Page 137”
“O. Metcalfe, Trustee—Jefferson College [from] Robt. D. Smith, D/T, Book KK, Page 193”
“O. Metcalfe, Trustee—Jefferson College [from] Levi G. Garrison, D/T, Book KK, Page 372”
“O. Metcalfe, Trustee for Calcote & Farrar [from] Joseph E. Kirk & Wife, D/T, Book KK, Page 403”
“O. Metcalfe, Trustee for Jefferson College [from] Levi G. Garrison, D/T, Book KK, Page 618”
“Oren Metcalfe, Trustee [from] Giles M. Hillyer, D/T, Book LL, Page 80”
⁹ O. Metcalfe household, 1840 U.S. census, Adams County, Mississippi, Natchez City, sheet 6, line 6; National Archives micropublication M704, roll 213.
¹⁰ O. Metcalfe household, 1850 U.S. census, Adams County, Mississippi, population schedule, town not stated, sheet 45, line 24, dwelling 170, family 141; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 368.
¹¹ “Ravenna,” Natchez Democrat, Natchez, Mississippi, Saturday, October 5, 1985, p. 24FP. Again on Saturday, October 2, 1993, p. 21.
¹² Inge is pronounced as inge in hinge.
¹³ O. Metcalfe household, 1860 U.S. census, Adams County, Mississippi, population schedule, Natchez, page 107, line 1, dwelling 781, family 781; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 577.
¹⁴ Death records of the City Sexton and City Clerk, City of Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi from 3 Jan 1857 to 12 Dec 1909: “Mrs. Zulieker [sic] R. Metcalfe d. May 15, 1870 at 50 yrs, disease not reported, Dr. Jno. C. Inge, Physician, bur. Plat 3, Lot 329.”
¹⁵ Tombstone, Plot 3, Natchez City Cemetery: “Zulieka Rosalie Lyon, May 31, 1822—May 15, 1870.” She is buried with her husband. She is also entered in the death register of the First Presbyterian Church, Natchez, Mississippi, by her granddaughter, Zuleika Metcalfe Lawrence (Lalie Adams).
¹⁶ Oren Metcalfe household, 1870 U.S. census, Adams County, Mississippi, population schedule, Natchez, page 278, sheet 47, line 3, dwelling 3477, family 3477; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 720.
¹⁷ Oren Metcalfe household, 1880 U.S. census, Adams County, Mississippi, population schedule, Natchez, enumeration district 51, supervisor’s district 3, page 3, sheet 63C, line 19, dwelling 18, family 18; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 639.
¹⁸ Death records of the City Sexton and City Clerk, City of Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi from 3 Jan 1857 to 12 Dec 1909: “Oren Metcalfe d. Nov 20, 1895 at 86 yrs, valvular disease of heart, Dr. Wm. A. McPheeters, Physician, bur. Plat 3, Lot 329.”
¹⁹ Tombstone, Plot 3, Natchez City Cemetery: “Orin Metcalfe, Jan 28, 1810—Nov 20, 1895.”
²⁰ Biographical and Historical Memoirs of Mississippi, Vol. II (Spartanburg, South Carolina: The Reprint Company, 1978), 432–433. This editon was reproduced from an 1891 edition in the Mississippi Department of Archives and History in Jackson, Mississippi. It is highly likely that the information in this account was taken directly from an interview with Oren. This author’s comments are included in brackets.

Images for Oren Metcalfe:

Oren Metcalfe.

Ravenna Manor House, courtesy Betty Grace Lewis.

Ninth Generation

Issue of Samuel Smith and ⁸Sybil Metcalf [2] (⁷Thomas Metcalf [1])

12. ⁹Samuel Horton Smith, son of Samuel Smith and ⁸Sybil Metcalf [2]. Born on 20 Aug. 1811 in Enfield, Hartford County, Connecticut. Died in 1865 in Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, 53 or 54 years old.

Married Caroline _____. Caroline _____ b. in 1811/2 in Massachusetts.

Issue of Samuel Horton Smith and Caroline _____:
      i. dau. ¹⁰Harriet Smith b. in 1833/4 in Ohio.
      ii. dau. Laura Smith b. in 1835/6 in Ohio.
52   iii. dau. Sybil Smith b. in 1838/9 in Ohio.
      iv. son Samuel H. Smith b. in 1841 in Ohio.
      v. dau. Eliza Smith b. in 1843 in Ohio.
      vi. son G. Roland Smith b. in 1846 in Ohio.

Notes on Samuel Horton Smith:

Chapin¹ said Samuel Horton Smith was born on 20 August 1811, and died in 1865 in Chardon, Ohio.

Horton and his family were enumerated in the 1850 federal census of Hambden, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:²

Horton Smith, 38, male, farmer, real property $3800, born Connecticut.
Caroline Smith, 38, female, born Massachusetts [sic].
Harriet Smith, 16, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Laura Smith, 14, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Sybil Smith, 11, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Samuel H. Smith, 9, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Eliza Smith, 7, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
C. R. Smith, 4, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Mark Welech, 22, male, farmer, born Ireland.

Horton and his family were enumerated in the 1860 federal census of Hambden, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:³

Horton Smith, 49, male, farmer, real property $6450, personal property $1100, born Connecticut.
Caroline Smith, 48, female, born New York.
Laura Smith, 24, female, born Ohio.
Sibbyll Smith, 21, female, born Ohio.
Eliza Smith, 17, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Samuel H. Smith, 18, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Rollen Smith, 13, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Orin Smith, 9, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.

Caroline and her family were enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Hambden, Geauga County, Ohio, in the household of her son Roland as follows:⁴

Roland Smith, 23, male, white, farmer, real property $6250, personal property $1565, born Ohio.
Caroline Smith, 59, female, white, keeping house, born New York.
Orrin Smith, 19, male, white, born Ohio.
Laura Smith, 30, female, white, tailoress, born Ohio.
Sybil Smith, 28, female, white, born Ohio.
Eliza Smith, 26, female, white, born Ohio.

Caroline and her son Roland were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Hambden, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:⁵

M. C. Smith, white, female, 68, widowed, keeping house, born Massachusetts, father born Connecticut, mother born Massachusetts.
G. R. Smith, white, male, 31, son, divorced, farm laborer, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born Massachusetts.

_______________
¹ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. I: First Seven Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 803.
² Horton Smith household, 1850 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Hambden Township, sheet 191, line 33, dwelling 46, family 52; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 682.
³ Horton Smith household, 1860 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Hambden, page 89, sheet 675, line 25, dwelling 761, family 712; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 967.
⁴ Roland Smith household, 1870 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Hambden Township, page 8, sheet 160, line 3, dwelling 56, family 56; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 1204.
⁵ M. C. Smith household, 1880 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Hambden, enumeration district 71, supervisor’s district 8, page 18, sheet 72B, line 15, dwelling 154, family 158; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 1019.

13. ⁹Maria Smith, dau. of Samuel Smith and ⁸Sybil Metcalf [2]. Born on 19 June 1815 in Enfield, Hartford County, Connecticut. Died on 18 April 1879 in Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, 63 years old.

Married _____ Faulk.

Issue of Maria Smith and _____ Faulk:
53   i. son ¹⁰Lawrence S. Faulk b. in 1833 in Ohio.
      ii. son Horton H. Faulk b. in 1835 in Ohio.
      iii. dau. Sybil Faulk b. in 1844 in Ohio.

Notes on Maria Smith:

Chapin¹ said Maria was born on 19 June 1815, and died on 18 April 1879 in Chardon, Ohio

Maria and her family were enumerated in the 1850 federal census of Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, in her mother’s household as follows:²

It appears that Maria’s husband, Mr. Faulk, died prior to the 1850 census.

Maria and her family were enumerated in the 1860 federal census of Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, in the household of her son Lawrence as follows:³

Lawrence S. Faulk, 28, male, laborer, born Ohio, married within the year.
Sarah A. Faulk, 25, female, dress maker, personal property $175, born Ohio, married within the year.
Maria Faulk, 45, female, real property $560, personal property $172, born Connecticut.
Sibbel Faulk, 16, female, personal property $5, born Ohio, attended school within the year.

Maria and her family were enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, in the household of her son Lawrence as follows:⁴

Lawrence Falk, 37, male, white, teamster, personal property $400, born Ohio.
Ann Falk, 37, female, whie, keeping house, born Ohio.
Juliette Falk, 10, female, white, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Nancy Falk, 9, female, white, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Minnie Falk, 3, female, white, born Ohio.
Flora Falk, 1, female, white, born Ohio.
Maria Falk, 55, female, white, real property $1500, born Vermont [sic], insane.
Horton Falk, 35, male, white, teamster, born Ohio.

The above enumeration was taken on 16 March. But Maria and her family were also enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, on 5 July by a different census marshall, in the household of a brother of her son Lawrence as follows:⁵

S. S. Falk, 36, male, white, day laborer, personal property $400, born Ohio.
Sarah Falk, 24, female, white, born Ohio.
Juliette Falk, 9, female, white, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Nancy Falk, 8, female, white, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Minnie Falk, 3, female, white, born Ohio.
Sara Falk, 10/12, female, white, born Ohio, born in August.
Maria Falk, 57, female, white, real property $1500, born Connecticut, insane.
Horton H. Falk, 34, male, white, born Ohio.

_______________
¹ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. I: First Seven Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 803.
² Samuel Smith household, 1850 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Township, sheet 237, line 19, dwelling 53, family 56; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 682.
³ Lawrence S. Faulk household, 1860 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Village, page 10, line 4, dwelling 83, family 84; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 967.
⁴ Lawrence Falk household, 1870 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Village, page 19, sheet 91 (continued on the next sheet), line 38, dwelling 137, family 154; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 1204.
⁵ S. S. Falk household, 1870 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Village, page 11, sheet 78, line 22, dwelling 111, family 114; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 1204.

14. ⁹Eliza Smith, dau. of Samuel Smith and ⁸Sybil Metcalf [2]. Born on 26 Aug. 1818 in Ohio. Died on 18 Dec. 1886, 68 years old.

Married Leander Jason Randall, son of Jason Randall (son of Sgt. Nicholas Randall and Content Phillips) and Martha Thompson, on 31 March 1846 when 27 years old (Leander Jason was 28 years old). Leander Jason Randall b. on 15 Feb. 1818 in New York; d. on 27 Sep. 1869, 51 years old.

Issue of Eliza Smith and Leander Jason Randall:
      i. dau. ¹⁰Sybil Randall b. in Feb. 1848; d. on 7 April 1848, about two months old.
      ii. dau. Lucinda Randall b. in Sep. 1849 in Ohio; d. on 12 March 1856, six years old.
54   iii. dau. Juliet Randall b. on 12 June 1852 in Ohio.
      iv. dau. Florence Randall b. in April 1855; d. on 1 Oct. 1856, a year old.

Notes on Eliza Smith:

Chapin¹ said Eliza, daughter of Samuel and Sybil (Metcalf) Smith, was born on 26 August 1818, She married Leander Jason Randall on 31 March 1846. He was born on 15 February 1818, They had four children. Leander died on 27 September 1869 and Eliza died on 18 December 1886.

Eliza and her family were enumerated in the 1850 federal census of Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:²

L. J. Randall, 31, male, merchant, real property $700, born New York.
Eliza Randall, 29, female, born Ohio.
Sarah Fellows, 12, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Lucinda Randall, 10/12, female, born Ohio.

Eliza and her family were enumerated in the 1860 federal census of Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:³

Leander J. Randall, 41, male, banker, real property $8000, personal property $1500, born New York.
Eliza Randall, 40, female, real property $500, born Connecticut [sic].
Juliett V. Randall, 7, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
William T. Rexford Jr., 26, male, merchant, real property $80, personal property $3000, born Ohio.
Wallia T. Rexford, 23, male, clerk, personal property $100, born Ohio.
Alice Armstrong, 23, female, domestic, born Pennsylvania.
John Gross, 25, male, laborer, born Germany.

Eliza and her daughter Julliete were enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio.⁴ The record is almost unreadable but lists Eliza, 49, born Ohio, and Julliett V.

_______________
¹ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. II: Eighth to Twelfth Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 1411.
² L. J. Randall household, 1850 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Township, sheet 234, line 33, dwelling 8, family 9; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 682.
³ Leander J. Randall household, 1860 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Village, page 11, sheet 597, line 31, dwelling 98, family 99; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 967.
⁴ Eliza Randall household, 1870 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Village, page 4, sheet 74, line 14, dwelling 36, family 37; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 1204.

15. ⁹George Kendall Smith, son of Samuel Smith and ⁸Sybil Metcalf [2]. Born about 1821, probably in Ohio. Died in Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio.

Married Anna Davis McGee.

Issue of George Kendall Smith and Anna Davis McGee:
55 i. dau. ¹⁰Lizzie Metcalf Smith b. in Jefferson County, Arkansas.

Notes on George Kendall Smith:

Chapin¹ said George Kendall Smith died in Chardon.

_______________
¹ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. I: First Seven Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 803.

16. ⁹Comfort Smith, son of Samuel Smith and ⁸Sybil Metcalf [2]. Born on 24 March 1825 in Ohio. Died in 1891 in Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, 65 or 66 years old.

Married Maryette _____. Maryette _____ b. between 1826 and 1829 in Ohio; d. before 1880.

Issue of Comfort Smith and Maryette _____:
i. son ¹⁰George B. Smith b. in 1850/1 in Ohio.
ii. son Frank E. Smith b. in 1852/3 in Ohio.

Notes on Comfort Smith:

Chapin¹ said Comfort was born on 24 March 1825 and died in 1891 in Chardon.

Comfort and his wife Mary/Maryette were enumerated in the 1850 federal census of Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, in his father’s family as follows:²

Comfort, his family and his mother were enumerated in the 1860 federal census of Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:³

Comfort, his family and his mother were enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:⁴

Comfort Smith, 45, male, white, [?] dealer, real property $2000, personal property $8000, born Ohio.
Mary Smith, 43, female, white, keeping house, born Ohio.
Sybil Smith, 80, femal, white, born Connecticut.
Frank Smith, 17, male, white, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Emma Pease, 14, female, white, born Ohio, attended school within the year.

Comfort was enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:⁵

Comfort Smith, white, male, 55, widowed, merchant, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born Connecticut.
Fanny Goldthrop, white, female, 20, single, housekeeper, born Canada, father born Canada, mother born Canada.
Alford Carpenter, white, male, 17, single, clerk in store, born New York, father born New York, mother born New York.

_______________
¹ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. I: First Seven Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 803.
² Samuel Smith household, 1850 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Township, sheet 237, line 19, dwelling 53, family 56; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 682.
³ Cofort Smith household, 1860 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon, page 96, line 5, dwelling 815, family 760; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 967.
⁴ Comfort Smith household, 1870 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Village, page 17, sheet 81, line 25, dwelling 168, family 172; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 1204.
⁵ Comfort Smith household, 1880 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Village, enumeration district 68, supervisor’s district 8, page 10, sheet 40C, line 14, dwelling 106, family 118; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 1018.

Issue of Jonathan Chandler and ⁸Elizabeth Metcalf [4] (⁷Thomas Metcalf [1])

17. ⁹Elizabeth Chandler, dau. of Jonathan Chandler and ⁸Elizabeth Metcalf [4]. Born on 13 May 1817 in Connecticut.

Married William Baker. William Baker b. in 1812/3 in New York.

Issue of Elizabeth Chandler and William Baker:
      i. dau. ¹⁰Sybil Baker b. in 1844/5 in Ohio.
      ii. son Frank Baker b. in 1846/7 in Ohio.
      iii. dau. Ella Baker b. in 1849 in Ohio.
      iv. dau. Nettie Baker b. in 1852/3 in Ohio.
      v. son William C. Baker b. in 1854/5 in Ohio; m. Fannie C. _____ (1861/2 in West Virginia–).

Notes on Elizabeth Chandler:

Elizabeth and her family, including her brother Francis, were enumerated in the 1850 federal census of Scipio, Seneca County, Ohio, as follows:¹

Wm Baker, 37, male, farmer, real property $3000, born New York.
Elizabeth Baker, 34, female, born Connecticut.
Sybell Baker, 5, female, born Ohio.
Frank Baker, 3, male, brn Ohio.
Ella Baker, 1, female, born Ohio.
Francis Chandler, 15, male, born Massachusetts.

The above enumeration was taken on 31 October 1850 by R. Crum. It appears to be a correction of the enumeration below taken by him on the previous day:²

William Baker, 37, male, farmer, real property $3500, born New York.
Elizabeth Baker, 22 [sic], female, born Connecticut.
Sibell Baker, 5, female, born Ohio.
Frank Baker, 3, male, born Ohiio.
Eta N. Baker, 1, female, born Ohio.
Francis Chacony [sic], 16, male, born Massachusetts.

Elizabeth and her family were enumerated in the 1860 federal census of Scipio, Seneca County, Ohio, as follows:³

William Baker, 47, male, farmer, real property $6000, personal property $2000, born New York.
Elizabeth Baker, 43, female, born Connecticut.
Zeba Baker, 16, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Elle Baker, 10, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Nette Baker, 7, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Willie Baker, 5, male, born Ohio.
Peter Seigneur, 23, male, laborer, born France.

Elizabeth and her family were enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Scipio, Seneca County, Ohio, as follows:⁴

William Baker, 57, male, white, farmer, real property $10,000, personal property $3000, born Ohio [sic].
Elizabeth Baker, 52, female, white, keeping house, born Ohio [sic].
Ella Baker, 20, female, white, without occupation, born Ohio. attended school within the year.
William Baker, 16, male, white, at home, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
L[?] B[?], 26, male, white, farm laborer, born Ohio, cannot write.

Elizabeth and her family were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Scipio, Seneca County, Ohio, as follows:⁵

William Baker, white, male, 66, married, farmer, born New York, father born Massachusetts, mother born New York.
Elizabeth C. Baker, white, female, 63, wife, married, keeping house, born Connecticut, father born Connecticut, mother born Connecticut.
William C. Baker, white, male, 25, son, married, works on farm, born Ohio, father born New York, mother born Connecticut.
Fannie C. Baker, white, female, 18, daughter-in-law, married, keeping house, born West Virginia, father born Virginia, mother born [Virginia?].

_______________
¹ Wm Baker household, 1850 U.S. census, Seneca County, Ohio, population schedule, Scipiio Township, sheet 47, line 7, dwelling 394, family 394; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 728.
² William Baker household, 1850 U.S. census, Seneca County, Ohio, population schedule, Scipio Township, sheet 42, line 36, dwelling 318, family 318; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 728.
³ William Baker household, 1860 U.S. census, Seneca County, Ohio, population schedule, Scipio Township, page 102, sheet 374, line 22, dwelling 736, family 778; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 1035.
⁴ William Baker household, 1870 U.S. census, Seneca County, Ohio, population schedule, Scipio Township, page 31, sheet 248, line 4, dwelling 163, family 163; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 1266.
⁵ William Baker household, 1880 U.S. census, Seneca County, Ohio, population schedule, Scipio Township, enumeration district 206, supervisor’s district 1, page 6, sheet 258B, line 46, dwelling 7, family 68; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 1065.

18. ⁹Henry Chandler, son of Jonathan Chandler and ⁸Elizabeth Metcalf [4]. Born on 12 Feb. 1830 in Massachusetts.

Married Frances E. _____. Frances E. _____ b. in 1838/9 in Massachusetts.

Issue of Henry Chandler and Frances E. _____:
i. son ¹⁰Albert Chandler b. in 1872/3 in New York.

Notes on Henry Chandler:

Henry was enumerated in the 1850 federal census of Venice Township, Seneca County, Ohio, in the household of his brother Horace as follows:¹

Henry, his brothers Josephus and Francis and his sister Martha were enumerated in the 1860 federal census of Buffalo, Erie County, New York, as follows:²

Henry Chandler, 30, male, engraver, personal property $500, born Massachusetts.
Josephus Chandler, 33, male, engraver, born Massachusetts.
Francis Chandler, 26, male, engraver, born Massachusetts.
David Schuyler, 22, male, engraver, born New York.
Martha Schuyler, 23, female, born New York.

Henry and his family, including his mother and the family of his brother Francis, were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Buffalo, Erie County, New York, as follows:³

Among their 18 boarders were listed:

_______________
¹ Horace M. Chandler household, 1850 U.S. census, Seneca County, Ohio, population schedule, Venice Township, sheet 90, line 21, dwelling 567, family 579; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 728.
² Henry Chandler household, 1860 U.S. census, Erie County, New York, population schedule, Buffalo Ward 2, page 28, sheet 240, line 20, dwelling 175, family 178; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 745.
³ Henry Chandler household, 1880 U.S. census, Erie County, New York, population schedule, Buffalo, 89 Niagara Street, enumeration district 159, supervisor’s district 11, page 49, sheet 47A, line 5, dwelling 314, family 375; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 831.

19. ⁹Francis M. Chandler, son of Jonathan Chandler and ⁸Elizabeth Metcalf [4]. Born on 31 March 1835 in Massachusetts.

Married Sarah T. _____. Sarah T. _____ b. in 1838/9 in New York.

Issue of Francis M. Chandler and Sarah T. _____:
      i. dau. ¹⁰Nellie Martha Chandler b. in 1867/8 in New York.
      ii. dau. Margaret Chandler b. in 1870 in New York.
      iii. dau. Sarah B. Chandler b. in 1873/4 in New York.

Notes on Francis M. Chandler:

Francis was enumerated in the 1850 federal census of Scipio, Seneca County, Ohio, in the family of his sister Elizabeth as follows:¹

The above enumeration was taken on 31 October 1850 by R. Crum. It appears to be a correction of the enumeration below taken by him on the previous day:²

Francis, his brothers Henry and Josephus and his sister Martha were enumerated in the 1860 federal census of Buffalo, Erie County, New York, as follows:³

Francis and his family, including his mother, were enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Buffalo, Erie County, New York, as follows:⁴

Francis and his family were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Buffalo, Erie County, New York, as boarders in the household of his brother Henry as follows:⁵

Among their 18 boarders were listed:

_______________
¹ Wm Baker household, 1850 U.S. census, Seneca County, Ohio, population schedule, Scipiio, sheet 47, line 7, dwelling 394, family 394; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 728.
² William Baker household, 1850 U.S. census, Seneca County, Ohio, population schedule, Scipio, sheet 42, line 36, dwelling 318, family 318; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 728.
³ Henry Chandler household, 1860 U.S. census, Erie County, New York, population schedule, Buffalo Ward 2, page 28, sheet 240, line 20, dwelling 175, family 178; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 745.
⁴ Frank M. Chandler household, 1870 U.S. census, Erie County, New York, population schedule, Buffalo Ward 10, page 84, sheet 524, line 14, dwelling 634, family 606; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 935.
⁵ Henry Chandler household, 1880 U.S. census, Erie County, New York, population schedule, Buffalo, 89 Niagara Street, enumeration district 159, supervisor’s district 11, page 49, sheet 47A, line 5, dwelling 314, family 375; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 831.

Issue of ⁸Thomas Metcalf [5] (⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and Paulina Beard

20. ⁹Horace Metcalf, son of ⁸Thomas Metcalf [5] and Paulina Beard. Born on 10 Aug. 1828 in Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio.

Married Sarah J. _____. Sarah J. _____ b. in 1835/6 in New York.

Issue of Horace Metcalf and Sarah J. _____:
i. dau. ¹⁰Emma Metcalf b. in 1853/4 in Ohio.

Notes on Horace Metcalf:

Horace was enumerated in his father’s household in the 1850 federal census of Chardon Township, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:¹

Horace and his family were enumerated in the 1860 federal census of Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, in the household of William G. Munsell as follows:²

William G. Munsell, 48, male, cabinet maker, real property $2550, personal property $800, born Vermont.
Harriett N. Munsell, 44, female, born Vermont.
Royal H. Munsell, 19, male, clerk, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Horace Metcalf, 30, male, pedler, personal property $100, born Ohio.
Sarah J. Metcalf, 24, female, born New York.
Emma Metcalf, 6, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.

Horace and his family were enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Springfield, Greene County, Missouri, as follows:³

Horace Metcalf, 42, male, white, tin smith, personal property $800, born Ohio.
Sarah Metcalf, 33, female, white, keeping house, born New York.
Emma Metcalf, 16, female, white, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Ellen Hughes, 35, female, white, personal property $700, born New York.
Alice Hughes, 17, female, white, born New York, attended school within the year.
William McCann, 23, male, white, clerk in store, personal property $100, born Canada, both parents of foreign birth.
[Servisa?] Clark, 25, female, black, domestic servant, born Missouri, cannot read or write.
Sarah Clark, 2/12, female, black, born Missouri in April.

_______________
¹ Thomas Metcalf household, 1850 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Township, sheet 239 (continued on the next sheet), line 41, dwelling 81, family 87; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 682.
² William G. Munsell household, 1860 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Village, page 18, sheet 599, line 14, dwelling 114, family 114; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 967.
³ Horace Metcalf household, 1870 U.S. census, Greene County, Missouri, population schedule, Springfield, Campbell Township, page 103, sheet 114, line 14, dwelling 699, family 705; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 777.

21. ⁹Thomas Metcalf, son of ⁸Thomas Metcalf [5] and Paulina Beard. Born on 22 June 1843 in Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio. Died before 1930, probably in Pottawattamie County, Iowa, at most 86 years old.

Married Eva C. Canfield, dau. of Delos W. Canfield (son of Platt Canfield and Mary Read) and Sophronia E. Allen (dau. of Ira Allen and Rebecca Calkins), in 1870 when 26 or 27 years old (Eva C. was 16 or 17 years old). Eva C. Canfield b. in April 1853 in Ohio.

Issue of Thomas Metcalf and Eva C. Canfield:
      i. son ¹⁰Thomas Metcalf b. in Nov. 1871 in Council Bluffs, Pottawattamie County, Iowa; m. Elsie M. _____ (May 1876 in Iowa–) in 1898/9 when about 27 years old (Elsie M. was about 22 years old).
56   ii. son Dr. Frank A. Metcalf b. in 1873 in Council Bluffs.
57   iii. dau. Delia Paulina Metcalf b. in June 1884 in Council Bluffs.

Notes on Thomas Metcalf:

Thomas was enumerated in his father’s household in the 1850 federal census of Chardon Township, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:¹

Thomas was enumerated in his father’s household in the 1860 federal census of Chardon Township, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:²

Chapin³ said Thomas married Eva Canfield and their daughter Delia Paulina married Henry Hurlburt Pinney.

Thomas and his family were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Council Bluffs, Pottawatamie County, Iowa, as follows:⁴

Thomas Metcalf, white, male, 37, married, merchant, born Ohio, father born _____, mother born _____.
Eva Metcalf, white, female, 35 [sic, probably 27], wife, married, keeping house, born Ohio, father born _____, mother born _____.
Thomas Metcalf, white, male, 9, son, single, attended school within the year, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Frank Metcalf, white, male, 7, son, single, attended school within the year, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Anna Peters, white, female, 21, servant, single, servant, born Missouri, father born Ireland, mother born England.

Thomas and his family were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Kane Township (near Council Bluffs), Pottawatamie County, Iowa, as follows:⁵

Thomas Metcalf, head of household, white, male, born Jun. 1843, 56, married 30 years, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born Ohio, clothing merchant, reads, writes, speaks English, owns mortgaged home.
Eva C. Metcalf, wife, white, female, born Apr. 1853, 47, married 30 years, three children all living, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, reads, writes, speaks English.
Della Metcalf, daughter, white, female, born June 1884, 16, single, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, at school, attended school within the year, reads, write, speaks English.

Thomas, his wife and mother-in-law were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Kane Township (near Council Bluffs), Pottawatamie County, Iowa, as follows:⁶

Thomas Metcalf, head of household, male, white, 65, married 39 years, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born Ohio, own income, reads, writes, owns mortgaged farm.
Eva Metcalf, wife, female, white, 56, married 39 years, three children all living, born Ohio, moher born Ohio, father born Vermont, speaks English, reads and writes.
Sophronia Canfield, mother-in-law, female, white, 76, widowed, four children, one living, born Vermont, father born Vermont, mother born Vermont, speaks English, reads and writes.

Thomas was enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Garner Township, Pottawattamie County, Iowa, in the household of his daughter Delia as follows:⁷

H. H. Pinney, head of household, rents, male, white, 46, married, reads, writes, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother born Pennsylvania, speaks English, farmer in general farm.
Della Pinney, wife, female, white, 36, married, reads, writes, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
Charles Pinney, son, male, white, 8, single, attended school within the year, born Iowa, father born Iowa, mother born Iowa.
Eleanor Pinney, daughter, female, white, 10/12, single, born Iowa, father born Iowa, mother born Iowa.
Ella O. Pinney, head of household! [sic, mother], owns farm, female, white, 69, widow, reads, writes, born Pennsylvania, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Pennsylvania, speaks English.
Thomas Metcalf, father-in-law, male, white, 78, widower, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English.

With regard to Thomas’ ancestry, the DAR lineage book said about his daughter:⁸

Mrs. Della Paulina Metcalf Pinney. Born in Council Bluffs, Iowa. Wife of Henry Hurlburt Pinney. . . . Daughter of Thomas Metcalf and Eva Canfield, his wife. Granddaughter of Thomas Metcalf and Paulina Beard, his wife; Delos W. Canfield and Saphronia Allen, his wife. Gr.-Granddaughter of Thomas Metcalf and Sibyl Chapin, his wife, m. 1788; Platt Canfield (1792–1841) and Mary Read (1791–1860), his wife, m. 1813; Jedediah Beard and Charlotte Nickols, his wife; Ira Allen and Rebecca Calkins, his wife. Gr.-gr.-granddaughter of Samuel Metcalf and (Lois) Kingsbury [sic, should be Hannah Richardson], his wife, m. 1763; Aaron Canfield and Lydia Platt, his wife, m. 1790; Amos Beard and Hannah Needham, his wife; Nathaniel Chapin and Sibyl Terry, his wife, m. 1761; Nathaniel Read and Rhoda Sedgwick (1768–1824), his wife; Stephen Calkins, Jr., and Saphronia Barrett, his first wife; Prince Allen and Experience King, his second wife. Gr.-gr.-gr.-granddaughter of Thomas Canfield and Lucy Burr, his wife; Amasa Read and Fannie Sprig, his wife; Stephen Calkins and Rebecca Rolland, his wife. Gr.-gr.-gr.-gr.-granddaughter of Thomas Abbe [sic] (d. 1759) and Rebekah, his wife; Samuel Canfield and Elizabeth Judson, his wife.

_______________
¹ Thomas Metcalf household, 1850 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Township, sheet 239 (continued on the next sheet), line 41, dwelling 81, family 87; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 682.
² Thomas Metcalf household, 1860 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Village, page 2, sheet 588, line 7, dwelling 10, family 10; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 967.
³ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. I: First Seven Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 803.
⁴ Thomas Metcalf household, 1880 U.S. census, Pottawattamie County, Iowa, population schedule, Council Bluffs Ward 3, enumeration district 193, supervisor’s district 3, page 6, sheet 291B, line 46, dwelling 58, family 58; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 361.
⁵ Thomas Metcalf household, 1900 U.S. census, Pottawattomie County, Iowa, population schedule, Kane Township, 133 Bluff Street, enumeration district 140, supervisor’s district 9, sheet 13B (continued on the next sheet), line 99, dwelling 306, family 309; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 455.
⁶ Thomas Metcalf household, 1910 U.S. census, Pottawattamie County, Iowa, population schedule, Kane Township, Bonham Avenue, enumeration district 129, supervisor’s district 9, sheet 15B, line 81, dwelling 251, family 252; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 421.
⁷ H. H. Pinney household, 1920 U.S. census, Pottawattamie County, Iowa, population schedule, Garner Township, enumeration district 131, supervisor’s district 9, sheet 5A, line 23, dwelling 95, family 96; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 510.
⁸ DAR, Lineage Book, Vol. XLI, 1902, 115–116, entry 40308.

22. ⁹Frank Metcalf, son of ⁸Thomas Metcalf [5] and Paulina Beard. Born on 28 March 1848 in Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio. Died on 4 April 1882, 34 years old.

Married Nellie Henry, dau. of _____ Henry and Hannah _____, on 5 Sep. 1878 when 30 years old (Nellie was 21 years old). Nellie Henry b. on 13 Aug. 1857 in Minneapolis, Hennepin County, Minnesota; d. on 23 Jan. 1947 in Atlanta, Fulton County, Georgia, 89 years old; m. (2) Sydney Smith (25 March 1856 in Georgia–) in 1884/5 when about 27 years old (Sydney was about 28 years old); issue (surname Smith): Lillia (2 Oct. 1885 in Georgia–), Sidney (11 Sep. 1887 in Georgia–), Louis (1 Sep. 1889 in Georgia–), James E. (20 Sep. 1895 in Georgia–) and Robin L. (4 Sep. 1896 in Georgia–).

Issue of Frank Metcalf and Nellie Henry:
i. son ¹⁰Frank H. Metcalf b. on 6 Aug. 1879 in Pennsylvania.
58 ii. son Truman Henry Metcalf b. on 17 July 1881 in Pennsylvania.

Notes on Frank Metcalf:

Frank was enumerated in his father’s household in the 1850 federal census of Chardon Township, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:¹

Frank was enumerated in his father’s household in the 1860 federal census of Chardon Township, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:²

Frank appears to be enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Titusville, Crawford County, Pennsylvania, in the household of Martin H Collins (others not shown here) as follows:³

Frank Metcalf, 22, male, white, oil producer, personal property $2500, born Ohio.

Frank and his family appear to be enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Bradford, McKean County, Pennsylvania, as follows:⁴

Frank Metcalf, white, male, 28 [sic], married, oil producer, born Ohio, father born New York [sic], mother born New York [sic].
Nellie Metcalf, white, female, 23, wife, married, born Pennsylvania [sic], father born New York, mother born Pennsylvania [sic].
Frank H. Metcalf, white, male, 9/12, born August, son, born Pennsylvania, father born Ohio, mother born Pennsylvania [sic].
Anna Smith, white, female, 19, servant, single, [?], born Ireland, father born Ireland, mother borh Ireland.

_______________
¹ Thomas Metcalf household, 1850 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Township, sheet 239 (continued on the next sheet), line 41, dwelling 81, family 87; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 682.
² Thomas Metcalf household, 1860 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Village, page 2, sheet 588, line 7, dwelling 10, family 10; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 967.
³ Martin H. Collins household, 1870 U.S. census, Crawford County, Pennsylvania, population schedule, Titusville Ward 2, page 19, sheet 639, line 33, dwelling 127, family 132; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 1331.
⁴ Frank Metcalf household, 1880 U.S. census, McKean County, Pennsylvania, population schedule, Bradford Ward 1, enumeration district 79, supervisor’s district 6, page 48, sheet 122D, line 47, dwelling 393, family 514; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 1153.

Notes on Nellie Henry:

Nellie appears to have been enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Atlanta, Fulton County, Georgia, as follows:¹

Sydney Smith, head of household, white, male, born Mar. 25, 1856, 44, married 15 years, born Georgia, father born Georgia, mother born Georgia, bookkeeping in [?] shop, reads, writes, speaks English.
Nellie M. Smith, wife, white, female, born Aug. 13, 1857, 43, married 15 years, seven children, six living, born Georgia [sic], father born Georgia [sic], mother born Georgia [sic], reads, writes, speaks English.
Frank Metcalf, stepson, white, male, born Aug. 1, 1878 [sic], 21, single, born Minnesota [sic], father born New Hampshire [sic], mother born Georgia [sic], bookkeeper, reads, writes, speaks English.
Lillia Smith, daughter, white, female, born Oct. 3, 1885, 14, single, born Georgia, father born Georgia, mother born Georgia [sic], at school, reads, writes, speaks English.
Sidney Smith Jr., son, white, male, born Sep. 11, 1887, 12, single, born Georgia, father born Georgia, mother born Georgia [sic], at school, reads, writes, speaks English.
Louis Smith, son, white, male, born Sep. 1, 1889, 10, single, born Georgia, father born Georgia, mother born Georgia [sic], at school, reads, writes, speaks English.
Robin L. Smith, daughter, white, female, born Sep. 4, 1896, 3, single, born Georgia, father born Georgia, mother born Georgia [sic].
Henry Metcalf, stepson, white, male, July 17, 1879 [sic], 20, single, born Minnesota [sic], father born New Hampshire [sic], mother born Georgia [sic], clerk [?], reads, writes, speaks English.
James E. Smith, son, white, female, born Sep. 20, 1895, 4, single, born Georgia, father born Georgia, mother born Georgia [sic].

Note that Henry could not have been in Georgia and Minnesota at the same time.

_______________
¹ Sydney Smith household, 1900 U.S. census, Fulton County, Georgia, population schedule, Atlanta Ward 3, 43 Garden, enumeration district 575, supervisor’s district 5, sheet 4B, line 73, dwelling 80, family 83; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 199.

Issue of ⁸Dr. Asa Baldwin Metcalfe [6] (⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and Barbara Allen Harris

23. ⁹Ellen Josephine Metcalfe, dau. of ⁸Dr. Asa Baldwin Metcalfe [6] and Barbara Allen Harris. Born on 22 Nov. 1827 in Hiram, Portage County, Ohio. Died on 11 March 1922 in Berkeley, Alameda County, California, 94 years old. Buried in Mountain View Cemetery, Piedmont, Alameda County, California.

Married Hon. John C. McHenry on 3 April 1847 in New Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi when 19 years old (Hon. John C. was 37 years old). Hon. John C. McHenry b. on 19 Oct. 1809 in Allington, Montgomery County, North Carolina; d. on 15 Nov. 1880 in San Francisco, San Francisco County, California, 71 years old; bur. in Mountain View Cemetery.

Issue of Ellen Josephine Metcalfe and Hon. John C. McHenry:
      i. dau. ¹⁰Elizabeth Harris McHenry b. on 4 Jan. 1850 in Algiers, Orleans Parish, Louisiana; d. on 9 July 1907 in Berkeley, 57 years old; bur. on 7 Aug. 1907 in Mountain View Cemetery; m. Prof. Emanuel Benjamin Lamare (April 1848 in France–6 Sep. 1916 in Berkeley), son of _____ Lamare and Caroline Goddefroy, in 1886 when 35 or 36 years old (Prof. Emanuel Benjamin was 37 or 38 years old).
      ii. son John McHenry b. in 1852; d. in 1852, an infant; bur. in Mountain View Cemetery.
      iii. dau. Mary McHenry b. on 20 Nov. 1855 in Temescal Rancho, Alameda County, California; d. on 13 Oct. 1947 in Berkeley, 91 years old; bur. in Mountain View Cemetery; m. William Keith (21 Nov. 1839 in Oldmeldrum, Aberdeenshire, Scotland–13 April 1911 in Berkeley) on 2 June 1883 when 27 years old (William was 43 years old).
59   iv. dau. Emma McHenry b. on 3 Feb. 1857 in Temescal Rancho.
60   v. son John McHenry b. on 28 Nov. 1858 in San Francisco.

Notes on Ellen Josephine Metcalfe:

The DAR¹ notes that Ellen Josephine Metcalfe, born circa 1827, married Judge M. John McHenry of New Orleans on 3 April 1847 in New Natchez, Mississippi.² He was born on 22 November 1827 [sic, Ellen was born on this date]. Ellen died on 11 March 1922 in Berkeley, California.

Ellen, her family and her mother were enumerated in the 1860 federal census of San Francisco, San Francisco County, California, as follows:³

(An earlier son named John born in 1852 had died soon after his birth.)

Ellen and her family were enumerated in the 1870 federal census of San Francisco, San Francisco County, California, as follows:⁴

John McHenry, 60, male, white, lawyer, real property $150,000, personal property $50m000m born North Carolina.
Ellen McHenry, 41, female, white, keeping house, born Ohio.
Bessie McHenry, 19, female, white, at home, born Louisiana.
Mary McHenry, 14, female, white, at home, born California.
Emma McHenry, 13, female, white, at home, born California.
John McHenry, 11, male, white, at home, born California, attended school within the year.
Ah Lom, 20, male, Chinese, domestic, born China, both parents of foreign birth.

Ellen, her family and her mother were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of San Francisco, San Francisco County, California, as follows:⁵

John McHenry, white, male, 70, married, lawyer, born North Carolina, father born Virginai, mother born Virginia.
Ellen J. McHenry, white, female, 51, wife, married, keeping house, born Ohio, father born Vermont, mother born Connecticut.
E. H. McHenry, white, female, 27, daughter, single, at home, born Louisiana, father born North Carolina, mother born Ohio.
Mary McHenry, white, female, 24, daughter, single, student, attended school within the year, born California, father born North Carolina, mother born Ohio.
Emma McHenry, white, female, 23, daughter, single, student, attended school within the year, born California, father born North Carolina, mother born Ohio.
John McHenry, white, male, 21, son, single, civil engineer, attended school within the year, born California, father born North Carolina, mother born Ohio.
B. A. Metcalf, white, female, 74 [sic], mother-in-law, widow, at home, born Connecticut, father born Rhode Island, mother born Rhode Island.

Ellen was enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Berkeley, Alameda County, California, sharing a home with her daughter Elizabeth’s family as follows:⁶

Ellan J. McHenry, head of household, white, female, born Nov. 1827, 72, widow, five children, four living, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born Connecticut, reads, writes, speaks English, owns home free of mortgage.

Family 98 following includes:

[?]ual LaMare, head of household, white, male, born April 1848, 52, married 13 years, born France, father born France, mother born France, immigrated in 1872, 28 years in the U.S., naturalized, teacher in high school, reads, writes, speaks English.
Elizabeth H. LaMare, wife, white, female, born Jan. 1850, 50, married 13 years, no children, born Louisiana, father born [?], mother born Ohio, reads, writes, speaks English.
Madame C., mother, white, female, born Aug. 1827, 72, widow, five children, four living, born France, father born France, mother born France, immigrated 1881, 19 years in U.S., reads, writes, speaks English.

Ellen was enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Berkeley, Alameda County, California, in the household of her son-in-law Charles Pond as follows:⁷

Charles F. Pond, head of household, male, white, 53, married 29 years, born Connecticut, father born Connecticut, mother born Connecticut, speaks English, Captain in U.S. Navy, reads, writes, owns home free of mortgage.
Emma M. Pond, wife, female, white, 53, married 29 years, three children all livng, born California, father born North Carolina, mother born Ohio, speaks English, reads, writes.
Charles M. Pond, son, male, white, 27, single, born California, father born Connecticut, mother born California, speaks English, division engineer on railroad, reads, writes.
John E. Pond, son, male, white, 25, single, born California, father born Connecticut, mother born California, speaks English, Ensign in U.S. Navy, reads, writes.
Elizabeth H. Pond, daughter, female, white, 23, single, born California, father born Connecticut, mother born California, speaks English, reads, writes.
Ellen J. McHenry, mother-in-law, female, white, 81, widow, five children, three living, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born Connecticut, speaks English, reads, writes.
John C. Pond, brother, male, white, 57, widower, born Connecticut, father born Massachusetts, mother born Connecticut, speaks English, own income, reads, writes.
Paul U. Pond, nephew, male, white, 17, single, born Missouri, father born Connecticut, mother born Connecticut, speaks English, reads, writes, attended school within the year.

Ellen and her daughter Mary were enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Berkeley, Alameda County, California, as follows:⁸

Ellen J. McHenry, head of household, owns mortgaged home, female, white, 92, widow, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born Connecticut, speaks English.
Mary McH. Keith, daughter, female, white, 64, widow, reads, writes, born California, father born North Carolina, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
Marietta M. Barker, house keeper, female, white, 40, widow, reads, writes, born Wisconsin, father born England - English, mother born England - English, speaks English, housekeeper in private familey employed for wages.

Some of the information is from Paula Stewart and John Pond. Paula thinks that John and Ellen were possibly married at the house of Ellen’s uncle, Oren Metcalfe.

_______________
¹ DAR Records of Families of Calif. Pioneers, Vol. 6, 369-372
² Betty Couch Wiltshire, compiler, Marriages and Deaths from Mississippi Newspapers, Vol. II: 1801–1850 (Bowie, Maryland: Heritage Books, Inc., 1989), 90, quotes her marriage notice in the Mississippi Free Trader on 7 April 1847: “Married near Kingston, by the Rev. S. W. Speer, the Hon. John McHenry, of New Orleans, to Miss Ellen Josephine, eldest daughter of Dr. A. B. Metcalfe, of this county.”
³ John McHenry household, 1860 U.S. census, San Francisco County, California, population schedule, San Francisco District 1, page 324, sheet 877, line 34, dwelling 2624, family 2965; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 68.
⁴ John McHenry household, 1870 U.S. census, San Francisco, California, population schedule, San Francisco Ward 4, page 119, sheet 390, line 14, dwelling 902, family 1285; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 80.
⁵ John McHenry household, 1880 U.S. census, San Francisco County, California, population schedule, San Francisco, 34 Glen Park Avenue, enumeration district 159, supervisor’s district 1, page 2, sheet 178B, line 13, dwelling 13, family 13; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 77.
⁶ Ellan J. McHenry household, 1900 U.S. census, Alameda County, California, population schedule, Berkeley Ward 3, 2301 Atherton Street, enumeration district 397, supervisor’s district 1, sheet 5A, line 19, dwelling 85, family 97; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 83.
⁷ Charles F. Pond household, 1910 U.S. census, Alameda County, California, population schedule, Berkeley Precinct 4, 2621 Ridge Road, enumeration district 46, supervisor’s district 3, sheet 7B, line 1, dwelling 116, family 135; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 72.
⁸ Ellen J. McHenry household, 1920 U.S. census, Alameda County, California, population schedule, Berkeley Precinct 56, 2701 Ridge Road, enumeration district 192, supervisor’s district 5, sheet 1A, line 10, dwelling 3, family 3; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 93.

Images for Ellen Josephine Metcalfe:

Ellen Josephine {Metcalfe) McHenry. Photo courtesy of John Pond.

Notes on Hon. John C. McHenry:

Some of the information is from Paula Stewart. She writes:

These are some of the notes on Judge John McHenry. This file lost most of it’s sources, but most of this comes from a SF Call Newpaper article about him and from the McHenry Collection at the Bancroft Library, UC Berkeley:
“‘The Hermitage.’ He and ‘Old Hickory’ became fast friends, despite disparity of age.”
“As was customary for young men of good family in the South a century ago, John McHenry lived at the home of Chief Justice Martin while studying law with him.”
“After eight years of notable service as judge of First Municipal Court of New Orleans, John McHenry resigned to come to California.”
“President Van Buren offered him the post of United States Minister to Spain - we had no ambassadors until long after that - but he preferred the law.”
“Wealthy planters and others of position offered inducements for Judge McHenry to remain in Louisiana.”
“His removal to California was in almost lordly style. As his agent, he sent ahead overland with furniture, law books, wines, supplies, of various kinds and other equipment, James Van Ness (later Mayor of San Francisco) . . . ”
Bancroft Library, UC Berkeley, has letters to and from the Judge in their McHenry collection. They list him b. 1809 d. 1880.
The Golden Gate arrived in San Francisco Harbor from Panama Jan. 9, 1852 with Judge and Ellen aboard. A “T. McHenry” departed Panama aboard the Golden Gate bound for San Francisco, May 21st of the same year. Could this be John’s brother Thomas?

Some of the information is from John Pond. He notes that John McHenry died at 1391 Taylor Street and was buried in Mountain View Cemetery.

24. ⁹George Edward Metcalfe, son of ⁸Dr. Asa Baldwin Metcalfe [6] and Barbara Allen Harris. Born on 18 Feb. 1829 in Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio. Died in 1903, 73 or 74 years old. Buried in Enlow Cemetery, Silver Creek, Wilkinson County, Mississippi.

Married Nancy Adaline Haran Enlow, dau. of Hiram E. Enlow (son of Charles Enlow and Elizabeth Beck) and Nancy Ann Enlow (dau. of Jesse Enlow and Ann Beck), on 24 June 1854 in Wilkinson County, Mississippi when 25 years old (Nancy Adaline Haran was 16 years old). Nancy Adaline Haran Enlow b. on 14 Feb. 1838 in Wilkinson County; d. on 12 June 1882, probably in Wilkinson County, 44 years old; bur. in Enlow Cemetery.

Issue of George Edward Metcalfe and Nancy Adaline Haran Enlow:
      i. son ¹⁰Wade Metcalfe b. in 1854/5 in Wilkinson County; d. young.
      ii. son Lamar Metcalfe b. in 1856/7 in Wilkinson County; d. young.
61   iii. son Jefferson Davis Metcalfe b. on 12 Jan. 1858 in Wilkinson County.
62   iv. son Asa Baldwin Metcalfe b. on 13 March 1860 in Wilkinson County.
      v. dau. Mary Emma Metcalfe b. in 1861/2 in Wilkinson County.
      vi. dau. Mary Elizabeth Metcalfe b. on 31 May 1864 in Wilkinson County; d. on 24 Feb. 1941, 76 years old.
      vii. son John Franklin Metcalfe b. in 1867/8 in Wilkinson County.
      viii. dau. Eliza Metcalfe b. in 1870/1 in Wilkinson County.
63   ix. son George W. Metcalfe b. on 12 July 1873 in Wilkinson County.
64   x. son Orin L. Metcalfe b. in Jan. 1877 in Wilkinson County.

Notes on George Edward Metcalfe:

The DAR¹ notes that George Edward Metcalfe, born on 18 February 1829 in Chardon, Ohio, fought in the War Between the States. He married Nancy Adaline Haran Enlaw [sic] on 25 June 1854 in Wilkinson County, Mississippi.²

Some of the information is from Paula Stewart and Jim Byrd. A photograph of his grave stone records George’s service in Company B, 10th Mississippi Infantry, CSA.

George and his family were enumerated in the 1860 federal census of Wilkinson County, Mississippi,³ as follows:

George Metcallf, 35 [sic], male, planter, real property $500, personal property $150, born Mississippi [sic].
Adeline Metcalf, 30 [sic], female, born Mississippi.
Jeff D. Metcalf, 3 [sic], born Mississippi.

George and his family were enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Wilkinson County, Mississippi,⁴ as follows:

Geo. E. Metcalfe, 42, male, white, Farmer, real property, $300, born Ohio, reads, writes.
Nancy A. Metcalfe, 32, female, white, keeping house, born Mississippi, reads, writes.
Jefferson D. Metcalfe, 12, male, white, at school, born Mississippi, attended school within past year, reads, writes.
Acey [Asa] W. Metcalfe, 10, male, white, at school, born Mississippi, attended school within past year, reads.
Mary Emma Metcalfe, 8, female, white, at school, born Mississippi, attended school within past year, reads.
Mary Elizabeth Metcalfe, 5, female, white, born Mississippi, reads.
John Franklin Metcalfe, 2, male, white, born Mississippi.

George’s sons Wade and Lamar are not listed in any census, which may indicate that they died young before 1860. (Note that son Jefferson named two of his sons Thomas Wade and Lamar McHenry, perhaps after his older and probably deceased brothers.)

George and his family were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Wilkinson County, Mississippi,⁵ as follows:

George Metcalf, white, male, 50, married, farming, born Ohio, faher born Vermont, mother born Rhode Island.
Adeline Metcalf, white, female, 40, wife, married, housewife, born Mississippi, father born Kentucky, mother born Mississippi.
E[micea?] Metcalf, white female, 15, daughter, attended school within the current year, born Mississippi, father born Ohio, mother born Mississippi.
John Metcalf, white, male, 11, son, attended school within the current year, writes, born Mississippi, father born Ohio, mother born Mississippi.
Eliza Metcalf, white, female, 9, daughter, attended school within the current year, writes, born Mississippi, father born Ohio, mother born Mississippi.
George Metcalf, white, male, 5, son, born Mississippi, father born Ohio, mother born Mississippi.
L[eonas?] Metcalf, white, male, 2, son, born Mississippi, father born Ohio, mother born Mississippi.

George and his youngest son were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Wilkinson County, Mississippi,⁶ as follows:

George E. Metcalfe, head of household, white, male, born Feb. 1829, 71, widower, born Ohio, father born Rhode Island [sic], mother born Vermont [sic]. truck farmer, reads, writes, speaks English, owns farm.
Orin L. Metcalfe, son, white, male, born Jan. 1877, 23, single, born Mississippi, father born Ohio, mother born Mississippi, framer, reads, writes, speaks English.

Excerpt from the Natchez [Mississippi] Democrat, Saturday, 6 March 1982:

Much could be written of this family and its connection with the founding fathers of New England. They were direct descendants of Governor William Bradford of the Plymouth Colony and prominent members of the Massachusetts Bay Colony.
The real story is with George Edward Metcalfe, the eldest son of Dr. and Mrs. Asa Baldwin Metcalfe, who remained in Mississippi. Other members of his family immigrated to California in the 1850s. He was the great-grandfather of Mrs. Byrne and when history is rewritten, his name will rank with other adventurous souls as James Long and Phillip Nolan.
As a lad, George attended the famous Oakland College near Lorman where sons of rich planters were educated. His letters at this time evidenced a restless spirit stirred by an irresistible impulse to explore the rest of the world. This lust for adventure led to a strange career filled with hardships and danger, but in old age he recalled these stirring events with a zestful satisfaction.
Following the Mexican War, much feeling against the Spaniards existed and newspapers openly espoused the course of downtrodden Cuba. Our national neutrality laws necessitated much secrecy concerning any move toward (furnishing) men and arms. But General Lopez came to Natchez where he met the best people and won much sympathy. A leading lawyer became a recruiting officer and J.F.H. Claiborne was a member of a committee to take subscriptions to the Cuban fund. It was then that George Metcalfe enlisted, disguising his real identity by giving his home as “Ireland”. This quirk of fate afterwards preserved his life.
The great event was the sailing from New Orleans of Pamiero with 450 men aboard, including William H. Holmes, John Hopkins, William Little, Sergeant Napoleon Collins, Charles A. Robinson, James M. Manderville, James Stanton, J. A. Forniquet and many others, none of who returned except George Metcalfe (and Henry Metcalfe).
Following their departure, anxious loved ones alternated between hope and despair. All hope vanished when word finally came confirming the public garroting of General Narcisco Lopez. In a pathetic last speech he had explained, “That he meant well in all he had done believing that the Cubans wanted a change of government.”
Then the editor added, “Had he had 4000 men such as he brought a sample of he would have been raised to the pinnacle of fame.”
This ended the expedition in which Natchez had invested money and blood. Those who escaped death on the battlefield were thrown into loathsome Spanish prisons to be executed by a firing squad. Among the latter was George Metcalfe (and his younger brother Henry) who was only 22, although already a veteran of two wars. A letter written from his dungeon is one of Mrs. Byrne’s prized possessions and may be seen at Cherokee.
Among those who fate remained a mystery were George E. Metcalfe and his brother Henry. Their father (Asa B. Metcalfe) had been dead for some years and their widowed mother was sick with grief and anxiety. Their father’s brother, Oren Metcalfe (Grandfather of the late W. A. Adams and the late Ferriday Byrnes and other prominent club members) was willing to leave no stone unturned to learn the whereabouts of the men.
One by one, companions had been put to death, especially those who had given their true nationality. Much bitterness was felt toward America, and believing young Metcalfe and his brother were subjects of Great Britain, they were spared because of the British Consul’s intervention. Henry died soon after reaching home.
He (George) once wrote in a letter: “My first enlistment in New Orleans (was) to go the Florida Indian War, next the Mexican War, next the Cuban War in 1851 and captured and sent to Spain in irons. Liberated in Balajado in the northeastern part nears the line of France; stayed in Spain six weeks and then went to New York City.”
TIME LINE OF George Edward Metcalfe:
Born February 18, 1829
Florida Indian War
Mexican War (1846-48) (Age17-18)
Cuban War (1851)(Age 22)
Married June 24, 1854
Civil War (1861-1865) (Age 32-36)
Died 1903 (Age 74)

_______________
¹ DAR Records of Families of Calif. Pioneers, Vol. 6, 369-372
² International Genealogical Index (IGI)—Mississippi, extracted record.
³ George Metcalf household, 1860 U.S. census, Wilkinson County, Mississippi, population schedule, page 17, sheet 540, line 28, dwelling 145, family 145; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 594.
⁴ Geo. E. Metcalfe household, 1870 U.S. census, Wilkinson County, Mississippi, population schedule, District 5, Woodville Post Office, page 308, sheet 393, line 34, dwelling 1, family 1; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 753. The dwellings and families on this page are all numbered 1 although the summary at the end of the page lists nine dwellings and nine families.
⁵ George Metcalf household, 1880 U.S. census, Wilkinson County, Mississippi, population schedule, Beat No. 5, enumeration district 154, supervisor’s district 3, page 23, sheet 560C, line 43, dwelling 183, family 186; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 669.
⁶ George E. Metcalfe household, 1900 U.S. census, Wilkinson County, Mississippi, population schedule, Beat No. 5, enumeration district 153, supervisor’s district 7, page 210, sheet 15B, line 81, dwelling 292, family 292; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 834.

Images for George Edward Metcalfe:

George Edward and Nancy Adaline Haran (Enlow) Metcalfe. Photo courtesy of Jim Byrd.

Headstone of George Edward Metcalfe. Photo courtesy of Jim Byrd.

Notes on Nancy Adaline Haran Enlow:

Some information is from Jim Byrd. A photograph of her grave stone records her dates of birth and death.

Nancy appears in the 1850 federal census of her father Hiram Enlow’s household in Wilkinson County, Mississippi,¹ as follows:

Hiram Enlow, 42, male, planter, real property $564, born Kentucky.
Nancy Enlow, 36 [sic], female, born Mississippi.
David Enlow, 18, male, planter, born Mississippi.
Mary Enlow, 14, female, born Mississippi.
Nancy Enlow, 12, female, born Mississippi.
Mary [sic, name does repeat] Enlow, 10, female, born Mississippi.
Jessee Enlow, 6, male, born Mississippi.
Emily Enlow, 4, female, born Mississippi.
Eliza Enlow, 2, female, born Mississippi.

_______________
¹ Hiram Enlow household, 1850 U.S. census, Wilkinson County, Mississippi, population schedule, sheet 299, line 39 (continued on next sheet), dwelling 575, family 579; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 382.

Images for Nancy Adaline Haran Enlow:

Headstone of Nancy Adaline Haran (Enlow) Metcalfe

25. ⁹Emma Zuleika Metcalfe, dau. of ⁸Dr. Asa Baldwin Metcalfe [6] and Barbara Allen Harris. Born on 2 Dec. 1840 in Adams County, Mississippi. Died on 3 June 1937 in Burlingame, San Mateo County, California, 96 years old. Buried in Mountain View Cemetery, Piedmont, Alameda County, California.

Married Dr. William Gilbert Hay. Dr. William Gilbert Hay b. in 1829/30 in Georgia; d. on 2 Nov. 1875 in San Francisco, San Francisco County, California, 45 years old.

Issue of Emma Zuleika Metcalfe and Dr. William Gilbert Hay:
i. son ¹⁰William Gilbert Hay b. in May 1867 in Santa Cruz, Santa Cruz County, California; d. before 1910 in San Francisco, at most 42 years old.
ii. dau. Emily Parkins Babcock Hay b. in 1868/9 in Santa Cruz; d. on 14 July 1937 in Burlingame, 68 years old; bur. in Mountain View Cemetery.

Notes on Emma Zuleika Metcalfe:

The DAR¹ notes that Emma Z. Metcalfe, probably born circa 1833 [sic], married Dr. William Gilbert Hay I of Georgia. William died on 2 November 1875 in San Francisco, California. Emma was alive in 1931 when she was living in Burlingame, California. They had two children, William and Emily.

Emma and her family were enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Santa Cruz, Santa Cruz County, California, as follows:²

William G. Hay, 40, male, white, physician, born Georgia.
Emma Z. Hay, 29, female, white, keeping house, born Mississippi.
William G. Hay, 3, male, white, born California.
Emily P. B. Hay, 1, female, white, born California.
Katie Sweeny, 25, female, white, domestic servant, born Ireland.

Emma and her children were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of San Francisco, San Francisco County, California, in the household of J. L. King (not shown below) as follows:³

E. M. Hay, white, female, 39, widow, library clerk, born Mississippi, father born [?], mother born Mississippi.
Wm. Hay, white, male, 13, son, single, att. school, attended school within the year, born California, father born Mississippi [sic], mother born Mississippi.
Emily Hay, white, female, 11, daughter, single, att. school, attended school within the year, born California, father born Mississippi [sic], mother born Mississippi.

Emma and a younger in-law named Clara Hay were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of San Francisco, San Francisco County, California, in the Renton Hotel (others not shown below) as follows:⁴

Emma M. Hay, boarder, white, female, born Dec. 1840, 59, widow, two children both living, born Mississippi, father born Vermont, mother born Connecticut, librarian, reads, writes, speaks English.
Clara Hay, boarder, white, female, born Nov. 1870, 29, single, born California, father born New York, mother born Mississippi, reads, writes, speaks English.

Emma and her daughter Emily were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of San Francisco, San Francisco County, California, as lodgers in the household of Francis H. Heiller (not shown below) as follows:⁵

Emma M. Hay, lodger, female, white, 69, widow, two children, one living, born Mississippi, father born Vermont, mother born Connecticut, speaks English, [?], reads, writes.
Emily P. B. Hay, lodger, female, white, [?], single, born California, father born Mississippi, mother born Georgia [father and mother reversed], speaks English, librarian in free library, works for wages, reads, writes.

Emma and her daughter Emily were enumerated in the 1920 federal census of San Francisco, San Francisco County, California, as follows:⁶

Emma Metcalf Hay, head of household, house owned free of mortgage, female, white, 79, widow, reads, writes, born Mississippi, father born Connecticut, mother born Connecticut, speaks English.
Emily P. B. Hay, daughter, female, white, 50, single, reads, writes, born California, father born Georgia, mother born Mississippi, speaks English, artist working on own account.

Emma was enumerated in the 1930 federal census of Burlingame, San Mateo County, California, in the household of her daughter Emily as follows:⁷

Emily Hay, [daughter, crossed out] head of household, owns home valued at $6500, radio set, female, white, 61, single, reads and writes, born California, father born Georgia, mother born Mississippi, speaks English, no occupation.
Emma Hay, mother, female, white, 89, widow, reads and writes, born Mississippi, father born Ohio [sic], mother born Ohio [sic], speaks English, no occupation

Some of the information is from Paula Stewart and John Pond.

_______________
¹ DAR Records of Families of Calif. Pioneers, Vol. 6, 369-372.
² William G. Hay household, 1870 U.S. census, Santa Cruz County, California, population schedule, Santa Cruz, page 24, sheet 414, line 33, dwelling 193, family 194; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 89.
³ J. L. King household, 1880 U.S. census, San Francisco County, California, population schedule, San Francisco, 1524 Clay Street, enumeration district 58, supervisor’s district 1, page 4, sheet 730D, line 16, dwelling 33, family 33; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 74.
⁴ James Anderson household, 1900 U.S. census, San Francisco County, California, population schedule, San Francisco, Renton Hotel, 712 Sutter, enumeration district 248, supervisor’s district 1, sheet 7A, line 19, dwelling 46, family 68; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 106.
⁵ Francis H. Heiller household, 1910 U.S. census, San Francisco County, California, population schedule, San Francisco Precinct 11, enumeration district 254, supervisor’s district 4, sheet 4A, line 15, dwelling 60, family 76; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 101.
⁶ Emma Metcalf Hay household, 1920 U.S. census, San Francisco County, California, population schedule, San Francisco Precinct 45, 2434 21st Avenue, enumeration district 352, supervisor’s district 4, sheet 2B, line 88, dwelling 49, family 49; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 142.
⁷ Emily Hay household, 1930 U.S. census, San Mateo County, California, population schedule, Burlingame, 1000 Vancouver, enumeration district 41-3, supervisor’s district 10, sheet 12B, line 59, dwelling 342, family 348; National Archives micropublication T636, roll 216.

Images for Emma Zuleika Metcalfe:

Emma Zuleike (Metcalfe) Hay. Photo courtesy of John Pond.

Issue of ⁸Ebenezer Metcalf [7] (⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and Louisa Chapin

26. ⁹Eliza Dixon Metcalf, dau. of ⁸Ebenezer Metcalf [7] and Louisa Chapin. Born on 19 Feb. 1838 in Ohio. Died on 28 Feb. 1872 in Toledo, Lucas County, Ohio, 34 years old.

Married Samuel Wagner on 31 March 1871 in Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio when 33 years old. Samuel Wagner of Toledo.

Issue of Eliza Dixon Metcalf and Samuel Wagner:
i. son ¹⁰Fred Compton Wagner b. on 18 Feb. 1872 in Toledo.

Notes on Eliza Dixon Metcalf:

Chapin¹ said Eliza Dixon, daughter of Eben and Lovica (Chapin) Metcalf, was born on 19 February 1838. She married Samuel Wagner of Toledo, Ohio, on 31 March 1871 in Chardon, Ohio. They had one child. She died on 28 February 1872 in Toledo. Chapin said that Eliza “possessed that excellent Christian grace, ‘charity, which suffereth long and is kind.’ A genial and sunny soul, ever striving to be of service to others.”

_______________
¹ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. II: Eighth to Twelfth Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 1411.

27. ⁹Isabella Linwood Metcalf, dau. of ⁸Ebenezer Metcalf [7] and Louisa Chapin. Born on 15 Sep. 1842 in Ohio. Died on 22 April 1871 in Toledo, Lucas County, Ohio, 28 years old.

Married Stephen Aaron Pomeroy, son of Stephen Bridgman Pomeroy (son of Stephen Pomeroy and Lydia Bridgman) and Abigail Scott, on 3 Aug. 1865 in Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio when 22 years old (Stephen Aaron was 31 years old). Stephen Aaron Pomeroy b. on 15 July 1834 in Huntsburg, Geauga County, Ohio; d. on 22 April 1873 in Toledo, 38 years old; m. (2) ⁹Catharine Lovica Metcalf [28] (31 July 1845 in Ohio–), dau. of ⁸Ebenezer Metcalf [7] and Louisa Chapin (dau. of George Chapin and Lucy Parsons), on 30 July 1872 when 38 years old (Catharine Lovica was 26 years old); issue (surname Pomeroy): ¹⁰Louis Stephen (27 June 1873 in Toledo–) [67].

Issue of Isabella Linwood Metcalf and Stephen Aaron Pomeroy:
65   i. son ¹⁰Norman Charles Pomeroy b. on 4 June 1866 in Toledo.
66   ii. son William Metcalf Pomeroy b. on 13 Sep. 1868 in Toledo.
      iii. son Fred Pomeroy b. in Jan. 1870 in Toledo; d. on 13 April 1871 in Toledo, a year old.

Notes on Isabella Linwood Metcalf:

Chapin¹ said Isabella L., daughter of Eben and Lovica (Chapin) Metcalf, was born on 15 September 1842. She married Stephen A. Pomeroy on 3 August 1865 in Chardon, Ohio. He was born on 15 July 1834. They had three children.

Isabella and her children were enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, in the household of her father-in-law as follows:²

Bridgman Pomeroy, 66, male, white, carpenter, personal property $200, born Massachusetts.
Abigail Pomeroy, 56, female, whie, keeping house, born New York.
Isabell Pomeroy, 28, female, white, born Ohio.
Norman Pomeroy, 5, male, white, born Ohio.
Willie Pomeroy, 2, male, white, born Ohio.

Stephen married second Isabella’s younger sister Catherine.

_______________
¹ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. II: Eighth to Twelfth Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 1411–1412.
² Bridgman Pomeroy household, 1870 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Village, page 14, sheet 88, line 36, dwelling 100, family 112; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 1204.

Notes on Stephen Aaron Pomeroy:

Stephen was enumerated in the 1850 federal census of Huntsburgh, Geauga County, Ohio, in the household of his father (whose surname is erroneously given as Brown as confirmed in the 1860 census) as follows:¹

S. B. Brown, 46, male, carpenter, born Massachusetts.
Abigail Pomeroy, 35, female, born New York.
Stephen Pomeroy, 16, male, laborer, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Lydia E. M. Pomeroy, 13, female, born born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Chloe J. S. Pomeroy, 5, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.

Stephen was enumerated in the 1860 federal census of Huntsburgh, Geauga County, Ohio, in the household of his father as follows:²

Stephen B. Pomeroy, 55, male, carpenter, real property $350, personal property $200, born Massachusetts.
Abigal Pomeroy, 45, female, born New York.
Stephan A. Pomeroy, 26, male, clerk, born Ohio.
Chloe E. Pomeroy, 15, female, born Ohio.

_______________
¹ S. B. Brown household, 1850 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Huntsburgh, sheet 168, line 3, dwelling 94, family 95; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 682.
² Stephen B. Pomeroy household, 1860 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Huntsburg, page 177, line 13, dwelling 1478, family 1396; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 967.

28. ⁹Catharine Lovica Metcalf, dau. of ⁸Ebenezer Metcalf [7] and Louisa Chapin. Born on 31 July 1845 in Ohio.

Married Stephen Aaron Pomeroy, son of Stephen Bridgman Pomeroy (son of Stephen Pomeroy and Lydia Bridgman) and Abigail Scott, on 30 July 1872 when 26 years old (Stephen Aaron was 38 years old). Stephen Aaron Pomeroy b. on 15 July 1834 in Huntsburg, Geauga County, Ohio; d. on 22 April 1873 in Toledo, Lucas County, Ohio, 38 years old; m. (1) ⁹Isabella Linwood Metcalf [27] (15 Sep. 1842 in Ohio–22 April 1871 in Toledo), dau. of ⁸Ebenezer Metcalf [7] and Louisa Chapin (dau. of George Chapin and Lucy Parsons), on 3 Aug. 1865 in Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio when 31 years old (Isabella Linwood was 22 years old); issue (surname Pomeroy): ¹⁰Norman Charles (4 June 1866 in Toledo–) [65], William Metcalf (13 Sep. 1868 in Toledo–bef. 1920) [66] and Fred (Jan. 1870 in Toledo–13 April 1871 in Toledo).

Issue of Catharine Lovica Metcalf and Stephen Aaron Pomeroy:
67 i. son ¹⁰Louis Stephen Pomeroy b. on 27 June 1873 in Toledo.

Notes on Catharine Lovica Metcalf:

Chapin¹ said Catharine Lovica, daughter of Eben and Lovica (Chapin) Metcalf, was born on 31 July 1845. She married Stephen A. Pomeroy. They had one child. Stephen died on 22 April 1873.

Stephen married first Catherine’s sister Isabella.

Catharine, her son, her stepson (and nephew) Norman and her mother were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:²

_______________
¹ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. II: Eighth to Twelfth Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 1412.
² Catharine Pomeroy household, 1900 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Village, enumeration district 44, supervisor’s district 18, sheet 11A, line 26, dwelling 278, family 289; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 1271.

Notes on Stephen Aaron Pomeroy:

Stephen was enumerated in the 1860 federal census of Huntsburgh, Geauga County, Ohio, in the household of his father as follows:²

_______________
¹ S. B. Brown household, 1850 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Huntsburgh, sheet 168, line 3, dwelling 94, family 95; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 682.
² Stephen B. Pomeroy household, 1860 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Huntsburg, page 177, line 13, dwelling 1478, family 1396; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 967.

29. ⁹Willis Seymour Metcalf, son of ⁸Ebenezer Metcalf [7] and Louisa Chapin. Born on 26 Oct. 1853 in Ohio.

Married first Hattie Norton on 7 Feb. 1884 in Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio when 30 years old (Hattie was 30 years old). Hattie Norton b. on 13 June 1853 in Pennsylvania; d. on 9 Aug. 1918, 65 years old.

Issue of Willis Seymour Metcalf and Hattie Norton:
i. dau. ¹⁰Garda Metcalf b. on 22 July 1885 in Burton, Geauga County, Ohio; m. Dr. Byron Bartlett Colvin (19 Jan. 1882–) on 1 Jan. 1913 when 27 years old (Dr. Byron Bartlett was 30 years old).

Married second Ada T. _____ in 1919/20 when about 66 years old (Ada T. was about 53 years old). Ada T. _____ b. in 1866/7 in Ohio.

Notes on Willis Seymour Metcalf:

Chapin¹ said Willis Seymour of Youngston, Ohio, son of Eben and Lovica (Chapin) Metcalf, was born on 26 October 1853. He married Hattie Norton on 7 February 1884 in Chardon, Ohio. She was born on 13 June 1853. They had one child. Hattie died on 9 August 1918.

It is not unlikely that Hattie died in the great influenza epidemic.

Willis and his family were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:²

Willis Metcalfe, head of household, white, male, born Oct. 1853, 46, married 16 years, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born Connecticut, [?], reads, writes, speaks English, owns mortgaged home.
Hattie Metcalfe, wife, white, female, born June 1853, 46, married 16 years, one child, one living, born Pennsylvania, father born New York, mother born Massachusetts, reads, writes, speaks English.
Garda Metcalfe, daughter, white, female, born July 1885, 14, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Pennsylvania, at school, attended school within the year, reads, writes, speaks English.

Willis and his second wife were enumerated in the 1930 federal census of Youngstown, Mahoning County, Ohio, as follows:³

Willis Metcalfe, head of household, owns home valued at $12,000, radio set, male, white, 75, married when 65 years old, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio [sic], mother born Ohio [sic], speaks English, lawyer in general practice.
Ada T. Metcalfe, 63, wife, female, white, 63, married when 53 years old, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born England [Isle of Mann struck out], mother born Ohio, speaks English.

_______________
¹ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. II: Eighth to Twelfth Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 1412.
² Willis Metcalfe household, 1900 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Village, enumeration district 44, supervisor’s district 18, sheet 11A, line 14, dwelling 275, family 285; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 1271.
³ Willis Metcalfe household, 1930 U.S. census, Mahoning County, Ohio, population schedule, Youngstown Ward 5, 2937 Hudson Avenue, enumeration district 50-70, supervisor’s district 10, sheet 22B, line 89, dwelling 376, family 428; National Archives micropublication T626, roll 1846.

Issue of Dr. Evert Denton and ⁸Sidney Metcalf [8] (⁷Thomas Metcalf [1])

30. ⁹Richard Evert Denton, son of Dr. Evert Denton and ⁸Sidney Metcalf [8]. Born on 10 Sep. 1826 in Huntsburg, Geauga County, Ohio.

Married Lydia Eliza Melinda Pomeroy, dau. of Stephen Bridgman Pomeroy (son of Stephen Pomeroy and Lydia Bridgman) and Abigail Scott, on 25 Nov. 1857 in Huntsburg when 31 years old (Lydia Eliza Melinda was 20 years old). Lydia Eliza Melinda Pomeroy b. on 6 June 1837 in Huntsburg.

Issue of Richard Evert Denton and Lydia Eliza Melinda Pomeroy:
68   i. son ¹⁰Franklin Evert Denton b. on 22 Nov. 1859 in Huntsburg.
69   ii. son Richard Linwood Denton b. on 17 July 1864 in Huntsburg.
      iii. son Harold Pomeroy Denton b. on 19 Sep. 1866 in Huntsburg; m. Eliza Russell Peachy (1872–).
70   iv. son George Metcalf Denton b. on 1 March 1871 in Huntsburg.

Notes on Richard Evert Denton:

Richard and his family were enumerated in the 1860 federal census of Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:¹

Richard E. Denton, 33, male, painter, real property $350, personal property $150, born Ohio.
Lydia E. Denton, 23, female, born Ohio.
Franklin E. Denton, 6/12, male, born Ohio.

Richard and his family were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:²

Richard E. Denton, white, male, 53, married, printer, born Ohio, father born Massachusetts [sic], mother born Connecticut.
Lydia E. Denton, white, female, 43, wife, married, housekeeper, born Ohio, father born Massachusetts, mother born New York.
Franklin E. Denton, white, male, 20, son, single, painter, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Richard L. Denton, white, male, 15, son, single, printer, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Harold P. Denton, white, male, 13, son, single, printer, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Georgie M. Denton, white, male, 9, son, single, at school, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.

_______________
¹ Richard E. Denton household, 1860 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Village, page 11, sheet 597, line 14, dwelling 94, family 95; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 967.
² Richard E. Denton household, 1880 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Villae, enumeration district 68, supervisor’s district 8, page 3, sheet 36D, line 32, dwelling 27, family 34; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 1018.

Notes on Lydia Eliza Melinda Pomeroy:

Lydia was enumerated in the 1850 federal census of Huntsburgh, Geauga County, Ohio, in the household of her father (whose surname is erroneously given as Brown as confirmed in the 1860 census) as follows:¹

_______________
¹ S. B. Brown household, 1850 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Huntsburgh, sheet 168, line 3, dwelling 94, family 95; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 682.

Issue of Jude Converse and ⁸Sidney Metcalf [8] (⁷Thomas Metcalf [1])

31. ⁹Julius Orrin Converse, son of Jude Converse and ⁸Sidney Metcalf [8]. Born on 1 May 1834 in Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio.

Married Julia Porter Wright, dau. of Daniel H. Wright (son of Daniel Wright and Achsah Clark) and Susan J. Porter, on 24 Sep. 1862 when 28 years old (Julia Porter was 27 years old). Julia Porter Wright b. in 1834/5 in Huntsburg, Geauga County, Ohio.

Issue of Julius Orrin Converse and Julia Porter Wright:
i. dau. ¹⁰Mary Ellen Converse b. in 1863/4 in Chardon.

Notes on Julius Orrin Converse:

A history of Geauga County tells of Julius:¹

. . . on the first day of May, 1834, was born the subject of this sketch. . . . He received the names of his uncle, the governor, and his mother’s younger brother, Orrin. The youngest living child of his mother, and for many years the sole offspring of her happy marriage, he was the idol of his father, and, from the day he could walk till the day when he followed that father to the grave, his almost inseparable companion.
Through infancy and childhood, he came near being a spoiled child. Such qualities, however, will safely pass through a great deal of dangerous petting. While he was yet in early childhood, his father was overtaken by a reverse of fortune, from which, in his own person, he never recovered.
Such education as he received in the forms of school came to him before he was thirteen; an apt child of Sidney Converse would receive a training at home little less than a liberal education. At sixteen he entered, as an apprentice, the printing office of William W. and Eli Bruce, publishers of the Geauga Republic. Here, by the processes which translate a young, plastic, ignorant boy into the expert, intelligent printer, his years multiplied, his form shot upward mostly, the volume of his brain increased, his mind formed, and his character developed. The office of a journalist may be the very best, or the worst possible, of all the places where a man grows, develops and ripens into the fixed forms of character and conduct. . . .
After his novitiate under the Bruces, young Converse worked on the Free Democrat, under Asper. This he followed into the hands of the late J. S. Wright, esq., who changed the name to the Jeffersonian Democrat, where he remained a subordinate till 1859, when he became proprietor and editor of the same journal, and has remained such to the present. In the meantime he studied law, and was admitted in 1858.
The Converses were Whigs, of course, and became Free-soilers and Republicans by natural logic and the law of events. On the election of Mr. Lincoln, he appointed Mr. Converse postmaster at Chardon, and renewed the appointment. This is the only office he ever held. I am not aware that he ever sought office.
It would be supererogation to speek of the Republican to the people of Geauga. As compared with the weekly press of the country, it holds a place with the first. . . .
On the twenty-fourth of December, 1862, he was united in marriage with Julia P., daughter of Daniel H. and Susan P. Wright, of Portage county. . . .
Of these parents, one daughter, Mary, now about fifteen, is the only offspring, who promises to develop in person and mind the advantages of both.
Mr. Converse’s parents have passed away. His father died February 4, 1874, and his mother February 9, 1875.
Mr. Converse has erected a fine and spacious residence on the site of the old homestead, and the family promises to perpetuate the traditions of charity, kindness and love, of the earlier home.

_______________
¹ Historical Society of Geauga County, Pioneer and General History of Geauga County, with Sketches of Some of the Pioneers and Prominent Men, 1798–1880 (no place: Historical Society of Geauga County, 1880), 356–358.

Notes on Julia Porter Wright:

“Mrs. Julia Wright Converse. Born in Huntsburg, Ohio. Wife of Julius O. Converse. . . . Daughter of Daniel H. Wright and Susan J. Porter, his wife. Granddaughter of Daniel Wright and Achsah Clark, his 2nd wife.”¹

_______________
¹ DAR, Lineage Book, Vol. LXIII, 1907, 187, entry 62557.

Issue of Dr. Oliver W. Ludlow and ⁸Harriet Metcalf [9] (⁷Thomas Metcalf [1])

32. ⁹Marie Antoinette Ludlow, dau. of Dr. Oliver W. Ludlow and ⁸Harriet Metcalf [9]. Born on 9 Feb. 1828 in Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio. Died on 11 April 1888, 60 years old.

Married Ransom P. Hodges, son of Joseph Hodges and Electa Clapp. Ransom P. Hodges b. in 1830/1 in New York.

Issue of Marie Antoinette Ludlow and Ransom P. Hodges:
      i. dau. ¹⁰Zuleika Hodges b. in 1861 in Ohio.
      ii. dau. Stella Hodges b. in 1862/3 in Ohio.
71   iii. son William Hodges b. in June 1866 in Ohio.
      iv. dau. Helen Hodges b. in 1868/9 in Ohio.

Notes on Marie Antoinette Ludlow:

Chapin¹ said Marie Antoinette was born on 9 February 1828 and died on 11 April 1888.

A history of Geauga County tells of Maria:²

Maria A., eldest daughter, married Ranson P. Hodges, and they have several children, but we do not know their names. They now reside in Cleveland, Ohio.

Marie and her family were enumerated in the 1870 federal census of East Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, as follows:³

Ransom Hodges, 39, male, white, carpenter and joiner, real property $1800, personal property $400, born Ohio.
Antionette [sic] Hodges, female, white, keeping house, born Ohio.
Zuleika Hodges, 9, female, white, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Stella Hodges, 7, female, white, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
William Hodges, 4, male, white, born Ohio.
Nellie Hodges, 2, female, white, born Ohio.

Marie and her family were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, as follows:⁴

Ransom P. Hodges, white, male, 50, married, carpenter, born New York, father born New York, mother born New York.
Marie Hodges, white, female, 42, wife, married, keeping house, born Ohio, father born New York, mother born Connecticut.
Zula Hodges, white, female, 18, daughter, single, at school, attended school within the year, born Ohio, father born New York, mother born Ohio.
Stella Hodges, white, female, 17, daughter, single, at home, born Ohio, father born New York, mother born Ohio.
Lim Hodges, white, male, 14, son, single, at school, attended school within the year, born Ohio, father born New York, mother born Ohio.
Helen Hodges, white, female, 11, daughter, single, at school, attended school within the year, born Ohio, father born New York, mother born Ohio.

_______________
¹ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. I: First Seven Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 805.
² Historical Society of Geauga County, Pioneer and General History of Geauga County, with Sketches of Some of the Pioneers and Prominent Men, 1798–1880 (no place: Historical Society of Geauga County, 1880), 206.
³ Ransom Hodges household, 1870 U.S. census, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, population schedule, East Cleveland Township, Collamer Post Office, page 104, sheet 311, line 2, dwelling 790, family 788; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 1192.
⁴ Ransom P. Hodges household, 1880 U.S. census, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, population schedule, Cleveland, enumeration district 25, supervisor’s district 6, page 19, sheet 282C, line 16, dwelling 145, family 174; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 1006.

Notes on Ransom P. Hodges:

Ransom was enumerated in the 1850 federal census of Huntgsburg, Geauga County, Ohio, in his father’s household as follows:¹

Joseph Hodges, 50, male, farmer, real property $2000, born New Jersey [sic].
Electa Hodges, 41, female, born Ohio.
Ransom, 19, male, farmer, born New Hampshire [sic].
Milessa Hodges, 17, female, born New Hampshire [sic], attended school within the current year.
Martha Hodges, 8, female, born Ohio, attended school within the current year.
Emerson Hodges, 6, male, born Ohio, attended school within the current year.
Corydon Hodges, 2, male, born Ohio.

(In the 1860 and 1880 censuses, Joseph is listed as born in New York.)

_______________
¹ Joseph Hodges household, 1850 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Huntsburgh Township, sheet 166, line 3, dwelling 56, family 57; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 682.

33. ⁹Linnaeus Charles Ludlow, son of Dr. Oliver W. Ludlow and ⁸Harriet Metcalf [9]. Born on 2 Aug. 1831 in Newbury, Geauga County, Ohio. Died on 24 Nov. 1902, 71 years old.

Married Helen A. Stafford, dau. of Charles Stafford (son of Tile Stafford and Damaris Vaughn) and Martha Smith, in 1857 in Ohio when 25 or 26 years old (Helen A. was 19 or 20 years old). Helen A. Stafford b. in Dec. 1837 in Ohio.

Issue of Linnaeus Charles Ludlow and Helen A. Stafford:
72   i. son ¹⁰William Wallace Ludlow b. in April 1858 in Ohio.
73   ii. son Rev. Arthur Ludlow b. in June 1861 in Ohio.
      iii. dau. Mary L. Ludlow b. in 1867/8 in Ohio.
74   iv. son Linnaeus Charles Ludlow b. in May 1873 in Ohio.
      v. son Dr. Alfred Irving Ludlow b. in Nov. 1875 in Ohio.
      vi. dau. Helen L. Ludlow b. in 1877/8 in Ohio.
75   vii. son Harold Stafford Ludlow b. on 22 April 1886 in Ohio.

Notes on Linnaeus Charles Ludlow:

Chapin¹ said Linnaeus Charles was born on 2 August 1831 and died on 24 November 1902.

A history of Geauga County tells of Linaeus:²

Linaeus C., eldest son of Dr. Oliver W. Ludlow, was born in Newbury, Ohio, came to Auburn with his parents, and in 1857 he married Helen A. Stafford, daughter of Charles Stafford, and they have six children—Wallace, Arthur, May, Linaeus C., Irving, and Helen. Mr. Ludlow resided in Auburn a short time after his marriage, and was then elected to the office of county recorder, two or three terms, and then moved to Cleveland, where he now resides.

His first name also appears as Lucius.

Linnaeus and his family were enumerated in the 1860 federal census of Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:³

Linnaues C. Ludlow, 28, male, recorder, real property $700, personal property $600, born Ohio.
Hellen A. Ludlow, 22, female, born Ohio.
William W. Ludlow, 2, male, born Ohio.

Linnaeus and his family were enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, as follows:⁴

Lucius Ludlow, 38, male, white, hotel keeper, real property $1050, person property $5000, born Ohio.
Helen Ludlow, 32, female, white, keeping house, born Ohio.
Wallace Ludlow, 12, male, white, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Arthur Ludlow, 9, male, white, born Ohio.
Mary Ludlow, 2, female, white, born Ohio.

Linnaeus and his family were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, as follows:⁵

Lineas Ludlow, white, male, 48, married, book keeper, born Ohio, father born New York, mother born Connecticut.
Ellen [sic] A. Ludlow, white, female, 42, wife, married, keeping house, born Ohio, father born New York, mother born Connecticut [sic].
William W. Ludlow, white, male, 22, son, single, book keeper, born Ohio, father born _____, mother born _____.
Arthur Ludlow, white, male, 19, son, single, school, attended school within the year, born Ohio, father born _____, mother born _____.
Mary L. Ludlow, white, female, 12, daughter, school, attended school within the year, born Ohio, father born _____, mother born _____.
Linneas C. Ludlow, white, male, 7, son, school, attended school within the year, born Ohio, father born _____, mother born _____.
Alfred I. Ludlow, white, male, 4, son, born Ohio, father born _____, mother born _____.
Helen L. Ludlow, white, female, 2, daughter, born Ohio, father born _____, mother born _____.
Marah L. Ludlow, white, female, 37, sister, single, assistant, born Ohio, father born New York, mother born Connecticut.
Adel Safford, white, female, 20, cousin, single, visiting, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother born New York.

Linnaeus and his family were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of East Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, as follows:⁶

Linnaus C. Ludlow, head of household, white, male, born Aug. 1831, 68, married 43 years, born Ohio, father born New York, mother born Vermont [sic], reads, writes, speaks English, owns home free of mortgage.
Helen Ludlow, wife, white, female, born Dec. 1834 [sic], [63 struck out] 65, married 43 years, 7 children, 6 living, born Ohio, father born New York, mother born New York [sic], reads, writes, speaks English.
Wallace W. Ludlow, son, white, male, born Apr. 1858, 42, widower, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, book keeper, reads, writes, speaks English.
Linnaus C. Ludlow Jr., son, white, male, born May 1873, 27, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, drives laundry wagon, reads, writes, speaks English.
A. Irving Ludlow, son, white, male, born Nov. 1875, 24, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, at school, attended school within the year, reads, writes, speaks English.
Harold Ludlow, son, white, male, born Apr. 1886, 14, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, at school, attended school within the year, reads, writes, speaks English.
Kate Ludlow, granddaughter, white, female, born Nov. 1883, 16, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Iowa, at school, attended school within the year, reads, writes, speaks English.
Myra Ludlow, granddaughter, white, female, born Apr. 1895, 5, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Iowa.

_______________
¹ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. I: First Seven Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 805.
² Historical Society of Geauga County, Pioneer and General History of Geauga County, with Sketches of Some of the Pioneers and Prominent Men, 1798–1880 (no place: Historical Society of Geauga County, 1880), 206.
³ Linnaues C. Ludlow household, 1860 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Village, page 7, sheet 593, line 19, dwelling 55, family 58; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 967.
⁴ Lucius Ludlow household, 1870 U.S. census, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, population schedule, Cleveland Ward 6, page 187, sheet 94, line 3, dwelling 1424, family 1539; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 1190.
⁵ Lineas Ludlow household, 1880 U.S. census, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, population schedule, Cleveland, enumeration district 21, supervisor’s district 6, page 29, sheet 139A, line 6, dwelling 2380, family 288; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 1006.
⁶ Linnaus C. Ludlow household, 1900 U.S. census, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, population schedule, East Cleveland Township, enumeration district 214, supervisor’s district 19, sheet 9B, line 87, dwelling 179, family 181; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 1260.

Notes on Helen A. Stafford:

Helen was enumerated in the 1850 federal census of Auburn, Geauga County, Ohio, in her father’s household as follows:¹

Charles Stafford, 36, male, blacksmith, born New York.
Martha Stafford, 33, female, born New York.
Helen Stafford, 12, female, born Ohio.
Louisa Stafford, 10. female, born Ohio.
Thomas Hoard, 25, male, blacksmith, born New York.

_______________
¹ Charles Stafford household, 1850 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Auburn Township, sheet 262, line 21, dwelling 126, family 127; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 682.

34. ⁹Benjamin Franklin Ludlow, son of Dr. Oliver W. Ludlow and ⁸Harriet Metcalf [9]. Born on 12 April 1833 in Newbury, Geauga County, Ohio. Died on 20 Oct. 1914, 81 years old.

Married Delia Messenger in 1861/2 when about 28 years old (Delia was about 24 years old). Delia Messenger b. in Aug. 1837 in Ohio.

Issue of Benjamin Franklin Ludlow and Delia Messenger:
      i. dau. ¹⁰Louise Evaline Ludlow b. in 1866 in Ohio.
      ii. son Clement O. Ludlow b. in 1870/1 in Ohio.
      iii. son Oliver L. Ludlow b. in Dec. 1872 in Ohio.

Notes on Benjamin Franklin Ludlow:

Chapin¹ said Benjamin Franklin was born on 12 April 1833 and died on 20 October 1914.

A history of Geauga County tells of Benjamin:²

Benjamin F., second son, was born in Newbury; came to Auburn with his parents, and in 1862 married Delia Messenger, and they have three children—Louis E., Clement O., and Oliver L. Mr. Ludlow resides on the old homestead where his father and mother both died.

Benjamin and his family, including his mother and two siblings, were enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Auburn, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:³

Benjamin and his family were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Auburn, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:⁴

Benjamin F. Ludlow, white, male, 47, married, pulverizer of skams, born Ohio, father born New York, mother born Connecticut.
Delia Ludlow, white, female, 42, wife, married, keeping house, born Ohio, father born _____, mother born _____.
Louise E. Ludlow, white, female, 13, daughter, attending school, attended school within the year, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Clement O. Ludlow, white, male, 9, son, attending school, attended school within the year, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Oliiver H. Ludlow, white, male, 7, son, attending school, attended school within the year, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.

Benjamin and his family were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Auburn, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:⁵

Benjiman F. Ludlow, head of household, white, male, born April 1833, 67, married 38 years, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born New York [sic, father and mother reversed], farmer, reads, writes, speaks English.
Delia Ludlow, wife, white, female, born Aug. 1837, 62, married 38 years, three children all living, born Ohio, father born Massachusetts, mother born Massachusetts, reads, writes, speaks English.
Oliver H. Ludlow, son, white, male, born Aug. 1872, 27, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, reads, writes, speaks English.

_______________
¹ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. I: First Seven Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 805.
² Historical Society of Geauga County, Pioneer and General History of Geauga County, with Sketches of Some of the Pioneers and Prominent Men, 1798–1880 (no place: Historical Society of Geauga County, 1880), 206.
³ Benjamin F. Ludlow household, 1870 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Auburn Township, page 3, sheet 11, line 7, dwelling 20, family 20; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 1204.
⁴ Benjamin F. Ludlow household, 1880 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Auburn Township, enumeration district 65, supervisor’s district 8, page 3, sheet 2C, line 42, dwelling 35, family 35; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 1018.
⁵ Benjamin F. Ludlow household, 1900 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Auburn Township, enumeration district 41, supervisor’s district 18, sheet 1A, line 9, dwelling 3, family 3; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 1271.

35. ⁹Washington Irving Ludlow, son of Dr. Oliver W. Ludlow and ⁸Harriet Metcalf [9]. Born on 18 March 1835 in Newbury, Geauga County, Ohio. Died on 21 Feb. 1916, 80 years old.

Married Florence _____ in 1882/3 when about 47 years old (Florence was about 33 years old). Florence _____ b. in March 1849 in New York.

Issue of Washington Irving Ludlow and Florence _____:
i. dau. ¹⁰Florence M. Ludlow b. in Jan. 1885 in Ohio.

Notes on Washington Irving Ludlow:

Chapin¹ said Washington Irving was born on 18 March 1835 and died on 21 February 1916.

A history of Geauga County tells of Washington:²

Washington I. was born in Newbury, and is, by profession, an inventor, and has obtained over twenty patents of his own inventions. He is probably one of the most successful inventors in the State. Mr. Ludlow is unmarried, and consequently has no particular abiding place; comes to the old homestead, in Auburn, occassionaly, but spends most of his time at other points.

Washington was enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, in the household of his brother Lycurgus as follows:³

Lycurgus Ludlow, white, male, 43, married, janitor, born Ohio, father born New York, mother born Connecticut.
Louisa M. Ludlow, white, female, 35, eife, married, keeping house, born England, father born England, mother born Scotland.
Lycurgus Ludlow Jr., male, white, male, 1, son, single, at home, born Ohio. father born Ohio, mother born England.
Washi G Ludlow, white, male, 45, brother, single, patent rights B[?], born Ohio, father born New York, mother born Connecticut.

The above census was recorded on 7 June 1880. Four or five days later (11/12 June 1880) Washington was enumerated again in the 1880 federal census of Auburn, Geauga County, Ohio, in the household of James Thomas (only Washington given here) as follows:⁴

Washington I. Ludlow, white, male, 46, inventor, born Ohio, father born New York, mother born Connecticut.

Washington and his family were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, as follows:⁵

Washington Ludlow, head of household, white, male, born March 1835, 65, married 17 years, born Ohio, father born New York, mother born Connecticut, Inventor, reads, writes, speaks English, rents home.
Florence Ludlow, wife, white, female, born March 1879, 51, married 17 years, one child, one living, born New York, father born New York, mother born New York, reads, writes, speaks English.
Florence M. Ludlow, daughter, white, female, born Jan. 1885, 15, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born New York, at [school], attended school within the year, reads, writes, speaks English.

_______________
¹ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. I: First Seven Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 805.
² Historical Society of Geauga County, Pioneer and General History of Geauga County, with Sketches of Some of the Pioneers and Prominent Men, 1798–1880 (no place: Historical Society of Geauga County, 1880), 206.
³ Lycurgus Ludlow household, 1880 U.S. census, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, population schedule, Cleveland, 390 Prospect Street, enumeration district 17, supervisor’s district 6, sheet 10C, line 20, dwelling 135, family 138; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 1006.
⁴ James Thomas household, 1880 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Auburn Township, enumeration district 65, supervisor’s district 8, page 8, sheet 4D, line 46, dwelling 92, family 92; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 1018.
⁵ Washington Ludlow household, 1900 U.S. census, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, population schedule, Cleveland Ward 7, 155 Windsor Avenue, enumeration district 29, supervisor’s district 19, sheet 13B, line 92, dwelling 218, family 271; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 1252.

36. ⁹Lycurgus C. Ludlow, son of Dr. Oliver W. Ludlow and ⁸Harriet Metcalf [9]. Born on 17 May 1837 in Newbury, Geauga County, Ohio. Died on 15 Aug. 1915, 78 years old.

Married Louisa M. _____ in 1870/1 when about 33 years old (Louisa M. was about 23 years old). Louisa M. _____ b. in Jan. 1847 in England.

Issue of Lycurgus C. Ludlow and Louisa M. _____:
i. son ¹⁰Lycurgus Ludlow b. in 1879/80 in Ohio; d. before 1900, at most 19 years old.

Notes on Lycurgus C. Ludlow:

Chapin¹ said Lycurgus was born on 17 May 1837 and died on 15 August 1915. (He was named after the founder of Sparta who lived circa 800 B.C.)

A history of Geauga County tells of Lycurgus:²

Lycurgus married in Cleveland several years since, and now resides in that city.

Lycurgus, his family and brother Washington were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, as follows:³

Lycurgus and his wife were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, as follows:⁴

Lycurgus Ludlow, head of household, white, male, born May 1837, 63, married 30 years, born Ohio, father born New York, mother born Connecticut, night watchman, reads, writes, speaks English, rents home.
Louise Ludlow, wife, white, female, born Jan. 1847, 53, married 30 years, four children none living, born England, father born England, mother born England, emigrated in 1870, in U.S. 30 years, reads, writes, speaks English.

Lycurgus and his wife were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, as follows:⁵

Lycurgus Ludlow, head of household, male, white, 72, married once for 39 years, born Ohio, father born New York, mother born Connecticut, speaks English, draftsman in iron works, works for wages, reads, writes, rents home.
Louisa M. Ludlow, wife, female, white, 65, married once for 39 years, three children none living, born England - English, father born England - English, mother born Scotland - Gaelic, immigrated in 1870, speaks English, reads, writes.

_______________
¹ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. I: First Seven Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 805.
² Historical Society of Geauga County, Pioneer and General History of Geauga County, with Sketches of Some of the Pioneers and Prominent Men, 1798–1880 (no place: Historical Society of Geauga County, 1880), 206.
³ Lycurgus Ludlow household, 1880 U.S. census, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, population schedule, Cleveland, 390 Prospect Street, enumeration district 17, supervisor’s district 6, sheet 10C, line 20, dwelling 135, family 138; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 1006.
⁴ Lycurgus Ludlow household, 1900 U.S. census, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, population schedule, Cleveland Ward 21, 1634 Cedar Avenue, enumeration district 103, supervisor’s district 19, sheet 5A, line 13, dwelling 91, family 105; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 1255.
⁵ Lycurgus Ludlow household, 1910 U.S. census, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, population schedule, Cleveland Ward 23, enumeration district 326, supervisor’s district 19, sheet 2A, line 14, dwelling 19, family 28; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 1174.

37. ⁹Harriet Ella Ludlow, dau. of Dr. Oliver W. Ludlow and ⁸Harriet Metcalf [9]. Born on 20 Oct. 1847 in Auburn, Geauga County, Ohio. Died on 1 Feb. 1888 in Burton, Geauga County, Ohio, 40 years old.

Married William Henry Reed, son of Anson Reed and Tryphena _____, on 1 Jan. 1867 in Burton when 19 years old (William Henry was 20 years old). William Henry Reed b. on 21 Aug. 1846, of Newbury, Geauga County, Ohio.

Issue of Harriet Ella Ludlow and William Henry Reed:
76   i. dau. ¹⁰Lou Ella Reed b. on 30 March 1869 in South Newbury, Geauga County, Ohio.
      ii. dau. Minnie Tryphena Reed b. on 8 May 1873 in Burton; d. on 2 July 1914, 41 years old.
77   iii. son Henry Hayes Reed b. on 12 June 1876 in Burton.
78   iv. son Ernest Waring Reed b. on 8 Nov. 1881 in Burton.
      v. dau. Florence Adele Reed b. on 3 May 1884 in Burton.

Notes on Harriet Ella Ludlow:

Chapin¹ said Harriet Ella, daughter of Dr. Oliver W. and Harriet (Metcalf) Ludlow, was born on 20 October 1847 in Auburn, Ohio. She married William Henry Reed on 1 January 1867 in Burton, Ohio. He was born on 21 August 1846. They had five children. Harriet died on 1 February 1888 in Burton.

A history of Geauga County tells of Harriet:²

Harriet E., third daughter, married William H. Reed, of Newbury. They have several children, but we do not know their names. They reside in Burton, Ohio, and Mr. Reed is engaged in carrying mail.

Harriet and her family were enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Newbury, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:³

Henry Reed, 23, male, white, farmer, personal property $500, born Ohio.
Ella Reed, 22, female, white, keeping house, born Ohio.
Louie Reed, 1, female, white, born Ohio.
James Waterton, 16, male, white, farm laborer, born Ohio, attended school within the year, cannot write.

Harriet and her family were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Burton, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:⁴

Henry W. Reed, white, male, 33, married, U.S. mail carrier, born Ohio, father born Massachusetts, mother born Massachusetts.
Ella H. Reed, white, female, 32, wife, married, keeping house, born Ohio, father born New York, mother born Connecticut.
Louie E. Reed, white, female 11, daughter, at school, attended school within the year, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Minnie B. Reed, white, female, 7. daughter, at school, attended school within the year, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Henry H. Reed, white, male, 4, son, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Wilbur Coe, white, male, 21, servant, single, hack driver, born Michigan, father born Connecticut, mother born Ohio.
Fred Slitor, white, male, 16, servant, single, hostler, attended school within the year, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.

_______________
¹ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. II: Eighth to Twelfth Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 1412.
² Historical Society of Geauga County, Pioneer and General History of Geauga County, with Sketches of Some of the Pioneers and Prominent Men, 1798–1880 (no place: Historical Society of Geauga County, 1880), 206.
³ Henry Reed household, 1870 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Newbury Township, page 7, sheet 259, line 14, dwelling 62, family 62; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 1204.
⁴ Henry W. Reed household, 1880 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Burton Village, enumeration district 67, supervisor’s district 8, page 8, sheet 20A, line 42, dwelling 79, family 90; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 1018.

Notes on William Henry Reed:

Henry was enumerated in the 1850 federal census of Newbury, Geauga County, Ohio, in his father’s household as follows:¹

Anson Reed, 43, male, farmer, born Massachusetts.
T. Reed, 38, female, born Massachusetts.
H. Reed, 15, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
B. Reed, 12, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
S. Reed, 10, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
M. Reed, 8, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
C. Reed, 6, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
H. Reed, 4, male born Ohio.
O. A. Reed, 1, female, born Ohio.
Jane Zephuuir, 16, female. born Ohio.

Henry is the H. Reed, age 4.

Henry was enumerated in the 1860 federal census of Newbury, Geauga County, Ohio, in his mother’s household as follows:²

Triphena Reed, 46, female, farming, real property $4440, personal property $400, born Massachusetts.
Bethia Reed, 22, female, milliner, born Ohio.
Mary Reed, 17, female, millinier, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Charles T. Reed, 15, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
William H. Read, 13, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Augusta D. Reed, 11, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Ella Reed, 9, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Levi Reed, 50, male, [?] currier, real property $40, born Massachusetts.
Lucinda Reed, 19, female, born Massachusetts, married within the year.

_______________
¹ Anson Reed household, 1850 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Newbury Township, sheet 273, line 3, dwelling 66, family 66; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 682.
² Triphena Reed household, 1860 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, South Newbury, sheet 907, line 32, dwelling 72, family 67; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 967.

38. ⁹Oliver Ellis Ludlow, son of Dr. Oliver W. Ludlow and ⁸Harriet Metcalf [9]. Born on 23 Dec. 1849 in Auburn, Geauga County, Ohio.

Married Eliza S. Richards, dau. of Gilbert A. Richards and Mehitable B. _____, in 1876/7 when about 27 years old (Eliza S. was about 24 years old). Eliza S. Richards b. in Sep. 1852 in Auburn; d. before 1930, at most 77 years old.

Issue of Oliver Ellis Ludlow and Eliza S. Richards:
79   i. son ¹⁰Hoyt G. Ludlow b. on 9 Nov. 1878 in Auburn.
      ii. son Oliver Wick Ludlow b. in Nov. 1881 in Burton, Geauga County, Ohio.
80   iii. son Day Lorin Ludlow b. on 10 Nov. 1884 in Burton.
      iv. son Rex Ellis Ludlow b. on 29 Nov. 1886 in Burton; m. Agnes B. _____ (1883/4 in Ohio–) in 1909/10 when about 23 years old (Agnes B. was about 26 years old).
      v. dau. Belle E. Ludlow b. in May 1890 in Burton; m. Robert N. Sturkey (1884/5 in Ohio–) in 1926/7 when about 36 years old (Robert N. was about 42 years old).
      vi. son Kress Vern Ludlow b. on 7 Dec. 1893 in Burton; d. on 9 Dec. 1966 in Lakewood, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, 73 years old; m. Lulu May Drake (6 Sep. 1900 in Ohio–1 May 1980 in Wooster, Wayne County, Ohio), dau. of Clinton Alva Drake and Laura C. May (dau. of John May and Sophia Miller), in 1929 when 35 or 36 years old (Lulu May was 28 or 29 years old).
      vii. dau. Leah J. Ludlow b. in June 1897 in Burton.

Notes on Oliver Ellis Ludlow:

Chapin¹ sad Oliver Ellis was born on 23 December 1849

A history of Geauga County tells of Oliver:²

Oliver E. Ludlow was born in Auburn; was married in 1876 to Eliza Richards, daughter of Gilbert A. Richards, and they have one son—Hoyt. They now reside on the farm formerly owned by Lorin Snow.

Oliver and his family were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Auburn, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:³

Oliver E. Ludlow, white, male, 30, married, farmer, born Ohio, father born New York, mother born Connecticut.
Eliza S. Ludlow, white, female, 27, wife, married, keeping house, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Hoyt G. Ludlow, white, male, 1, son, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.

Oliver and his family were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Burton, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:⁴

Oliver E. Ludlow, head of household, white, male, born Dec. 1849, 50, married 23 years, born Ohio, father born New York, mother born Connecticut, day laborer, reads, writes, speaks English, rents home.
Eliza S. Ludlow, wife, white, female, Sep. 1852, 47, married 23 years, seven children all living, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, reads, writes, speaks English.
Oliver W. Ludlow, son, white, male, born Nov. 1891, 18, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, day laborer, reads, writes, speaks English.
Day L. Ludlow, son, white, male, born Nov. 1884, 15, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, at school, attended school within the year, reads, writes, speaks English.
Rex E. Ludlow, son, white, male, born Nov. 1886, 13, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, at school, attended school within the year, reads, writes, speaks English.
Belle E. Ludlow, daughter, white, female, born May 1890, 10, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, at school, attended school within the year, reads, writes, speaks English.
Kress V. Ludlow, son, white, male, born Dec. 1893, 6, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, at school, attended school within the year.
Leah J. Ludlow, daughter, white, female, born June 1897, 2, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.

Oliver and his family were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Burton, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:⁵

Oliver S. Ludlow, head of household, male, white, 60, married one for 33 years, born Ohio, father born New York, mother born Connecticut, speaks English, retail merchant in gents furnishing, works on own account, reads, writes, owns mortgaged home.
Eliza S. Ludlow, wife, female, white, 57, married once for 33 years, seven children all living, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, reads, writes.
O. Wick Ludlow, son, male, white, 28, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, packer of [maple?] products, works for wages, reads, writes.
Belle E. Ludlow, daughter, female, white, 19, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, operator in telephone exchange, works for wages, reads, writes.
Kress V. Ludlow, son, male, white, 16, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, reads, writes, attended school within the year.
Leah Ludlow, daughter, female, white, 12, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, reads, writes, attended school within the year.

Oliver and his family were enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Burton, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows (three boarding families not included):⁶

Oliver E. Ludlow, head of household, owns home free of mortgage, male, white, 70, married, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Connecticut [sic], mother born Connecticut, speaks English, laborer in syrup house, works for wages.
Eliza S. Ludlow, wife, female, white, 68, married, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, [at] home.
Beth [sic, Belle] E. Ludlow, daughter, female, white, 29, single, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, telephone operator.
Kress V. Ludlow, son, male, white, 26, singles, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, clerk in [grocery?] store.
Leah J. Ludlow, daughter, female, white, 23, single, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, teacher in public school.

Oliver was enumerated in the 1930 federal census of Burton, Geauga County, Ohio, in the household of their daughter Belle as follows:⁷

Robert N. Sturkey, head of household, owns home valued at $2600, radio set, male, white, 45, married first when 22 years old, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, janitor in a school, works for wages, employed.
Belle L. Sturkey, wife, female, white, 39, married first when 36 years old, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
Oliver E. Ludlow, father-in-law, male, white, 80, widower, married first when 27 years old, reads and writes, born Ohio, fathe born New York, mother born Connecticut, speaks English.
Ellis Ludlow, nephew-in-law, male, white, 12, single, attended school within the year, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English.

_______________
¹ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. I: First Seven Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 805.
² Historical Society of Geauga County, Pioneer and General History of Geauga County, with Sketches of Some of the Pioneers and Prominent Men, 1798–1880 (no place: Historical Society of Geauga County, 1880), 206.
³ Oliver E. Ludlow household, 1880 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Auburn Township, enumeration district 65, supervisor’s district 8, page 3, sheet 2C, line 13, dwelling 28, family 28; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 1018.
⁴ Oliver E. Ludlow household, 1900 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Burton Village, enumeration district 43, supervisor’s district 18, sheet 6A, line 32, dwelling 99, family 103; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 1271.
⁵ Oliver S. Ludlow household, 1910 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Burton, enumeration district 54, supervisor’s district 18, sheet 6A, line 14, dwelling 5, family 6; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 1185.
⁶ Oliver E. Ludlow household, 1920 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Burton Township, Hotchkiss Street, enumeration district 61, supervisor’s district 18, sheet 9B, line 86, dwelling 248, family 249; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 1385.
⁷ Robert N. Sturkey household, 1930 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Burton Township, Hotchkiss Street, enumeration district 28-3, supervisor’s district 5, sheet 4A, line 22, dwelling 109, family 114; National Archives micropublication T626, roll 1803.

Notes on Eliza S. Richards:

Eliza was enumerated in the 1860 federal census of Auburn, Geauga County, Ohio, in the household of her father as follows:¹

G. A. Richards, 34, male, farmer, real property $5000, personal property $1480, born Ohio.
M. Richards, 31, female, born Ohio.
E. Richards, 7, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
E. Richards, 5, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
L. Richards, 5/12, male, born Ohio.

Eliza was enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Auburn, Geauga County, Ohio, in the household of her father as follows:²

Gilbert A. Richards, 44, male, white, farmer, real property $17,000, personal property $3000, born Ohio.
Mahitable B. Richards, 41, female, white, keeping house, born Ohio.
Eliza Richards, 17, female, white, school teacher, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Ella Richards, 15, female, white, at home, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Lorin Richards, 11, male, white, at school, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Gay Allshouse, 20, male, white, farm laborer, born Ohio.

_______________
¹ G. A. Richards household, 1860 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Auburn Township, page 49, line 12, dwelling 395, family 369; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 967.
² Gilbert A. Richards household, 1870 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Auburn Township, page 5, sheet 12, line 36, dwelling 44, family 44; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 1204.

Issue of ⁸George A. Metcalf [10] (⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and Mary Ann Sikes

39. ⁹Mary Eliza Metcalf, dau. of ⁸George A. Metcalf [10] and Mary Ann Sikes. Born on 11 Jan. 1832 in Geauga County, Ohio. Died in 1911 in Omar, Seneca County, Ohio, 78 or 79 years old.

Married first John B. Crall on 14 April 1851 in Richland County when 19 years old (John B. was 25 years old). John B. Crall b. in 1825/6 in Pennsylvania; d. in 1857 in Seneca County, 31 years old.

Issue of Mary Eliza Metcalf and John B. Crall:
81   i. son ¹⁰John B. Crall b. on 22 June 1853 in Ohio.
      ii. child _____ Crall b. say in 1855 in Ohio; d. young.
      iii. child _____ Crall b. say in 1857 in Ohio; d. young.

Married second John J. Haller say in 1859 in Ohio when 26 or 27 years old (John J. was 37 years old). John J. Haller b. in 1821/2 in Switzerland; d. in 1911 in Ohio, 89 years old.

Issue of Mary Eliza Metcalf and John J. Haller:
82   iv. dau. ¹⁰Lue Netta Haller b. in Sep. 1860 in Ohio.
83   v. dau. Mary Belle E. Haller b. on 30 Nov. 1862 in Ohio.
      vi. dau. Ella A. Haller b. in 1864/5 in Ohio.
      vii. son Edward A. Haller b. in May 1866 in Ohio; m. Maude E. Bates (1875/6 in Ohio–) in 1908 when 41 or 42 years old (Maude E. was 32 years old).
      viii. son George R. Haller b. in 1866/7 in Ohio.
      ix. child _____ Haller b. say in 1869/70 in Ohio; d. in infancy.
      x. dau. Kitty M. Haller b. in 1871/2 in Ohio.
84   xi. son Frank M. Haller b. in Jan. 1874 in Ohio.

Notes on Mary Eliza Metcalf:

Ohio Marriages, 1803–1900, lists the marriage of Mary E. Metcalf and J. B. Crall on 14 April 1851 in Richland County.

Mary and her family by her second husband John Haller were enumerated in the 1860 federal census of Celina, Mercer County, Ohio, as follows:¹

John Heller, 36, male, master cabinet maker, real property $300, personal property $900, born Switzerland.
Mary Heller, 27, female, born Ohio.
John Heller, 6, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Carnah Dobleman, 24, male, cabinet maker, born France.
George Keaster, 18, male, apprentice, born Ohio.

Mary and her family by her second husband John Haller were enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Liberty, Mercer County, Ohio, as follows:²

John J. Heller, 49, male, white, saw miller, real property $1000, personal property $1800, born Switzerland, father and mother of foreign birth.
Mary Heller, 28, female, white, keeps house, born Ohio.
John Heller, 16, male, white, attends school, born Ohio, father of foreign birth, attended school within the current year.
Lue Netta Heller, 9, female, white, attends school, born Ohio, father of foreign birth, attended school within the current year.
Belle Heller, 7, female, white, attends school, born Ohio, father of foreign birth, attended school within the current year.
Edgar Heller, 5, male, white born Ohio, father of foreign birth.

Mary and her family by her second husband John Haller were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Liberty, Mercer County, Ohio, as follows:³

John J. Haller, white, male, 58, married, farmer, born Switzerland, father born Switzerland, mother born Switzerland.
Mary Haller, white, female, 48, wife, married, keeping house, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born Massachusetts.
Eddie Haller, white, male, 16, son, single, attended school within the year, born Ohio, father born Switzerland, mother born Ohio.
Ella A. Haller, white, female, 15, daughter, single, attended school within the year, born Ohio, father born Switzerland, mother born Ohio.
George R. Haller, white, male, 13, son, single, works on farm, attended school within the year, born Ohio, father born Switzerland, mother born Ohio.
Kittie [?] Haller, white, female, 8, daughter, single, attended school within the year, born Ohio, father born Switzerland, mother born Ohio.
Frank M. Haller, white, male, 6, son, single, attended school within the year, born Ohio, father born Switzerland, mother born Ohio.

Mary, her son Edward and grandaughter Edna were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Missouri Valley, Harrison County, Iowa, as follows:⁴

Mary E. Haller, head of household, white, female, born Jan. 1832, 68, widow, 11 children, 8 living, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born Massachusetts, housekeeper, reads, writes, speaks English, owns [mortgaged?] home.
Edward A. Haller, son, white, male, born May 1866, 34, single, born Ohio, father born Switzerland, mother born Ohio, boiler maker, reads, writes, speaks English.
Edward Tucker, lodger, white, male, born Mar. 1872, 28, single, born Ohio, father born Kentucky, mother born Kentucky, boiler maker helper, reads, writes, speaks English.
Edna M. Haller, granddaughter, white, female, born Oct. 1891, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, at school, attended school within the year.

_______________
¹ John Heller household, 1860 U.S. census, Mercer County, Ohio, population schedule, Celina, Jefferson Township, page 133, sheet 429, line 26, dwelling 906, family 909; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 1009.
² John J. Heller household, 1870 U.S. census, Mercer County, Ohio, population schedule, Liberty Township, Celina Post Office, page 10, sheet 146, line 35, dwelling 73, family 67; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 1243.
³ John J. Haller household, 1880 U.S. census, Mercer County, Ohio, population schedule, Liberty Township, enumeration district 188, supervisor’s district 2, page 10, sheet 475B, line 45, dwelling 85, family 88; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 1048.
⁴ Mary E. Haller household, 1900 U.S. census, Harrison County, Iowa, population schedule, Missouri Valley City Ward 3, Michigan Street, enumeration district 88, supervisor’s district 9, sheet 10B, line 75, dwelling 220, family 223; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 436.

Notes on John B. Crall:

John appears to be enumerated in the 1850 federal census of Venice Township, Seneca County, Ohio, residing in an inn headed by John Shade, innkeeper, as follows (only John given here):¹

John B. Craul, 24, male, born Ohio.

It is likely his parents were born in Pennsylvania based on the surnames Craul, Crall and Krall.

John died prior to the 1860 census, but his son John B. (Jr.) was enumerated in St. John, Harrison County, Iowa, in 1900, and in Freeman Township, Spokane County, Washington, in 1910. John B. (Jr.) was recorded as born in Ohio in June 1853, his father in Pennsylvania (rather’s parents) and his mother in Connecticut (mother’s parents).

Harry B., son of John B. (Jr.) was enumerated in Deming, Whatcom County, Washington, in 1920, and in Port Angelus, Clallam County, Washington, in 1930, where John B. (Jr.) is said to have died in 1939.

_______________
¹ John Shade household, 1850 U.S. census, Seneca County, Ohio, population schedule, Venice Township Township, sheet 82, line 17, dwelling 461, family 473; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 728.

40. ⁹Lucretia S. Metcalf, dau. of ⁸George A. Metcalf [10] and Mary Ann Sikes. Born on 10 Oct. 1833 in Seneca County, Ohio. Died on 11 July 1888 in St. Louis, Missouri, 54 years old.

Married Dr. William S. Wortman on 16 Oct. 1851 in Richland County when 18 years old (Dr. William S. was 22 years old). Dr. William S. Wortman b. in 1828/9 in Ohio.

Issue of Lucretia S. Metcalf and Dr. William S. Wortman:
      i. son ¹⁰Albert Wortman b. in 1852 in Ohio.
      ii. dau. Mary Isabelle Wortman b. in 1853/4 in Ohio.
      iii. dau. Ella Wortman b. in 1854/5 in Ohio; m. John Huseman (1849/50 in Pennsylvania–).
      iv. dau. Carrie Wortman b. in 1862 in Ohio.
      v. dau. Myrtle Wortman b. in 1872/3 in Missouri.

Notes on Lucretia S. Metcalf:

Ohio Marriages, 1803–1900, lists the marriage of Lucretia S. Metcalf and W. L. Wortman on 16 October 1851 in Richland County.

Lucretia and her family were enumerated in the 1860 federal census of Ridgefield, Huron County, Ohio, as follows:¹

Wm. S. Wortman, 31, male, physician, real property $8000, personal property $1000, born Ohio.
Lucretia Wortman, 26, female, born Ohio.
Issabell Wortman, 6, female, born Ohio, attended school wihin the year.
Albert Wortman, 5, male, born Ohio, attended school wihin the year.
Ella Wortman, 5, female, born Ohio.
Eva Wortman, 13, female, born Ohio.

Lucretia and her family were enumerated in the 1870 federal census of St. Louis, Missouri, as follows:²

Wm. Wortman, 41, male, white, physician, real property $22,000, personal property $5000, born Ohio.
Lucretia Wortman, 36, female, white, keeps house, born Ohio.
Albert Wortman, 17, male, white, at school, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Mary Wortman, 16, female, white, at school, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Ella Wortman, 15, female, white, at school, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Carrie Wortman, 7, female, white, at school, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Rachel Allen, 35, female, white, housekeeper, born Indiana.

Lucretia and her family were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of St. Louis, Missouri, as follows:³

Wm. Wortman, white, male, 51, married, doctor, born Ohio, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Pennsylvania.
Lucretia Wortman, white, female, 47, wife, married, keep house, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born Connecticut.
Bell Wortman, white, female, 26, daughter, single, at home, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Carrie Wortman, white, female, 18, daughter, single, at home, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Myrtle Wortman, white, female, 7, daughter, single, at school, attended school within the year, born Missouri, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.

The St. Louis City Death Records, 1850–1908, list Lucretia S. Wortman, died 11 July 1888, 1302 Olive, vol. 22, p. 308, county library RDSL 31, Missouri Archive C 10387, SLGS Rolls 322.

_______________
¹ Wm S. Wortman household, 1860 U.S. census, Huron County, Ohio, population schedule, Ridgefield Township, Monroeville Post Office, page 347, sheet 170, line 33, dwelling 2789, family 2615; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 990.
² Wm. Wortman household, 1870 U.S. census, St. Louis (Independent City), Missouri, population schedule, St. Louis Ward 11, page 37, sheet 427, line 24, dwelling 177, family 278; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 821.
³ Wm. Wortman household, 1880 U.S. census, St. Louis (Independent City), Missouri, population schedule, St. Louis, enumeration district 7, supervisor’s district 1, page 16, sheet 16D, line 19, dwelling 148, family 199; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 717.

41. ⁹Gilbert A. Metcalf, son of ⁸George A. Metcalf [10] and Mary Ann Sikes. Born on 23 April 1835 in Seneca County, Ohio. Died on 20 April 1909 in Ashland County, 73 years old.

Married Sarah Anne Cox, dau. of George Cox (son of Joseph Cox and Margaret _____) and Hannah _____, on 23 April 1857 in Richland County when 22 years old (Sarah Anne was 21 years old). Sarah Anne Cox b. in Nov. 1835 in Ohio.

Issue of Gilbert A. Metcalf and Sarah Anne Cox:
      i. dau. ¹⁰Ida M. Metcalf b. in 1857/8 in Ohio; d. before 1900, at most 41 years old.
85   ii. son Charles A. Metcalf b. in 1860/1 in Ohio.
86   iii. son William Ludlow Metcalf b. in June 1864 in Ohio.

Notes on Gilbert A. Metcalf:

Ohio Marriages, 1803–1900, lists the marriage of Gilbert A. Metcalf and Sarah Ann Cox on 23 April 1857 in Richland County.

Gilbert and his family were enumerated in the 1860 federal census of Sharon Township, Richland County, Ohio, in the household of Sarah’s grandfather Joseph as follows:¹

Joseph Cox, 78, male, farmer, real property $9000, personal property $400, born Virginia.
Marget Cox, 71, female, born Pennsylvania.
Sarah Metcalf, 24, female, born Ohio.
Gilbert Metcalf, 25, male, born Ohio.
Ida Metcalf, 2, female, born Ohio.
George Lee, 16, male, born Ohiio, attended school within the year.

Gilbert and his family were enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Shelby, Richland County, Ohio, as follows:²

Gilbert A. Metcalf, 35, male, white, livery keeper, real property $1000, born Ohio.
Sarah A. Metcalf, 34, female, white, keeping house, born Ohio.
Ida M. Metcalf, 12, female, white, at home, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Charles R. Metcalf, 10, male, white, at home, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Willie S. Metcalf, 6, male, white, at home, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
William Metcalf, 21, male, black, works in livery stable, born Ohio.

Sarah and her children were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Reed Township, Seneca County, Ohio, as follows:³

Sarah Metcalf, white, female, 43, married, keeping house, born Ohio, father born Virginia, mother born Pennsylvania.
Ida Metcalf, white, female, 22, daughter, single, house keeping, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Oho.
William, white, male, 17, son, single, attended school within the year, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.

Sarah was enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Reed, Seneca County, Ohio, in the household of her son William as follows:⁴

William Metcalf, head of household, white, male, born June 1864, 35, married 14 years, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, farmer, reads, writes, speaks English, rents farm.
Eva Metcalf, wife, white, female, born Sept. 1966, 33, married 14 years, four children, four living, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, reads, writes, speaks English.
Frank Metcalf, son, white, male, born Feb. 1887, 13, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, at school, attended school within the year, reads, writes, speaks English.
Arlington Metcalf, son, white, male, born Sept. 1889, 10, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, at school, attended school within the year, reads, writes, speaks English.
Don Metcalf, son, white, male, born Oct. 1891, 8, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Jessie Metcalf, son, white, male, born Feb. 1898, 1, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Sarah Metcalf, mother, white, female, born Nov. 1835, 64, married, three children, two living, born Ohio, father born Virginia, mother born Pennsylvania, reads, writes, speaks English.

Gilbert was enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Toledo, Lucas County, Ohio, as a patient in the Toledo State Hospital as follows (only Gilbert is shown below):⁵

Gilbert A. Metcalf, white, male, born April 1835, 65, married 43 years, born Ohio, father born Massachusetts, mother born Massachusetts, reads, writes, speaks English.

_______________
¹ Joseph Cox household, 1860 U.S. census, Richland County, Ohio, population schedule, Sharon Township, shelby Post Office, page 264, sheet 132 (continued on the next sheet), line 37, dwelling 1862, family 1872; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 1028.
² Gilbert A. Metcalf household, 1870 U.S. census, Richland County, Ohio, population schedule, Shelby Village, page 18, sheet 315, line 8, dwelling 149, family 149; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 1261.
³ Sarah Metcalf household, 1880 U.S. census, Seneca County, Ohio, population schedule, Reed, enumeration district 207, sheet 227B, line 32, dwelling 54, family 59; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 1065.
⁴ William Metcalf household, 1900 U.S. census, Seneca County, Ohio, population schedule, Reed Township, enumeration district 115, supervisor’s district 12, sheet 13B, line 81, dwelling 276, family 283; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 1320.
⁵ Gilbert A. Metcalf household, 1900 U.S. census, Lucas County, Ohio, population schedule, Toledo, Toledo State Hospital, enumeration district 113, supervisor’s district 8, sheet 15B, line 86, dwelling 1, family 1; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 1299.

Notes on Sarah Anne Cox:

Sarah was enumerated in the 1850 federal census of Sharon Township, Richland County, Ohio, in the household of Sarah’s grandfather Joseph as follows:¹

Joseph Cox, 66, male, farmer, real property $4000, born Virginia.
Margarett Cox, 60, female, born Virginia.
Sarah Ane Cox, 14, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
John See, 5, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.

Sarah’s father George was enumerated on the same sheet as follows:²

George Cox, 40, male, real property $2000, born Virginia.
Hannah Cox, 36, female, born Pennsylvania.
Joseph Cox, 12, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Catharine Cox, 10. female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
David Cox, 6, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Charles Cox, 2, male, born Ohio.
Elizabeth Cox, 1/12, female, born Ohio.

_______________
¹ Joseph Cox household, 1850 U.S. census, Richland County, Ohio, population schedule, Sharon Township, sheet 352, line 36, dwelling 178, family 178; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 724.
² George Cox household, 1850 U.S. census, Richland County, Ohio, population schedule, Sharon Township, sheet 352, line 22, dwelling 175, family 175; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 724.

42. ⁹Orin E. Metcalf, son of ⁸George A. Metcalf [10] and Mary Ann Sikes. Born on 6 Jan. 1837 in Seneca County, Ohio.

Married first Sarah J. McManigal, dau. of James McManigal and Eliza A. _____, on 4 Oct. 1857 in Seneca County when 20 years old (Sarah J. was 15 years old). Sarah J. McManigal b. in 1841/2 in Ohio.

Issue of Orin E. Metcalf and Sarah J. McManigal:
i. dau. ¹⁰Mary E. Metcalf b. in 1860/1 in Ohio.

Married second Elizabeth Douglas, dau. of James Douglas and Mary _____, on 29 Jan. 1864 in Richland County when 27 years old (Elizabeth was 19 years old). Elizabeth Douglas b. in April 1844 in England.

Issue of Orin E. Metcalf and Elizabeth Douglas:
87   ii. son ¹⁰George D. Metcalf b. in 1863/4 in Ohio.
      iii. child _____ Metcalf b. say in 1865/6 in Ohio; d. young.
      iv. child _____ Metcalf b. say in 1867/8 in Ohio; d. young.
      v. dau. Mirta D. Metcalf b. in 1869/70 in Ohio.
88   vi. son Welby J. Metcalf b. in 1871/2 in Ohio.
      vii. child _____ Metcalf b. say in 1873/4 in Ohio; d. young.
      viii. dau. Ida Bell Metcalf b. in Aug. 1877 in Ohio.

Notes on Orin E. Metcalf:

Ohio Marriages, 1803–1900, lists the marriage of Orin E. Metcalf and Sarah McManigal on 4 October 1857 in Seneca County, and the marriage of Orrin E. Metcalf and Elizabeth Douglass on 29 January 1864 in Richland County.

Orin was not found in the 1860 federal census.

Orin and his family by his second wife Elizabeth were enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Mill Creek, Williams County, Ohio, as follows:¹

Oren Metcalf, 33, male, white, farmer, real property $2000, personal property $500. born Ohio.
Elisabeth Metcalf, 24 [sic, 26], female, white, keeping house, born England, both parents of foreign birth.
Mary E. Metcalf, 9, female, white, attending school, born Ohio, mother of foreign birth [sic], attended school within the current year.
George Metcalf, 6, male, white, attending school, born Ohio, mother of foreign birth [sic], attended school within the current year.
Mertie Metcalf, 1, female, white, born Ohio, mother of foreign birth.
George Wagner, 26, male, white, farm laborer, born Ohio.

Orin and his family by his second wife Elizabeth were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Wright Township, Hillsdale County, Michigan, as follows:²

Orin E. Metcalf, white, male, 42, married, farmer, born Ohio, father born Ohio [sic], mother born Ohio [sic].
Elizabeth Metcalf, white, female, 36, wife, married, keeping house, born England, father born England, mother born England.
George D. Metcalf, white, male, 16, son, single, works on farm, attended school within the year, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born England.
Mirta D. Metcalf, white, female, 10, daughter, single, helps kee house, attended school within the year, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born England.
Welby J. Metcalf, white, male, 8, son, single, [attended school within the year struck out], born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born England.

Orin and his second wife Elizabeth were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Missouri Valley, Harrison County, Iowa, as follows:³

Orin E. Metcalf, head of household, white, male, born Jan. 1837, married 38 [sic] years, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born Massachusetts, carpenter, reads, writes, speaks English, owns mortgaged home.
Bessie Metcalf, wife, white, female, born Apr. 1844, 56, married 38 [sic] years, eight children [probably includes stepdaughter Mary], three living born England, father born England, mother born England, immigrated in 1845, in U.S. 55 years, reads, writes, speaks English.

Orin, his second wife Elizabeth and daughter Ida were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Spokane, Spokane County, Washington, as follows:⁴

Oren E. Metcalf, head of household, male, white, 73, married twice, married last for 45 [sic, 46] years, born Ohio, father born Ohio [sic], mother born Ohio [sic], speaks English, home carpenter, works for wages, reads, writes, rents home.
Bessie Metcalf, wife, female, white, 66, married once for 45 years, seven children, three living, born England - English, father born England - English, mother born England - English, speaks English, reads, writes.
Ida B. Metcalf, daughter, female, white, 32, single, born Iowa [sic], father born Ohio, mother born England - English, speaks English, saleslady in store, works for wages, reads, writes.

Orin’s daughter Ida, who apparently had been “placed out” as a young child, was enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Fremont, Dodge County, Nebraska, as a “boarder” in the family of John P. Hoff as follows (only Ida shown below):⁵

Ida B. Metcalf, boarder, white, female, born Aug. 1877, 22, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born England, dry goods clerk, reads, writes, speaks English.

Ida, still single, was enumerated in the 1930 federal census of Spokane, Spokane County, Washington, as follows:⁶

Ida Bell Metcalf, head of household, rents for $23.50, radio set, female, white, 50 [sic, 53], single, speaks English, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born England, reads and writes, dep. manager in dry goods store, works for wages.

_______________
¹ Oren Metcalf household, 1870 U.S. census, Williams County, Ohio, population schedule, Mill Creek, page 9, sheet 127 (continued on the next sheet), line 37, dwelling 73, family 73; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 1282.
² Orin E. Metcalf household, 1880 U.S. census, Hillsdale County, Michigan, population schedule, Wright Township, enumeration district 97, supervisor’s district 1, page 12, sheet 339D, line 1, dwelling 1220, family 121; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 581.
³ Orin E. Metcalf household, 1900 U.S. census, Harrison County, Ohio, population schedule, Missouri Valley City Ward 3, enumeration district 88, supervisor’s district 9, sheet 15B, line 67, dwelling 320, family 325; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 436.
⁴ Oren E. Metcalf household, 1910 U.S. census, Spokane County, Washington, population schedule, Spokane Ward 1, 517 E. Third Avenue, enumeration district 154, supervisor’s district 3, sheet 5A, line 28, dwelling 71, family 115; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 1670.
⁵ John P. Hoff household, 1900 U.S. census, Dodge County, Nebraska, population schedule, Fremont Ward 4, enumeration district 90, supervisor’s district 3, sheet 15B, line 61, dwelling 309, family 353; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 922.
⁶ Ida Bell Metcalf household, 1930 U.S. census, Spokane County, Washington, population schedule, Spokane Ward 3, Apt. at 1227 W. Riverdon Avenue, enumeration district 32-61, supervisor’s district 5, sheet 2A, line 8, dwelling 10, family 139; National Archives micropublication T626, roll 2517.

Notes on Sarah J. McManigal:

Sarah was enumerated in the 1850 federal census of Venice Township, Seneca County, Ohio, in her father’s household as follows:¹

James McManigal, 39, male, merchant, born Pennsylvania.
Eliza A. McManigal, 32, female, born Ohio.
Lucinda McManigal, 12, female, born Ohio.
Wm. C. McManigal, 10, male, born Ohio.
Samuel McManigal, 6, male, born Ohio.
Sarah J. McManigal, 8, female, born Ohio.
James E. McManigal,4, male, born Ohio.
Irena C. McManigal, 10/12, female, born Ohio.

_______________
¹ James McManigal household, 1850 U.S. census, Seneca County, Ohio, population schedule, Venice Township, sheet 84, line 25, dwelling 492, family 504; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 728.

Notes on Elizabeth Douglas:

Elizabeth was enumerated in the 1860 federal census of Sharon Township, Richland County, Ohio, in her father’s household as follows:¹

James Douglas, 40, male, farmer, real property $4000, person property $500, born England.
Mary Douglas, 40, female, born England.
Elizabth Douglas, 16, female, born England.
Wm. Douglas, 14, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Jane Douglas, 12, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Joseph Douglas, 10, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Thomas Douglas, 7, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
John Douglas, 5, male, born Ohio.
Mary Douglas, 2, female, born Ohio.
James Douglas, 3/12, male, born Ohio.
Henry Kirkpatrick, 27, male, farm hand, born Germany.

_______________
¹ James Douglas household, 1860 U.S. census, Richland County, Ohio, population schedule, Sharon Township, Shelby Post Office, page 266, sheet 133 (continued on the next sheet), line 40, dwelling 1875, family 1885; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 1028.

43. ⁹Martha E. Metcalf, dau. of ⁸George A. Metcalf [10] and Mary Ann Sikes. Born on 13 May 1840 in Seneca County, Ohio.

Married Joseph W. Harbaugh on 9 Oct. 1857 in Seneca County when 17 years old (Joseph W. was 22 years old). Joseph W. Harbaugh b. in July 1835 in Pennsylvania; d. before 1910, at most 74 years old.

Issue of Martha E. Metcalf and Joseph W. Harbaugh:
89   i. son ¹⁰Dell F. Harbaugh b. on 4 Sep. 1858 in Ohio.
      ii. son William W. Harbaugh b. on 17 July 1860 in Ohio; m. _____ _____.
      iii. child _____ Harbaugh b. say in 1862 in Ohio; d. young.
      iv. child _____ Harbaugh b. say in 1864 in Ohio; d. young.
      v. child _____ Harbaugh b. say in 1866 in Ohio; d. young.
      vi. son Harry W. Harbaugh b. in Jan. 1869 in Ohio; m. Harriet T. _____ (1879/80 in Kansas–) in 1901/2 when about 32 years old (Harriet T. was about 22 years old).
      vii. dau. Carrie B. Harbaugh b. in June 1870 in Ohio.
      viii. son Delbert F. Harbaugh b. in 1883/4 in Kansas; m. Elizabeth _____ (1908/9 in Illinois–) in 1927/8 when about 44 years old (Elizabeth was about 19 years old).

Notes on Martha E. Metcalf:

Ohio Marriages, 1803–1900, lists the marriage of Martha E. Metcalf and Joseph Harbaugh on 9 October 1857 in Seneca County.

Martha and her family were enumeraed in the 1860 federal census of Venice Township, Seneca County, Ohio, as follows:¹

J. W. Harbaugh, 25, male, blacksmith, real property $1200, personal property $30, born Pennsylvania.
Martha E. Harbaugh, 20, female, born Ohio.
Delfast [sic] Harbaugh, 1, male, born Ohio.

Martha and her family were enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Shelby, Richland County, Ohio, as follows:²

Joseph W. Harbaugh, 35, male, white, saloon keeper, real property $1200, born Pennsylvania.
Martha E. Harbaugh, 29, female, white, keeping house, born Ohio.
Dell F. Harbaugh, 12, male, white, at home, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
William W. Harbaugh, 10. male, white, at home, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Clara Harbaugh, 2, female, white, at home, born Ohio.
Harra Harbaugh, 2, male, white, at home, born Ohio.

Martha and her family were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Kansas City, Jackson County, Missouri, as follows:³

Joseph W. Harbaugh, head of household, white, male, born July 1835, 64, married 43 years, born Pennsylvania, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Pennsylvania, blacksmith, works on own account, reads, writes, speaks English, rents home.
Martha E. Harbaugh, wife, white, female, born May 1840, 60, married 43 years, seven children, four living, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born Massachusetts, reads, writes, speaks English.
Harry W. Harbaugh, son, white, male, born Jan. 1869, 31, single, born Ohio, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Ohio, book keeper, reads, writes, speaks English.
Carrie Harbaugh, daughter, white, female, born Jun. 1870, 29, single, born Ohio, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Ohio, reads, writes, speaks English.

Martha and her children were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Grant Township, Richardson County, Nebraska, as follows:⁴

Martha Harbaugh, head of household, female, white, 70, widow, seven children, four living, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born Massachusetts, speaks English, reads, writes, rents home.
William Harbaugh, son, male, white, 49, widow, born Ohio, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Ohio, speaks English, laborer Miles Ranch, works for wages, reads, writes.
Carrie Harbaugh, daughter, female, white, 38, single, born Ohio, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Ohio, speaks English, reads, writes.
Delbert F. Harbaugh, son, male, white, 26, single, born Kansas, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Ohio, speaks English, laborer Miles Ranch, works for wages, reads, writes.

_______________
¹ J. W. Harbaugh household, 1860 U.S. census, Seneca County, Ohio, population schedule, Venice Township, Attica Post Office, page 10, sheet 231, line 15, dwelling 72, family 65; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 1035.
² Joseph W. Harbaugh household, 1870 U.S. census, Richland County, Ohio, population schedule, Shelby Village, page 6, sheet 309, line 11, dwelling 45, family 45; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 1261.
³ Joseph W. Harbaugh household, 1900 U.S. census, Jackson Couny, Missouri, population schedule, Kansas City Ward 10, 2532 Montgall Street, enumeration district 118, supervisor’s district 5, sheet 9B, line 96, dwelling 185, family 191; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 864.
⁴ Martha Harbaugh household, 1910 U.S. census, Richardson County, Nebraska, population schedule, Grant Township, Grant Precinct, enumeration district 169, supervisor’s district 1, sheet 10B, line 94, dwelling 228, family 226; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 854.

Notes on Joseph W. Harbaugh:

Joseph was enumerated in the 1850 federal census of Venice Township, Seneca County, Ohio, in his mother’s household as follows:¹

Mary Harbaugh, 42, female, born Pennsylvania.
Jacob Harbaugh, 18, male, laborer, born Pennsylvania, attended school within the year.
Joseph Harbaugh, 15, male, laborer, born Pennsylvania, attended school within the year.
Sarah A. Harbaugh, 11 [or 10], female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Rachel Harbaugh, 9, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.

The line above Mary Harbaugh’s entry has another son John working for a neighbor’s family:

John Harbaugh, 17, male, laborer, born Pennsylvania, attended school within the year.

_______________
¹ Mary Harbaugh household, 1850 U.S. census, Seneca County, Ohio, population schedule, Venice Township, page 141, sheet 71, line 14, dwelling 290, family 300; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 728.

44. ⁹Harriet Augusta Metcalf, dau. of ⁸George A. Metcalf [10] and Mary Ann Sikes. Born on 17 Feb. 1842 in Seneca County, Ohio. Died on 13 March 1915 in Venice, Seneca County, Ohio, 73 years old.

Married John Q. Holmes, son of John Holmes and Sabina _____, on 29 March 1860 in Seneca County when 18 years old (John Q. was about 22 years old). John Q. Holmes b. in March 1838 in Ohio; d. in 1919, 80 or 81 years old.

Issue of Harriet Augusta Metcalf and John Q. Holmes:
90   i. dau. ¹⁰Clara Augusta Holmes b. on 24 Jan. 1861 in Ohio.
91   ii. son Gilbert Edgar Holmes b. in July 1865 in Ohio.
92   iii. son Frank C. Holmes b. in 1867/8 in Ohio.
      iv. dau. Sabina Holmes b. in 1873/4 in Ohio.

Notes on Harriet Augusta Metcalf:

Ohio Marriages, 1803–1900, lists the marriage of John Q. Holmes and Harriet Medcalf on 29 March 1860 in Seneca County, Ohio.

Harriet and her husband were enumeraed in the 1860 federal census of Venice Township, Seneca County, Ohio, as follows:¹

John Q. Holmes, 22, male, blacksmith, real property $300, personal property $185, born Ohio.
Harriet Holmes, 18, female, born Ohio.

Harriet and her family were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Monroe Township, Allen County, Ohio, as follows:²

John Q. Holmes, white, male, 42, married, farmer, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Harriet A. Holmes, white, female, 32, wife, married, keeping house, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born Massachusetts.
Gilbert E. Holmes, white, male, 15, son, single, at home, attended school within the year, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Frank C. Holmes, white, male, 12, son, single, at home, attended school within the year, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Savina Holmes, white, female, 6, daughter, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.

(That Frank married Malinda and had the listed children is not certain. They have not been found in other censuses.)

Harriet and her husband were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Attica, Venice Township, Seneca County, Ohio, as follows:³

Jno. Q. Holmes, head of household, white, male, born Mar. 1838, 62, married 40 years, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, retired, reads, writes, speaks English, owns home free of mortgage.
Harriet J. [sic] Holmes, wife, white, female, born Feb. 1842, 58, married 40 years, four children, four living, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born Massachusetts, reads, writes, speaks English.

_______________
¹ John Q. Holmes household, 1860 U.S. census, Seneca County, Ohio, population schedule, Venice Township, Attica Post Office, page 10, sheet 231, line 21, dwelling 74, family 67; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 1035.
² John Q. Holmes household, 1880 U.S. census, Allen County, Ohio, population schedule, Monroe Township, enumeration district 215, supervisor’s district 1, page 28, sheet 331D, line 44, dwelling 233, family 247; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 990.
³ Jno. Q. Holmes household, 1900 U.S. census, Seneca County, Ohio, population schedule, Attica, Venice Township, enumeration district 119, supervisor’s district 12, sheet 18A, line 23, dwelling 391, family 398; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 1320.

Notes on John Q. Holmes:

John was enumerated in the 1850 federal census of Venice Township, Seneca County, Ohio, in his father’s household as follows:¹

John Holmes, 42, male, farmer, real property $2500, born Unknown.
Sabina Holmes, 41, female, born New York.
Elizabeth Holmes, 20, female, born Ohio.
Sarah Holmes, 18, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Rebina Holmes, 16, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Amos Holmes, 16, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
John Holmes, 12, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Almeda Holmes, 11, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
David Holmes, 7, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.

_______________
¹ John Holmes household, 1850 U.S. census, Seneca County, Ohio, population schedule, Venice Township, sheet 68, line 14, dwelling 257, family 267; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 728.

45. ⁹George M. Metcalf, son of ⁸George A. Metcalf [10] and Mary Ann Sikes. Born on 24 Jan. 1844 in Seneca County, Ohio. Died on 6 June 1906 in Seneca County, 62 years old.

Married first Harriet E. Wise, dau. of Solomon Wise and Isabelle Torrence, on 17 Nov. 1867 in Seneca County when 23 years old (Harriet E. was 21 years old). Harriet E. Wise b. on 15 Feb. 1846 in Seneca County; d. on 22 Feb. 1886 in Attica, Seneca County, Ohio, 40 years old.

Married second Margaret A. _____ in 1887/8 when about 43 years old (Margaret A. was about 29 years old). Margaret A. _____ b. in Dec. 1858 in Ohio.

Issue of George M. Metcalf and Margaret A. _____:
i. child ¹⁰_____ Metcalf b. after 1888; d. before 1900, at most ten years old.

Notes on George M. Metcalf:

Ohio Marriages, 1803–1900, lists the marriage of George M. Metcalf and Harriet E. Wise on 17 November 1867 in Seneca County.

George and Harriet were enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Reed Township, Seneca County, Ohio, next door to the family of Harriet’s father Solomon as follows:¹

George Metcalf, 25, male, white, farmer, personal property $300, born Ohio.
Harriet Metcalf, 24, female, white, keeping house, born Ohio.

George and Harriet were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Reed Township, Seneca County, Ohio, as follows:²

George Metcalf, white, male, 35, married, [?] B&O, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born Massachusetts.
Harriet Metcalf, white, female, 33, wife, married, keeping house, born Ohio, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Pennsylvania.

George and his second wife were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Reed Township, Seneca County, Ohio, as follows:³

George M. Metcalf, head of household, white, male, born Jan. 1844, 56, married 12 years, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born Massachusetts, farmer, reads, writes, speaks English, rents farm.
Margaret A. Metcalf, wife, white, female, born Dec. 1858, 41, married 12 years, one child, none living, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, reads, writes, speaks English.

Margaret’s child may have been by a previous marriage.

_______________
¹ Solomon Wise household, 1870 U.S. census, Seneca County, Ohio, population schedule, Reed Township, Bloomville Post Office, page 11, sheet 226, line 8, dwelling 85, family 89; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 1266.
² George Metcalf household, 1880 U.S. census, Seneca County, Ohio, population schedule, Reed, enumeration district 207, sheet 227B, line 11, dwelling 47, family 52; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 1065.
³ George M. Metcalf household, 1900 U.S. census, Seneca County, Ohio, population schedule, Reed Township, enumeration district 115, supervisor’s district 12, sheet 4, line 83, dwelling 85, family 89; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 1320.

Notes on Harriet E. Wise:

Harriet (listed as the second Margarette) was enumerated in the 1850 federal census of Venice Township, Seneca County, Ohio, in her father’s family in the household of Frederick Cook as follows:¹

Frederick Cook, 28, male, cooper, born [Pennsylvania?].
Sarah Cook, 23, female, born Ohio, cannot read and write.
Solomon Wise, 41, male, laborer, born Pennsylvania.
Isabelle Wise, 28, female, born Ohio, cannot read and write.
Margarette Wise, 17, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
John Wise, 12, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Nancy Wise, 8, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Margarette Wise, 4, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
George W. Wise, 3, male, born Ohio.
Eliza J. Wise, 10/12, born Ohio.

The first Margarette listed is probably a daughter of Solomon by a previous marriage.

Solomon and his family were enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Reed Township, Seneca County, Ohio, next door to George and Harriet as follows:²

Solomon Wilse, 62, male, white, blacksmith, real property $2000, personal property $1000, born Pennsylvania.
Isabelle Wise, 49, female, white, keeping house, born Ohio.
George Wise, 21, male, white, farm laborer, born Ohio.
Mary E. Wise, 16, female, white, at home, born Ohio.
William Wise, 14, male, white, at home, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Charles Wise, 12, male, white, attending school, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Ellen Wise, 7, female, white, born Ohio.
Frederick Wise, 4, male, white, born Ohio.

_______________
¹ Frederick Cook household, 1850 U.S. census, Seneca County, Ohio, population schedule, Venice Township, sheet 89, line 30, dwelling 549, family 561; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 728.
² Solomon Wise household, 1870 U.S. census, Seneca County, Ohio, population schedule, Reed Township, Bloomville Post Office, page 10, sheet 225 (continued on the next sheet), line 40, dwelling 84, family 88; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 1266.

46. ⁹Clara Pauline Metcalf, dau. of ⁸George A. Metcalf [10] and Mary Ann Sikes. Born in Jan. 1849 in Seneca County, Ohio. Died on 29 Jan. 1917 in Hamilton County, Tennessee, about 68 years old.

Married first Charles F. Pruden, son of Ezra Pruden and Naomi _____, on 25 Oct. 1868 in Seneca County when 19 years old (Charles F. was 24 years old). Divorced. Charles F. Pruden b. in 1843/4 in Ohio; m. (2) Matilla _____ (1850/1 in Ohio–); issue (surname Pruden): Claudia (1872/3 in Ohio–).

Issue of Clara Pauline Metcalf and Charles F. Pruden:
i. dau. ¹⁰Mary E. Pruden b. in 1868/9 in Ohio.

Married second James Burton on 19 Nov. 1871 in Seneca County when 22 years old (James was 18 years old). James Burton b. in 1852/3 in Ohio.

Issue of Clara Pauline Metcalf and James Burton:
      ii. son ¹⁰Clement Burton b. in 1871/2 in Ohio.
      iii. son Oliver Burton b. in 1873/4 in Ohio.
      iv. son James Burton b. in 1875/6 in Ohio.
      v. dau. Lunetta Burton b. in 1877/8 in Ohio.
      vi. dau. Nellie M. Burton b. in March 1880 in Ohio.

Notes on Clara Pauline Metcalf:

The IGI lists an extracted record of the marriage of Clara Pauline Metcalf and Charles F. Pruden on 25 October 1868 in Seneca County, Ohio.

Ohio Marriages, 1803–1900, lists the marriage of Clara Metcalf and James Burton on 19 November 1871 in Seneca County. The IGI lists an extracted record of the same marriage.

Clara and her family by Charles Pruden are enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Norwich Township, Huron County, Ohio, as follows:¹

Chas. F. Pruden, 27, male, white, farmer, born Ohio.
Clara Pruden, 21, female, white, born New York [sic].
Mary Pruden, 1, female, white, born Ohio.
[Albi?] Pruden, 17, female, white, born Ohio, attended school within the year.

Charles Pruden and his second family are enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Norwich Township, Huron County, Ohio, as follows:²

Chas. F. Pruden, white, male, 36, married, farmer, bor Ohio, father born New York, mother born New York.
Matilla Pruden, white, female, 29, wife, married, keeping house, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born New York.
Claudia Pruden, white, female, 7, daughter, single, going to school, attended school within the year, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.

Mary, daughter of Charles and Clara, was enumerated close by on the same census page in the household of Charles parents Ezra and Naomi as follows:³

Ezra Pruden, white, male, 60, married, farmer, born New York, father born New Jersy, mother born New York.
Naomi Pruden, white, female, 57, wife, married, keeping house, born New York, father born Connecticut, mother born Connecticut.
Mary E. Pruden, white, female, 11, granddaughter, single, going to school, attended school within the year, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Rebeca Fry, white, female, 30, servant, single, domestice, born Ohio, father born Virginia, mother born Virginia.
John Frost, white, male, 19, servant, single, farm laborer, attended school within the year, born Oho, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.

Clara and her family by James Burton were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Liberty Township, Mercer County, Ohio, as follows:⁴

James Burton, white, male, 27, married, shoemaker, born Ohio, father born Unknown, mother born Unknown.
Clara Burton, white, female, 31, wife, married, keeping house, father born Connecticut, mother born Massachusetts.
Clement Burton, white, male, 8, son, single, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born Massachusetts.
Olliver Burton, white, male, 6, son, single, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born Massachusetts.
James Burton, white, male, 4, son, single, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born Massachusetts.
Lunetta, white, female, 2, daughter, single, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born Massachusetts.
Nellie M. Burton, white, female 3/12, born Mar., daughter, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born Massachusetts.

An indexer of this almost unreadable census page read the birthplace of the mother of Clara and the children as Mississippi, probably misreading Mass as Miss and copying Clara’s entries down through the children.

_______________
¹ Chas. F. Pruden household, 1870 U.S. census, Huron County, Ohio, population schedule, Norwich Township, Monroeville Post Office, page 5, sheet 471, line 16, dwelling 32, family 35; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 1225.
² Charles F. Pruden household, 1880 U.S. census, Huron County, Ohio, population schedule, Norwich Township, enumeration district 151, supervisor’s district 6, page 10, sheet 168B, line 23, dwelling 107, family 109; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 1035.
³ Ezra Pruden household, 1880 U.S. census, Huron County, Ohio, population schedule, Norwich Township, enumeration district 151, supervisor’s district 6, page 10, sheet 168B, line 11, dwelling 104, family 105; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 1035.
⁴ James Burton household, 1880 U.S. census, Mercer County, Ohio, population schedule, Liberty Township, enumeration district 188, supervisor’s district 2, page 7, sheet 474D (continued on the next sheet), line 50, dwelling 58, family 61; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 1048.

Issue of ⁸Oren Metcalfe [11] (⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and Zuleika Rosalie Lyons

47. ⁹Lt. James Bard Metcalfe CSA, son of ⁸Oren Metcalfe [11] and Zuleika Rosalie Lyons. Born on 15 Jan. 1846 in Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi. Baptized on 29 Nov. 1846 in Natchez when ten months old. Died on 9 July 1924 in Fernhurst, Suquamish, Kitsap County, Washington, 78 years old. Buried in Suquamish Cemetery, Suquamish.

Married Mary Louise Boarman, dau. of Thomas Michael Boarman and Mary _____, on 25 June 1877 in San Francisco, San Francisco County, California when 31 years old (Mary Louise was 21 years old). Mary Louise Boarman b. on 11 Aug. 1855 in California; d. on 7 Feb. 1935 in Fernhurst, 79 years old; bur. in Suquamish Cemetery.

Issue of Lt. James Bard Metcalfe CSA and Mary Louise Boarman:
93 i. son ¹⁰Thomas Oren Metcalfe b. on 3 Nov. 1880 in San Francisco.
ii. son James Vernon Metcalfe b. on 31 July 1887 in Seattle, King County, Washington; m. Viola O. (Scartum) Ridgeway (8 April 1890 in Fairchild, Eau Claire County, Wisconsin–).

Notes on Lt. James Bard Metcalfe CSA:

Lieutenant James Bard Metcalfe¹ was born on 15 January 1846 in Natchez and baptized there on 29 November of that year.

He volunteered for service with the Confederacy with the 10th Mississippi Cavalry. He served in the War Between the States with Breckinridge’s Brigade from May 1862 to April 1863. He joined Breckinridge’s escort in April 1863 and was detailed out in September 1864. At some point he was captured and made a daring escape at the Battle of Franklin, swimming the Duck River and rejoining the Confederate forces in Murphreesboro. He was again captured at the Battle of Fort Tyler on 17 April 1865 at the end of the War. He left service commissioned as a 19-year old Lieutenant.²

After the War, in 1870, James was a clerk in a bank in Natchez. By 1873 he moved to San Francisco, California, where he initially worked in a bank. He then studied law while clerking for the Bard and Pratt law firm. After passing the California bar and being admitted to practice before the California Supreme Court, he became a partner in that firm in 1877. He married Louise Boarman on 25 June of that year in San Francisco.³ She was born on 11 August 1855 in northern California, probably before her family arrived in Red Bluff in Tehama County.

James and his family were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of San Francisco, San Francisco County, California, in the family of his mother-in-law Mary Boarman as follows:⁴

Mary Boarman, white, female, 47 [sic], widowed, born Ireland, father born Ireland, mother born Ireland.
Tho. Boarman, white, male, 18, son, single, at college, born California, father born Maryland,mother born Ireland.
Margaret Boarman, white, female, 21, daughter, married, born California, father born Maryland,mother born Ireland.
Jas. B. Metcalfe, white, male, 30 [sic, 34], son-in-law, married, lawyer, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi [sic], mother born Mississippi.
Louise Metcalfe, white, female, 22 [sic, 24], daughter, born California, father born Maryland,mother born Ireland.
Johana Twohig, white, female, 35, servant, single, domestic, born Ireland, father born Ireland, mother born Ireland.

James moved to Seattle, Washington, in 1883 where he joined a law firm which became Metcalfe, Turner & Burleigh.⁵ He was appointed the first and only Attorney-General of the Washington Territory in 1888 by the Territorial Governor, Eugene Semple, to prepare official data for entrance of the Territory as a state and to help compose the constitution. The Territory was admitted to the Union on 11 November 1889.

James was listed in the 1889 city directory of Seattle as “James B. Metcalfe, Attorney-General for Washington Territory and Lawyer, 3 and 4 Poncin Building at Main, southwest corner of South 11th.”

James and his family were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Seattle, King County, Washington, as follows:⁶

James B. Metcalf, head of household, white, male, born Jan. 1846, 54, married 23 years, born Mississippi, father born Connecticut, mother born Mississippi, lawyer, reads, writes, speaks English, own home with mortgage.
Louise Metcalf, wife, white, female, born Aug. 1859 [sic, 1855], 40 [sic, 44], married 23 years, two children, both living, born California, father born Maryland, mother born Scotland, [sic, Ireland].
Thomas O. Metcalf, son, white, male, born Nov. 1880, 19, single, born California, father born Mississippi, mother born California, miner, reads, writes, speaks English.
James V. Metcalf, son, white, male, born July 1887, 12, born Washington, father born Mississippi, mother born California, at school, reads, writes, speaks English.
Margaret Boarman, sister-in-law, white, female, born Dec. 1861 [sic, 1857], 38 [sic, 42], single, born California, father born Maryland, mother born Scotland [sic], reads, writes, speaks English.
Frank B. Boarman, cousin-in-law, white, male, born Jan. 1860, 40, single, born Missouri, father born Maryland, mother born Missouri, miner, reads, writes, speaks English.

In 1905 James decided to build a summer home, called Fernhurst, on the water front at the northern boundary of the Suquamish Indian Reservation in Kitsap County, Washington, about 20 miles north of Bremerton, to which he and his family gradually moved over the next several years (between 1910 and 1920). A prominent man, Metcalf Street [without the terminal e] in Sedro-Woolley, Washington, is named after James. (P. A. Woolley, after which the town is named, was a close associate of James.)

James and his family were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Seattle, King County, Washington, as follows:⁷

James B. Metcalf, head of household, male, white, 57 [sic,, 64], married 33 [?] years, born Mississippi, father born Connecticut, mother born Mississippi, speaks English, attorney [in general practice], works on own account, reads, writes, owns home free of mortgage.
Louise Metcalf, wife, female, white, 48 [sic, 54], married 33 [?] years, two children, both living, born California, father born Maryland, mother born Ire. - English, speaks English, reads, writes.
Thomas O. Metcalf, son, male, white, 25 [sic, 29], single, born California, father born Mississippi, mother born California, speaks English, mill man, reads, writes.
James V. Metcalf, son, male, white, 22, single, born Washington, father born Mississippi, mother born California, speaks English, attorney [in general practice], works on own account, reads, writes.
Marguerite Boarman, sister-in-law, female, white, 40 [sic, 52], single, born California, father born Mississippi, mother born Ire. - English, reads, writes.
Hirato Okamoto, servants, male, Japanese, 21, single, born Jap. - Japanese, father born Jap. - Japanese, mother born Jap. - Japanese, speaks English, servant, family, reads and writes.

James and his family were enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Suquamish, Ktsap County, Washington, as follows:⁸

James B. Metcalfe, head of household, home owned and mortgaged, male, white, 70 [sic, 74], married, reads, writes, born Mississippi, father born Connecticut, mother born Louisiana [sic, Mississippi], speaks English, attorney in general practice, employer.
Louise B. Metcalfe, wife, female, white, 65 [sic, 64], married, reads, writes, born California, father born Maryland, mother born Ireland (mother tongue English), speaks English.
Margaret Boarman, sister-in-law, female, white, 55 [sic, 62], single, reads, writes, born California, father born Maryland, mother born Ireland (mother tongue English), speaks English.
Vernon J. Metcalfe, son, male, white, 31 [sic, 32], single, reads, writes, born Washington, father born Mississippi, mother born California, speaks English, solicitor (freight), wage worker.
Francis B. Boarman, cousin, male, white, 55, single, reads, writes, born Missouri, father born Maryland, mother born Missouri, life insurance agent, works on own account.

James died on 9 July 1924 at Fernhurst, 78 years old.⁹ Louise was injured in an automobile accident and was an invalid at Fernhurst for several years.

Louise, age 74, was enumerated in the 1930 federal census of Suquamish, Kitsap County, Washington, in the household of her son Vernon, age 40 [sic, 42], who was a retail store salesman, along with her sister Margarat, still unmarried at age 68 [sic, 72].¹⁰ Her other son Thomas, age 49, was enumerated in that year in Houston, Harris County, Texas, with his wife Helen, age 39, and son Thomas O., age 7, working as a salesman for a lumber company.¹¹

Louise died at Fernhurst on 7 February 1935, 79 years old. James and Louise are buried in the “White House” section of the Suquamish Cemetery, Suquamish, Kitsap County, Washington, row 1, grave 2. The inscription (all in uppercase) is:

JAMES BARD METCALFE
MISSISSIPPI PVT. BRECKENRIDGE GUARDS
CONFEDERATE STATES ARMY
JAN 15, 1846 JULY 09, 1924

LOUISE BOARMAN METCALFE
AUG 11, 1851 [sic, 1855] FEB 07, 1935

Margaret (Metcalfe) Hassin wrote the author on 12 October 2002:

The following is a re-type of a biography of General James Bard Metcalfe written by his younger son, James Vernon Metcalfe in 1967.
I have redone this because the copy is so hard to read. I have written it exactly as Vernon did to preserve its authenticity. However, it appears to be a draft as the chronology is wrong. I believe that Vernon was just recalling stories about his father and would have later gone back and organized them.
Also, I have typed it verbatim, so there are some errors in spelling and punctuation.
Margaret Metcalfe Hassin
(James Vernon’s older brother, Thomas Oren Metcalfe, was my grandfather.)

This is the included biography:

Gen. James B. Metcalfe
In the early days of the State of Washington a gentlemen attained a prominent role as an attorney, politician, candidate, orator, historian, civic leader and benefactor. His outstanding accomplishment for the public was his activities as Attorney General of the Territory of Washington during the period when the Territory was making preparations for entry into the United States in 1889. His efforts and legal advice on the procedures for admission as a State were greatly appreciated at that time. He was Gen. James B. Metcalfe of Seattle.
He began his life in Natchez, Mississippi in a beautiful antebellum home which today is one of the historic mansions opened each year for inspection by the public by reason of the beauty of its architecture among homes visited during the Natchez pilgrimage.
Gen. Metcalfe was born on January 10, 1846 and at the age of fifteen years he volunteered for service in the confederate army as a member of the 10th Mississippi Cavalry. This unit was very actively engaged during the War Between the States and the young man was commissioned as a lieutenant before the close of the war and was so mustered out.
In 1873 he went West to California and after a year in banking practice he began the study of law in the offices of Bard and Pratt in San Francisco. He was soon admitted to the Supreme Court of California and was given a partnership in the Bart and Pratt law firm.
In 1876 he married Miss Louise Boarman in San Francisco. Mrs. Metcalfe’s father came to California driving a covered wagon across the mid-West deserts as a member of a wagon train. He settled in Red Bluff for years and later moved to San Francisco.
Mrs. Metcalfe was the first college graduate from the Holy Names Academy in San Francisco. Their marriage brought together two families each of which was entitled to a coat-of-arms tracible back into English history. These insignia of the Boarman-Metcalfe marriage are very similar in their composition and material memorialized.
From a San Francisco paper in 1883:
“J. B. Metcalfe, a lawyer of good repute, and a genial gentleman, leaves this city, with his family, on the morrow, on the steamer, State of California, for Seattle, W. T. where he intends to cast his lot and grow up with a growing country. The General is well and favorably known in this city and State and we bespeak for him the kindest consideration on the part of those of our readers In the Northwest, who know that we rarely praise, since mankind is very chary in furnishing praiseworthy subjects.”
After his arrival in Seattle his legal associates were Junius Rochester, C. W. Linn, Andrew F. Burleigh and Judge John S. Jurey. Mr. Joshua Green for about a year studied law (with these associates) in this office before joining the steamboat personnel and later entering banking.
In 1887 Gen. Metcalfe was appointed Attorney General of the Territory of Washington by Governor Eugene Semple and in this capacity advised in the drawing of the Enabling Act under which the Territory became the State of Washington on November 11, 1889. That is the date which the Pioneer Association of the State of Washington fixes the time before which a person must have been a resident of the area in order to qualify as a pioneer and pass on that privilege to his direct decendants.
Gen. Metcalfe was the only Attorney General appointed for the Territory of Washington and he held the office for a short time after the admission of the State to the Union.
In 1887 Gen. Metcalfe was helpful as a director in the organization of the Seattle Construction Company which built the Yesler Way Cable car line from downtown to Leschi Park on Lake Washington. Invitations for its opening were issued to occur at 11 A. M., September 29, 1888. Mr. T. T. Minor was president of the line. An editorial in the Seattle Star attributed the success of the founding of the cable line to Gen Metcalf and ex-mayor John Leary.
While still living in San Francisco he made a trip to Washington, D.C. and visited the grave of George Washington at Mt. Vernon, Md. He obtained permission from the guard to take a generous slip from the weeping willow trees surrounding the grave of Washington. The parents of these trees had been presented to the officers of the U.S. S. Saranac as an international compliment to the United States from the French Government, in 1830. Those slips were from the weeping willow trees surrounding the grave of Napoleon on the Isle of St. Helena off the coast of South Africa. Napoleon had been buried there in 1820 where he remained for 17 years before his removal to the monument of des Invalides in Paris.
Gen. Metcalfe brought the maturing slip to Seattle in 1883 and planted it at his home at Ninth and Main Streets where it grew to a very stately tree. In 1907 it was offered to the Alaska Yukon Pacific Exposition but it was considered too large to move. The tree was destroyed by the Jackson Street regrade but slips had been planted at the same spot behind the former Hotel Tacoma, where they flourish to this day in 1967.
One tree drapes close to the Freeway between Jackson and Main Streets. The Seattle Housing Authority has acquired the land where the trees are growing and expects to preserve them in a park, in 1968.
In politics he was not successful although he was very active in speaking in many of the cities of Washington. It was probably due to his being a Southern Democrat that the people still remembered the troubles of the War Between the States and it was only around the beginning of the century that these memories softened as campaign issues.
One odd issue did rise in 1884 when he was running for City Attorney. He had offered the use of his law office for a meeting place of Englishmen planning a celebration of the birthday of Queen Victoria. The following charge against him was distributed:
“Will the Freemen of Seattle support an office seeker who is such a lover of Monarchy as to wish to celebrate the birthday of a Queen?
IRISH AMERICANS”
September 3, 1888 The State Democratic party was holding its convention in Spokane Falls to name a candidate to the United States Congress as a delegate. Gen. Metcalfe was conceded to be the very enthusiastic choice of the Democrats. The following is a press report of the proceedings:
“Attorney General Metcalfe, Chairman of the delegation from King County, rose and proceeded to the space in front of the chairmen amidst the deafening cheers of the Convention . . . (Long and vociferous applause, the speaker being compelled to wait several minutes) . . . (here deafening cheers broke forth again)”
He then offered the name of Hon. C. S. Voories for the position of Delegate. The motivating reason for his surprise action may have been a telegram from his family in Seattle:
“Please father do not accept nomination for delegate to Congress”
Signed by his son just born, his 10 year old son, their grandmother and his wife.
In 1908 he ran for the office of Mayor of Seattle in a very active campaign but he was unsuccessful.
June 7, 1889 the Seattle fire occurred and a newspaper reported:
“The San Francisco building . . . Gen. J. B. Metcalfe led a party to the roof of the building anda line of hose was soon raised by means of a rope. Again the terrible insufficiency of water balked the herculian efforts of the workers. The water barely came from the nozzle of the hose and the firefighters found themselves weaponless in the face of a terrible enemy.”
As a sportsman he had the strange experience of shooting a white deer on Whidby Island in 1892. It was a two pronged buck which he took to a taxidermist and then placed it on exhibition in Hardy & Halls Gun Shop on Front Street. A white deer was considered to be a vagary of a fairy tale but this real specimen was a startling reality. It was offered as an exhibit in the Chicago Worlds Fair.
One of the most exciting cases in Washington criminal history was the trials of George M. Miller for the murders of James Manning Colman and Wilbur Patten in 1886 in Lake Washington at Kennydale near Renton. The feelings of the public were so bitter that a change of venue was granted and the case was heard in Port Townsend. The jury was out 40 hours and disagreed. A second trial was held in Seattle in 1887 and the jury stayed out two days and disagreed. The third trial was in Port Madison, Kitsap County. The jury found Miller guilty and he was sentenced to be hanged. Gen. Metcalfe as Miller’s attorney got a stay of execution in 1888 and presented the case to the State Supreme Court who decided that the verdict must have been rendered on suspicion. A nonsuit was granted and Miller released.
Another legal accomplishment gained as a Proctor and Advocate in Admiralty was the defense of a steamship company in its relationship to its shippers. The case was The Sitka Trading Company vs. the Pacific Coast Steamship Company. and was the first case to be heard in the U.S. District Court after its establishment in the Territory of Alaska in May, 1885. The trial was held in Sitka and the subject matter of the cause was an example of freight rate rules in the operation of vessels. The practice was that if a shipper would send all of his shipments of goods on the particular line than he would receive a lower rate than other shippers who used competing lines occasionally.
Today this practice is common in conference line vessels in their shipping contracts. The winning argument of the Alaska case was that unless all of the shipper’s business was placed with the defendant line, then in competition the elegant steamship could not survive competition and Alaska’ s freight delivery would suffer shipment on slow sailing vessels or on little tugs sufficient to carry the monthly mails.
At the time of the Chinese troubles on the Pacific Coast when the many immigrants from China who had been brought in as laborers to build trans American railroads, were threatened by mobs of U.S. citizens because the low wages paid the Chinese caused them to monopolize the labor market. The Chinese were willing to return to their home land but were in danger of injury as they gathered to go aboard the outbound steamer. To prevent a riot, a volunteer group of Seattle citizens was formed to protect the Chinese during the embarkation. The group bore armbands saying: COM. OF SAFETY. Gen. Metcalfe served actively with this Committee and preserved his arm band.
Farther interest by Gen. Metcalfe in Alaskan affairs was assistance that he rendered in the Alaska boundary dispute between the United States and Canada. He prepared a mass of details which the U.S. Congress placed before a Commission appointed to settle the dispute.
In 1907 he was appointed a special representative of the Alaska, Yukon Pacific Exposition and was sent East to secure participation of six Eastern States and Mississippi in the international exposition in Seattle.
In the time of eulogies for deceased friends and prominent men, he made many beautiful memorials. He was chosen to speak in Seattle upon the death of General Ulysius S. Grant in mourning for whom all business houses were closed and military parades were held in honor of the deceased. Gen. Grant’s son acknowledged “this tribute from an opponent of my father who had worn the Confederate gray uniform twenty years previously.”
He also gave the memorial address for the Knights of Pythias for their deceased members as he was the Past Chancellor and Gr. Rep. Of Queen City Lodge No. 10, Division No. 1 Uniform Rank. At that time that organization had many lodges in the cities of this state.
In 1905 Gen. Metcalfe purchased for a summer home, a waterfront area on the northern boundary of the Suquamish Indian Reservation on Squaib (Miller’s) Bay. He built a comfortable home there and became well acquainted with the Indians who passed across his land on one of their ancient trails. He was sympathetic with their economic condition as the U.S. Government had allocated homesites to various Indian families but the Indians were not permitted to sell their lands even though some of the old families were seriously in need of food. It took several years of official correspondence with the Department before they consented to permit the sale of homesteads. The first to be sold was the area now occupied by the town of Suquamish which was purchased and developed by Hon. Ole Hanson who served as Mayor of Seattle.
Quite an argument arose about the naming of the site as Mr. Hanson wanted to call it “Silverstrand” by reason of the white clam shells thickly covering the nearby beaches as relics of the many Indian potlatches held in the Ole Man House. The Indians wanted the site to be called “Suquamish” as an honor to the tribe of which Seattle had been Chief. After an active demonstration, the wishes of the Indians were finally met.
In 1920 at the request of William Rogers, Chief of the Suquamish Indians and his klootchman Queen Annie, the local residents were organized by Gen. Metcalfe to establish Chief Seattle Day at Suquamish which became a yearly memorial which the Indians and delegates and visitors from Seattle found to be very interesting. The evening before the celebration the Indians would gather in camp-fire light and practice their tribal dances which affected them deeply with nostalgia.
The next morning a special steamer from Seattle would bring the official city representatives and many visitors. After memorial services held grave side by the local Catholic priest at the Chief’s graveside, the Indians danced their tribal dances. A Jewish Seattle City Councilman officially summarized the affair in his address:
“when a Jew and a Catholic Priest join in honoring a dead Indian, the millennium has arrived.”
“So the Seattle Chamber of Commerce, which was betting that Carmack & Co. had hit on something big, realized before any other Chamber in the country that if we were to get the miners coming as well as going, we jolly well better have a Federal Government Assay office in Seattle.
“And on April 21, 1897 at 3:30 in the afternoon, the Board of Trustees of the Chamber, which was chaired by one of our prominent attorneys, General J. B. Metcalfe, . . . made the first move to get a Government Assay Office.”
Sons of the Profits, page 811 (?)
Metcalfe was Carmack’s private attorney
In 1884 the City Council established the Park Department and acquired the area of Denny Park, Mr. David T. Denny, James B. Metcalfe and R. J. Graham constituted the Park Board.
He was widely sought for by cities in Washington as an orator especially for celebrations of the Fourth of July and his speeches were printed in full by the local newspapers. His use of words was very elegant and charming to this audiences. One subject in particular was an historical account of the discovery of Puget Sound by Vancouver and his naming of the various bays and mountains. The subject matter must have been very deeply studied by him for it made a lasting impression on his audiences one of which in Port Townsend was delivered on the centennial of its discovery and naming by George Vancouver on May 7, 1792. The oration was so well remembered by the old pioneers that six years later they petitioned him earnestly in writing to have it republished:
“This interesting historical address is invaluable to the Pioneers and first settlers, now living, as a work of reference, and every family in this state should have a copy, to be read and studied by the children as an important part of our early history.”
Signed:
James G. Swan, Robert C. Hill, J. S. Kuhn, Charles Eisenbeis, F. W. Hastings
At the celebration of the Centennial in Port Townsend, Gen. Metcalfe met Mr. P. A. Woolley and they discussed the advantages of establishing a townsite which Mr. Woolley then accomplished and named the area for himself and its main plotted street for Gen. Metcalfe. Later the site was combined with an adjoining area and is now Sedro-Woolley. The street name still remains.
By World War I time Gen. Metcalfe had found semi-retired living at Suqusmish to be most pleasing and he permanently moved to his beach side home “Fernhurst” but still maintained his law office in Seattle.
On July 9th, 1924 his very active life came to an end at Suquamish. He left two sons, Thomas Oren and James Vernon. Tom was attracted by the lumber business in the South and managed several mills in Louisiana., and he left a son and three grand children now resident in Canton, Mississippi. Vernon remained in Seattle, was married, and served as an attorney, a naval officer in two World Wars, practiced foreign trade, and was a professor in law and commerce at Seattle University.
Gen. Metcalfe’s wife, Louise Boarman was active for year in church interests and served on the Seattle Library Board. A serious accident rendered her an invalid for many years during her residence at Suquamish.
As Gen. Metcalfe was such a true friend of the Indians, the Suquamish head-men considered it an honor to give him a burial plot in their cemetery in Suquamish and designated to be near the grave site of Chief Seattle.
As it was necessary because of lack of roads to move his coffin by row boat from the beach home to their cemetary at Suquamish, the eulogy of the minister was very fitting when he quoted at the home:
“Sunset and evening star and one clear call for me
And may there be no moaning of the bar
When I put out to sea.”
By James Vernon Metcalfe (sig.)

_______________
¹ Information provided by Kate Don Brandon (Mrs. George Lawrence Adams) of Natchez, Mississippi, in personal communications, 20 April 1994.
Additional information provided by Margaret (Metcalfe) Hassin of Yazoo City, Mississippi, in various personal communications, September 2002 to September 2003.
Noel V. Bourasaw, “James Bard Metcalfe—Washington Territory Attorney General and P.A. Woolley’s advance man,” Skagit River Journal, published on-line on Nov. 27, 2003 at http://www.stumpranchonline.com/skagitjournal/S-W/Pre-1900/MetcalfeJames.html.
Register of Baptisms, First Presbyterian Church, Natchez, Mississippi.
International Genealogical Index (IGI)—Mississippi, gives his birth date as 1848 which is at variance with baptismal, family and Census records by two years.
The 1850 census of Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi, lists him in his father’s household as 5 years old. The 1860 census lists him in his father’s household as 14 years old. The 1870 Federal Census of Natchez lists him in his father’s household as 24 years old.
² His War record appears in the application for membership of Zuleika Metcalfe Lawrence in the United Daughters of the Confederacy. There she quotes her sources as “Records of Camp No. 20, United Confederate Veterans, Natchez and Adams County.” Her statements were expanded and confirmed in an affidavit signed by Roane Fleming, Zuleika’s first cousin, who also comments that his army records were kept under the name James O. Metcalfe. (Research also uncovered a James B. Medcalf who served in the 11th (Perrin’s) Mississippi Cavalry.)
³ James marriage notice appeared in the San Francisco Daily Morning Call on June 27, 1877, page 4, column 3: “Metcalfe—Boarman—In this city, June 25, James B. Metcalfe to Louise Boarman.”
⁴ Mary Metcalfe household, 1880 U.S. census, San Francisco County, California, population schedule, San Francisco, enumeration district 167, supervisor’s district 1, page 18, sheet 288B, line 9, dwelling 156, family 176; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 77.
⁵ James B. Metcalf household, 1900 U.S. census, King County, Washington, population schedule, Seattle Ward 1, enumeration district 84, supervisor’s district 1, sheet 13B, line 2, dwelling 150, family 220; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 1744.
⁶ Biographical and Historical Memoirs of Mississippi, Vol. II (Spartanburg, South Carolina: The Reprint Company, 1978), 432–433.
⁷ James B. Metcalf household, 1910 U.S. census, King County, Washington, population schedule, Seattle Ward 7, 2429 Federal Avenue, enumeration district 144, supervisor’s district 1, sheet 66B, line 81, dwelling 342, family 387; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 1661.
⁸ James B. Metcalfe household, 1920 U.S. census, Kitsap County, Washington, population schedule, Suquamish Precinct, enumeration district 69, supervisor’s district 2, sheet 28A, line 46, dwelling 15, family 46; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 1932.
⁹ Vernon Metcalf household, 1930 U.S. census, Kitsap County, Washington, population schedule, Suquamish Precint, enumeration district 18-48, supervisor’s district 2, sheet 1B (continued on the next sheet), line 99, dwelling 35, family 35; National Archives micropublication T626, roll 2506.
¹⁰ Thomas O. Metcalfe household, 1930 U.S. census, Harris County, Texas, population schedule, Houston, 1724 Kensington Street, enumeration district 101-113, supervisor’s district 26, sheet 35A, line 18, dwelling 416, family 471; National Archives micropublication T626, roll 2349.
¹¹ Death Certificate #162 (Washington State Death Index, 1907-1996, reel #3).

Images for Lt. James Bard Metcalfe CSA:

Lt. James Bard Metcalfe, CSA, as the Attorney General of Washington Territory in 1888.

Notes on Mary Louise Boarman:

1840 Census entry from Baltimore, Maryland, which may apply to Mary Louise’ paternal grandfather:¹

W[illia]m Boarman. 1 Male under 5. 1 Male 5 and under 10. 1 Male 15 and under 20. 1 Male 20 and under 30. 1 Male 30 and under 40. 1 Female 5 and under 10. 1 Female 20 and under 30. 1 Female 50 and under 60.

The male 15 to 19 may be Thomas, Mary Louise’ father, probably age 15 or 16. The male 30 to 39 may be William, Thomas’ father, probably in his late 30s. Thomas’ mother may have died since no female of the right age is listed. Note that Thomas’ probable brother in the 1850 census below is named William, indicating that their father might be named William.

1850 Census entry from Charles County, Maryland, which may apply to Mary Louise’ father Thomas:²

Thomas J. Boarman. Age 25. Male. Farmer. Value of real estate owned $4,000. Born Maryland.
W[illia]m Boarman. Age 21. Male. Farmer. Born Maryland.
Rose A. Boarman. Age 33. Female. Born Maryland.
Jane Boarman. Age. 28. Female. Born Maryland.
May Boarman. Age. 17. Female. Born Maryland.

If the other people in Thomas’ household were his brothers and sisters, their birth order was Rose b. 1816/7; Jane b. 1821/2; Thomas b. 1824/5; William b. 1828/9; and May b. 1832/3, with Thomas (as oldest male) acting as head of household.

Note that in 1850, Thomas J. is listed and in 1860 below Thomas M. is listed. If these are the same person, it may be that Thomas was named something like “Thomas James Michael Boarman” and, combined with the 1860 census where Thomas was listed as age 36 (b. 1823/4), his indicated birth year would be 1824.

It would seem that Thomas left Baltimore with his siblings before 1850 (perhaps on the death of their father) and became a farmer in Charles County, Maryland.

1860 Census entry from Red Bluff, California:³

T. M. Boarman. Age 36 years. Male. Occupation [unreadable]. Personal property $2,000. Real property $30,000. Born Maryland.
Mary Boarman. Age 32 years. Female. Born Ireland.
L[ouise] Boarman. Age 5 years. Female. Born California.
Marg[aret] Boarman. Age 2 years. Female. Born California.
Tho[ma]s Boarman. Age 3/12 year. Male. Born California.
Augusta Pinkham. Age 26. Female. Servant. Born Maine.

1870 Census entry from Red Bluff, California:⁴

Boarman, Mary. Age 45 years. Female. White. Keeping House. Real property $3,650. Personal property $75,000. Born Ireland. Father of foreign birth. Mother of foreign birth.
Boarman, Ma[r]y L. Age 15 years. Female. White. At Home. Born California. Mother of foreign birth. Attended school within the year.
Boarman, Marg[ar]et. Age 12 years. Female. White. At Home. Born in California. Mother of foreign birth.
Boarman, Tho[ma]s M. Age 8 years. Male. White. At Home. Born in California. Mother of foreign birth. Attended school within the year. Cannot read. Cannot write.
Adams, Anne. Age 32[?]. Female. White. At Home. Born Mississippi.

It appears that Thomas was not in Red Bluff at the time of the census, perhaps away on business.

From Margaret (Metcalfe) Hassin on 14 September 2003:

Howard--
You had asked me earlier about any info on the Boarmans. I found an old picture of a small cemetery. It has a tall monument in the middle and a couple of smaller ones. Written on the back is the following:
Red Bluff Sept. 13 - 51
Grandpa and grandma Boarman’s grave.
Plot covers two lots, - fenced area and big trees on right. in all 12 graves.
All in excellent state of preservation
Purchase Apr. 27, 1863. [This date has a pencil line through it and Dec. 31, 1862 is written above it.]
4 persons buried
(Two minor children
See little marble lamb)
There is a small monument with a lamb lying on top, but I can’t see the other markers. I can see 2 concrete urns (one in right corner and one in left corner) and the little cemetery is surrounded by a wrought iron fence. There are 2 big trees beside it. There are words on the big monument, but I can’t read them. This is an OLD picture and small--about 3-1/2' x 6'.
Wouldn’t it be great if we could find this cemetery!
I will try to scan and email to you.
Margaret

From Margaret (Metcalfe) Hassin on 14 September 2003:

Howard--
I was looking through my “stuff”--found an email from the Genealogica Research team of the Tehama County Gen. & Historical Society. They say:
“One of our pioneer chroniclers indicates Thomas Michael born in Baltimore, MS in 1824 came to Red Bluff (from where is unknown) in 1859. He appears in the 1860 & 1870 census, a resident of Red Bluff . He died in Red Bluff April 13, 1891. It is said three of his five children survived him, Mary Louise, Margaret and Thomas Mills. The children are listed as:
Mary Louise BOARMAN, born 1855
Margaret BOARMAN, born California 1859
Thomas M. BOARMAN, born July 19, 1860, died Red Bluff Nov. 16, 1861
Thomas Mills BOARMAN, born Red Bluff Sept 24, 1862
Gertrude BOARMAN, born Jan. 11, 1866, died May 13, 1866
This is the extend of our records for the BOARMAN family in Tehama County. We deduce that Mary Louise was not born in Tehama as her birthdate indicates she was 4 yrs. old when her family came to this area.”
My contact there is: Scott Sherman, Reference Librarian for the Genealogical Research Team. Email: rssroots@pacbell.net
Margaret

_______________
¹ Wm Boarman household, 1840 U.S. census, Baltimore County, Maryland, Baltimore City, Ward 12, page 299, line 6; National Archives micropublication M704, roll 161.
² Thomas J. Boarman household, 1850 U.S. census, Charles County, Maryland, population schedule, Bojantown District, page 280, sheet 189, line 14, dwelling 1092, family 1092; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 290.
³ T. M. Boarman household, 1860 U.S. census, Tehama County, California, population schedule, Red Bluff, page 923, line 35, dwelling 538, family 538; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 70.
⁴ Mary Boarman household, 1870 U.S. census, Tehama County, California, population schedule, Red Bluff, page 77, sheet 180A, line 1, dwelling 1, family 1; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 92.

48. ⁹William Lyons Metcalfe, son of ⁸Oren Metcalfe [11] and Zuleika Rosalie Lyons. Born on 30 Sep. 1849 in Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi. Baptized on 30 May 1851 in Natchez when a year old. Died before 1922, at most 72 years old.

Married Mary H. Roche, dau. of Maj. James Richard Roche (son of James R. Roche and Winifred Ann Mitchell) and Susan E. Mitchell (dau. of Spencer Mitchell and Lucy Peach), on 1 March 1881 in St. Paul’s Church, San Francisco, San Francisco County, California when 31 years old (Mary H. was about 18 years old). Divorced. Mary H. Roche b. in March 1863 in Washington, District of Columbia; d. on 21 June 1919 in Washington, 56 years old; bur. on 25 June 1919 in Glenwood Cemetery, Washington; m. (2) Lemuel J. Barber (March 1861 in New York–), son of Daniel Barber (son of Zebediah Barber and Charlotte _____) and Sara Elizabeth _____, on 19 Dec. 1891 when 28 years old (Lemuel J. was 30 years old).

Issue of William Lyons Metcalfe and Mary H. Roche:
94 i. dau. ¹⁰Bernice Roche Metcalfe b. on 19 Feb. 1882 in Ravenna Manor House, Natchez.
95 ii. son John Rousseau Metcalfe b. on 11 Sep. 1884 in Manhattan, New York County, New York.

Notes on William Lyons Metcalfe:

William (called Will) was born on 30 September 1849 in Natchez¹ and baptized there on 30 May 1851.² He adopted the use of the middle initial L (which does not appear in his baptismal record), and it is highly likely that it stood for Lyons, after his mother’s family.

Not much is known about Will’s life. He trained for the law and ultimately qualified. It was noted that on 16 November 1872, while an Assistant in the Chancery [Court] Clerk’s Office in Natchez, he petitioned the Southern Claims Commission for $300 in recompense for one light gray horse taken from him on 15 August 1863 when he was thirteen years old.³ George S. Whitcomb, Frank Howe, Orin Metcalfe and Charles Smith (“colored”), all residents of Natchez, were “witnesses to prove the taking, use, and value of the property.” Will based his claim on the following incident:

[The horse] was taken from your petitioner on or about the 15th day of August AD 1863, by Major Warden of the 4th Illinois Cavalry Vols. and his Command and turned over to S. S. Whitney, Captain and A. Q. M. [Assistant Quartermaster] of the Post & District of Natchez, Miss. for the use of a portion of the Army Stationed at said post and District as he fully believes. That Brig. Gen. Ransom⁴ Commanded said post at that time.
Your petitioner would State that said property was previously taken by the Troops of said post at Natchez, and on application to General Ransom, Commanding, the property was returned to your petitioner, but was again taken as above stated;—No receipt or voucher was ever given for said property.

Will deposed that he had never voluntarily served in the Confederate Army or Navy, and that he never voluntarily provided supplies to the Confederate Army or Navy—a standard declaration appended to virtually all petitions at the time. He was fifteen years old when the War ended.

His claim was disallowed, and we don’t even know the horse’s name!

Will married Mary (Mamie) H. Roche of Washington, D.C., on 1 March 1881 in San Francisco.⁵ Mamie was living there with her father and stepmother at the time. Will probably had gone there to practice law.

On 2/10/03 7:14 PM, John Pond at jep111@earthlink.net wrote:

“Hi Howard! Sorry to be so long out of touch, but you might find this interesting from the San Francisco Morning Call, August 17, 1880 (emphasis added):

The Pond-McHenry Nuptials. The wedding of Mr. Charles F. Pond, of the United States Navy, and Miss Emma McHenry, daughter of the Hon. John McHenry, of this city, was celebrated on Tuesday evening last at the residence of the bride’s parents, No. 34 Glen Park Avenue. The services were conducted according to the ritual of the Episcopal Church by the Rev. Wm. H. Platt, of Grace Cathedral. As was generally understood, the wedding was very private with the relatives, and only a few of the intimate friends of the family were present. The bride was attended by Miss Syria Brown, daughter of the late J. Ross Brown, of Oakland, as first bridesmaid, Miss Bessie McHenry and Miss Mary McHenry, and Miss Emily Hay. The groom was waited upon by his brother officer, Lieutenant Charles Putnam, first groomsman, assisted by Mr. Wm. L. Metcalfe, Mr John McHenry, Jr., and Master Willie Hay.
According to the regulations of the army and navy, the groom and his first groomsman wore the social-intercourse uniform, which made a pleasing contrast with the plainer dress of the other groomsmen. Lieutenant Pond is at present connected with the United States Coast Survey steamer Hassler, which ship he will join after his leave expires, some time in September next.
The bride was the recipient of many beautiful and costly presents. Among those present were Dr. and Mrs. Wm. H. Platt and Miss Platt, Mr. and Mrs J.B. Metcalfe and Miss Boarman, Miss Wallace, Messrs. Ryland and Richard Wallace, Judge S.S. Wright, Mr. Kirk Wright, Miss Nannie Wright, Miss Lizzie Wright, Judge James McM. Shafter and Miss Julia Shafter, Major Roche, U.S.A., Mrs. and Miss Roche, Dr. and Mrs. Farwell, Lieutenant Coffin, Mrs. Simenton and Chief Engineer Aston, U.S.N., Mr. and Mrs. Dottie Sargent, Mrs. Spencer Brown, Miss Poole, Mr. Maurice Dore and Misses Dore, Mr. F.B. Boarman, Mr. E.B. Lamare, Mr. H.I. Coon, Mr. Charles Jackson, Dr. Ledyard, Mr. William Cary Jones, Mr. Hubert Vischer, Mr. Charles Hay and Mr. Lindhart. Mr. Pond and his fair bride are at present at Santa Cruz, and after visitng Monterey will return to this city and be at home to their friends on Fridays after the 19th instant, at the residence of their parents, No. 34 Glen Park Avenue.

Looks like your g-grandparents might have gotten ideas at my g-grandparent’s wedding! Also, note that Elizabeth McHenry and her future husband Emanuel Lamare were also there. Love must have been in the air! Hope all is well with you. Cheers! John Pond.”

Will and Mamie had two children. While Will was a Protestant son of the Confederacy, Mamie was a Catholic daughter of a Union officer. It apparently wasn’t a completely successful marriage, ending in the last half of the 1880s, and Will was subsequently noted as a lawyer in Oregon in 1891.⁶

A marriage was recorded⁷ in Multnomah County, Oregon (Portland) of a William L. Metcalf and Lena L. Howard, both of Multnomah County, in 1 January 1894 in the study of Trinity Church. The minister was G. W. Gist, Pastor of Grace Methodist Episcopal Church in Portland, Oregon, and the witnesses were Bronetta Kenyon and Mary E. Squires.

A census record⁸ places a William L. Metcalfe in San Francisco in 1900. This William was born in Mississippi and in 1900 was single and a roomer in the household of John Broadwood at 1945 Howard Street. His listed occupation was that of a solicitor (one meaning of which is a lawyer who prepares legal papers and practices in the lower courts, which is consistent with Will’s training). However, Thie William’s age is listed as 35, born in 1865, father born Mississippi, mother born Louisiana. It is uncertain whether the birth date and parents’ birth places are erroneous and this is Will, or the birth date is correct and parents’ places erroneous and this is another William L. Metcalfe born in Mississippi some 15 or 16 years later (no record of such a birth has yet been found).

In any case, no further marriage record nor death record has yet been found for Will on the west coast.

_______________
¹ The 1850, 1860 and 1870 Federal Censuses of Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi, list William in his father’s household as 1/2, 10 and 21 years old, respectively.
² Register of Baptisms, First Presbyterian Church, Natchez, Mississippi.
³ Records of the Southern Claims Commission, Petition, William L. Metcalfe of Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi.
⁴ Thomas Edward Greenfield Ransom (1834–1864) was appointed Brigadier General, USA, on 15 April 1863 and took command of a brigade at Vicksburg, Mississippi.
⁵ The marriage notice appeared in the San Francisco Daily Morning Call on Wednesday, March 2, 1881, p. 4: “Metcalfe—Roche—In this city, March 1, at St. Paul’s Episcopal Church, by Rev. Wm. H. Platt, Wm. L. Metcalfe to Miss Mary H. Roche, daughter of Major Jas. R. Roche, U.S. A., both of San Francisco.”
⁶ Biographical and Historical Memoirs of Mississippi, Vol. II (Spartanburg, South Carolina: The Reprint Company, 1978), 432–433. This editon was reproduced from an 1891 edition in the Mississippi Department of Archives and History in Jackson, Mississippi.
⁷ Xerographic copy of marriage certificate in the possession of the author, provided by a researcher at the Genealogical Forum of Oregon, Inc., in Portland, on 30 May 2006, taken from the Multnomah County, Oregon, Marriage Record Book 10, page 16.
⁸ John Broadwood household, 1900 U.S. census, San Francisco County, California, population schedule, San Francisco, enumeration district 101, supervisor’s district 1, sheet 2B, line 85, dwelling 31, family 50; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 102. William is listed on line 39.

Images for William Lyons Metcalfe:

William Lyons (“Will”) Metcalfe. Photo courtesy of John Pond.

Notes on Mary H. Roche:

Mary (called Mamie or Mame), the fifth child of James Richard Roche and Susan E. Mitchell, was born in 1862/3 in Washington, D.C. Mamie was enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Washington, D.C., in the household of her father and mother as follows:¹

James R. Roach, 45 [sic, 40], male, white, clerk Treasury Dept., personal property $1000, born Maryland.
Susan Roach, 41 [sic, 38/39], female, white, keeping house, born Maryland.
James A. Roach, 16, male, white, page at Capitol, born D. Columbia.
John C. Roach, 10, male, whie, at home, born D. Columbia, attended school within the year.
Mary H. Roach, 7, female, born D. Columbia.
William M. Roach, 4, born D. Columbia.
Alice Graham, 17, female, white, at home, born D. Columbia.
Matilda Janeway, 40, female, black, domestic servant, born Maryland, cannot read or write.
Henry C. Lee, 12, male, black, domestic servant, born Maryland.

Mamie was listed in the 1880 federal census of San Francisco, San Francisco County, California, in the household of her father and stepmother as follows:²

James R. Roche, white male, 45 [sic, 50], married, U.S. Army, born Maryland, father born Ireland, mother born Maryland.
Eliza Lee Roche, white, female, 35 [sic, 38], wife, married, keeping house, born Maryland, father born Maryland, mother born Delaware [sic, Maryland].
Mary Roche, white, female, 17, daughter, single, at home, born District of Columbia, father born Maryland, mother born Maryland.
Wm M. Roche, white, male, 14, son, at ome, single, born District of Columbia, father born Maryland, mother born Maryland, attended school within the year.
Ah Lee Doon, asian, male, 19, domestic, single, domestic. Unemployed two months during current year, born China, father born China, mother born China.

Mamie’s marriage to William (Will) L. Metcalfe of Natchez, Mississippi, in 1881 apparently wasn’t a completely successful marriage, ending later in the 1880s. Will was thirteen years her senior.

Mamie married second Lemuel J. Barber on 19 December 1891 by whom she had no children.

Lemuel, Mamie and Mamie’s son John Rousseau by Will were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Washington, D.C., as follows:³

Lemuel J. Barber, head of household, white, male, born March 1861, 39, married nine years, born New York, father born New York, mother born New York, electrician, reads, writes, speaks English, owns mortgaged home.
Mary R. Barber, wife, white, female, born March 1863, 37, married nine years, two children, two living, born District of Columbia, father born Maryland, mother born Maryland, reads, writes, speaks English.
Rousseau Barber, son, white, male, born Sept. 1884, 15, single, born New York, father born New York [sic, Mississippi], mother born District of Columbia.

Lemuel and Mamie are enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Cameron County, Texas, as follows:⁴

Lemuel Barber, head of household, male, white, 49, married 26 years [sic, should be 18], born New York, father born New York, mother born New York, speaks English, farmer, works on own account, reads and writes.
Mary R. Barber, wife, female, white, 47, married 26 years [sic, should be 18], two children both living, born District of Columbia, father born Virginia [sic, Maryland], mother born Virginia [sic, Maryland], speaks English, reads and writes. (Both children were, of course, by Will.)

Listed as a resident of Bethel, Connecticut, Mamie died 21 June 1919 in Washington, D.C., and was buried there in Glenwood Cemetery on 25 June 1919.⁵

Mamie was described as a joyful and fun person (and rather short, blond and heavyset) by her granddaughter, Elizabeth Metcalfe (Elisabeth Oberwinder).

_______________
¹ James R. Roach household, 1870 U.S. census, District of Columbia, population schedule, Georgetown, Washington, page 168, sheet 587, line 8, dwelling 1145, family 1228; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 127.
² James R. Roche household, 1880 U.S. census, San Francisco County, California, population schedule, San Francisco, enumeration district 15-9, supervisor’s district 1, page 3, sheet 179C, line 39, dwelling 26, family 29; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 77. Noted as at 29 Glen Park Avenue.
³ Lemuel J. Barber household, 1900 U.S. census, District of Columbia, population schedule, Washington, Wheeler Road, enumeration district 10, supervisor’s district 1, sheet 44A, line 16, dwelling 892, family 926; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 158.
⁴ Lemuel Barber household, 1910 U.S. census, Cameron County, Texas, population schedule, part of Justice Precinct 5, enumeration district 34, supervisor’s district 10, sheet 16B, line 76, dwelling 291, family 296; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 1536.
⁵ Letter from Glenwood Cemetery. She is buried as Mary R. Barber in Lot 193, Section B, Site 1, interred on 25 June 1919. Sites 2, 7, 8 and 9 have been accounted for. Site 3 had not been used as of the date of the letter. All said sites were purchased by James R. Roche on 26 June 1862. Sites 4, 5, 6, 10, 11 and 12 were purchased on the same date by a Harriet Mitchell, and a Harriet Mitchell is interred in Site 5. (Harriet may have the the mother of Susan E. Mitchell.) The remaining sites had not been used.
A notation under remarks in the cemetery records on 1 August 1901: Widow Mrs. Eliza Lee Roche in California—children by first wife—James A. Roche—38 Mass. Ave. Mary H. Roche Barber—Anacostia, D.C. Mr. Wm. M. Roche, Los Angeles, California.

Images for Mary H. Roche:

Mary H. (“Mamie”) Roche.

49. ⁹Zuleika Rosalie Metcalfe, dau. of ⁸Oren Metcalfe [11] and Zuleika Rosalie Lyons. Born on 15 March 1855 in Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi. Baptized on 20 April 1856 in Natchez when a year old. Died on 14 Sep. 1937 in Natchez, 82 years old.

Married Maj. George Dilse Lawrence, son of Eli U. Lawrence and Martha _____, on 2 June 1885 in Natchez when 30 years old (Maj. George Dilse was 44 years old). Maj. George Dilse Lawrence b. on 5 May 1841 in Vicksburg, Warren County, Mississippi; d. on 29 Dec. 1896 in Natchez, 55 years old; m. (1) Edna F. Conway (1846/7 in Virginia–); issue (surname Lawrence): Conway M. (1868/9 in Mississippi–), Katie C. (1872/3 in Mississippi–) and Edmond F. (1875/6 in Mississippi–).

Issue of Zuleika Rosalie Metcalfe and Maj. George Dilse Lawrence:
i. son ¹⁰Robert Trabue Lawrence b. on 9 April 1886 in Natchez; d. on 14 Nov. 1954 in Washington, District of Columbia, 68 years old; bur. in City Cemetery, Natchez; m. Agnes Morris (of Natchez–), dau. of Hon. _____ Morris.
96 ii. dau. Zuleika Metcalfe Lawrence b. on 21 Sep. 1888 in Rome, Floyd County, Georgia.

Notes on Zuleika Rosalie Metcalfe:

Zuleika (“Zulie”) Rosalie Metcalfe, was born 15 March 1855 in Natchez and baptized there on 20 April 1856.¹

She married George Dilse Lawrence on 2 June 1885 in Natchez. He was born on 5 May 1841 in Fredericksburg, Virginia [sic, the censuses consistently state he was born in Mississippi, no doubt in Vicksburg]. He served in the Confederate Army where he rose to the rank of Major. He had married first _____ Conway and had three children: son Conway and two daughters [sic, the census states two sons and one daughter]. By 1891 George had become superintendant of the Southern Department of the Louisville, New Orleans & Texas Railroad in Rome, Georgia, where he and Zulie resided for about ten years. When Zulie’s father Oren died in November 1895 George moved back to Natchez to take over Oren’s insurance business, and they lived in Zulie’s former home Ravenna. Also living in Ravenna were Zulie’s sister Anna with her husband and two children. George died a year after moving back to Natchez, on 29 December 1896 in Natchez, and Ravenna passed to Zulie’s brother Richard Inge Metcalfe. Zulie survived George by forty years.²

Zulie and her children were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi, in the household of her sister Anna as follows:³

James S. Flemming, head of household, white, male, born Oct. 1858, 42, married 11 years, born Mississippi, father born Virginia, mother born Mississippi, merchant, reads, writes, speaks English.
Anna M. Flemming, wife, white, female, born July 1831, 38, married 11 years, three children, two living, born Mississippi, father born Connecticut, mother born Mississippi, reads, writes, speaks English.
Mary R. Flemming, daughter white, female, born Aug 1890, 9, single, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, reads, writes, speaks English.
James S. Flemming, son, white, male, born Sept.1892, 7, single, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi.
Zulika Lawrence, sister-in-law, white, female, born Mch. 1855, 45, married [?] years, born Mississippi, father born Connecticut, mother born Mississippi.
Robert A. Lawrence, nephew, white, male, born [June?] 1885, 14, single, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, at school, attended school within the year, reads, writes, speaks English.
Zulika M. Lawrence, niece, white, female, born Sept. 1888, 12, single, born Georgia, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, at school, attended school within the year, reads, writes, speaks English.
Hibernia Trabue, cousin, white, female, born June 1839, 60, widowed, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, reads, writes, speaks English.

Hibernia (Inge) Trabue was Zulie’s second cousin. Also listed were eight black servants.

About 1900 Zulie built a separate home for her family close to and on the grounds of Ravenna, naming it Ravenna Cottage. A few years later Anna’s husband built a large 2-1/2-story home for his family nearby on the grounds of Ravenna, naming it Ravennaside. Located at 601 South Union Street, Ravennaside “is imposing in its beauty and fascinating in its architecture, including its 231 feet of porch sweeping around three sides of the house and 11 doorways that open onto galleries. . . . The entrance hall is one of the grandest in Natchez, featuring a wide staircase and an elaborate fireplace and mantel on one side and double doors leading into the front parlor on the opposite side.”⁴ The home has now been fully restored by Mr. and Mrs. John Van Hook, and is open as a bed-and-breakfast.

Zulie, her daughter and Hibernia were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi, as follows:⁵

Zuleika Lawrence Sr., head of household, female, white, 55, married, two children both living, born Mississippi, father born Connecticut, mother born Mississippi, speaks English, reads, writes, owns home free of mortgage.
Zulieka Lawrence Jr., daughter, female, white, 21, single, born Georgia, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, speaks English, reads, writes.
Hibernia Trabue, cousin, female, white, 68, widowed, no children, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, speaks English, reads, writes.

Zulie was enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi, in her daughter Zuleika’s family as follows:⁶

Will Adams, head of household, owns home free of mortgage, male, white, 48 [sic, 45 in January], married, reads, writes, born in United States, father born in United States, mother born in United States, speaks English, druggist in drug store working on own account.
Zuleika L. Adams, wife, female, white, 31, married, reads, writes, born Georgia, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, speaks Engish.
George Adams, son, male, white, 8-8/12 [sic, 6-0/12 in January], single, reads, writes, born Mississippi, father born United States, mother born Georgia, speaks English.
Roane F. Adams, daughter, female, white, 7-1/12 [sic, 4-6/12 in January, applies to daughter Zuleika], single, reads, writes, born Mississippi, father born United States, mother born Georgia, speaks English.
Zuleika L. Adams, daughter, female, white, 2-6/12 [sic, 2-5/12 in January, applies to daughter Roane], single, reads, writes, born Mississippi, father born United States, mother born Georgia, speaks English.
Zulika L. Lawrence, mother, female, white, 63 [sic, 64 in January], widowed, reads, writes, born Mississippi, father born United States, mother born Mississippi, speaks English.

The reference to January relates to the census being taken “as of” 1 January 1920.

Zulie was enumerated in the 1930 federal census of Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi, with her daughter Zuleika’s family, as follows:⁷

William A. Adams, head of household, owns home worth $7000, wons radio set, male, white, 56, married when 30 years old, reads and writes, born Louisiana, father born Louisiana [sic], mother born Mississippi, speaks English, drug store merchant, employed.
Zuleika L. Adams, wife, female, white, 41, married when 21 years old, reads and writes, born Georgia, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, speaks English.
William A. Adams, son, male, with, 19, single, attended school in current year, reads and writes, born Mississippi, father born Louisiana, mother born Georgia, speaks English.
George L. Adams, son, male, white, 16, singles, attended school in current year, reads and writes, born Mississippi, father born Louisiana, mother born Georgia, speaks English.
Roane F. Adams, daughter, female, white, 12, single, attended school in current year, reads and writes, born Mississippi, father born Louisiana, mother born Georgia, speaks English.
Zuleika Lawrence, mother-in-law, female, white, 75, widowed, married when 29 years old, reads and writes, reads and writes, born Mississippi, father born Connecticut, mother born Mississippi, speaks English. She is listed at 603 Union.

Zulie died on 14 September 1937 in Natchez. She and George had two children.

_______________
¹ Register of Baptisms, First Presbyterian Church, Natchez, Mississippi.
1860, 1870 and 1880 Federal Censuses of Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi, where she is listed in her father’s household as 4, 15 and 25 years old, respectively.
² Kate Don Brandon (Mrs. George Lawrence Adams) of Natchez, Mississippi, in personal communications, 20 April 1994, was the source of information on Zulie and her descendants.
Zulie’s obituary from the Natchez Democrat (undated copy, probably mid-September 1937).
International Genealogical Index (IGI)—Mississippi,.
Biographical and Historical Memoirs of Mississippi, Vol. II (Spartanburg, South Carolina: The Reprint Company, 1978), 432–433.
³ James S. Flemming household, 1900 U.S. census, Adams County, Mississippi, population schedule, Natchez, Ward 4, Union Street, enumeration district 10, supervisor’s district 7, sheet 5A, line 35, dwelling 89, family 93; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 799.
⁴ “Ravennaside,” Natchez Democrat, Natchez, Mississippi, Saturday, October 2, 1993, p. 34.
⁵ Zuleika Lawrence Sr. household, 1910 U.S. census, Adams County, Mississippi, population schedule, Natchez Ward 4 Beat 1, enumeration district 10, supervisor’s district 1, sheet 7, line 91, dwelling 130, family 156; National Archives micropublication T324, roll 731.
⁶ Will Adams household, 1920 U.S. census, Adams County, Mississippi, population schedule, Natchez Ward 4, 603 Ravenna Place, enumeration district 10, supervisor’s district 7, sheet 4A, line 4, dwelling 77, family 80; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 868.
⁷ William A. Adams household, 1930 U.S. census, Adams County, Mississippi, population schedule, Natchez Ward 4, Beat 1, 601 Union, enumeration district 1-7, supervisor’s district 10, sheet 2B, line 70, dwelling 38, family 44; National Archives micropublication T626, roll 1137.

Notes on Maj. George Dilse Lawrence:

George was enumerated in the 1850 federal census of Vicksburg, Warren County, Mississippi, in the household of his father as follows:¹

Eli U. Lawrence, 40, male, clerk, born Tennessee.
Martha Lawrence, 34, female, born Tennessee
George D. Lawrence, 9, male, born Mississippi.
Frank S. Lawrence, 7, male, born Mississippi.
Isabella J. Lawrence, 4, female, born Mississippi.
Elias S. Lawrence, 2, male, born Mississippi.

George and his family by his first wife were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Vicksburg, Warren County, Mississippi, as follows:²

Geo. D. Lawrence, white, male, 39, genl. supt., married, genl. supt., born Mississipi, father born Mississippi [sic], mother born Mississippi [sic].
Ed[na?] F. Lawrence, white, female, 32, wife, married, house duty, born Virginia, father born Virginia, mother born Virginia.
Conway M. Lawrence, white, male, 11, son, attended school within the year, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Virginia.
Edmo[nd] F. Lawrence, white, male, 4, son, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Virginia.
Katie C. Lawrence, white, female, 7, daughter, attended school within the year, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Virginia.

_______________
¹ Eli U. Lawrence household, 1850 U.S. census, Warren County, Mississippi, population schedule, Vicksburg, sheet 198, line 8, dwelling 463, family 481; National Archives micropublication M432, roll 382.
² Geo. D. Lawrence household, 1880 U.S. census, Warren County, Mississippi, population schedule, Vicksburg Fourth Ward, enumeration district 73, supervisor’s district 3, page 44, sheet 435D, line 13, dwelling 520, family 543; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 667.

50. ⁹Anna Metcalfe, dau. of ⁸Oren Metcalfe [11] and Zuleika Rosalie Lyons. Born on 8 July 1861 in Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi. Baptized on 1 Dec. 1861 in Natchez when four months old. Died on 29 May 1936 in Natchez, 74 years old.

Married James Stockman Fleming on 23 Oct. 1886 in Natchez when 25 years old (James Stockman was 27 years old). James Stockman Fleming b. on 15 Nov. 1858 in Natchez; d. on 17 Jan. 1932 in Natchez, 73 years old.

Issue of Anna Metcalfe and James Stockman Fleming:
      i. child ¹⁰_____ Fleming b. say in 1888 in Ravenna, Natchez; d. in infancy in Ravennaside, Natchez.
      ii. dau. Mary Roane Fleming b. on 11 Aug. 1890 in Ravenna; d. on 3 Oct. 1970 in Ravennaside, 80 years old; m. Charles Ferriday Byrnes (14 Aug. 1890 in Ravenna–5 Feb. 1956 in Ravenna), son of R. Lee Byrnes and Helen Ferriday, on 26 May 1917 in Presbyterian Church, Natchez when 26 years old (Charles Ferriday was 26 years old).
      iii. son James Stockman Fleming b. on 28 Aug. 1892 in Ravenna; d. on 17 March 1960 in Ravennaside, 67 years old.

Notes on Anna Metcalfe:

Anna Metcalfe, born on 8 July 1861 at Ravenna in Natchez and baptized in Natchez on 1 December of that year,¹ married James Stockman Fleming on 23 October 1886 in Natchez. He was born 15 November 1858 in Natchez and became a merchant there by 1891. He owned the Metcalfe Insurance Company and was a cotton broker and plantation owner.

Anna and her family along with her sister Zuleika and Zuleika’s family were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi, as follows:²

James S. Flemming, head of household, white, male, born Oct. 1858, 42 [sic, 41], married 11 [sic, 13] years, born Mississippi, father born Virginia, mother born Mississippi, merchant, reads, writes, speaks English.
Anna M. Flemming, wife, white, female, born July 1831, 38, married 11 [sic] years, three children, two living, born Mississippi, father born Connecticut, mother born Mississippi, reads, writes, speaks English.
Mary R. Flemming, daughter white, female, born Aug 1890, 9, single, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, reads, writes, speaks English.
James S. Flemming, son, white, male, born Sept.1892, 7, single, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi.
Zulika Lawrence, sister-in-law, white, female, born Mch. 1855, 45, married [?] years, born Mississippi, father born Connecticut, mother born Mississippi.
Robert A. Lawrence, nephew, white, male, born [June?] 1885, 14, single, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, at school, attended school within the year, reads, writes, speaks English.
Zulika M. Lawrence, niece, white, female, born Sept. 1888, 12, single, born Georgia, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, at school, attended school within the year, reads, writes, speaks English.
Hibernia Trabue, cousin, white, female, born June 1839, 60, widowed, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, reads, writes, speaks English.

Hibernia (Inge) Trabue was Anna’s second cousin. Also listed were eight black servants.

Anna and her family were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi, as follows:³

James S. Fleming Sr., head of household, male, white, 51, married 23 years, born Mississippi, father born Virginia, mother born Kentucky, speaks English, own account, reads, writes, owns home free of mortgage.
Anna M. Fleming, wife, female, white, 48, married 23 years, three children, two living, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, speaks English, reads, writes.
Mary R. Fleming, daughter, female, white, 19, single, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, speaks English, reads, writes.
James S. Fleming Jr., son, male, white, 17, single, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, speaks English, reads, writes, attended school within the year.

Also enumerated were one mulatto and two black servants.

Anna and her family were enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi, as follows:⁴

James Flemming, head of household, owns home free of mortgage, male, white, 60, married, reads, writes, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, speaks Engllish, insurance agent working on own account.
Anna Flemming, wife, female, white, 58, married, reads, writes, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, speaks English
James Flemming Jr., son, male, white, 26, single, reads, writes, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, speaks English, lawyer working in office on own account.

Also listed were one mulatto and three black servants.

Anna and her family, including daughter Roane and her husband, were enumerated in the 1930 federal census of Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi, as follows:⁵

James S. Fleming, head of household, owns home worth $12,000, radio set, male, white, 71, married when 30 years old, speaks English, born Mississippi, father born Virginia, mother born Mississippi, speaks English, manager of insurance company, employed.
Anna M. Fleming, wife, female, white, 69, married when 27 years old, reads and writes, born Mississippi, father born Connecticut, mother born Mississippi, speaks English.
James S. Fleming, son, male, white, 37, single, reads and writes, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, speaks English, lawyer in law office, employed, veteran of World War.
Ferriday Byrnes, son-in-law, male, white, 39, married 27 years, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, speaks English, lawyer in office, employed, veteran of World War.
Roane F. Byrnes, daughter, female, white, 39, married 27 years, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, speaks English.

Three servants recorded as negro were also enumerated.

James died on 17 January 1932 and Anna died on 29 May 1936, both in Natchez.

_______________
¹ Register of Baptisms, First Presbyterian Church, Natchez, Mississippi.
Kate Don Brandon (Mrs. George Lawrence Adams) of Natchez, Mississippi, in personal communications, 20 April 1994, was the source of information on Anna and her children.
1870 and 1880 Federal Censuses of Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi, where she is listed in her father’s household as 9 and 18 years old, respectively.
Biographical and Historical Memoirs of Mississippi, Vol. II (Spartanburg, South Carolina: The Reprint Company, 1978), 432–433.
² James S. Flemming household, 1900 U.S. census, Adams County, Mississippi, population schedule, Natchez, Ward 4, Union Street, enumeration district 10, supervisor’s district 7, sheet 5A, line 35, dwelling 89, family 93; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 799.
³ James S. Fleming Sr. household, 1910 U.S. census, Adams County, Mississippi, population schedule, Natchez Ward 4 Beat 1, 601 Union, enumeration district 10, supervisor’s district 1, sheet 7, line 83, dwelling 129, family 155; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 731.
⁴ James Flemming household, 1920 U.S. census, Adams County, Mississippi, population schedule, Natchez Ward 4, 601 Union Street, enumeration district 10, supervisor’s district 7, sheet 3B, line 98, dwelling 78, family 78; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 868.
⁵ James S. Fleming household, 1930 U.S. census, Adams County, Mississippi, population schedule, Natchez Ward 4, Beat 1, 605 Union, enumeration district 1-7, supervisor’s district 10, sheet 2B, line 78, dwelling 46, family 46; National Archives micropublication T626, roll 1137.

Notes on James Stockman Fleming:

James was enumerated in his brothers’ family (no parents listed in the neighborhood) in the 1860 federal census of Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi, as follows:¹

Isaac Fleming, 15, male, white, no occupation, born Mississippi, attended school within the year.
Alfred Fleming, 13, male, white, no occupation, born Mississippi, attended school within the year.
James S. Fleming, 11, male, white, no occupation, born Mississippi, attended school within the year.
John Leslie, 1, male, white, no occupation, born Mississippi.

_______________
¹ Isaac Fleming household, 1870 U.S. census, Adams County, Mississippi, population schedule, Natchez, page 347, sheet 82, line 1, dwelling 4314, family 4314; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 720.

51. ⁹Richard Inge Metcalfe, son of ⁸Oren Metcalfe [11] and Zuleika Rosalie Lyons. Born on 29 May 1866 in Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi. Baptized on 28 Oct. 1866 in Natchez when four months old. Died on 25 Jan. 1908 in Ravenna, Natchez, 41 years old. Buried in City Cemetery, Natchez.

Married Louise W. Leonard, dau. of Rufus F. Leonard and Lizzie C. _____, in 1888/9 when about 22 years old (Louise W. was about 17 years old). Louise W. Leonard b. on 8 April 1871 in Mississippi; d. on 13 April 1952 in Ravenna, 81 years old; bur. in City Cemetery.

Issue of Richard Inge Metcalfe and Louise W. Leonard:
97 i. dau. ¹⁰Louise L. Metcalfe b. on 9 March 1900 in Ravenna.

Notes on Richard Inge Metcalfe:

Richard Inge Metcalfe, born on 29 May 1866 in Natchez and baptized there on 28 October of that year.¹ married Louise Learned. After his father’s death in 1895, Richard inherited Ravenna. He became a bank clerk and later an insurance agent.

Richard and Louise were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi, in the household of Louise’s father as follows:²

Rufuss Leonard, head of household, white, male, born Dec. 1834, 65, married 32 years, born Mississippi, father born Maine, mother born Maine, capitalist, reads, writes, speaks English, owns farm free of mortgage.
Lizzie C. Leonard, wife, white, female born Dec. 1842, 57, married 32 years, three children, two living, born Mississippi, father born Scotland, mother born Scotland, housekeeping, reads, writes, speaks English.
Andrew B. Leonard, son, white, male, born Jan. 1869, married 2 years, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, capitalist, reads, writes, speaks English.
Louisa Metcalfe, daughter, white, female, born Apr. 1871, 29, married 2 years, no children, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, housekeeping, reads, writes, speaks English.
Richard Metcalfe, son-in-law, white, male, born June 1866, 33, married 2 years, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, insurance agent, reads, writes, speaks English.
Elizabeth Leonard, daughter-in-law, white, female, born Oct. 1873, 26, married 2 years, one child living, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, housekeeping, reads, writes, speaks English.
Elizabeth Leonard, granddaughter, white, female, born Sept. 1899, 8/12, single, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi.
Helen Montgomery, friend, white, female, born Feb. 1843, 57, single, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, has no occupation, reads, writes, speaks English.

Richard died on 25 January 1908 at Ravenna.³ He and Louise had a daughter.

_______________
¹ Register of Baptisms, First Presbyterian Church, Natchez, Mississippi, provides a birth date of 21 January 1866. This seems to be in error based on his tombstone and the 1900 census. January may be a misreading of June.
² Ruffus Leonard household, 1900 U.S. census, Adams County, Mississippi, population schedule, Natchez Ward 1 Beat 4, enumeration district 4, supervisor’s district 7, sheet 10B, line 65, dwelling 180, family 236; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 799.
³ Death records of the City Sexton and City Clerk, City of Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi from 3 Jan 1857 to 12 Dec 1909: “Richard I. Metcalfe d. Jan. 25, 1908, at 41 yrs, thrombosis busilar artery, Dr. W. T. Jones, Physician, bur. City Square.”
Tombstone, Plot 3, Natchez City Cemetery: “Richard Inge Metcalfe, May 29, 1866—Jan. 24, 1908.”

Notes on Louise W. Leonard:

Tombstone, Plot 3, Natchez City Cemetery: “Louise Learned Metcalfe, Apr. 8, 1871—Apr. 13, 1952.”

Louise was enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi, in her father’s family as follows:¹

R. F. Leunard, white, male, 45, married, lumber merchant, born Mississippi, father born Maine, mother born Mississipp.
S. C. Leunard, white, female, 37, wife, married, keeping house, born Mississippi, father born Scotland, mother born Scotland.
A. B. Leunard, white, male, 11, son, at school, attended school within the year, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi.
L. W. Leunard, white, female, 9, daughter, at school, attended school within the year, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi.
B. B. Leunard, white female, 7, daughter, at home, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi.
H. M. Montgomery, white, female, 39, companion, single, at home, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born [?].
R. S. Blythe, white, male, 18, [ward?], single, at school, born Mississippi, father born Scotland, mother born [?].
Maria Dorsey, mulatto, female, 35, servant, single, cook, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born [?].
T. W. Blythe, white, female, 22, servant, single, house servant, born Mississippi, father born Scotland, mother born [?].

Louise was enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi, as follows:²

Louise Metcalfe, head of household, female, white, 39, widowed, one child, one living, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, speaks English, reads and writes, owns home free of mortgage.

Louise and her daughter were enumerated in the 1930 federal census of Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi, as follows:³

Louise L. Metcalf, head of household, owns home worth $5000, female, white, 59, widowed, married when 19 years old, reads and writes, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, speaks English.
Louise L. Metcalf, daughter, female, white, 28, single, reads and writes, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, speaks English.

_______________
¹ R. F. Leunard household, 1880 U.S. census, Adams County, Mississippi, population schedule, Natchez, enumeration district 48, supervisor’s district 3, page 24, sheet 2D, line 8, dwelling 30, family 35; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 639.
² James S. Fleming Sr. household, 1910 U.S. census, Adams County, Mississippi, population schedule, Natchez Ward 4 Beat 1, 601 Union, enumeration district 10, supervisor’s district 1, sheet 7, line 94, dwelling 131, family 157; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 731.
³ James S. Fleming household, 1930 U.S. census, Adams County, Mississippi, population schedule, Natchez Ward 4, Beat 1, 603 Union, enumeration district 1-7, supervisor’s district 10, sheet 2B, line 76, dwelling 39, family 45; National Archives micropublication T626, roll 1137.

Tenth Generation

Issue of ⁹Samuel Horton Smith [12] (⁸Sybil Metcalf [2], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and Caroline _____

52. ¹⁰Sybil Smith, dau. of ⁹Samuel Horton Smith [12] and Caroline _____. Born in 1838/9 in Ohio.

Married W. Beach. W. Beach b. in 1842/3 in England.

Issue of Sybil Smith and W. Beach:
i. son ¹¹Fred Beach b. in July 1879 in Ohio.

Notes on Sybil Smith:

Sybil and her family were enumated in the 1880 federal census of Hambden, Geauga County, Ohio, next door to her mother and brother Roland as follows:¹

W. Beach, white, male, 37, married, farmer, born England, father born England, mother born England.
Sybil Beach, white, female, 40, wife, married, keeping house, born Ohio, father born _____, mother born Massachusetts.
Freddie Beach, white, male, 10/12, born in July, son, single, born Ohio, father born England, mother born Ohio.

_______________
¹ W. Beach household, 1880 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Hambden, enumeration district 71, supervisor’s district 8, page 18, sheet 72B, line 17, dwelling 155, family 159; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 1019.

Issue of _____ Faulk and ⁹Maria Smith [13] (⁸Sybil Metcalf [2], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1])

53. ¹⁰Lawrence S. Faulk, son of _____ Faulk and ⁹Maria Smith [13]. Born in 1833 in Ohio.

Married Sarah Ann _____. Sarah Ann _____ b. in 1834 in Ohio.

Issue of Lawrence S. Faulk and Sarah Ann _____:
      i. dau. ¹¹Juliette E. Faulk b. in 1860 in Ohio.
      ii. dau. Nancy E. Faulk b. in 1861 in Ohio.
      iii. dau. Minnie Faulk b. in 1866/7 in Ohio; d. young.
      iv. dau. Flora May Faulk b. in Aug. 1869 in Ohio.

Notes on Lawrence S. Faulk:

Lawrence and his family were enumerated in the 1860 federal census of Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:¹

Lawrence and his family were enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:²

The above enumeration was taken on 16 March. But Lawrence’s children were also enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, on 5 July by a different census marshall, in the household of a brother as follows:³

Lawrence and his family were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:⁴

Lorence S. Faulk, white, male, 47, married, laborer, employed 5 months during the current year, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Sarah N. Faulk, white, female, 46, wife, married, housekeeping, born Ohio, father born New York, mother born New York.
Juliette E. Faulk, white, female, 19, daughter, single, at home, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Nancy E. Faulk, white, female, 18, daughter, single, at home, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
May Faulk, white, female, 10, daughter, single, at home, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Horton H. Faulk, white, male, 45, brother, single, laborer, employed 6 moths during the current year, born Ohio, father born New York [sic], mother born Ohio.

_______________
¹ Lawrence S. Faulk household, 1860 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Village, page 10, line 4, dwelling 83, family 84; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 967.
² Lawrence Falk household, 1870 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Village, page 19, sheet 91 (continued on the next sheet), line 38, dwelling 137, family 154; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 1204.
³ S. S. Falk household, 1870 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Village, page 11, sheet 78, line 22, dwelling 111, family 114; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 1204.
⁴ Lorence S. Faulk household, 1880 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Village, enumeration district 68, supervisor’s district 8, page 5, sheet 37B, line 39, dwelling 49, family 61; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 1018.

Issue of Leander Jason Randall and ⁹Eliza Smith [14] (⁸Sybil Metcalf [2], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1])

54. ¹⁰Juliet Randall, dau. of Leander Jason Randall and ⁹Eliza Smith [14]. Born on 12 June 1852 in Ohio. Died on 17 Oct. 1919, 67 years old.

Married Wilford Ira Canfield, son of Delos W. Canfield (son of Platt Canfield and Mary Read) and Sophronia E. Allen (dau. of Ira Allen and Rebecca Calkins), on 22 May 1872 when 19 years old (Wilford Ira was 21 years old). Wilford Ira Canfield b. on 17 Dec. 1850 in Ohio; d. on 8 Nov. 1909, 58 years old.

Issue of Juliet Randall and Wilford Ira Canfield:
      i. son ¹¹Leander Randall Canfield b. on 7 June 1873 in Ohio.
98   ii. son Delos Wilford Canfield b. on 3 July 1875 in Ohio.
99   iii. dau. Florence Eliza Canfield b. on 27 Sep. 1885 in Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio.
      iv. son Ira Allen Canfield b. on 12 Sep. 1895.

Notes on Juliet Randall:

Chapin¹ said Juliet V., daughter of Leander Jason and Eliza (Smith) Randall, was born on 12 June 1852. She married Ira Wilford Canfield on 22 May 1872. He was born 17 December 1850. They had four children. He died on 8 November 1909 and she died on 17 October 1919.

Juliett and her family were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, next door to her father-in-law as follows:²

Wilford I. Canfield, white, male, 29-, married, fire and life insurance agent, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Vermont.
Juliaett V. Canfield, white, female, 28, wife, married, housekeeper, born Ohio, father born New York, mother born Ohio.
L. Randall, white, mael, 7, son, single, attended school within the year, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother borh Ohio.
Delos W. Randall Jr., white, male, 5, son, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother borh Ohio.

_______________
¹ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. II: Eighth to Twelfth Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 1968–1969.
² Wilford I. Canfield household, 1880 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Village, enumeration district 68, supervisor’s district 8, page 9, sheet 39B, line 44, dwelling 103, family 115; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 1018.

Issue of ⁹George Kendall Smith [15] (⁸Sybil Metcalf [2], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and Anna Davis McGee

55. ¹⁰Lizzie Metcalf Smith, dau. of ⁹George Kendall Smith [15] and Anna Davis McGee. Born in Jefferson County, Arkansas.

Married Peter Bridges.

Issue of Lizzie Metcalf Smith and Peter Bridges:
i. dau. ¹¹Louise Bridges b. in Pine Bluff, Jefferson County, Arkansas; m. W. A. Jackson.

Notes on Lizzie Metcalf Smith:

“Mrs. Lizzie Metcalf [Smith] Bridges. Born in Jefferson County, Ark. Wife of Peter Bridges. . . . Daughter of George Kendall Smith and Anna Davis McGee, his wife. Granddaughter of Samuel Smith and Sybil Metcalf (b. 1789), his wife.”¹

_______________
¹ DAR, Lineage Book, Vol. LXX, 1908, 270, entry 69766.

Issue of ⁹Thomas Metcalf [21] (⁸Thomas Metcalf [5], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and Eva C. Canfield

56. ¹⁰Dr. Frank A. Metcalf, son of ⁹Thomas Metcalf [21] and Eva C. Canfield. Born in 1873 in Council Bluffs, Pottawattamie County, Iowa.

Married Rebecca L. _____ in 1904/5 when about 31 years old (Rebecca L. was about 25 years old). Rebecca L. _____ b. in 1879 in Illinois.

Issue of Dr. Frank A. Metcalf and Rebecca L. _____:
      i. son ¹¹Frederick T. Metcalf b. in 1905/6 in Illinois.
      ii. son Frank D. Metcalf b. in 1909 in Illinois.
      iii. dau. Ruth Metcalf b. in 1912/3 in Illinois.

Notes on Dr. Frank A. Metcalf:

Frank and his family were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Chicago, Cook County, Illinios, as follows:¹

Frank A. Metcalf, head of household, male, white, 36, married five years, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, spealks English, physician, Dr. [?], reads, writes.
Rebecca L. Metcalf, wife, female, white, 31, married five years, two children both living, born Illinois, father born Illinois, mother born Illinois, speaks English, reads, writes.
Frederick T. Metcalf, son, male, white, 4, single, born Illinois, father born Iowa, mother born Illinois.
Frank D. Metcalf, son, male, white, 10/12, single, born Illinois, father born Iowa, mother born Illinois.

Frank and his family were enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Chicago, Cook County, Illinios, as follows:²

Frank Metcalf, head of household, rents, male, white, 46, married, reads, writes, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, medical physician.
Rebecca Metcalf, wife, female, white, 40, married, reads, writes, born Illinois, father born Illinois, mother born Connecticut, speaks English.
Frederick Metcalf, son, male, white, 14, single, attended school within the year, reads, writes, born Illinois, father born Iowa, mother born Illinois, speaks English.
Frank Metcalf, son, male, white, 11, single, attended school within the year, reads, writes, born Illinois, father born Iowa, mother born Illinois, speaks English.
Ruth Metcalf, daughter, female, white, 7, single,attended school within the year, born Illinois, father born Iowa, mother born Illinois.

Frank and his family were enumerated in the 1930 federal census of Chicago, Cook County, Illinios, as follows:³

Frank Metcalf, head of household, rents for $95/month, radio set, male, white, 56, married when 31 years old, reads and writes, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, doctor, general practice.
Rebecca Metcalf, wife, female, white, 50, married when 25 years old, reads and writes, born Illinois, father born Illinois, mother born Connecticut, speaks English.
Frederick Metcalf, son, male, white, 24, single, attended school within the year, reads and writes, born Illinois, father born Iowa, mother born Illinois, speaks English, industrial [?], meat packing.
Frank D. Metcalf, son, male, white, 21, single, attended school within the year, reads and writes, born Illinois, father born Iowa, mother born Illinois, speaks English, [Ablicitor?], meat packing.
Ruth Metcalf, daughter, female, white, 17, single, attended school within the year, reads and writes, born Illinois, father born Iowa, mother born Illinois, speaks English.

_______________
¹ Frank A. Metcalf household, 1910 U.S. census, Cook County, Illinois, population schedule, Chicago Ward 7, enumeration district 380, supervisor’s district 1, sheet 2A, line 14, dwelling 17, family 31; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 247.
² Frank Metcalf household, 1920 U.S. census, Cook County, Illinois, population schedule, Chicago Ward 7, 6728 Ridgeland Avenue, enumeration district 450, supervisor’s district 1, sheet 2A, line 39, dwelling 19, family 46; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 316.
³ Frank Metcalf household, 1930 U.S. census, Cook County, Illinois, population schedule, Chicago Ward 7 Block 14, 6728 Ridgeland Avenue, enumeration district 16-255, supervisor’s district 29, sheet 2B, line 86, dwelling 9, family 50; National Archives micropublication T626, roll 424.

57. ¹⁰Delia Paulina Metcalf, dau. of ⁹Thomas Metcalf [21] and Eva C. Canfield. Born in June 1884 in Council Bluffs, Pottawattamie County, Iowa.

Married Hurlburt Henry Pinney, son of Dr. Charles H. Pinney and Ella O. _____, in 1909/10 when about 25 years old (Hurlburt Henry was about 35 years old). Hurlburt Henry Pinney b. in 1874 in Council Bluffs.

Issue of Delia Paulina Metcalf and Hurlburt Henry Pinney:
i. son ¹¹Charles H. Pinney b. on 23 Oct. 1911 in Iowa; d. on 19 July 1998 in Harlan, Shelby County, Iowa, 86 years old.
ii. dau. (May be living) Pinney

Notes on Delia Paulina Metcalf:

Chapin¹ said Delia Paulina married Henry Hurlburt Pinney.

Delia and her family were enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Garner Township, Pottawattamie County, Iowa, as follows:²

H. H. Pinney, head of household, rents, male, white, 46, married, reads, writes, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother born Pennsylvania, speaks English, farmer in general farm.
Della Pinney, wife, female, white, 36, married, reads, writes, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
Charles Pinney, son, male, white, 8, single, attended school within the year, born Iowa, father born Iowa, mother born Iowa [sic].
Eleanor Pinney, daughter, female, white, 10/12, single, born Iowa, father born Iowa, mother born Iowa.
Ella O. Pinney, head of household! [sic, mother], owns farm, female, white, 69, widow, reads, writes, born Pennsylvania, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Pennsylvania, speaks English.
Thomas Metcalf, father-in-law, male, white, 78, widower, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English.

Delia and her family were enumerated in the 1930 federal census of Garner Township, Pottawattamie County, Iowa, as follows:³

Hurlbert H. Pinney, head of household, owns farm, male, white, 55, married when 35 years old, reads and writes, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio [sic], speaks English, farmer on general farm.
Dela P. Pinney, wife, female, white, 45, married when 25 years old, reads and writes, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
Charles H. Pinney, son, male, white, 19, single, reads and writes, born Iowa, father born Iowa, mother born Iowa, speaks English.
Eleanor Pinney, daughter, female, white, 10, single, attended scholl within the year, reads and writes, born Iowa, father born Iowa, mother born Iowa, speaks English.

_______________
¹ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. I: First Seven Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 803.
² H. H. Pinney household, 1920 U.S. census, Pottawattamie County, Iowa, population schedule, Garner Township, enumeration district 131, supervisor’s district 9, sheet 5A, line 23, dwelling 95, family 96; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 510.
³ Hurlbert H. Pinney household, 1930 U.S. census, Pottawattamie County, Iowa, population schedule, Garner Township, enumeration district 78-8, supervisor’s district 8, sheet 11A, line 35, dwelling 244, family 250; National Archives micropublication T626, roll 678.

Notes on Hurlburt Henry Pinney:

Hurlburt was enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Council Bluffs, Pottawattamie County, Iowa, in his father’s household as follows:¹

Charles N. Pinney, white, male, 38, married, physician, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born New York.
Ella Pinney, white, female, 30, wife, married, keeping house, born Pennsylvania, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Peensylvania.
Hurlburt Pinney, white, male, 5, son, single, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother born Pennsylvania.
Lois Pinney, white, female, 3, daughter, single, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother born Pennsylvania.
Frank Pinney, white, male, 1, son, single, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother born Pennsylvania.
Annie Kelly, white, female, 18, servant, single, servant, born Ireland, father born Ireland, mother born Ireland.

_______________
¹ Pinney,Charles H. household, 1880 U.S. census, Pottawattamie County, Iowa, population schedule, Council Bluffs, enumeration district 194, supervisor’s district 3, page 19, sheet 345C, line 2, dwelling 173, family 197; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 361.

Issue of ⁹Frank Metcalf [22] (⁸Thomas Metcalf [5], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and Nellie Henry

58. ¹⁰Truman Henry Metcalf, son of ⁹Frank Metcalf [22] and Nellie Henry. Born on 17 July 1881 in Pennsylvania. Died in Nov. 1968 in Los Angeles County, California, 87 years old.

Married Florence C. Rutherford in 1914/5 when about 33 years old (Florence C. was about 26 years old). Florence C. Rutherford b. in 1888/9 in Minnesota.

Issue of Truman Henry Metcalf and Florence C. Rutherford:
      i. son ¹¹Truman C. Metcalf b. in 1917/8 in California.
      ii. son (May be living) Metcalf
      iii. son (May be living) Metcalf

Notes on Truman Henry Metcalf:

Truman was the grandfather of Sally Metcalf.

The California Death Index, 1940–1997, lists Truman H. Metcalf, SS#561-14-2348, male, born 17 July 1881, Pennsylvania, died 11 November 1968, Los Angeles, mother’s maiden name Henry.

The Social Security Death Index lists Truman Metcalf, #561-14-2348, last resided 91202 Glendale, Los Angeles, California, born 17 July 1881, died November 1968, SSN issued in California before 1951.

The World War I Draft Registration Cards, 1917–1918, lists Truman Henry Metcalf, 103 N. Harvard, Los Angeles 20, California, born 17 July 1881, white, roll 1530902, draft board 13, age 37, white, natural born, clerk at Union Oil Co. of Calif., nearest relative Florence Rutherford Metcalf.

Truman (as Henry T.) appears to be enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Minneapolis, Hennepin County, Minnesota, with his grandmother Hannah Henry as follows:¹

Hannah Henry, head of household, white, female, born March 1837, 63, widow, two children, one living, born New York, father born New York, mother born New York, reads, writes, speaks English.
Henry T. Metcalf, grandson, white, male, born July 1882 [sic], 17, single, born Pennsylvania, father born New York [sic], mother born Minnesota, reads, writes, speaks English.

Truman (listed as Henry) appears to have been enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Atlanta, Fulton County, Georgia, in the family of Nellie’s second husband as follows:²

Note that Truman could not have been in Georgia and Minnesota at the same time.

Truman and his family were enumerated in the 1930 federal census of Los Angeles, Los Angeles County, California, as follows:³

Truman H. Metcalf, head of household, owns home valued at $7000, male, white, 48, married when 33 years old, reads and writes, born Pennsylvania, father born Illinois, mother born Minnesota, speaks English, clerk in Oil Company.
Florence C. Metcalf, wife, female, white, 41, married when 26 years old, reads and writes, born Minnesota, father born New York, mother born New York, speaks English.
Truman C. Metcalf, son, male, white, 12, single, attended school within the year, reads and writes, born California, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Minnesota, speaks English.
Robert L. Metcalf, son, male, white, 10, single, attended school within the year, reads and writes, born California, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Minnesota, speaks English.
George W. Metcalf, son, male, white, 6, single, attended school within the year, born California, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Minnesota, speaks English.

_______________
¹ Hannah Henry household, 1900 U.S. census, Hennepin County, Minnesota, population schedule, Minneapolis Ward 5, enumeration district 61, supervisor’s district 5, sheet 14A, line 33, dwelling 234, family 326; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 767.
² Sydney Smith household, 1900 U.S. census, Fulton County, Georgia, population schedule, Atlanta Ward 3, 43 Garden, enumeration district 575, supervisor’s district 5, sheet 4B, line 73, dwelling 80, family 83; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 199.
³ Truman H. Metcalf household, 1930 U.S. census, Los Angeles County, California, population schedule, Los Angeles, 611 North Harvard Boulevard, enumeration district 16-165, supervisor’s district 16, sheet 5A, line 17, dwelling 128, family 132; National Archives micropublication T626, roll 139.

Issue of Hon. John C. McHenry and ⁹Ellen Josephine Metcalfe [23] (⁸Dr. Asa Baldwin Metcalfe [6], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1])

59. ¹⁰Emma McHenry, dau. of Hon. John C. McHenry and ⁹Ellen Josephine Metcalfe [23]. Born on 3 Feb. 1857 in Temescal Rancho, Alameda County, California. Died on 6 Aug. 1934 in Berkeley, Alameda County, California, 77 years old. Buried in Mountain View Cemetery, Piedmont, Alameda County, California.

Married Rear Adm. Charles Fremont Pond, son of Enoch Pond and Sarah A. _____, on 10 Aug. 1880 in San Francisco, San Francisco County, California when 23 years old (Rear Adm. Charles Fremont was 23 years old). Rear Adm. Charles Fremont Pond b. on 26 Oct. 1856 in Brooklyn, Windham County, Connecticut; d. on 5 Aug. 1929 in Berkeley, 72 years old; bur. on 13 Aug. 1929 in Mountain View Cemetery.

Issue of Emma McHenry and Rear Adm. Charles Fremont Pond:
100   i. son ¹¹Charles McHenry Pond b. in 1882/3 in California.
101   ii. son Cdr. John Enoch Pond b. on 10 May 1884 in Berkeley.
      iii. dau. Elizabeth Keith Pond b. on 12 Oct. 1886 in Vallejo, Solano County, California; d. on 6 Sep. 1955 in Alameda, Alameda County, California, 68 years old; bur. in Mountain View Cemetery.

Notes on Emma McHenry:

Emma was enumerated in her father’s family in the 1860 federal census of San Francisco, San Francisco County, California, as follows:¹

(An earlier son named John born in 1852 had died soon after his birth.)

Emma was enumerated in her father’s family in the 1870 federal census of San Francisco, San Francisco County, California, as follows:²

Emma was enumerated in her father’s family in the 1880 federal census of San Francisco, San Francisco County, California, as follows:³

John McHenry, white, male, 70, married, lawyer, born North Carolina, father born Virginai, mother born Virginia.
Ellen J. McHenry, white, female, 51, wife, married, keeping house, born Ohio, father born Vermont, mother born Connecticut.
E. H. McHenry, white, female, 27, daughter, single, at home, born Louisiana, father born North Carolina, mother born Ohio.
Mary McHenry, white, female, 24, daughter, single, student, attended school within the year, born California, father born North Carolina, mother born Ohio.
Emma McHenry, white, female, 23, daughter, single, student, attended school within the year, born California, father born North Carolina, mother born Ohio.
John McHenry, white, male, 21, son, single, civil engineer, attended school within the year, born California, father born North Carolina, mother born Ohio.
B. A. Metcalf, white, female, 74 [sic], mother-in-law, widow, at home, born Connecticut, father born Rhode Island, mother born Rhode Island.

Emma, her family, mother and brother-in-law were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Berkeley, Alameda County, California, as follows:⁴

Charles F. Pond, head of household, male, white, 53, married 29 years, born Connecticut, father born Connecticut, mother born Connecticut, speaks English, Captain in U.S. Navy, reads, writes, owns home free of mortgage.
Emma M. Pond, wife, female, white, 53, married 29 years, three children all livng, born California, father born North Carolina, mother born Ohio, speaks English, reads, writes.
Charles M. Pond, son, male, white, 27, single, born California, father born Connecticut, mother born California, speaks English, division engineer on railroad, reads, writes.
John E. Pond, son, male, white, 25, single, born California, father born Connecticut, mother born California, speaks English, Ensign in U.S. Navy, reads, writes.
Elizabeth K. Pond, daughter, female, white, 23, single, born California, father born Connecticut, mother born California, speaks English, reads, writes.
Ellen J. McHenry, mother-in-law, female, white, 81, widow, five children, three living, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born Connecticut, speaks English, reads, writes.
John C. Pond, brother, male, white, 57, widower, born Connecticut, father born Massachusetts, mother born Connecticut, speaks English, own income, reads, writes.
Paul U. Pond, nephew, male, white, 17, single, born Missouri, father born Connecticut, mother born Connecticut, speaks English, reads, writes, attended school within the year. Some information is from Paula Stewart and John Pond.

The following notice, provided by John Pond, appeared in the San Francisco Morning Call on 17 August 1880:

The Pond-McHenry Nuptials.
The wedding of Mr. Charles F. Pond, of the United States Navy, and Miss Emma McHenry, daughter of the Hon. John McHenry, of this city, was celebrated on Tuesday evening last at the residence of the bride’s parents, No. 34 Glen Park Avenue. The services were conducted according to the ritual of the Episcopal Church by the Rev. Wm. H. Platt, of Grace Cathedral. As was generally understood, the wedding was very private with the relatives, and only a few of the intimate friends of the family were present. The bride was attended by Miss Syria Brown, daughter of the late J. Ross Brown, of Oakland, as first bridesmaid, Miss Bessie McHenry and Miss Mary McHenry, and Miss Emily Hay. The groom was waited upon by his brother officer, Lieutenant Charles Putnam, first groomsman, assisted by Mr. Wm. L. Metcalfe, Mr John McHenry, Jr., and Master Willie Hay.
According to the regulations of the army and navy, the groom and his first groomsman wore the social-intercourse uniform, which made a pleasing contrast with the plainer dress of the other groomsmen. Lieutenant Pond is at present connected with the United States Coast Survey steamer Hassler, which ship he will join after his leave expires, some time in September next.
The bride was the recipient of many beautiful and costly presents. Among those present were Dr. and Mrs. Wm. H. Platt and Miss Platt, Mr. and Mrs J.B. Metcalfe and Miss Boarman, Miss Wallace, Messrs. Ryland and Richard Wallace, Judge S.S. Wright, Mr. Kirk Wright, Miss Nannie Wright, Miss Lizzie Wright, Judge James McM. Shafter and Miss Julia Shafter, Major Roche, U.S.A., Mrs. and Miss Roche, Dr. and Mrs. Farwell, Lieutenant Coffin, Mrs. Simenton and Chief Engineer Aston, U.S.N., Mr. and Mrs. Dottie Sargent, Mrs. Spencer Brown, Miss Poole, Mr. Maurice Dore and Misses Dore, Mr. F.B. Boarman, Mr. E.B. Lamare, Mr. H.I. Coon, Mr. Charles Jackson, Dr. Ledyard, Mr. William Cary Jones, Mr. Hubert Vischer, Mr. Charles Hay and Mr. Lindhart. Mr. Pond and his fair bride are at present at Santa Cruz, and after visitng Monterey will return to this city and be at home to their friends on Fridays after the 19th instant, at the residence of their parents, No. 34 Glen Park Avenue.

_______________
¹ John McHenry household, 1860 U.S. census, San Francisco County, California, population schedule, San Francisco District 1, page 324, sheet 877, line 34, dwelling 2624, family 2965; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 68.
² John McHenry household, 1870 U.S. census, San Francisco, California, population schedule, San Francisco Ward 4, page 119, sheet 390, line 14, dwelling 902, family 1285; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 80.
³ John McHenry household, 1880 U.S. census, San Francisco County, California, population schedule, San Francisco, 34 Glen Park Avenue, enumeration district 159, supervisor’s district 1, page 2, sheet 178B, line 13, dwelling 13, family 13; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 77.
⁴ Charles F. Pond household, 1910 U.S. census, Alameda County, California, population schedule, Berkeley Precinct 4, 2621 Ridge Road, enumeration district 46, supervisor’s district 3, sheet 7B, line 1, dwelling 116, family 135; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 72.

Notes on Rear Adm. Charles Fremont Pond:

The information is from Paula Stewart and John Pond.

John notes he was a graduate US Naval Academy in 1876. He died at his home on Ridge Road.

60. ¹⁰John McHenry, son of Hon. John C. McHenry and ⁹Ellen Josephine Metcalfe [23]. Born on 28 Nov. 1858 in San Francisco, San Francisco County, California. Died on 10 May 1935 in Berkeley, Alameda County, California, 76 years old. Buried in Mountain View Cemetery, Piedmont, Alameda County, California.

Married Frances Veronica Reynolds, dau. of Patrick Reynolds and Ann _____, in 1886 when 27 or 28 years old (Frances Veronica was 23 or 24 years old). Frances Veronica Reynolds b. on 12 Feb. 1862 in Massachusetts; d. on 30 April 1942 in Alameda County, California, 80 years old; bur. in Mountain View Cemetery.

Issue of John McHenry and Frances Veronica Reynolds:
      i. son ¹¹John McHenry b. on 1 Oct. 1888 in San Francisco; d. on 31 March 1950 in San Francisco, 61 years old.
      ii. son Reynolds McHenry b. in Feb. 1890 in San Francisco.
102   iii. dau. Frances Reynolds McHenry b. on 11 Oct. 1898 in San Francisco.
      iv. son Robert McHenry b. on 7 July 1901 in California; d. on 23 April 1960 in San Francisco, 58 years old.

Notes on John McHenry:

John was enumerated (as William) in his father’s family in the 1860 federal census of San Francisco, San Francisco County, California, as follows:¹

(An earlier son named John born in 1852 had died soon after his birth.)

John was enumerated in his father’s family in the 1870 federal census of San Francisco, San Francisco County, California, as follows:²

John was enumerated in his father’s family in the 1880 federal census of San Francisco, San Francisco County, California, as follows:³

John McHenry, white, male, 70, married, lawyer, born North Carolina, father born Virginai, mother born Virginia.
Ellen J. McHenry, white, female, 51, wife, married, keeping house, born Ohio, father born Vermont, mother born Connecticut.
E. H. McHenry, white, female, 27, daughter, single, at home, born Louisiana, father born North Carolina, mother born Ohio.
Mary McHenry, white, female, 24, daughter, single, student, attended school within the year, born California, father born North Carolina, mother born Ohio.
Emma McHenry, white, female, 23, daughter, single, student, attended school within the year, born California, father born North Carolina, mother born Ohio.
John McHenry, white, male, 21, son, single, civil engineer, attended school within the year, born California, father born North Carolina, mother born Ohio.
B. A. Metcalf, white, female, 74 [sic], mother-in-law, widow, at home, born Connecticut, father born Rhode Island, mother born Rhode Island.

John and his family were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of San Francisco, San Francisco County, California, as follows:⁴

John McHenry, head of household, white, male, born Nov. 1858, 41, married 14 years, born California, father born North Carolina, mother born Ohio, [?], reads, writes, speaks English, rents home.
Fannie V. McHenry, wife, white, female, born Feb. 1862, 38, married 14 years, three children all living, born Massachusetts, father born Maryland, mother born Maryland, reads, writes, speaks English.
John McHenry, son, white, male, born Oct. 1888, 12, single, born California, father born California, mother born Massachusetts, at school, reads, writes, speaks English.
Reynolds McHenry, son, white, male, born Feb. 1890, 10, single, born California, father born California, mother born Massachusetts, at school, reads, writes, speaks English.
Fannie McHenry, daughter, white, female, born Oct. 1898, 1, single, born California, father born California, mother born Massachusetts, at school, reads, writes, speaks English.

John and his family were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Berkeley, Alameda County, California, as follows:⁵

John McHenry, head of household, male, white, 50, married first 23 years, born California, father born Tennessee [sic], mother born Ohio, speaks English, building architect, working on own account, reads, writes, owns mortgaged home.
Francis McHenry, wife, female, white, 46, married first 23 years, four children all living, born Massachusetts, father born Ireland - English, mother born Ireland - English, speaks English.
Reynolds McHenry, son, male, white, 20, single, born California, father born California, mother born Massachusetts, speaks English, reads, writes, attended school within the year.
Francis McHenry, daughter, female, white, 11, single, born California, father born California, mother born Massachusetts, speaks English, reads, writes, attended school within the year.
Robert McHenry, son, male, white, 9, single, born California, father born California, mother born Massachusetts, speaks English, reads, writes, attended school within the year.
John McHenry, son, male, white, 22, single, born California, father born California, mother born Massachusetts, speaks English, city architect, works for wages, reads, writes, attended school within the year.

John and his family were enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Berkeley, Alameda County, California, as follows:⁶

John McHenry, head of household, owns home free of mortgage, male, white, 61, married, reads, writes, born California, father born North Carolina, mother born Ohio, speaks English, general practice architect working on own account.
Frances B. [sic] McHenry, female, white, 57, married, reads, writes, born Massachusetts, father born Ireland - English, mother born Ireland - English, speaks English.
Francis McHenry, daughter, female, white, 21, single, attended school within the year, reads, writes, born California, father born California, mother born Massachusetts, speaks English.
Robert McHenry, son, male, white, 19, single, attended school within the year, reads, writes, born California, father born California, mother born Massachusetts, speaks English.

John and his family were enumerated in the 1930 federal census of Berkeley, Alameda County, California, as follows:⁷

John McHenry, head of household, owns home valued at $11,000, radio set, male, white, 71, married when 28 years old, reads and writes, born California, father born North Carolina, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
Frances V. McHenry, wife, female, white, 67, married 26 years, reads and writes, born Massachusetts, father born Northern Ireland, mother born Northern Ireland, speaks English.
John McHenry Jr., son, male, white, 43, single, reads and writes, born California, father born California, mother born Massachusetts, speaks English, aerial photographer.

Some information is from Paula Stewart and John Pond.

John was cremated.

_______________
¹ John McHenry household, 1860 U.S. census, San Francisco County, California, population schedule, San Francisco District 1, page 324, sheet 877, line 34, dwelling 2624, family 2965; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 68.
² John McHenry household, 1870 U.S. census, San Francisco, California, population schedule, San Francisco Ward 4, page 119, sheet 390, line 14, dwelling 902, family 1285; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 80.
³ John McHenry household, 1880 U.S. census, San Francisco County, California, population schedule, San Francisco, 34 Glen Park Avenue, enumeration district 159, supervisor’s district 1, page 2, sheet 178B, line 13, dwelling 13, family 13; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 77.
⁴ John McHenry household, 1900 U.S. census, San Francisco County, California, population schedule, San Francisco, [3343?] 22nd Street, enumeration district 110, supervisor’s district 1, sheet 1A, line 48, dwelling 10, family 13; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 102.
⁵ John McHenry household, 1910 U.S. census, Alameda County, California, population schedule, Berkeley, 2210 Ellsworth Avenue, enumeration district 48, supervisor’s district 3, sheet 2B, line 51, dwelling 17, family 32; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 72.
⁶ John McHenry household, 1920 U.S. census, Alameda County, California, population schedule, Berkeley Precinct 38, 2210 Ellsworth Avenue, enumeration district 183, supervisor’s district 5, sheet 1A, line 4, dwelling 1, family 2; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 93.
⁷ John McHenry household, 1930 U.S. census, Alameda County, California, population schedule, Berkeley, 1578 Scenic Avenue, enumeration district 1-319, supervisor’s district 8, sheet 12A, line 26, dwelling 184, family 251; National Archives micropublication T636, roll 111.

Notes on Frances Veronica Reynolds:

Some information is from Paula Stewart and John Pond.

She was cremated.

Issue of ⁹George Edward Metcalfe [24] (⁸Dr. Asa Baldwin Metcalfe [6], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and Nancy Adaline Haran Enlow

61. ¹⁰Jefferson Davis Metcalfe, son of ⁹George Edward Metcalfe [24] and Nancy Adaline Haran Enlow. Born on 12 Jan. 1858 in Wilkinson County, Mississippi. Died on 18 July 1934 in Wilkinson County, 76 years old. Buried in Enlow Cemetery, Silver Creek, Wilkinson County, Mississippi.

Married Nancy Emmaline Estes in 1882 in Wilkinson County when 23 or 24 years old (Nancy Emmaline was 17 or 18 years old). Nancy Emmaline Estes b. on 31 May 1864 in Mississippi; d. on 24 Feb. 1941 in Mississippi, 76 years old; bur. in Enlow Cemetery.

Issue of Jefferson Davis Metcalfe and Nancy Emmaline Estes:
      i. dau. ¹¹Annie Leona Metcalfe b. on 20 July 1883 in Mississippi; m. Jesse Sumpter Parker on 11 July 1901 in Wilkinson County when 17 years old.
      ii. dau. Barbara Allen Metcalfe b. on 18 April 1888 in Mississippi; d. on 6 Jan. 1966, 77 years old; bur. in Enlow Cemetery; m. Ellison S. Felter (5 April 1880–29 Nov. 1952) on 3 May 1903 in Wilkinson County when 15 years old (Ellison S. was 23 years old).
      iii. son Thomas Wade Metcalfe b. on 24 Jan. 1891 in Mississippi; d. in 1941, 49 or 50 years old; bur. in Enlow Cemetery; m. Ruby E. Hastings (1891/2 in Mississippi–) on 20 Dec. 1908 in Wilkinson County when 17 years old (Ruby E. was 16 years old).
      iv. son William Wallace Metcalfe b. in Dec. 1893 in Mississippi; d. in 1945, 51 or 52 years old; bur. in Enlow Cemetery; m. Ella _____ (of Bangor, Penobscot County, Maine–).
      v. son Jefferson Davis Metcalfe m. Gladys Cavin on 5 May 1934 in Wilkinson County.
      vi. son Lamar McHenry Metcalfe b. on 14 May 1905; d. on 8 Jan. 1948 in New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, 42 years old; bur. in Enlow Cemetery; m. (1) Lelia Anders on 13 Jan. 1929 in Wilkinson County when 23 years old; m. (2) Margaret Elizabeth McDaniel (29 Nov. 1916–18 Aug. 1990) on 10 Dec. 1935 in Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi when 30 years old (Margaret Elizabeth was 19 years old).

Notes on Jefferson Davis Metcalfe:

Jefferson and his family were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Wilkinson County, Mississippi, as follows:¹

Jeff D. Metcalfe, head of household, white, male, born Jan. 1858, 42, married [stricken 14], born Mississippi, father born Ohio, mother born Mississippi, engineer in saw mill, reads, writes, speaks English, owns farm free of mortgage.
Nancy E. Metcalfe, wife, white, female, born May 1864, 36, married qw years, nine [sic] children, four living, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, reads, writes, speaks English.
Annie L. Metcalfe, daughter, white, female, born July 1883, 16, single, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, at school, attended school within the year, reads, writes, speaks English.
Barbara A. Metcalfe, daughter, white, female, born Apr. 1888, 12, single, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, at school, attended school within the year, reads, writes, speaks English.
Thomas R. Metcalfe, son, white, male, born Jan. 1891, 9, single, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, at school, attended school within the year, reads, writes, speaks English.
William A. Metcalfe, son, white, male, born Dec. 1893, 6, single, born Mississippi, father born Mississippi, mother born Mississippi, at school, attended school within the year, reads, writes, speaks English.

Some information is from Jim Byrd. He notes that Jefferson was named after the President of the Confederate States of America who was the best friend of Jefferson’s father, George.

_______________
¹ Jeff D. Metcalfe household, 1900 U.S. census, Wilkinson County, Mississippi, population schedule, Beat 5, enumeration district 153, supervisor’s district 7, sheet 25B, line 51, dwelling 495, family 495; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 834.

Images for Jefferson Davis Metcalfe:

Jefferson Davis Metcalfe and his family. His wife was Nancy Emmaline Estes. His sons are, from left to right, William Wallace Metcalfe, Jefferson Davis Metcalfe, Jr., and Thomas Wade Metcalfe. Photo courtesy of Jim Byrd.

62. ¹⁰Asa Baldwin Metcalfe, son of ⁹George Edward Metcalfe [24] and Nancy Adaline Haran Enlow. Born on 13 March 1860 in Wilkinson County, Mississippi. Died on 8 Oct. 1926, 66 years old. Buried in Wesley Church Cemetery, Saint Joseph, Tensas Parish, Louisiana.

Married Francis Lucinda Keller on 3 April 1885 in Wilkinson County when 25 years old (Francis Lucinda was 18 years old). Francis Lucinda Keller b. on 13 Nov. 1866 in Wilkinson County; d. on 1 Feb. 1904, 37 years old; bur. in Vidalia, Concordia Parish, Louisiana.

Issue of Asa Baldwin Metcalfe and Francis Lucinda Keller:
      i. dau. ¹¹Nancy Matilda Metcalfe b. on 19 Feb. 1886; d. on 23 Nov. 1947, 61 years old; bur. in Elmwood Cemetery, Birmingham, Jefferson County, Alabama; m. _____ Henderson.
      ii. dau. Selena Metcalfe b. on 27 Jan. 1888; d. before 4 Feb. 1904, at most 16 years old.
      iii. dau. Louise Metcalfe b. on 30 Aug. 1889; d. on 23 Jan. 1963, 73 years old; bur. in City Cemetery, Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi; m. Elliot Devereux Cavin (30 May 1881–26 May 1963 bur. in City Cemetery).
      iv. dau. Georgia Anna Metcalfe b. on 3 Jan. 1891; d. on 9 Jan. 1940, 49 years old; bur. in Elmwood Cemetery; m. _____ Tyler.
103   v. son William Arthur Metcalfe b. on 22 Feb. 1893 in Saint Joseph, Tensas County.
      vi. son Henry McNair Metcalfe b. on 13 Aug. 1895 in Adams County; d. on 25 April 1961, 65 years old; bur. in Wilkinson County; m. Georgia Louella Beattie on 23 Jan. 1916 in Wilkinson County when 20 years old.
      vii. dau. Annie Eliza Metcalfe b. on 12 June 1898.
      viii. dau. Ellen Viola “Elva” Metcalfe b. on 4 Feb. 1901 in Concordia Parish, Louisiana; m. _____ Henderson.
      ix. dau. Meriable Metcalfe b. on 27 Oct. 1903 in Concordia Parish; d. in 1905, one or two years old.

Notes on Asa Baldwin Metcalfe:

His children were taken from the Bible of Ellen Viola “Elva” (Metcalfe) Henderson.

Birth and death dates were taken from his gravestone, where his middle initial is given as B.

Two marriage dates are listed in Mississippi Marriages, 1776–1935 at Ancestry.com: with Francis Lucinda Keller on 30 January 1885 and with Francis L. Keller on 3 April 1885, both in Wilkinson County.

Images for Asa Baldwin Metcalfe:

Asa B. Metcalfe’s headstone.

63. ¹⁰George W. Metcalfe, son of ⁹George Edward Metcalfe [24] and Nancy Adaline Haran Enlow. Born on 12 July 1873 in Wilkinson County, Mississippi. Died on 1 Nov. 1955, 82 years old. Buried in Enlow Cemetery, Silver Creek, Wilkinson County, Mississippi.

Married Mattie Anders, dau. of George W. Anders (son of Adam P. Anders and Melinda _____) and Elizabeth E. _____, on 25 June 1899 in Wilkinson County when 25 years old (Mattie was 18 years old). Mattie Anders b. on 24 May 1881 in Wilkinson County; d. on 22 July 1936, 55 years old; bur. in Enlow Cemetery.

Issue of George W. Metcalfe and Mattie Anders:
      i. son ¹¹Lewis D. Metcalfe b. in May 1900 in Wilkinson County; d. young.
      ii. son Louis Metcalfe b. in 1902/3 in Wilkinson County.
      iii. son Archie Jefferson Metcalfe b. on 3 Oct. 1906 in Wilkinson County; d. on 7 Oct. 1933, 27 years old; bur. in Enlow Cemetery.
      iv. dau. Elizabeth Metcalfe b. in 1907/8 in Wilkinson County.
      v. son Arlie Evans Metcalfe b. on 28 March 1911 in Wilkinson County.
      vi. son Hiram Bilbo Metcalfe b. on 1 Aug. 1916 in Wilkinson County; d. on 14 April 1971, 54 years old; bur. in Enlow Cemetery.
      vii. dau. (May be living) Metcalfe

64. ¹⁰Orin L. Metcalfe, son of ⁹George Edward Metcalfe [24] and Nancy Adaline Haran Enlow. Born in Jan. 1877 in Wilkinson County, Mississippi.

Married Louisa E. “Lula” Anders, dau. of George W. Anders (son of Adam P. Anders and Melinda _____) and Elizabeth E. _____, on 14 Oct. 1900 in Wilkinson County when 23 years old (Louisa E. “Lula” was 17 years old). Louisa E. “Lula” Anders b. in Aug. 1883 in Wilkinson County.

Issue of Orin L. Metcalfe and Louisa E. “Lula” Anders:
      i. son ¹¹Asa C. Metcalfe b. in 1902/3 in Wilkinson County.
      ii. son Pollard C. Metcalfe b. in 1903/4 in Wilkinson County.
      iii. son George R. Metcalfe b. in 1905/6 in Wilkinson County.
      iv. son Oren E. Metcalfe b. in July 1909 in Wilkinson County.
      v. dau. Edith A. M. Metcalfe b. in 1912/3 in Wilkinson County.
      vi. dau. Adeline E. Metcalfe b. in Aug. 1916 in Wilkinson County.
      vii. dau. Mary Metcalfe b. in Sep. 1918 in Wilkinson County; d. young.
      viii. son (May be living) Metcalfe

Issue of Stephen Aaron Pomeroy and ⁹Isabella Linwood Metcalf [27] (⁸Ebenezer Metcalf [7], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1])

65. ¹⁰Norman Charles Pomeroy, son of Stephen Aaron Pomeroy and ⁹Isabella Linwood Metcalf [27]. Born on 4 June 1866 in Toledo, Lucas County, Ohio.

Married Maude Ives. Maude Ives b. in 1877/8 in Pennsylvania.

Issue of Norman Charles Pomeroy and Maude Ives:
i. son ¹¹Verne Metcalf Pomeroy b. on 3 May 1907.

Notes on Norman Charles Pomeroy:

Chapin¹ said Norman C. was born on 4 June 1866.

Norman was enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, in the household of his aunt (and stepmother) Catharine as follows:²

Norman and his family were enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Canton, Stark County, Ohio, as follows:³

Norman C. Pomeroy, head of household, rents home, male, white, 51 [sic], reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, machinist in railroad shop, works for wages.
Maude A. Pomeroy, wife, female, white, 42, married, reads, writes, born Pennsylvania, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Pennsylvania, speaks English.
Verne M. Pomeroy, son, white, male, 12, single, attended school within the year, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Pennsylvania, speaks English.

_______________
¹ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. II: Eighth to Twelfth Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 1412.
² Catharine Pomeroy household, 1900 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Chardon Village, enumeration district 44, supervisor’s district 18, sheet 11A, line 26, dwelling 278, family 289; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 1271.
³ Norman C. Pomeroy household, 1920 U.S. census, Stark County, Ohio, population schedule, Canton City Ward 6, 1204 Third Street S. W., enumeration district 55, supervisor’s district 15, sheet 8A, line 43, dwelling 153, family 206; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 1434.

66. ¹⁰William Metcalf Pomeroy, son of Stephen Aaron Pomeroy and ⁹Isabella Linwood Metcalf [27]. Born on 13 Sep. 1868 in Toledo, Lucas County, Ohio. Died before 1920, at most 51 years old.

Married Matilda A. H. Kootz in 1896 in Brooklyn, Kings County, New York when 27 or 28 years old (Matilda A. H. was 21 or 22 years old). Matilda A. H. Kootz b. in July 1874 in New York.

Issue of William Metcalf Pomeroy and Matilda A. H. Kootz:
i. child ¹¹_____ Pomeroy d. young.
ii. son Edward S. Pomeroy b. on 12 Nov. 1898 in New York, New York.

Notes on William Metcalf Pomeroy:

Chapin¹ said Willie M. was born on 13 September 1868.

William and his family were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Brooklyn, Kings County, New York, as follows:²

William M. Pomeroy, head of household, white, male, born Sept. 1868, 31, married 4 years, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, [tax?] expert, reads, writes, speaks English, rents home.
Matilda Pomeroy, wife, white, female, born July 1874, married 4 years, two children, one living, born New York, father born Germany, mother born Germany, reads, writes, speaks English.
Edward S. Pomeroy, son, white, male, born Nov. 1898, 1, single, born New York, father born Ohio, mother born New York.
Henrietta Cootz, sister-in-law, white, female, born May 1865, 35, single, born New York, father born Germany, mother born Germany, operator, reads, writes, speaks English.

_______________
¹ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. II: Eighth to Twelfth Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 1412.
² William M. Pomeroy household, 1900 U.S. census, Kings County, New York, population schedule, Brooklyn Borough Ward 22, 319 Third Street, enumeration district 358, supervisor’s district 2, sheet 14B, line 74, dwelling 86, family 309; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 1059.

Notes on Matilda A. H. Kootz:

Matilda, her son and sister were enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Brooklyn, Kings County, New York, as follows:¹

Matilda Pomeroy, head of household, rents, female, white, 43 [sic], widow, reads, writes, born New York, father born Germany - German, mother born Germany - German, speaks English, dressmaker, works on own account.
Edward Pomeroy, son, male, white, 21, single, reads, writes, born New York, father born Ohio, mother born New York, speaks English, helper in [?], works for wages.
Christina Coontz, sister, female, white, 50, single, reads, writes, born New York, father born Germany - German, mother born Germany - German, speaks English, shirt make in lshirt house, works for wages.

Matilda and her son were enumerated in the 1930 federal census of Brooklyn, Kings County, New York, as follows:²

Matilda Pomeroy, head of household, rents home for $40 per month, radio set, female, white, 55, widow, married when 18 years old, reads and writes, born New York, father born Germany, mother born Germany, speaks Engllish.
Edward Pomeroy, son, male, white, 29, single, reads and writes, born New York, father born Ohio, mother born New York, mechanic in boiler works, works for wages.

_______________
¹ Matilda Pomeroy household, 1920 U.S. census, Kings County, New York, population schedule, Brooklyn Borough, 105 East Third Street, enumeration district 710, supervisor’s district 3, sheet 14A, line 10, dwelling 179, family 300; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 1163.
² Matilda Pomeroy household, 1930 U.S. census, Kings County, New York, population schedule, Brooklyn Borough, enumeration district 24-637, supervisor’s district 30, sheet 16A, line 30, dwelling 173, family 213; National Archives micropublication T626, roll 1516.

Issue of Stephen Aaron Pomeroy and ⁹Catharine Lovica Metcalf [28] (⁸Ebenezer Metcalf [7], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1])

67. ¹⁰Louis Stephen Pomeroy, son of Stephen Aaron Pomeroy and ⁹Catharine Lovica Metcalf [28]. Born on 27 June 1873 in Toledo, Lucas County, Ohio.

Married Pearl Sawyer on 12 Sep. 1900 when 27 years old (Pearl was 25 years old). Pearl Sawyer b. in 1874/5 in Ohio.

Issue of Louis Stephen Pomeroy and Pearl Sawyer:
i. son ¹¹Sawyer Pomeroy b. in 1904/5 in Ohio.

Notes on Louis Stephen Pomeroy:

Chapin¹ said Louis S. was born on 27 June 1873.

He was born two months after his father’s death.

Louis and his family were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, as follows:²

Louis S. Pomeroy, head of household, male, white, 36, married once 9 years, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, operator in publishing company, works for wages, reads, writes, owns home free of mortgage.
Pearl Pomeroy, wife, female, white, 35, married once 9 years, one child, one living, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, reads, writes.
Sawyer Pomeroy, son, male, white, 5, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, attended school within the year.

Louis and his family were enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, as follows:³

Louis F. Pomeroy, head of household, rents, male, white, 46, married, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, linotype operator in printing company, works for wages.
Pearl Pomeroy, wife, female, white, 45, married, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
Sawyer Pomeroy, son, male, white, 15, single, attended school within the year, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English

_______________
¹ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. II: Eighth to Twelfth Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 1412.
² Louis S. Pomeroy household, 1910 U.S. census, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, population schedule, Cleveland Ward 26,10905 Olivet Avenue, enumeration district 401, supervisor’s district 19, sheet 4A, line 9, dwelling 64, family 66; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 1176.
³ Louis F. Pomeroy household, 1920 U.S. census, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, population schedule, Cleveland Ward 25, 10905 Olivet Avenue, enumeration district 474, supervisor’s district 19, sheet 3A, line 41, dwelling 37, family 55; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 1372.

Issue of ⁹Richard Evert Denton [30] (⁸Sidney Metcalf [8], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and Lydia Eliza Melinda Pomeroy

68. ¹⁰Franklin Evert Denton, son of ⁹Richard Evert Denton [30] and Lydia Eliza Melinda Pomeroy. Born on 22 Nov. 1859 in Huntsburg, Geauga County, Ohio.

Married Martha Ann Goldthorpe on 14 Oct. 1882 when 22 years old (Martha Ann was 25 years old). Martha Ann Goldthorpe b. in April 1857 in Canada.

Issue of Franklin Evert Denton and Martha Ann Goldthorpe:
i. son ¹¹Paul Evert Denton b. on 24 Dec. 1884.

69. ¹⁰Richard Linwood Denton, son of ⁹Richard Evert Denton [30] and Lydia Eliza Melinda Pomeroy. Born on 17 July 1864 in Huntsburg, Geauga County, Ohio.

Married first Harriet Louise Pierce. Harriet Louise Pierce b. in 1868 in Huntsburg.

Issue of Richard Linwood Denton and Harriet Louise Pierce:
i. dau. ¹¹Catherine L. Denton b. on 9 June 1885 in Huntsburg.

Married second Pearl Maud Stanton on 5 Nov. 1897 when 33 years old (Pearl Maud was 22 years old). Pearl Maud Stanton b. on 28 April 1875 in Huntsburg.

70. ¹⁰George Metcalf Denton, son of ⁹Richard Evert Denton [30] and Lydia Eliza Melinda Pomeroy. Born on 1 March 1871 in Huntsburg, Geauga County, Ohio.

Married Maud Miller Russell on 29 March 1900 when 29 years old (Maud Miller was 25 years old). Maud Miller Russell b. in 1874/5 in Huntsburg.

Issue of George Metcalf Denton and Maud Miller Russell:
      i. son ¹¹Richard Russell Denton b. on 26 Feb. 1901 in Pennsylvania.
      ii. son George Pomeroy Denton b. on 24 Oct. 1902 in Pennsylvania.
      iii. dau. Sarah L. Denton b. in 1911/2 in Ohio.

Issue of Ransom P. Hodges and ⁹Marie Antoinette Ludlow [32] (⁸Harriet Metcalf [9], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1])

71. ¹⁰William Hodges, son of Ransom P. Hodges and ⁹Marie Antoinette Ludlow [32]. Born in June 1866 in Ohio.

Married Henrietta _____ in 1894/5 when about 28 years old (Henrietta was about 25 years old). Henrietta _____ b. on 30 May 1869 in Michigan; d. on 5 Nov. 1942 in Los Angeles, Los Angeles County, California, 73 years old.

Issue of William Hodges and Henrietta _____:
i. son ¹¹Lester H. Hodges b. in Oct. 1896 in Ohio.

Notes on William Hodges:

William and his family were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Glenville, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, as follows:¹

William W. Hodges, head of household, white, male, born June 1866, 33, married five years, born Ohio, father born New York, mother born New York [sic], architect, reads, writes, speaks English, owns home free of mortgage.
Henrietta H. Hodges, wife, white, female, born May 1869, 31, married five years, one child, one living, born Michigan, father born Ireland, mother born Connecticut, reads, writes, speaks English.
Lester H. Hodges, son, white, male, born Oct. 1896, 3, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Michigan.

(Henrietta’s sister Ella A. is enumerated in the same dwelling as the next family with her husband Albert J. Hitz.)

Henrietta is listed in the California Death Index, 1940–1997, born 30 May 1869 in Michigan, died 5 November 1942 in Los Angeles.

_______________
¹ William W. Hodges household, 1900 U.S. census, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, population schedule, Glenville Village, enumeration district 216, supervisor’s district 19, sheet 52A, line 45, dwelling 1115, family 1186; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 1260.

Issue of ⁹Linnaeus Charles Ludlow [33] (⁸Harriet Metcalf [9], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and Helen A. Stafford

72. ¹⁰William Wallace Ludlow, son of ⁹Linnaeus Charles Ludlow [33] and Helen A. Stafford. Born in April 1858 in Ohio.

Married first _____ _____.

Issue of William Wallace Ludlow and _____ _____:
i. dau. ¹¹Catherine M. Ludlow b. in Nov. 1883 in Ohio.
ii. dau. Myra E. Ludlow b. in April 1895 in Ohio.

Married second Alice M. _____ in 1901/2 when about 43 years old (Alice M. was about 45 years old). Alice M. _____ b. in 1856/7 in Illinois.

Notes on William Wallace Ludlow:

William and his family by his second wifevwere enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Cleveland Heights, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, as follows:¹

William W. Ludlow, head of household, male, white, 52, married second time 8 years, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, treasurer stove manufacturer, works for wages, reads, writes, owns home free of mortgage.
Alice M. Ludlow, wife, female, white, 53, married first time 8 years, no children, born Illinois, father born Indiana, mother born Pennsylvania, speaks English, reads, writes.
Catherine M. Ludlow, daughter, female, white, 26, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Illinois [sic], speaks English, office clerk at telephone compnay, works for wages, reads, writes.
Mira E. Ludlow, daughter, female, white, 14, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio [sic], speaks English, reads, writes, attended school within the current year.

William was enumerated in the 1930 federal census of Cleveland Heights, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, in the household of his brother Harold as follows:²

Harold Ludlow, head of household, owns home valued at $8000, radio set, male, white, 43, married when 23 years old, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, supervisor at telephone company.
Bessie Ludlow, wife, female, white, 37, married when 18 years old, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born England, mother born England, speaks English.
Paul Ludlow, son, male, white, 13, single, attended school within current year, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
Wallace Ludlow, brother, male, white, 71, widower, does not [sic] read and write, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, worker in general office of store company.

_______________
¹ William W. Ludlow household, 1910 U.S. census, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, population schedule, Cleveland Height Village, enumeration district 10, supervisor’s district 19, sheet 3A, line 3, dwelling 49, family 52; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 1164.
² Harold Ludlow household, 1930 U.S. census, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, population schedule, Cleveland Heights, 2220 Grandview, enumeration district 18-574, supervisor’s district 5, sheet 19A, line 25, dwelling 73, family 108; National Archives micropublication T626, roll 1784.

73. ¹⁰Rev. Arthur Ludlow, son of ⁹Linnaeus Charles Ludlow [33] and Helen A. Stafford. Born in June 1861 in Ohio.

Married first _____ _____.

Issue of Rev. Arthur Ludlow and _____ _____:
104 i. son ¹¹Carroll G. Ludlow b. in June 1889 in Ohio.

Married second Rosa R. _____ in 1892/3 when about 31 years old (Rosa R. was about 33 years old). Rosa R. _____ b. in Jan. 1859 in Ohio; d. before 1920, at most 60 years old.

Notes on Rev. Arthur Ludlow:

Arthur, his son Carroll and his second wife Rosa were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, as follows:¹

Arthur Ludlow, head of household, white, male, born June 1861, 38, married 7 years, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, presbyterian clergyman, reads, writes, speaks English, owns mortgaged home.
Rosa R. Ludlow, wife, white, female, born Jan. 1859, 41, married 7 years, no children, born Ohio, father born Germany, mother born Germany, reads, writes, speaks English.
Carroll G. Ludlow, son, white, male, born June 1889, 10, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, at school, attended school within the current year, reads, writes, speaks English.

Arthur, his son Carroll and his second wife Rosa were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, as follows:²

Arthur C. Ludlow, head of household, male, white, 48, married second time 17 years, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, minister of church, works for wages, reads, writes, owns mortgaged home.
Rosa R. Ludlow, wife, female, white, 44, married first time 17 years, born Ohio, father born Germany - German, mother born Germany - German, speaks English, reads, writes.
Carroll G. Ludlow, son, male, white, 20, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, shipping clerk in hardware, works for wages, reads, writes.

Arthur was enumerated alone in the 1920 federal census of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, as follows:³

Arthur C. Ludlow, head of household, male, white, 58, widower, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, pastor of church, works for wages.

_______________
¹ Arthur Ludlow household, 1900 U.S. census, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, population schedule, Cleveland Ward 27, enumeration district 141, supervisor’s district 19, sheet 3A, line 21, dwelling 54, family 55; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 1257.
² Arthur C. Ludlow household, 1910 U.S. census, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, population schedule, Cleveland Ward 18, 9719 Miles Avenue S.E., enumeration district 275, supervisor’s district 19, sheet 11A, line 44, dwelling 225, family 243; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 1173.
³ Arthur C. Ludlow household, 1920 U.S. census, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, population schedule, Cleveland Ward 15, 9719 Miles, enumeration district 295, supervisor’s district 19, sheet 7A, line 39, dwelling 35, family 160; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 1367.

74. ¹⁰Linnaeus Charles Ludlow, son of ⁹Linnaeus Charles Ludlow [33] and Helen A. Stafford. Born in May 1873 in Ohio.

Married Cora A. _____ in 1902/3 when about 29 years old (Cora A. was about 24 years old). Cora A. _____ b. in 1878 in Ohio.

Issue of Linnaeus Charles Ludlow and Cora A. _____:
i. son ¹¹William L. Ludlow b. in 1904/5 in Ohio.
ii. son Arthur S. Ludlow b. in 1907/8 in Ohio.

Notes on Linnaeus Charles Ludlow:

Linnaeus and his family were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Elyria, Lorain Couny, Ohio, as follows:¹

Linneous C. Ludlow, head of household, male, white, 36, married once 7 years, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, paymaster at steel mill, reads, writes, owns home free of mortgage.
Cora A. Ludlow, wife, female, white, 34m married once 7 years, two children, both living, born Ohio, father born England - English, mother born England - English, speaks English, reads, writes.
William L. Ludlow, son, male, white, 5, single, born Ohio, father bor Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
Arthur S. Ludlow, son, male, white, 2, single, born Ohio, father bor Ohio, mother born Ohio.

Cora and her children were enumerated in the 1930 federal census of Elyria, Lorain Couny, Ohio, as follows:²

Cora A. Ludlow, head of household, owns home valued at $7000, radio set, female, white, 52, widow, 24 years old when first married, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born England, mother born England, speaks English.
William Ludlow, son, male, white, 25, single, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, teacher in public school, works for wages.
Arthur Ludlow, son, male, white, 22, singlereads and writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, printer in print shop, works for wages.

_______________
¹ Linneous C. Ludlow household, 1910 U.S. census, Lorain County, Ohio, population schedule, Elyria Ward 2, 5 Tattersall Court, enumeration district 108, supervisor’s district 184, sheet 13B, line 60, dwelling 214, family 231; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 1206.
² Cora A. Ludlow household, 1930 U.S. census, Lorain County, Ohio, population schedule, Elyria Township, 219 West Street, enumeration district 47-38, supervisor’s district 4, sheet 1A, line 29, dwelling 8, family 9; National Archives micropublication T626, roll 1831.

75. ¹⁰Harold Stafford Ludlow, son of ⁹Linnaeus Charles Ludlow [33] and Helen A. Stafford. Born on 22 April 1886 in Ohio.

Married Bessie J. _____ in 1909/10 when about 23 years old (Bessie J. was about 17 years old). Bessie J. _____ b. in 1892 in Ohio.

Issue of Harold Stafford Ludlow and Bessie J. _____:
i. son ¹¹Paul F. Ludlow b. in July 1916 in Ohio.

Notes on Harold Stafford Ludlow:

Harold and his family were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Elyria, Lorain County, Ohio, as follows:¹

Harold S. Ludlow, head of household, male, white, 23, married zero years, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, [?] factory, works for wages, reads, writes, rents home.
Gessie Ludlow, wife, female, white, 18, married zero years, no children, born Ohio, father born England - English, mother born England - English, speaks English, reads, writes.

Harold is listed in the World War I Draft Registration Cards, 1917–1918, registered on 13 September 1919, as Harold Stafford Ludlow, medium height, heavier build, brown eyes, brown hair, not disabled, living in Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, workimg as a wire chief in a telephone company, born 22 April 1886, wife Bessie J. Ludlow.

Harold, his family and his brother were enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Cleveland Heights, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, as follows:²

Harold S. Ludlow, head of household, owns mortgaged home, male, white, 33, married, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, electrician in telephone company, works for wages.
Bessie J. Ludlow, wife, female, white, 28, married, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born England - English, mother born England - English, speaks English.
Paul F. Ludlow, son, male, white, 3-5/12, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.

Harold, his family and his brother were enumerated in the 1930 federal census of Cleveland Heights, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, as follows:³

_______________
¹ Harold S. Ludlow household, 1910 U.S. census, Lorain County, Ohio, population schedule, Elyria Ward 4, 229 East Eighth Street, enumeration district 114, supervisor’s district 13, sheet 6A, line 4, dwelling 140, family 148; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 1206.
² Harold S. Ludlow household, 1920 U.S. census, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, population schedule, Cleveland Heights Village, 2220 Grandview Avenue, enumeration district 527, supervisor’s district 19, sheet 1B, line 63, dwelling 12, family 15; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 1374.
³ Harold Ludlow household, 1930 U.S. census, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, population schedule, Cleveland Heights, 2220 Grandview, enumeration district 18-574, supervisor’s district 5, sheet 19A, line 25, dwelling 73, family 108; National Archives micropublication T626, roll 1784.

Issue of William Henry Reed and ⁹Harriet Ella Ludlow [37] (⁸Harriet Metcalf [9], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1])

76. ¹⁰Lou Ella Reed, dau. of William Henry Reed and ⁹Harriet Ella Ludlow [37]. Born on 30 March 1869 in South Newbury, Geauga County, Ohio.

Married Frederick H. Crittenden, son of Henry W. Crittenden (son of Frederick W. Crittenden and Deborah Alden) and Phebe Caroline Morse (dau. of Moses Morse and Lydia Augusta Thompson), on 7 Nov. 1889 in Burton, Geauga County, Ohio when 20 years old (Frederick H. was 21 years old). Frederick H. Crittenden b. on 26 Feb. 1868 in Ohio; d. on 19 March 1936 in Eustis, Lake County, Florida, 68 years old.

Issue of Lou Ella Reed and Frederick H. Crittenden:
i. dau. ¹¹Cecile E. Crittenden b. on 26 Sep. 1890 in Burton; m. Dwight Strong (13 May 1880–) on 28 June 1916 in Burton when 25 years old (Dwight was 36 years old).
ii. dau. Arleen Crittenden b. on 16 Oct. 1894.

Notes on Lou Ella Reed:

Chapin¹ said Lou Ella, daughter of William Henry and Harriet Ella (Ludlow) Reed of Burton, Ohio, was born on 30 March 1869 in South Newbury, Ohio. She married Fred H. Crittendon on 7 November 1889 in Burton. He was born on 26 February 1868. They had two children.

Lou, her family and sister Florence were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Burton, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:²

Fred H. Crittenden, head of household, white, male, born Feb. 1868, 32, married 11 years, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, druggist, reads, writes, speaks English, owns home free of mortgage.
Lou E. Crittenden, wife, white, female, born March 1869, 31, married 11 years, two children both living, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, reads, writes, speaks English.
Cecile E. Crittenden, daughter, white, female, born Sep. 1890, 9, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, at school, attended school within the year.
Arleen Crittenden, daughter, white, female, born Oct. 1894, 5, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Florence A. Reed, sister-in-law, white, female, born Mayv1884, 16, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, at school, attended school within the year, reads, writes, speaks English.

Fred’s father and mother were enumerated on the same page next door to Fred.

Florence and her family were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Burton, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:³

Fred H. Crittenden, head of household, male, white, 42, married once for 21 years, born Ohio, father born Ohiio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, retail merchant in drug and sundry, works on own accound, reads, writes, owns home mortgage free.
Lou E. Crittenden, wife, female, white, 41, single [sic], married 21 years, two children both living, born Ohio, father born Ohiio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, reads, writes.
Cecile E. Crittenden, daughter, female, white, 19, single, born Ohio, father born Ohiio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, reads, writes, attended school within the year.
Arleen Crittenden, daughter, female, white, 15, single, born Ohio, father born Ohiio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, reads, writes, attended school within the year.
Celest Crittenden, niece, female, white, 11, single, born Ohio, father born Ohiio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, reads, writes, attended school within the year.

Lou and her family were enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Burton, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:⁴

Fred Crittenden, head of household, owns home mortgage free, male, white, 51, married, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, cashier at bank. works for salary.
Lou Crittenden, wife, female, white, 50, married, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
Arleen Crittenden, daughter, female, white, 24, single, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, teacher in public school, works for salary.

_______________
¹ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. II: Eighth to Twelfth Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 1969.
² Fred H. Crittenden household, 1900 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Burton Village, Krtland [Steet], enumeration district 43, supervisor’s district 18, sheet 8A, line 17, dwelling 135, family 140; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 1271.
³ Fred H. Crittenden household, 1910 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Burton Village, East Park Avenue, enumeration district 54, supervisor’s district 18, sheet 3B, line 67, dwelling 20, family 20; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 1185.
⁴ Fred Crittenden household, 1920 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Burton Village, enumeration district 61, supervisor’s district 18, sheet 12B, line 85, dwelling 355, family 360; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 1385.

Notes on Frederick H. Crittenden:

Henry was enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Burton, Geauga County, Ohio, in the household of his father as follows:¹

Henry W. Crittenden, white, male, 39, married, druggist, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born Massachusetts.
Phebe C. Crittenden, white, female, 33, wife, married, keeping house, born Ohio, father born Massachusetts, mother born Ohio.
Freddie H. Crittenden, white, male, 12, son, at school, attended school within the year, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Bird S. Crittenden, white, male, 5, son, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.

_______________
¹ Henry W. Crittenden household, 1880 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Burton Village, enumeration district 67, supervisor’s district 8, page 4, sheet 18A, line 46, dwelling 41, family 44; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 1018.

77. ¹⁰Henry Hayes Reed, son of William Henry Reed and ⁹Harriet Ella Ludlow [37]. Born on 12 June 1876 in Burton, Geauga County, Ohio.

Married Edith M. Smith, dau. of Albert Smith and Rachel _____, in 1899/1900 when about 23 years old (Edith M. was about 22 years old). Edith M. Smith b. in 1877 in Detroit, Wayne County, Michigan.

Issue of Henry Hayes Reed and Edith M. Smith:
i. son ¹¹Howard A. Reed b. in 1903 in Detroit.

Notes on Henry Hayes Reed:

Chapin¹ said Henry Hayes was born on 12 June 1876.

Henry and his family were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Detroit, Wayne County, Michigan, as follows:²

Henry H. Reed, head of household, male, white, 33, married once 10 years, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, [?], works for wages, reads, writes, owns mortgaged home.
Edith M. Reed, wife, female, white, 12, married once 10 years, one child, one living, born Michigan, father born Englamd - English, mother born Canada - English, speaks English, reads, writes.
Howard A. Reed, son, male, white, 7, single, born Michigan, father born Ohio, mother born Michigan, attended school within the year.
Rachel Smith, mother-in-law, female, white, 65, widow, two children both living, born Canada - English, father born England - English, mother born England - English, immigrated in 1861, speaks English, own income, reads, writes.

Henry and his family were enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Detroit, Wayne County, Michigan, as follows:³

Henry H. Reed, head of household, rents, male, white, 43, married, reads, writes, born [Burton struck out] Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, salesman of produce - rice [hutchins?], works for wages.
Edith M. Reed, wife, female, white, 42, married, reads, writes, born [Detroit struck out] Michigan, father born England - English, mother born Canada - English, speaks English.
Howard Reed, son, male, white 16, single, attended school within the year, reads, writes, born[Detroit struck out] Michigan, father born [Burton struck out] Ohio, mother born[Detroit struck out] Michigan, speaks English.

_______________
¹ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. II: Eighth to Twelfth Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 1412.
² Henry H. Reed household, 1910 U.S. census, Wayne County, Michigan, population schedule, Detroit Ward 1, 49 Rosedale Court, enumeration district 22, supervisor’s district 1, sheet 5A (continued on the next sheet), line 50, dwelling 101, family 107; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 679.
³ Henry H. Reed household, 1920 U.S. census, Wayne County, Michigan, population schedule, Detroit Ward 16, 188 Oregon [Street], enumeration district 513, supervisor’s district 1, sheet 3A, line 14, dwelling 42, family 58; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 815.

Notes on Edith M. Smith:

Edith was enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Detroit, Wayne County, Michigan, in her father’s household as follows:¹

Albert Smith, white, male, 36, married, baker, born England, father born England, mother born England.
Rachel Smith, white, female, 36, wife, married, keeping house, born Canada, father born England, mother born England.
Earnest Smith, white, male, 5, son, single, [at] school, attended school within the year, born Michigan, father born England, mother born Canada.
Edith Smith, white, femlae, 3, daughter, single, [at] home, born Michigan, father born England, mother born Canada.

_______________
¹ Albert Smith household, 1880 U.S. census, Wayne County, Michigan, population schedule, Detroit Ward 3, 85 Congress [Street], enumeration district 272, supervisor’s district 1, page 6, sheet 17B, line 15, dwelling 4330, family 43; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 611.

78. ¹⁰Ernest Waring Reed, son of William Henry Reed and ⁹Harriet Ella Ludlow [37]. Born on 8 Nov. 1881 in Burton, Geauga County, Ohio.

Married Mabel M. _____ about 1907 when about 26 years old (Mabel M. was about 23 years old). Mabel M. _____ b. in 1883/4 in Ohio.

Issue of Ernest Waring Reed and Mabel M. _____:
      i. dau. ¹¹Erna Arcele Reed b. about 1908 in Ohio.
      ii. dau. Frances A. Reed b. about 1910 in Michigan.
      iii. son Ludlow Reed b. in 1914/5 in Michigan.
      iv. dau. (May be living) Reed

Notes on Ernest Waring Reed:

Chapin¹ said Ernest Waring was born on 8 November 1881.

Ernest and his family were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Detroit, Wayne County, Michigan, as follows:²

Ernest W. Reed, head of household, male, white, 28, married once for three years, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, salesman in shoe house, works for wages, reads, writes, rents home.
Mabelle M. Reed, wife, female, white, 26, married once for three years, two children both living, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, reads, writes.
Erna A. Reed, son [sic], male [sic], 2, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Frances A. Reed, daughter, female, white, 2/12, single, born Michigan, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
M. Irma Kringelman, boarder, female, white, 20, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, telephone operator, works for wages, reads, writes.

Ernest and his family were enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Detroit, Wayne County, Michigan, as follows:³

Ernest W. Reed, head of household, rents, male, white, 38, married, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, salesman in shoe store, works for wages.
Mabel Reed, wife, female, white, 36, married, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Germany - German, speaks English.
Arcele Reed, daughter, female, white, 11, single, attended school within the year, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
Francis Reed, daughter, female, white, 9, single, attended school within the year, born Michigan, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Ludlow Reed, son, male, white, 5, single, attended school within the year, born Michigan, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.

Ernest and his family were enumerated in the 1930 federal census of Detroit, Wayne County, Michigan, as follows:⁴

Ernest W. Reed, head of household, owns home valued at $7500, male, white, 48, married when 26 years old, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, teacher in music, musician, employed.
Mabell Reed, wife, female, white, 42, married when 18 [sic], reads and writes, born Ohio, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Germany, speaks English, payroll clerk in express compnay, employed.
Arcele Reed, daughter, female, white, 22, single, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, saleswoman for florist, employed.
Frances Reed, daughter, female, white, 21, single, reads and writes, born Michigan, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, file clerk at Edison Company, employed.
Ludlow Reed, son, male, white, 15, single, attended school within the year, reads and writes, born Michigan, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
Shirley Reed, daughter, female, white, 9, single, attended school within the year, reads and writes, born Michigan, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.

_______________
¹ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. II: Eighth to Twelfth Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 1412.
² Ernest W. Reed household, 1910 U.S. census, Wayne County, Michigan, population schedule, Detroit Ward 13, 1067 Willis Avenue, enumeration district 198, supervisor’s district 1, sheet 13B, line 87, dwelling 256, family 284; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 686.
³ Ernest W. Reed household, 1920 U.S. census, Wayne County, Michigan, population schedule, Detroit Ward 19, 1419 Mack Avenue, enumeration district 595, supervisor’s district 145, sheet 15B, line 87, dwelling 320, family 370; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 818.
⁴ Ernest W. Reed household, 1930 U.S. census, Wayne County, Michigan, population schedule, Detroit Ward 19, enumeration district 82-687, supervisor’s district 22, sheet 2A, line 47, dwelling 34, family 34; National Archives micropublication T626, roll 1060.

Issue of ⁹Oliver Ellis Ludlow [38] (⁸Harriet Metcalf [9], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and Eliza S. Richards

79. ¹⁰Hoyt G. Ludlow, son of ⁹Oliver Ellis Ludlow [38] and Eliza S. Richards. Born on 9 Nov. 1878 in Auburn, Geauga County, Ohio.

Married Jessie L. _____ in 1899/1900 when about 21 years old (Jessie L. was about 21 years old). Jessie L. _____ b. in April 1878 in Ohio.

Issue of Hoyt G. Ludlow and Jessie L. _____:
      i. child ¹¹_____ Ludlow b. about 1901 in Ohio; d. before 1910.
      ii. son Gilbert H. Ludlow b. in 1902/3 in Ohio.
      iii. dau. Alice E. Ludlow b. in 1904/5 in Ohio.
      iv. dau. Edith M. Ludlow b. in 1905/6 in Ohio.
      v. dau. Margaret B. Ludlow b. in Dec. 1908 in Ohio.
      vi. son Ellis W. Ludlow b. in June 1916 in Ohio.

Notes on Hoyt G. Ludlow:

Hoyt and his wife were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Burton, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:¹

Hoyt G. Ludlow, head of household, white, male, born Nov. 1878, 21, married zero years, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, salesman boot, shoe and clothing, reads, writes, speaks English, rents home.
Jessie L. Ludlow, wife, white, female, born Apr. 1878, 22, married zero years, no children, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, telephone operator, reads, writes, speaks English.

Hoyt and his family were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Burton, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:²

Hoyt G. Ludlow, head of household, male, white, 31, married once for 10 years, born Ohio, father born Ohiio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, salesman in grocery, works for wages, reads, writes, rents home.
Jessie Ludlow, wife, female, white, 31, married once for 10 years, five children, four living, born Ohio, father born Ohiio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, reads, writes.
Gilbert H. Ludlow, son, male, white, 7, single, born Ohio, father born Ohiio, mother born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Alice E. Ludlow, daughter, female, white, 5, single, born Ohio, father born Ohiio, mother born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Edith M. Ludlow, daughter, female, white, 4, single, born Ohio, father born Ohiio, mother born Ohio.
Margaret B. Ludlow, daughter. female, white, 1-5/12, single, born Ohio, father born Ohiio, mother born Ohio.
Milda Grudel, servant, female, white, 18, single, born Ohio, father born Germany - German, mother born Ohio, speaks English, servant in private family, works for wages, reads, writes.

Hoyt was listed in the World War I Draft Registration Cards, 1917–1918, as Hoyt Gillbert Ludlow, meat cutter, born 9 November 1878, 39 years old, tall, medium build, blue eyes, grey hair, wife Jessie Ludlow, residing at 3217 Ruby Avenue, Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, roll number 1831701, dated 9/12/18.

Hoyt and his family were enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, as follows:³

Hoyt G. Ludlow, head of household, rents home, male, white, 41, married, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, salesman in meat market, works for wages.
Jessie L. Ludlow, wife, female, white, 41, married, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English
Gilbert H. Ludlow, son, male, white, 17, single, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, tool maker in steel plant, works for wages.
Alice E. Ludlow, daughter, female, white, 15, single, attended school within the year, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
Edith N. Ludlow, daughter, female, white, 13, single, attended school within the year, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
Margaret D. Ludlow, daughter, female, white, 11, single, attended school within the year, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
Ellis W., son, male, white 3-7/12, single, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Charles W. Naley, boarder, male, white, 19, single, reads, writes, born New York, father born New York, mother born New York, speaks English, machinist in machine shop, works for wages.

_______________
¹ Hoyt G. Ludlow household, 1900 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Burton Village, enumeration district 43, supervisor’s district 18, sheet 10A, line 19, dwelling 173, family 181; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 1271.
² Hoyt G. Ludlow household, 1910 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Burton Village, Goodwin Avenue, enumeration district 54, supervisor’s district 18, sheet 3B, line 72, dwelling 21, family 21; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 1185.
³ Hoyt G. Ludlow household, 1920 U.S. census, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, population schedule, Cleveland Ward 6, 3217 Ruby Avenue, enumeration district 107, supervisor’s district 19, sheet 12A, line 24, dwelling 199, family 150; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 1362.

80. ¹⁰Day Lorin Ludlow, son of ⁹Oliver Ellis Ludlow [38] and Eliza S. Richards. Born on 10 Nov. 1884 in Burton, Geauga County, Ohio.

Married Carrie P. _____ between 1906 and 1908. Carrie P. _____ b. in 1884/5 in Ohio.

Issue of Day Lorin Ludlow and Carrie P. _____:
i. son ¹¹William P. Ludlow b. in 1913/4 in Ohio.

Notes on Day Lorin Ludlow:

Day and his wife were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Burton, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:¹

Day L Ludlow, head of household, male, white, 25, married once for two years, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, retail merchant of gents furnishings, working on own account, reads, writes, rents home.
Carrie Ludlow, wife, female, white, 25, married once for two years, [1 child scratched out], none living, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, reads, writes.

Day was recorded in the World War I Draft Registration Cards, 1917–1918, roll 1832236, as Day Lorin Ludlow, born 10 November 1884, white, residing in Burton, Geauga County, Ohio, clerk in the White Motor Co. on St. Clare Ave., Cleveland, Ohio, wife Carrie P[?] Ludlow, medium height, medium build, grey eyes, brown hair, no disabilities.

Day and his family were enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, as follows:²

D. L. Ludlow, head of household, male, white, 35, married, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, foreman in motor company, works for wages.
Carrie Ludlow, wife, female, white, 35, married, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
William Ludlow, son, male, white, 6, single, attended school within the year, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
William Barber, boarder, male, white, 35, single, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, mechanic in motor company, works for wages.

Day and his family were enumerated in the 1930 federal census of Burton, Geauga County, Ohio, as follows:³

Day L. Ludlow, head of household, owns home valued at $5000, radio set, male, white 45, married 23 years, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
Carie P. Ludlow, wife, female, white, 46, married 23 years, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
William P. Ludlow, son, male, white, 16, single, attended school within the year, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English.

_______________
¹ Day L. Ludlow household, 1910 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Burton Village, enumeration district 54, supervisor’s district 18, sheet 4A, line 47, dwelling 16, family 18; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 1185.
² D. L. Ludlow household, 1920 U.S. census, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, population schedule, Cleveland Ward 21, 1371 E. 85th Street, enumeration district 419, supervisor’s district 149, sheet 1B, line 91, dwelling 16, family 22; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 1370.
³ Day L. Ludlow household, 1930 U.S. census, Geauga County, Ohio, population schedule, Burton Village, South Cheshire Street, enumeration district 29-3, supervisor’s district 5, sheet 5B, line 70, dwelling 168, family 173; National Archives micropublication T626, roll 1803.

Issue of John B. Crall and ⁹Mary Eliza Metcalf [39] (⁸George A. Metcalf [10], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1])

81. ¹⁰John B. Crall, son of John B. Crall and ⁹Mary Eliza Metcalf [39]. Born on 22 June 1853 in Ohio. Died on 4 Sep. 1939 in Port Angeles, Clallam County, Washington, 86 years old.

Married Rose Eva _____ in 1883/4 when about 30 years old (Rose Eva was about 25 years old). Rose Eva _____ b. in July 1858 in Ohio.

Issue of John B. Crall and Rose Eva _____:
      i. child ¹¹_____ Crall b. say in 1885 in Iowa.
105   ii. son Harry G. Crall b. in July 1887 in Iowa.
      iii. son Frank D. Crall b. in July 1889 in Iowa.
      iv. dau. Eva M. Crall b. in Nov. 1891 in Iowa.
      v. child _____ Crall b. say in 1894/5 in Iowa; d. young.
      vi. dau. Leaba F. Crall b. in Jan. 1897 in Iowa.
106   vii. son Donald J. Crall b. in June 1898 in Iowa.

Notes on John B. Crall:

John and his family were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of St. John, Harrison County, Iowa, as follows:¹

John B. Crall, head of household, white, male, born June 1853, 46, married 26 [sic, probably 16] years, born Ohio, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Connecticut, farmer, reads, writes, speaks English, rents farm.
Rose E. Crall, wife, white, female, born July 1858, 41, married 26 [sic, probably 16] years, seven children, six living, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, reads, writes, speaks English.
Harry G. Crall, son, white, male, born July 1887, 12, single, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, at school, attended school within the year, reads, writes, speaks English.
Frank D. Crall, son, white, male, born July 1889, 10, single, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, at school, attended school within the year, reads, writes, speaks English.
Eva M. Crall, daughter, white, female, born Nov. 1891, single, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, at school, attended school within the year.
Leaba F. Crall, daughter, white, female, born Jan. 1897, 3, single, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Donald J. Crall, son, white, male, born June 1898, 11/12, single, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.

John and his family were enumerated in the 1910 federal census ofDeming, Whatcom County, Washington, as follows:²

John B. Crall, head of household, male, white, 56. married once 26 years, born Ohio, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Connecticut, speaks English, farming on home farm, reads, writes, owns mortgaged farm.
Eva Crall, wife, female, white, 50, married once 26 years, 7 children, 6 living, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, reads, writes.
Frank Crall, son, male, white, 20, single, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, laborer on home farm, reads, writes.
Eva Crall, daughter, female, white, 18, single, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, reads, writes.
Della Crall, daughter, female, white, 13, single, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, reads, writes, attended school within the year.
Donald Crall, son, male, white, 10, single, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, reads, writes, attended school within the year.

_______________
¹ John B. Crall household, 1900 U.S. census, Harrison County, Iowa, population schedule, St. John Township, enumeration district 86, supervisor’s district 9, sheet 11B, line 92, dwelling 217, family 222; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 436.
² John B. Crall household, 1910 U.S. census, Spokane County, Washington, population schedule, Freeman Township, enumeration district 138, supervisor’s district 3, sheet 18A, line 16, dwelling 67, family 69; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 1669.

Issue of John J. Haller and ⁹Mary Eliza Metcalf [39] (⁸George A. Metcalf [10], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1])

82. ¹⁰Lue Netta Haller, dau. of John J. Haller and ⁹Mary Eliza Metcalf [39]. Born in Sep. 1860 in Ohio. Died on 27 July 1954 in Spokane, Spokane County, Washington, 93 years old.

Married David Henry Kochenderfer, son of Joseph Henry Kochenderfer and Lavina Artz (dau. of Johannes Artz and Sara Spengler), on 17 Aug. 1876 in Ohio when 15 years old (David Henry was 20 years old). David Henry Kochenderfer b. on 7 June 1856 in Franklin Township, Richland County, Ohio; d. on 8 July 1924 in Spokane, 68 years old.

Issue of Lue Netta Haller and David Henry Kochenderfer:
      i. dau. ¹¹Leah Clara Kochenderfer b. on 7 June 1877 in Crawford County; d. on 8 July 1924 in Spokane, 47 years old.
      ii. dau. Myrtle May Kochenderfer b. on 8 Dec. 1881 in Ohio; d. on 8 June 1889 in Ohio, seven years old.
      iii. son Walter Earl Kochenderfer b. on 26 Aug. 1888 in Ohio; d. in Sep. 1970 in Danville, Contra Costa County, California, 82 years old.
      iv. dau. Ruby Gladys Kochenderfer b. on 27 Sep. 1892 in Ohio; d. on 12 May 1961 in Seattle, King County, Washington, 68 years old.
      v. son Elmer Kochenderfer b. on 4 Feb. 1895 in Ohio; d. on 27 May 1895, three months old.
      vi. dau. Atha Haller Kochenderfer b. on 13 Aug. 1898 in Missouri; d. on 10 Dec. 1998 in Spokane, 100 years old.
      vii. son Frank Irvin Kochenderfer b. on 5 Dec. 1902 in Washington; d. on 4 March 1949 in Washington, 46 years old.

Notes on Lue Netta Haller:

Nettie and her family were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Jackson, Crawford County, Ohio, as follows:¹

Henry Kochendorfer, white, male, 24, married, fancy wood work, born Pennsylvania, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Pennsylvania.
Hettie Kochendorfer, white, female, 20, wife, married, house keeper, born Ohio, father born Switzerland, mother born New York [sic].
Leah Kochendorfer, white, female, 2, daughter, born Ohio, father born _____, mother born _____.

David’s father is enumerated in the next family:²

Joseph Kochendorfer, white, male, 62, married, farmer, born Pennsylvania, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Pennsylvania.
Lavina Kochendorfer, white, female, house keeper, born Pennsylvania, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Pennsylvania.
Rosa Kochendorfer, white, female, 21, daughter, house keeper, born Ohio, father born _____, mother born _____.

Nettie and her family were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Waitsburg, Walla Walla County, Washington, as follows:³

David H. Kochenderfer, head of household, white, male, born June 1856, 43, married 23 years, born Ohio, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Pennsylvania, carpenter, reads, writes, speaks English.
Nettie Kochenderfer, wife, white, female, born Sept. 1860, 39, married 23 years, four children, four [sic] living, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, reads, writes, speaks English.
Leah Kochenderfer, daughter, white, female, born June 1877, 22, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, stenographer, attended school within the year, reads, writes, speaks English.
Walter Kochenderfer, son, white, male, born Aug. 1888, 11, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, at school, attended school within the year, reads, writes, speaks English.
Rubie Kochenderfer, daughter, white, female, born Sept. 1892, 7, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, stenographer, attended school within the year, reads, writes, speaks English.
Atha Kochenderfer, daughter, white, female, born Aug. 1898, 1, single, born Missouri, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.

Nettie and her family were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Spokane, Spokane County, Washington, as follows:⁴

Henry D. Kochenderfer, head of household, male, white, 54, married once for 35 years, born Ohio, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Pennsylvania, speaks English, carpenter, works for wages, reads, writes, owns home free of mortgage.
Nettie Kochenderfer, wife, female, 50, married once for 35 years, 7 children, five living, born Ohio, father born Germany [sic], mother born New York [sic], speaks English, reads, writes.
Ruby Kochenderfer, daughter, female, white, 16, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, saleslady in shoe department, works for wages, reads, writes.
Atha Kochenderfer, daughter, female, ehite, 11, single, born Missouri, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, reads, writes, attended school within the year.
Frank Kochderfer, son, male, white, 7, single, single, born Washington, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, attended school within the year.

Nettie and her husband were enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Spokane, Spokane County, Washington, as follows:⁵

David H. Kochenderfer, head of household, owns home free of mortgage, male, white, 64, married, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Pennsylvania, speaks English, cabinet maker in carpenter shop, works for wages.
Nettie Kochenderfer, wife, female, white, 59, married, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Switzerland - German, mother born New York [sic], speaks English.

_______________
¹ Henry Kochendorfer household, 1880 U.S. census, Crawford County, Ohio, population schedule, Jackson Township, enumeration district 102, supervisor’s district 6, page 31, sheet 443B, line 22, dwelling 47, family 48; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 1003.
² Joseph Kochendorfer household, 1880 U.S. census, Crawford County, Ohio, population schedule, Jackson Township, enumeration district 102, supervisor’s district 6, page 31, sheet 443B, line 26, dwelling 48, family 49; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 1003.
³ David H. Kochenderfer household, 1900 U.S. census, Walla Walla County, Washington, population schedule, Waitsburg, enumeration district 86, supervisor’s district 2, sheet 11A, line 40, dwelling 206, family 210; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 1752.
⁴ Henry D. Kochenderfer household, 1910 U.S. census, Spokane County, Washington, population schedule, Spokane Ward 4, 4444 Madison, enumeration district 180, supervisor’s district 3, sheet 20A, line 22, dwelling 24, family 27; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 1671.
⁵ David H. Kochenderfer household, 1920 U.S. census, Spokane County, Washington, population schedule, Spokane, 4444 Madison Street, enumeration district 222, supervisor’s district 5, sheet 1B, line 75, dwelling 20, family 20; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 1941.

83. ¹⁰Mary Belle E. Haller, dau. of John J. Haller and ⁹Mary Eliza Metcalf [39]. Born on 30 Nov. 1862 in Ohio. Died on 28 Dec. 1946 in Spokane, Spokane County, Washington, 84 years old.

Married William Rudolf Haller, son of Rodolphus Haller and Mary _____, in 1879 when 16 or 17 years old (William Rudolf was 18 or 19 years old). William Rudolf Haller b. on 15 March 1860 in Elba, Lapeer County, Michigan; d. on 15 March 1948 in Tacoma, Pierce County, Washington, 88 years old.

Issue of Mary Belle E. Haller and William Rudolf Haller:
      i. dau. ¹¹Mary Blanche Haller b. on 22 Dec. 1879 in Hadley, Lapeer County, Michigan; d. on 9 Feb. 1965 in Shelton, Mason County, Washington, 85 years old; m. Luther Stanley Ferguson (26 Dec. 1872 in Birmingham, Oakland County, Michigan–11 Dec. 1949 in Tacoma) on 5 Sep. 1899 in Ubly, Huron County, Michigan when 19 years old (Luther Stanley was 26 years old).
      ii. dau. Lois N. Haller b. in March 1881 in Michigan; m. Joseph Kreigler (1867 in Bohemia, Czech Republic–).
      iii. son Walter Haller b. on 1 June 1883 in Bad Axe, Huron County, Michigan; d. on 2 Nov. 1897 in Bad Axe, 14 years old.
      iv. dau. Gladys Haller b. in June 1892 in Bad Axe; m. D. I. Fritz.
      v. son Roland M. Haller b. in Jan. 1897 in Bad Axe.
      vi. dau. Helen/Elsie R. Haller b. on 10 Aug. 1900 in Bad Axe; m. William Bookwalter.

Notes on Mary Belle E. Haller:

Mary and her family were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Hadley, Lapeer County, Michigan, as follows:¹

William Haller, white, male, 21, married during the current year, working in carpenter shop. born Michigan, father born Switzerland, mother born Switzerland.
Mary Bell Haller, white, female, 17, wife, married during the current year, keeping house, born Ohio, father born Switzerland, mother born Ohio.
Mary Blanch, white, female, 6/12, born Dec. [1879], daughter, single, born Michigan, father born Michigan, mother born Ohio.

Mary and her family were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Bad Axe, Huron County, Michigan, as follows:²

William Haller, head of household, white, male, born Mar. 1860, 40, married 21 years, born Michigan, father born Switzerland, mother born Switzerland, carpenter, reads, writes, speaks English, owns mortgaged home.
Bell Haller, wife, white, female, born Nov. 1863, 36, married 21 years, five children, four living, born Ohio, father born Switzerland, mother born Ohio, reads, writes, speaks English.
Lois Haller, daughter, white, female, born Mar. 1881, 19, single, born Michigan, father born Michigan, mother born Ohio, dressmaker, reads, writes, speaks English.
Gladys Haller, daughter, white, female, born June 1892, 7, single, born Michigan, father born Michigan, mother born Ohio, attended school within the year, reads, writes, speaks English.
Roland Haller, son, white, male, born Jan. 1897, 3, single, born Michigan, father born Michigan, mother born Ohio.

Mary and her family were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Five Mile Township, Spokane County, Washington, as follows:³

Wm. Haller, head of household, male, white, 50, married once for 32 years, born Michigan, father born Switzerland, mother born Switzerland, speaks English, farmer on [?] farm, works on own account, reads, writes, owns farm free of mortgage.
Mary Bell Haller, wife, female, white, 47, married once for 32 years, six children, five living, born Ohio, father born Switzerland, mother born Ohio, speaks English, housekeeper in own home, reads, writes.
Gladys Haller, daughter, female, white, 17, single, born Michigan, father born Michigan, mother born Ohio, speaks English, helps at home, reads, writes.
Roland Haller, son, male, white, 13, single, born Michigan, father born Michigan, mother born Ohio, speaks English, helps at home, reads, writes, attended school within the year.
Helen Haller, daughter, female, white, 10, single, born Michigan, father born Michigan, mother born Ohio, speaks English, helps at home, reads, writes, attended school within the year.

Mary and her family were enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Spokane, Spokane County, Washington, in the household of her son-in-law Joseph Kreigler as follows:⁴

Joseph Kreigler, head of household, owns home free of mortgage, male, white, 53, married, immigrated in 1885, naturalized in 1891, born Bohemia - German, father born Bohemia - German, mother born Bohemia - German, speaks English, owner of [RS?] lumber yard, works on own account.
Lois N. Kreigler, wife, female, white, 38, married, reads, writes, born Michigan, father born Michigan, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
Joseph E. Kreigler, son, male, white, 23, single, attended school within the year, reads, writes, born North Dakota, father born Bohemia - German, mother born Michigan, speak English.
William Haller, father-in-law, male, white, 59, married, reads, writes, born Michigan, father born Switzerland - German, mother born Switzerland - German, speaks English.
Belle E. Haller, mother-in-law, female, white, 57, married, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Switzerland - German, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
Rolland M. Haller, brother-in-law, male, whit, 23, single, reads, writes, born Michigan, father born Michigan, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
Elsie R. Haller, sister-in-law, female, white, 19, single, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Michigan, mother born Ohio, speaks English.

Mary and her husband were enumerated in the 1930 federal census of Spokane, Spokane County, Washington,as follows:⁵

William Haller, head of household, owns home valued at $2500, male, white, 70, married when 19 years old, reads and writes, born Michigan, father born Switzerland, mother born Switzerland, speaks English, janitor in market, works for wages.
Mary B. Haller, wife, female, white, 67, married when 16 years old, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born Switzerland, mother born Ohio, speaks English.

_______________
¹ William Haller household, 1880 U.S. census, Lapeer County, Michigan, population schedule, Hadley Village, enumeration district 168, supervisor’s district 3, page 31, sheet 250C, line 26, dwelling 324, family 334; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 589.
² Wiliam Haller household, 1900 U.S. census, Huron County, Michigan, population schedule, Bad Axe Village, Colfax Township, enumeration district 6, supervisor’s district 7, sheet 2B, line 64, dwelling 40, family 40; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 715.
³ Wm. Haller household, 1910 U.S. census, Spokane County, Washington, population schedule, Five Mile Township, enumeration district 129, supervisor’s district 3, sheet 17B, line 61, dwelling 36, family 36; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 1669.
⁴ Joseph Kreigler household, 1920 U.S. census, Spokane County, Washington, population schedule, Spokane City Ward 4, 735 W. Chelan Avenue, enumeration district 239, supervisor’s district 5, sheet 7B (continued on the next sheet), line 96, dwelling 172, family 181; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 1941.
⁵ William Haller household, 1930 U.S. census, Spokane County, Washington, population schedule, Spokane City Ward 4, enumeration district 32-28, supervisor’s district 5, sheet 12B, line 62, dwelling 215, family 249; National Archives micropublication T626, roll 28.

Notes on William Rudolf Haller:

William was enumerated in the 1860 federal census of Elba, Lapeer County, Michigan, in his father’s household as follows:¹

Rodolphus Haller, 30, male, cabinet maker, real property $400, personal property $100.
Mary Haller, 30, female, born Michigan.
John Haller, 7, male, born New York, attended school within the year.
Andrew Haller, 4, male, born Michigan.
Henry Haller, 2, male, born Michigan.
William F. Haller, 4/12, male, born Michigan.

_______________
¹ Haller,Rodolphus household, 1860 U.S. census, Lapeer County, Michigan, population schedule, Elba Township, Farmers Creek Post Office, page 242, line 29, dwelling 1941, family 1817; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 549.

84. ¹⁰Frank M. Haller, son of John J. Haller and ⁹Mary Eliza Metcalf [39]. Born in Jan. 1874 in Ohio.

Married Pearl M. _____ in 1896 when 21 or 22 years old (Pearl M. was 16 or 17 years old). Pearl M. _____ b. in Sep. 1879 in Indiana.

Issue of Frank M. Haller and Pearl M. _____:
      i. child ¹¹_____ Haller b. say in 1897/8 in Ohio; d. young.
      ii. son Ishmail D. Haller b. in Feb. 1900 in Ohio.
107   iii. dau. Helen F. Haller b. in 1902/3 in Ohio.
      iv. son John D. Haller b. in 1905/6 in Ohio.
      v. dau. Esther Haller b. in 1907/8 in Ohio.
      vi. son Charles E. Haller b. in 1911 in Ohio.
      vii. dau. Ruth A. Haller b. in 1914 in Ohio.
      viii. son Marvin F. Haller b. in March 1916 in Ohio.
      ix. dau. (May be living) Haller
      x. son (May be living) Haller
      xi. son (May be living) Haller

Notes on Frank M. Haller:

Frank and his family were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Celina, Mercer County, Ohio, as follows:¹

Frank Haller, head of household, white, male, born Jan. 1874, 26, married 3 years, born Ohio, father born Switzerland, mother born Ohio, drayman, reads, writes, speaks English, rents home.
Pearl M. Haller, wife, white, female, born Sept. 1879, 20, married 3 years, one child, one living, born Ohio [sic], father born Ohio, mother born Indiana, reads, writes, speaks English.
Ishmail D. Haller, son, white, male, born Feb. 1900, 4/12, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio [sic].

Frank and his family were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Celina, Mercer County, Ohio, as follows:²

Frank Haller, head of household, male, white, 35, married once for 13 years, born Ohio, father born Switzerland - German, mother born Ohio, speaks English, machinist in furniture factory, works for wages, reads, writes, rents home.
Pearl Haller, wife, female, white, 30, married once for 13 years, five children, four living, born Indiana, father born Ohio, mother born Indiana, speaks English, reads, writes.
Ishmail Haller, son, male, white, 10, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Indiana, speaks English, reads, writes, attended school within the year.
Helen Haller, daughter, female, white, 7, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Indiana, attended school within the year.
John Haller, son, male, white, 4, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Indiana.
Esther Haller, daughter, female, white, 2, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Indiana.

Frank and his family were enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Dayton, Montgomery County, Ohio, as follows:³

Frank Haller, head of household, owns mortgaged home, male, white 46, married, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Switzerland - French, mother born Ohio, speaks English, wood finisher in wheel factory, works for wages.
Pearl Haller, wife, female, white, 40, married, reads, writes, born Indiana, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
Ishmael Haller, son, male, white, 19, single, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Indiana, speaks English, electrician in electrical shop, works for wages.
Helen Gilman, daughter, female, white, 17, married, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Indiana, speaks English.
John Haller, son, male, white, 14, single, attended school in the current year, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Indiana, speaks English.
Esther Haller, daughter, female, white, 12, single, attended school in the current year, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Indiana, speaks English.
Charles Haller, son, male, white, 8, single, attended school in the current year, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Indiana, speaks English.
Ruth Haller, daughter, female, white, 5, single, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Indiana.
Marvin Haller, son, male, white, 3-10/12, single, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Indiana.
Mary Haller, daughter, female, white, 1-0/12, single, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Indiana.
John C. Gilman, son-in-law, male, white, 21, married, reads, writes, born Colorado, father born Colorado, mother born Colorado, speaks English, machine [?] in machine company.

Frank and his family were enumerated in the 1930 federal census of Dayton, Montgomery County, Ohio, as follows:⁴

Frank H. Haller, head of household, owns home valued at $5500, male, white, 56, married when 22 years old, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born Switzerland, mother born Ohio, speaks Engliish, wood finisher [?], works for wages.
Pearl Haller, wife, female, white, 50, married when 17 years old, reads and writes, born Indiana, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
John D. Haller, son, male, white, 24, single, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Indiana, speaks English, auto mechanic, works for wages.
Charles E. Haller, son, male, white, 19, single, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Indiana, speaks English, machinist - [fare reg?], works for wages.
Ruth A. Haller, daughter, female, white, 16, single, attended school within the current year, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Indiana, speaks English.
Marvin f. Haller, son, male, white, 12, single, attended school within the current year, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Indiana, speaks English.
Mary P. Haller, daughter, female, white, 11, single, attended school within the current year, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Indiana, speaks English.
Helen F. Gilman, daughter, female, white, 27, divorced, married when 17 years old,reads and writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Indiana, speaks English, saleslady in ready-to-wear, works for wages.
Calvin R. Gilman, grandson, male, white, 10, single, attended school within the current year, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born Colorado, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
Delbert D. Haller, son, male, white, 5, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Indiana.

_______________
¹ Frank Haller household, 1900 U.S. census, Mercer County, Ohio, population schedule, Celina Ward 2, enumeration district 84, supervisor’s district 3, sheet 8B, line 82, dwelling 165, family 171; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 1304.
² Frank Haller household, 1910 U.S. census, Mercer County, Ohio, population schedule, Celina Village Ward 3, 218 Mill Street, enumeration district 118, supervisor’s district 9, sheet 22A, line 8, dwelling 473, family 509; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 1214.
³ Frank Haller household, 1920 U.S. census, Montgomery County, Ohio, population schedule, Dayton Ward 4, 61 Pioneer Street, enumeration district 112, supervisor’s district 249, sheet 6A (continued on the next sheet), line 45, dwelling 133, family 137; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 1420.
⁴ Frank H. Haller household, 1930 U.S. census, Montgomery County, Ohio, population schedule, Dayton Ward 4, 61 Pioneer Street, enumeration district 57-32, supervisor’s district 23, sheet 19B, line 58, dwelling 235, family 370; National Archives micropublication T626, roll 1852.

Issue of ⁹Gilbert A. Metcalf [41] (⁸George A. Metcalf [10], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and Sarah Anne Cox

85. ¹⁰Charles A. Metcalf, son of ⁹Gilbert A. Metcalf [41] and Sarah Anne Cox. Born in 1860/1 in Ohio.

Married Florence N. Hathaway on 1 Jan. 1888 in Seneca County when 27 years old (Florence N. was 27 years old). Florence N. Hathaway b. in 1860/1 in Ohio.

Issue of Charles A. Metcalf and Florence N. Hathaway:
i. dau. ¹¹Alice C. Metcalf b. in 1889/90 in Ohio.

Notes on Charles A. Metcalf:

Ohio Marriages, 1803–1900, lists the marriage of Charles A. Metcalf and Florence Hathaway on 1 January 1888 in Seneca County.

Charles and his family were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Reed, Seneca County, Ohio, as follows:¹

Charles A. Metcalf, head of household, male, white, 49, married 23 years, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Virginia [sic], speaks English, farmer, general farming, works on own account, reads, writes, owns farm free of mortgage.
Florence N. Metcalf, wife, female, white, 49, married 23 years, one child, one living, born Ohio, father born Massachusetts, mother born New York, speaks English, reads, writes.
Alice C. Metcalf, daughter, female, white, 20, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, teacher of instrumental music, works for wages, reads, writes.

_______________
¹ Charles R. Metcalf household, 1910 U.S. census, Seneca County, Ohio, population schedule, Reed Township, enumeration district 168, supervisor’s district 12, sheet 5A, line 21, dwelling 105, family 107; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 1229.

86. ¹⁰William Ludlow Metcalf, son of ⁹Gilbert A. Metcalf [41] and Sarah Anne Cox. Born in June 1864 in Ohio. Died before 1920, at most 55 years old.

Married Eva C. Raymond, dau. of Isaac Raymond (son of George Raymond and Hannah Read) and Frances L. Couch (dau. of James L. Couch and Celestia C. _____), on 2 Sep. 1885 in Seneca County when 21 years old (Eva C. was about 19 years old). Eva C. Raymond b. in Sep. 1866 in Attica, Seneca County, Ohio; d. in Perrysville, Ashland County, Ohio.

Issue of William Ludlow Metcalf and Eva C. Raymond:
108   i. son ¹¹Frank Raymond Metcalf b. on 24 Feb. 1887 in Attica.
109   ii. son Arlington D. Metcalf b. in Sep. 1889 in Attica.
110   iii. son Donald Colburn Metcalf b. in Oct. 1891 in Attica.
111   iv. son Jesse Ladow Metcalf b. on 1 Feb. 1899 in Reed Township, Seneca County, Ohio.
112   v. son James Roland Metcalf b. on 16 Nov. 1904 in Reed Township.

Notes on William Ludlow Metcalf:

Ohio Marriages, 1803–1900, lists the marriage of William Metcalf and Eva Raymond on 2 September 1885 in Seneca County.

William, his family and his mother were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Reed, Seneca County, Ohio, as follows:¹

William, his family and his mother were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Reed, Seneca County, Ohio, as follows:²

William L. Metcalf, head of household, male, white, 46, married 24 years, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, laborer, section railroad, works for wages, reads, writes, owns mortgaged farm.
Eva C. Metcalf, wife, female, white, 44, married 24 years, five children, five living, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born New York, speaks English, reads, writes.
Frank R. Metcalf, son, male, white, 23, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, farmer, general farming home farm, works on own account, reads, writes.
Arlington D. Metcalf, son, male, white, 20, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, farmer, general farming home farm, works on own account, reads, writes.
Don C. Metcalf, son, male, white, 18, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, carpenter on houses, works for wages, reads, writes.
Jesse Y. Metcalf, son, male, white, 11, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, reads, writes, attended school in the current year.
Rolla J. Metcalf, son, male, white, 5, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Sarah A. Metcalf, mother, female, white, 74, widow, two children, two living, born Ohio, father born Virginia, mother born Pennsylvania, speaks English, reads, writes.

Eva (a widow) was enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Perrysburg, Wood County, Ohio, in the household of her son Jesse as follows:³

Jesse L. Metcalf, head of household, rents home, male, white, 20, married, reads,writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, laborer farrow manufacturing company, work for wages.
Bertha F. Metcalf, wife, female, white, 25, married, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
James R. Metcalf, brother, male, white, 15, single, attended school within the year, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Eva Metcalf, mother, female, white, [52?], widow, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, laborer, [?] company, works for wages.

_______________
¹ William Metcalf household, 1900 U.S. census, Seneca County, Ohio, population schedule, Reed Township, enumeration district 115, supervisor’s district 12, sheet 13B, line 81, dwelling 276, family 283; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 1320.
² William L. Metcalf household, 1910 U.S. census, Seneca County, Ohio, population schedule, Reed Township, enumeration district 168, supervisor’s district 12, sheet 5A, line 13, dwelling 104, family 106; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 1229.
³ Jesse L. Metcalf household, 1920 U.S. census, Wood County, Ohio, population schedule, Perrysburg, enumeration district 171, supervisor’s district 6, sheet 3A, line 35, dwelling 61, family 63; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 1449.

Notes on Eva C. Raymond:

Eva was enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Reed Township, Seneca County, Ohio, in the household of her father as follows:¹

Isaac Raymond, 43, male, white, farmer, real property $4000, personal property $1000, born Ohio.
Francis Raymond, 33, female, white, keeping house, born New York.
James Raymond, 13, male, white, attending school, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Eva C. Raymond, 3, female, white, born Ohio.
Jesse W. Raymond, 1, male, white, born Ohio.

Eva was enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Reed Township, Seneca County, Ohio, in the household of her father as follows:²

Isaac Raymond, white, male, 53, married, farming, born Ohio, father born New York, mother born New York.
Francis Raymond, white, female, 45, wife, married, house keeping, born Ohio, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Pennsylvania.
Alva Raymond, white, male, 25, son, single, laborer, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born New York.
Eva Raymond, white, female, 13, daughter, single, attended school within the year, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born New York.
Jesse Raymond, white, female, 11, daughter single, attended school within the year, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born New York.

Sons Alva and James are the same person—the 1900 census lists only three children for Isaac and Frances.

Some information is from Ancestry.com’s OneWorldTree.

_______________
¹ Isaac Raymond household, 1870 U.S. census, Seneca County, Ohio, population schedule, Reed Township, Bloomville Post Office, page 2, sheet 222 (continued on the next sheet), line 40, dwelling 18, family 20; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 1266.
² Isaac Raymond household, 1880 U.S. census, Seneca County, Ohio, population schedule, Reed, enumeration district 207, supervisor’s district 1, page 1, sheet 275A, line 16, dwelling 4, family 4; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 1065.

Issue of ⁹Orin E. Metcalf [42] (⁸George A. Metcalf [10], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and Elizabeth Douglas

87. ¹⁰George D. Metcalf, son of ⁹Orin E. Metcalf [42] and Elizabeth Douglas. Born in 1863/4 in Ohio.

Married Minnie Mae _____ in 1884/5 when about 21 years old (Minnie Mae was about 19 years old). Minnie Mae _____ b. in 1865/6 in Iowa.

Issue of George D. Metcalf and Minnie Mae _____:
i. dau. ¹¹Bernice Metcalf b. in 1886/7 in Iowa.

Notes on George D. Metcalf:

George and his family were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Hillyard, Spokane County, Washington, as follows:¹

George Metcalf, head of household, male, white, 45, married once for 25 years, born Ohio, father born Michigan [sic], mother born England, speaks English, foreman in railraod boiler shops, works for wages, reads, writes, owns mortgaged home.
Minnie Metcalf, wife, female, white, 44, married once for 25 years, one child, one living, born Iowa, father born Indiana, mother born Illinois, speaks English, reads, writes.
Bernice Metcalf, daughter, female, white, 23, single, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother born Iowa, speaks English, stenographer for master mechanic, works for wages, reads, writes.

George and his wife were enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Hillyard, Spokane County, Washington, as follows:²

George D. Metcalf, head of household, owns home free of mortgage, male, white, 54, married, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born England - English, speaks English, boiler maker for railway.
Minnie Mae Metcalf, wife, female, white, 53, married, reads, writes, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English.

George and his wife were enumerated in the 1930 federal census of Spokane, Spokane County, Washington, as follows:³

George D. Metcalf, head of household, owns home valued at $4000, radio set, male, white, 64, married when 21 years old, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born Michigan [sic], mother born England, speaks English, boiler foreman in round house, works for wages.
Minnie Metalf, wife, female, white, 63, married when 18 years old, reads and writes, born Iowa, father born Indiana, mother born Illinois, speaks English.

_______________
¹ George Metcalf household, 1910 U.S. census, Spokane County, Washington, population schedule, Hillyard City, 315 Everett Avenue, enumeration district 207, supervisor’s district 3, sheet 11B, line 92, dwelling 246, family 261; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 1669.
² George D. Metcalf household, 1920 U.S. census, Spokane County, Washington, population schedule, Hillyard City Ward 3, 315 Everett Avenue, enumeration district 136, supervisor’s district 5, sheet 10A, line 35, dwelling 66, family 59; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 1940.
³ George D. Metcalf household, 1930 U.S. census, Spokane County, Washington, population schedule, Spokane Ward 4, 2707 Liberty, enumeration district 32-22, supervisor’s district 5, sheet 14B, line 70, dwelling 193, family 193; National Archives micropublication T626, roll 2515.

88. ¹⁰Welby J. Metcalf, son of ⁹Orin E. Metcalf [42] and Elizabeth Douglas. Born in 1871/2 in Ohio.

Married Leah M. _____ in 1893/4 when about 22 years old (Leah M. was about 17 years old). Leah M. _____ b. in 1876/7 in Illinois.

Issue of Welby J. Metcalf and Leah M. _____:
      i. dau. ¹¹Helen Metcalf b. in 1895/6 in Iowa.
      ii. son Harold J. Metcalf b. in 1898 in Iowa; m. Jessie _____ (1899/1900 in England–) in 1929/30 when about 31 years old (Jessie was about 30 years old).
      iii. son Edgar G. Metcalf b. in 1905 in Washington; m. Marguerite _____ (1908/9 in Kansas–) in 1927/8 when about 22 years old (Marguerite was about 19 years old).

Notes on Welby J. Metcalf:

Welby and his family were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Spokane, Spokane County, Washington, as follows:¹

W. J. Metcalf, head of household, male, white, 38, married once for 16 years, born Ohio, father born United States, mother born United States, speaks English, grocery merchant, working on own account, reads, writes, owns mortgaged home.
Leah Metcalf, wife, female, 34, married once for 16 years, three children, three living, born Illinois, father born Ohio, mother born Iowa, speaks English, reads, writes.
Helen Metcalf, daughter, female, white 14, single, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother born Illinois, speaks English, reads, writes, attended school within the year.
Harold J. Metcalf, son, male, white, 11, single, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother born Illinois, speaks English, reads, writes, attended school within the year.
Edgar Metcalf, son, male, white, 5, single, born Washington, father born Ohio, mother born Illinois, speaks English.

Welby and his family were enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Long Beach, Los Angeles County, California, as follows:²

Welby J. Metcalf, head of household, rents home, male, white, 43, married, reads, writes, born Iowa [sic], father born Iowa [sic], mother born Iowa, speaks English, landlord of apt. house, works on own account.
Leah Metcalf, wife, female, white, 43, married, reads, writes, born Iowa, father born Iowa [sic], mother born Iowa, speaks English.
Harold Metcalf, son, male, white, 22, single, reads, writes, born Iowa, father born Iowa, mother born Iowa, speaks English, mechanic in shop, works for wages.
Edgar Metcalf, son, male, white, 14. single, attended school within the year, reads, writes, born Washington, father born Iowa, mother born Iowa, speaks English.

Welby and his family were enumerated in the 1930 federal census of Los Angeles, Los Angeles County, California, as follows:³

Welby J. Metcalf, head of household, owns home valued at $3500, radio set, male, white, 58, married when 22 years old, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born England, speaks English, manager of grocery, works for wages.
Leah M. Metcalf, wife, female, white, 53, married when 17 years old, reads and writes, born Illinois, father born Maryland, mother born Illinois, speaks English.
Harold J. Metcalf, son, male, white, 32, married when 32 years old, born Iowa, father born Ohio, mother bor Illinois, speaks English, repair man for bicycle[s], works for wages.
Jessie Metcalf, daughter-in-law, female, white, 30, married when 30 years old, reads and writes, born England, father born England, mother born England, English spoken in home before coming to U.S., immigrated in 1926, alien, speaks English, hair dresser in beauty shop, works for wages.

Welby’s son Edgar and his wife were enumerated in the house behind Welby’s in the 1930 federal census of Los Angeles, Los Angeles County, California, as follows:⁴

Edgar G. Metcalf, head of household, rents for $20 per month, radio set, male, white, 25, married when 23 years old, reads and writes, born Washington, father born Ohio, mother born Illinois, speaks English, salesman of tamales, works for wages.
Marguerite Metcalf, wife, female, white, 21, married when 19 years old, born in Kansas, father born in United States, mother born in United States, speaks English.

_______________
¹ W. J. Metcalf household, 1910 U.S. census, Spokane County, Washington, population schedule, Spokane Ward 1, 2422 Third Avenue, enumeration district 157, supervisor’s district 3, sheet 5B, line 75, dwelling 80, family 99; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 1670.
² Welby J. Metcalf household, 1920 U.S. census, Los Angeles County, California, population schedule, Long Beach Ward 5, 25 South Magnolia Avenue, enumeration district 75, supervisor’s district 8, sheet 30B, line 60, dwelling 336, family 631; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 104.
³ Welby J. Metcalf household, 1930 U.S. census, Los Angeles County, California, population schedule, Los Angeles, 1036 Glen Arbor, enumeration district 19-659, supervisor’s district 15, sheet 18B, line 90, dwelling 424, family 427; National Archives micropublication T626, roll 161.
⁴ Edgar G. Metcalf household, 1930 U.S. census, Los Angeles County, California, population schedule, Los Angeles, rear of 1036 Glen Arbor, enumeration district 19-659, supervisor’s district 15, sheet 18B, line 94, dwelling 425, family 428; National Archives micropublication T626, roll 161.

Issue of Joseph W. Harbaugh and ⁹Martha E. Metcalf [43] (⁸George A. Metcalf [10], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1])

89. ¹⁰Dell F. Harbaugh, son of Joseph W. Harbaugh and ⁹Martha E. Metcalf [43]. Born on 4 Sep. 1858 in Ohio. Died before 1930, at most 71 years old.

Married first _____ _____.

Issue of Dell F. Harbaugh and _____ _____:
i. dau. ¹¹Maude E. Harbaugh b. in May 1882 in Ohio.
ii. son Chester Harbaugh b. in Feb. 1884 in Ohio.

Married second Clara M. _____ in 1888/9 when about 30 years old (Clara M. was about 29 years old). Clara M. _____ b. in Jan. 1859 in Ohio.

Issue of Dell F. Harbaugh and Clara M. _____:
113 iii. son ¹¹Joseph W. Harbaugh b. in June 1891 in Kansas.

Notes on Dell F. Harbaugh:

Dell and his family were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of St. Louis, Missouri, as follows:¹

Del Harbaugh, head of household, white, male, born Sep. 1858, 41, married 11 years, born Ohio, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Ohio, [?], reads, writes, speaks English, rents home.
Clara Harbaugh, wife, white, female, born Jan. 1859, married 11 years, three children, three living, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, reads, writes, speaks English.
Maude Harbaugh, daughter, white, female, born May 1882, 18, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, reads, writes, speaks English.
Chaster Harbaugh, son, white, male, born Feb. 1884, 16, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, reads, writes, speaks English.
Joseph Harbaugh, son, white, male, born Jun. 1891, 9, single, born Kansas, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, at school, attended school within the year, speaks English.

Dell and his family were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Grant Township, Richardson County, Nebraska, as follows:²

Dell F. Harbaugh, head of household, male, white, 52, married once for 21 years, born Ohio, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Ohio, speaks English, manager of ranch [?], works for wages, reads, writes, rents farm.
Clara M. Harbaugh, wife, female, white, 51, married twice, 21 years in present marriage, three children, three living, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, reads, writes.
Maud E. Harbaugh, daughter, female, white, 26, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, reads, writes.
Joseph W. Harbaugh, son, male, white, 19, single, born Kansas, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, farm land on ranch, works for wages, reads, writes.
Goldie Billings, house work, female, white, 19, single, born Nebraska, father born Nebraska, mother born Nebraska, speaks English, hired girl, housework, works for wages, reads, writes.

It appears that two of Dell and Clara’s children were by a previous marriage of Dell (assumed because of their surname Harbaugh and no notation of their being stepchildren of Dell) or of Clara (suggested by the notation of her marriage to Dell being her second).

Dell and his family were enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Kansas City, Jackson County, Missouri, as follows:³

Dell A. [sic], Harbaugh, head of household, rents, male, white, 60, married, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Connecticut, speaks English, proprietor of garage, works on own account.
Clara M. Harbaugh, wife, female, white, 60, married, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
Goldie Harbaugh, daughter-in-law, female, white, 30, widow, reads, writes, born Nebraska, father born Nebraska, mother born Nebraska, speaks English.
Joseph P. Harbaugh, grandson, male, white, 8, single, attended school within the year, born Nebraska, father born Kansas, mother born Nebraska, speaks English.
Robert W. Harbaugh, grandson, male, white, 4-6/12, born Nebraska, father born Kansas, mother born Nebraska, speaks English.
Del Forrest Harbaugh, grandson, male, white, 1-2/12, born Missouri, father born Kansas, mother born Nebraska, speaks English.

Clara (a widow) and her family were enumerated in the 1930 federal census of Kansas City, Jackson County, Missouri, as follows:⁴

Clara Harbaugh, head of household, owns home valued at $3000, female, white, 69, widow, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, moother born Ohio, speaks English.
Carrie Harbaugh, sister-in-law, female, white, 59, single, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Ohio, speaks English, saleslady in department store, works for wages.
Dell Forest Harbaugh, grandson, male, white, 11, single, attended school within the year, reads and writes, born Missouri, father born Kansas, mother born Nebraska, speaks English.

_______________
¹ Del Harbaugh household, 1900 U.S. census, St. Louis (Independent City), Missouri, population schedule, St. Louis Ward 24, enumeration district 357, supervisor’s district 11, sheet 22B (continued on the next sheet), line 100, dwelling 361, family 449; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 899.
² Dell F. Harbaugh household, 1910 U.S. census, Richardson County, Nebraska, population schedule, Grant Township, Grant Precinct, enumeration district 169, supervisor’s district 1, sheet 10B, line 94, dwelling 228, family 226; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 854.
³ Dell A. Harbaugh household, 1920 U.S. census, Jackson County, Missouri, population schedule, Kansas City Ward 7, 521 Wabash Avenue, enumeration district 113, supervisor’s district 5, sheet 6A, line 5, dwelling 100, family 141; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 927.
⁴ Clara Harbaugh household, 1930 U.S. census, Jackson County, Missouri, population schedule, Kansas City Ward 12, 3829 East 9[th Street], enumeration district 48-179, supervisor’s district 5, sheet 6A, line 37, dwelling 93, family 106; National Archives micropublication T626, roll 1200.

Notes on Clara M. _____:

Her surname may have been Sipe.

Issue of John Q. Holmes and ⁹Harriet Augusta Metcalf [44] (⁸George A. Metcalf [10], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1])

90. ¹⁰Clara Augusta Holmes, dau. of John Q. Holmes and ⁹Harriet Augusta Metcalf [44]. Born on 24 Jan. 1861 in Ohio. Died on 6 Dec. 1945 in Seneca County, 84 years old.

Married Marion Featheringill, son of George Washington Featheringill (son of Elias Featheringill and Hannah Bogart) and Elvira Fruchey (dau. of John Calvin Fruchey and Rachel Brakebill), on 20 Feb. 1879 in Putnam County when 18 years old (Marion was 25 years old). Marion Featheringill b. on 25 Dec. 1853 in Ohio; d. on 25 May 1946 in Huron County, 92 years old.

Issue of Clara Augusta Holmes and Marion Featheringill:
      i. son ¹¹David F. Featheringill b. in Feb. 1880 in Ohio; d. in 1960, 79 or 80 years old.
      ii. son Harley J. Featheringill b. in Sep. 1881 in Ohio; d. in 1954, 72 or 73 years old.
      iii. son Albert M. Featheringill b. in Aug. 1883 in Ohio; d. in 1945, 61 or 62 years old.
      iv. son Lee H. Featheringill b. in Feb. 1886 in Ohio.
      v. dau. Aimee B. Featheringill b. in March 1888 in Ohio.
      vi. dau. Ora P. Featheringill b. in March 1892 in Ohio.
      vii. child _____ Featheringill b. say in 1894/5 in Ohio; d. young.
      viii. son John E. Featheringill b. in Aug. 1897 in Ohio.
      ix. child _____ Featheringill b. say in 1900 in Ohio; d. young.
      x. dau. Veneta Clarice Featheringill b. in 1902/3 in Ohio; d. in 1932, 29 years old.

Notes on Clara Augusta Holmes:

Clara and her family were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Pleasant Township, Putnam County, Ohio, as follows:¹

Marion Featheringill, white, male, 26, married, farmer, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
Clara Featheringill, white, female, 19, wife, married, keeping house, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.
David F. Featheringill, white, malle, 4/12, born Feb., son, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.

Clara and her family were enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Pleasant Township, Putnam County, Ohio, as follows:²

Marion Featheringill, head of household, white, male, born Dec. 1863, 46, married 21 years, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, farmer, reads, writes, speaks English, owns mortgaged farm.
Clara Featheringill, wife, white, female, born Jan. 1861, 39, married 21 years, eight children, seven living, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, reads, writes, speaks English.
David F. Featheringill, son, white, male, born Feb. 1880, 20, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, farm laborer, reads, writes, speaks English.
Harley J. Featheringill, son, white, male, born Sep. 1881, 18, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, farm laborer, reads, writes, speaks English.
Albert M. Featheringill, son, white, male, born Aug. 1883, 16, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, farm laborer, attended school within the year, reads, writes, speaks English.
Lee H. Featheringill, son, white, male, born Feb. 1886, 14, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, farm laborer, attended school within the year, reads, writes, speaks English.
Aimie B. Featheringill, daughter, white, female, born Mar. 1888, 12, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, attended school within the year, reads, writes, speaks English.
Ora P. Featheringill, daughter, white, female, born Mar. 1892, 8, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, attended school within the year.
John A. Featheringill, son, white, male, born Aug. 1897, 2, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.

Clara and her family were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Pleasant Township, Putnam County, Ohio, as follows:³

Marion Featheringill, head of household, male, white, 56, married once for 31 years, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, farmer on general farm, reads, writes, owns farm free of mortgage.q
Clara A. Featheringill, wife, female, white, 49, married once for 31 years, ten children, eight living, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, reads, writes.
Ora P. Featheringill, daughter, female, white, 18, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, reads, writes.
John E. Featheringill, son, male, white, 12, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, reads, writes, attended school within the year.
George W. Featheringill, father, male, white, 79, widower, born Ohio, father born Virginia, mother born Pennsylvania, speaks English, own income, reads, writes.

Clara and her family were enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Pleasant Township, Putnam County, Ohio, as follows:⁴

Marion Featheringill, head of household, owns farm free of mortgage, male, white, 66, married, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, farmer on general farm, works on own account.
Clara A. Featheringill, wife, female, white, 58, married, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
John E. Featheringill, son, male, white, 22, single, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, farm laborer on home farm, works for wages.
Clarice V. Featheringill, daughter, female, white, 17, single, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
N[?]lin G. Featheringill, grandaughter, male [sic], white, 1-2/12, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.

_______________
¹ Marion Featheringill household, 1880 U.S. census, Putname County, Ohio, population schedule, Pleasant Township, enumeration district 141, supervisor’s district 1, page 33, sheet 468A, line 26, dwelling 360, family 373; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 1061.
² Marion Featheringill household, 1900 U.S. census, Putnam County, Ohio, population schedule, Pleasant Township, enumeration district 71, supervisor’s district 4, sheet 13A, line 4, dwelling 236, family 237; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 1316.
³ Marion Featheringill household, 1910 U.S. census, Putnam County, Ohio, population schedule, Pleasant Township, enumeration district 81, supervisor’s district 4, sheet 3B, line 52, dwelling 53, family 53; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 1226.
⁴ Marion Featheringill household, 1920 U.S. census, Putname County, Ohio, population schedule, Pleasant Township, Carl Road, enumeration district 111, supervisor’s district 4, sheet 1B, line 70, dwelling 15, family 15; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 1429.

Notes on Marion Featheringill:

Marion (with the surname Fisheringill) was enumerated in the 1860 federal census of Pleasant Township, Putnam County, Ohio, in his father’s household as follows:¹

Geo. Fisheringill, 30, male, farm s[?], 30, male, 30, personal property $298, born Ohio.
Eleois Fisheringill, 27, female, born Ohio.
Marion Fisheringill, 6, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Thos. J. Fisheringill, 4, male, born Ohio.
Fred L. Fisheringill, 2, male, born Ohio.
Unnamed Fisheringill, 1/12, male, born Ohio.

Eleois’ name is given as Elvira Fruchy in the 1850 federal census of Pleasant Township, Putnam County, Ohio.

_______________
¹ Geo. Fisheringill household, 1860 U.S. census, Putnam County, Ohio, population schedule, Pleasant Township, page 87, sheet 435, line 9, dwelling 612, family 612; National Archives micropublication M653, roll 1027.

91. ¹⁰Gilbert Edgar Holmes, son of John Q. Holmes and ⁹Harriet Augusta Metcalf [44]. Born in July 1865 in Ohio.

Married Ella M. Leidy, dau. of Michael Leidy and Mary _____, in 1889/90 when about 24 years old (Ella M. was about 20 years old). Ella M. Leidy b. in July 1869 in Ohio.

Issue of Gilbert Edgar Holmes and Ella M. Leidy:
i. son ¹¹Lester E. Holmes b. in Oct. 1895 in Ohio.

Notes on Gilbert Edgar Holmes:

Gilbert and his family were enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Jackson Township, Putnam County, Ohio, in the household of his father-in-law as follows:¹

Michael Leidy, head of household, white, male, bron Mar. 1820, 80, married 32 years, born Pennsylvania, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Pennsylvania, reads, writes, speaks English, owns mortgaged home.
Mary Leidy, wife, white, female, born Oct. 1843, 56, married 32 years, nine children, six living, born Ohio, father born Virginia, mother born Pennsylvania, reads, speaks English.
Gilbert E. Holmes, son-in-law, white, male, born July 1865, 34, married 11 years, born Ohio. father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, farmer, reads, writes, speaks English, owns mortgaged farm.
Ella M. Holmes, daughter, white, female, born July 1869, 30, marrried 11 years, one child, one living, born Ohio, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Ohio, reads, writes, speaks English.
Lester E. Holmes, grandson, white, male, born Oct. 1895, 4, single, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio.

Gilbert and his family were enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Pleasant Township, Hancock County, Ohio as follows:²

Edgar G. Holmes, head of household, male, white, 44, married once for 21 years, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, farmer on general farm, works on own account, reads, writes, owns farm free of mortgage.
Lyda [sic] E. Holmes, wife, female, white, 40. married once for 21 years, one child, one living, born Ohio, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Pennsylvania [sic], speaks English, reads, writes.
Lester E. Holmes, son, male, white, 13, singlle, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, reads, writes, attended school within the year.

Gilbert and his wife were enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Allen, Hancock County, Ohio, as follows:³

Gilbert E. Holmes, head of household, owns home free of mortgage, male, white, 54, married, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, farmer in general farming, works on own account.
Ella Holmes, wife, female, white, 50, married, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Ohio, speaks English.

Gilbert, his wife and a granddaughter were enumerated in the 1930 federal census of Allen, Hancock County, Ohio, as follows:⁴

Gilbert E. Holmes, head of household, owns home valued at $1500, male, white, 64, married when 24 years old, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, house carpenter, works for wages.
Ella Holmes, wife, female, white, 60, married when 20 years old, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
Hilda M. Holmes, granddaughter, female, white, 10, single, reads and writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Massachusetts, speaks English.

_______________
¹ Michael Leidy household, 1900 U.S. census, Putnam County, Ohio, population schedule, Jackson Township, enumeration district 61, supervisor’s district 4, sheet 11B, line 80, dwelling 209, family 212; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 1315.
² Edgar G. Holmes household, 1910 U.S. census, Hancock County, Ohio, population schedule, Pleasant Township, enumeration district 82, supervisor’s district 7, sheet 11A, line 28, dwelling 306, family 313; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 1186.
³ Gilbert E. Holmes household, 1920 U.S. census, Hancock County, Ohio, population schedule, Allen Township, farm on Stough Road, enumeration district 42, supervisor’s district 7, sheet 2A, line 32, dwelling 39, family 40; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 1385.
⁴ Gilbert E. Holmes household, 1930 U.S. census, Hancock County, Ohio, population schedule, Allen Township, Stough Road, enumeration district 32-2, supervisor’s district 12, sheet 7B, line 96, dwelling 169, family 172; National Archives micropublication T626, roll 1820.

Notes on Ella M. Leidy:

Ella was enumerated in the 1870 federal census of Jackson Township, Putnam County, Ohio, in her father’s household as follows:¹

Michael Leidy, 49, male, white, farmer, real property $6000, personal property $1419, born Pennsylvania.
Mary Leidy, 31, female, white, keeping house, born Ohio.
William Leidy, 18, male, white, farm laborer, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
John Leidy, 15, male, white, farm laborer, born Ohio, attended school within the year.
Elmina Leidy, 7 [sic, 1], female, white, born Ohio.
Lucinda Faber, 14, female, white, born Illinois, attended school within the year.
David Faber, 9, male, white, born Illinois, attended school within the year.
Joseph Faber, 7, male, white, born Ohio, attended school within the year.

Mary was Michael’s second wife with whom he had Ella M. (Elmina in 1870, Allamina in 1880 ten years old), Malinda A., Ida Jane and Benjamin F. With his first wife Matilda (born 1823/4 Pennsylvania) he had at least Mary, William and John A.

_______________
¹ Michael Leidy household, 1870 U.S. census, Putnam County, Ohio, population schedule, Jackson Township, Kalida Post Office, page 3, sheet 319, line 23, dwelling 18, family 17; National Archives micropublication M593, roll 1260.

92. ¹⁰Frank C. Holmes, son of John Q. Holmes and ⁹Harriet Augusta Metcalf [44]. Born in 1867/8 in Ohio.

Married Malinda A. _____. Malinda A. _____ b. in 1871/2 in Ohio.

Issue of Frank C. Holmes and Malinda A. _____:
      i. dau. ¹¹Emma Holmes b. in 1889/90 in Ohio.
      ii. dau. Mary A. Holmes b. in 1891/2 in Ohio.
      iii. son John B. Holmes b. in 1895/6 in Ohio.
      iv. son Floyd M. Holmes b. in 1897/8 in Ohio.
      v. dau. Doris Holmes b. in 1902/3 in Ohio.
      vi. dau. Sly Holmes b. in 1906/7 in Ohio.
      vii. son Edgar Holmes b. in 1913/4 in Michigan.

Notes on Frank C. Holmes:

Frank and his family were enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Whiteford Township, Monroe County, Michigan, as follows:¹

Frank C. Holmes, head of household, rents, male, white, 52, married, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, farmer on general farm, works on own account.
Malinda A. Holmes, wife, female, white, 48, married, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Pennsylvania, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
Emma Holmes, daughter, female, white, 30, single, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, inspector in auto factory, works for wages.
Mary A. Holmes, daughter, female, white, 28, single, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, inspector in auto factory, works for wages.
John B. Holmes, son, male, white, 24, son, single, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, machnist in auto factory, works for wages.
Floyde M. Holmes, son, male, white, 22, single, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English, inspector in auto factory, works for wages.
Dahris Holmes, daughter, female, white, 17, single, attended school within the year, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
Sly Holmes, daughter, female, white, 13, single, attended school within the year, reads, writes, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English.
Edgar Holmes, son, male, white, 6, single, born Michigan, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, speaks English.

_______________
¹ Frank C. Holmes household, 1920 U.S. census, Monroe County, Michigan, population schedule, Whiteford Township, farm, enumeration district 128, supervisor’s district 2, sheet 7B, line 64, dwelling 138, family 138; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 786.

Issue of ⁹Lt. James Bard Metcalfe CSA [47] (⁸Oren Metcalfe [11], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and Mary Louise Boarman

93. ¹⁰Thomas Oren Metcalfe, son of ⁹Lt. James Bard Metcalfe CSA [47] and Mary Louise Boarman. Born on 3 Nov. 1880 in San Francisco, San Francisco County, California. Died on 4 Oct. 1955, 74 years old.

Married Helen Francis Smith, dau. of William Smith and Mary C. _____, in 1917/8 when about 37 years old (Helen Francis was about 27 years old). Helen Francis Smith b. in 1890 in Bolivar, Polk County, Missouri.

Issue of Thomas Oren Metcalfe and Helen Francis Smith:
114 i. son ¹¹Thomas Oren Metcalfe b. on 23 Dec. 1922 in Beaumont, Jefferson County, Texas.

Notes on Thomas Oren Metcalfe:

Some of the information is from Margaret (Metcalfe) Hassin.

Notes on Helen Francis Smith:

The information is from Margaret (Metcalfe) Hassin.

On 10/10/2002 3:51 PM, Margaret Hassin at dhassin@dixie-net.com wrote:

did i tell you what i found out about my gm? i have deleted some of my old emails, so if i have, just ignore me.
gm was born Faney B. Smith in 1890. She appears on a 1900 census as that. Mother had a document from Dept of Commerce stating that. It is dated 1/20/1955--her husband died in oct of that year, so i am betting she had to prove who she was maybe for insurance purposes. sometime after she left home,she decided to change her name to helen francis or francis helen, depending on which document you look at. i am hoping if i ever get her marriage cert it has her real name on it. i am pretty sure she did not change it legally.
i have had 2 people look up in the new orleans and some texas lists and found no marr cert for them.
do you have any suggestions?
margaret

On 9/18/2003 3:51 PM, Margaret Hassin at dhassin@dixie-net.com wrote:

Also, I didn’t know if you wanted to add to your data that my grandmother changed her name to Helen Francis Smith. I have a document from the federal govt. (not sure what branch b/c it is at home) stating that she was in the 1900 census as daughter of William and Mary C. Smith in Jefferson City, MO. The document is dated in 1955, so I am sure she got it to prove that she was the wife of Pop who died in Oct. 1955.

Margaret

Issue of ⁹William Lyons Metcalfe [48] (⁸Oren Metcalfe [11], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and Mary H. Roche

94. ¹⁰Bernice Roche Metcalfe, dau. of ⁹William Lyons Metcalfe [48] and Mary H. Roche. Born on 19 Feb. 1882 in Ravenna Manor House, Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi. Baptized on 8 April 1882 in Trinity Church, Natchez when a month old. Died on 27 Jan. 1952 in Los Angeles, Los Angeles County, California, 69 years old. Buried in Holy Cross Cemetery, Los Angeles.

Married Richard Maria Wilhelm Oberwinder, son of Prof. Heinrich Conrad Ludwig Wilhelm Emil Oberwinder (son of Johannes Oberwinder and Karoline Elisabetha Christiane Henriette Bender) and Juditha Catharina Maria Treÿer (dau. of Johannes Treÿer and Franziska Albrecht), on 8 Oct. 1903 in Dresden, Sachsen, Germany when 21 years old (Richard Maria Wilhelm was 29 years old). Divorced. Richard Maria Wilhelm Oberwinder b. on 9 Aug. 1874 in Vienna, Vienna, Austria; d. on 29 July 1953 in Chicago, Cook County, Illinois, 78 years old; bur. in Beverly Cemetery, Blue Island, Cook County, Illinois.

Issue of Bernice Roche Metcalfe and Richard Maria Wilhelm Oberwinder:
115   i. son ¹¹John Charles Metcalfe b. on 2 Aug. 1904 in Berlin, Germany.
      ii. dau. Elizabeth Metcalfe b. on 11 Sep. 1905 in Berlin; d. on 25 Feb. 1998 in Notre Dame, St. Joseph County, Indiana, 92 years old; bur. in St. Mary’s Convent, Notre Dame.
116   iii. son James Joseph Metcalfe b. on 16 Sep. 1906 in Berlin.
      iv. son Andrew John Metcalfe b. on 20 April 1912 in Berlin; d. in 1988 in Los Angeles, 75 or 76 years old; m. Virginia Smith (–1988 in Los Angeles).

Notes on Bernice Roche Metcalfe:

Bernice (sometimes spelled Berenice) was born Hibernia Trabue Metcalfe at Ravenna manor house in Natchez at 7 pm on 19 February 1882.¹ She was baptized at Trinity (Episcopal) Church in Natchez on Easter evening, 8 April 1882, by Reverend Alexander Marks and sponsored by Dr. John C. Inge (first cousin of William’s mother, family doctor and father of Ellen Hibernia Inge next), Ellen Hibernia (Inge) Trabue (Bernice’s namesake and William’s second cousin who married Robert H. Trabue) and Mary R. Shields. Within eight months Bernice apparently was living in Washington, D.C.² By September 1885 she and her mother were in New York City where her brother Jack was born.

After her parents divorced, Bernice spent her childhood in Los Angeles, California, with her step grandmother, Eliza Lee Mitchell, second wife of Bernice’s maternal grandfather, James Richard Roche. Eliza lived at 231 West 31st Street (now commercial buildings) in Los Angeles in January 1896 after James’ death, and Bernice lived there with her.

Bernice was well-trained as a pianist, studying under the renowned Teresa Carañeo. Eliza Lee made sure that concert pianists visiting Los Angeles also came to her home to give additional instruction to Bernice. In 1900, Bernice left home and toured Europe giving concerts. It was on tour in Germany that she met Richard Maria Wilhelm Oberwinder, a German journalist. Their first encounter was at a hospice in Bonn on 6 August 1902.³

Bernice and Richard were married in Dresden on 8 October 1903 and had four children, all born in Germany.

On 19 February 1914, Bernice left Richard and returned to the U.S. with the three older children,⁴ arriving that month in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, from Bremen, Germany, aboard the Brandenburg. They continued aboard the Brandenburg to Galveston, Texas, arriving 15 March 1914,⁵ where Bernice joined her mother, Mamie Roche, and her stepfather, Lemuel J. Barber. This was the first time Bernice had seen her mother since childhood, and the children loved their grandmother, described as a joyful and fun person (and rather short, blond and heavyset). Being citizens of the U.S. by derivation, the children all took their mother’s surname, Metcalfe, and the various given names given for them.

Bernice and the children were then brought to Los Angeles by William M. Roche, their great-uncle, to live for six months with Eliza Lee Mitchell, their step-great-grandmother, at 2727 Halldale Street, now a neighborhood park.

In September 1914 they moved back to the Texas ranch of Bernice’s mother and stepfather, about five miles outside of Raymondsville, near the school which the children attended.

In 1916, Bernice’s brother Jack Barber (John Rousseau Metcalfe) and his wife May visited Bernice and the children in Texas and took the children north to school and college in Notre Dame, Indiana, for which Jack paid. Bernice moved to Chicago later. Son Andrew joined them in July 1922, having been brought over from Germany by a family friend, Herr Manning.

In 1919 Bernice divorced Richard, in spite of being a devout Catholic. Richard didn’t know about the divorce until he emigrated to the U.S. in December 1922. They never reunited and rarely saw each other again, although Richard regularly saw the children and grandchildren.

Bernice was enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Washington, D.C., as a teacher at Holy Cross Academy as follows:⁶

Berenice Oberwinder, employee, female, white, 37, single, reads, write, born Mississippi, father born U.S., mother born Washington, D.C., speaks English, teacher, academy, works for wages.

About 1940, Bernice joined her son John and his family in Washington, D.C. In 1950, in ill health, she moved to Los Angeles where her daughter Elizabeth oversaw her care. She died on 27 January 1952 and was buried in Holy Cross Cemetery in Los Angeles.⁷

Richard died the next year in Chicago and was buried in Beverly Cemetery in Blue Island, Illinois, on the South Side of Chicago.

_______________
¹ The information on Bernice is provided from the personal knowledge of the author, his aunt Elizabeth Metcalfe (Bernice’ daughter) and from Bernice’s death certificate. Bernice’s birth and baptism appear in a handwritten note pasted in her scrapbook in the possession of the author, and in the subsequently acquired copy of her baptism from Trinity Church listing William L. and Mary R. Metcalfe as her parents.
² Pictures of Bernice dated 19 October 1882 and labeled “8 months today” were taken by G. W. Davis of Washington, D.C., and of Richmond, Virginia.
³ Photograph of Hospice noting date and place of first meeting.
⁴ Bernice left Andrew, age twenty months at the time, in Germany. (Bernice said that the German government in those days required that one male child stay in Germany.)
⁵ Galveston Passenger Lists, 1896–1948. S. S. Brandenburg. Bernice Oberwinder. Married to an alien. Arrival Date: 15 March 1914. Age 32 years. Female. Housewife. Reads and writes. Nationality: Germany. Race or People: Germany. Last Residence: Berlin, Germany. Port of Departure: Bremen, Germany. Date of Departure: 19 February 1914. Port of Arrival: Galveston, Texas. Friend’s Name: Eliza Lee Roche. Last Residence: Germany. Birth Place: Natchez, United States of America. Accompaniesd by son Hellmut, Age 9-1/2, daughter Elizabeth, Age 8-1/2, and son James, Age 7-1/2. Microfilm Roll Number 16. Page 75.
⁶ Academy of the Holy Cross household, 1920 U.S. census, District of Columbia, population schedule, Washington, 2935 Upton Street, enumeration district 167, supervisor’s district 40, page 274, sheet 13A, line 43; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 210.
⁷ See headstone on grave 5, lot 393, section G. Office records note that the immediate cause of her death was pneumonia at age 69.

Images for Bernice Roche Metcalfe:

Bernice Roche Metcalfe (born Hibernia Trabue Metcalfe) at the time of her marriage to Richard Oberwinder, 1903, in Germany.

Notes on Richard Maria Wilhelm Oberwinder:

Richard became a journalist and diplomat:¹

. . . Richard Oberwinder, besides being a newspaperman, also served in the diplomatic corps of Kaiser Wilhelm II. Drafted into the German Army in 1917, he was disabled the next year and was eventually sent to Berne, Switzerland, where he was assigned to special research in the national library. But, brought up on his father’s “Weltkrise,” he sent his wife and children to the United States in February, 1914—five months before World War I burst on an astonished world. Yet this far-sighted decision was not too strange, since his wife was American, born Bernice Metcalfe in Natchez, Mississippi . . . who . . . had not renounced her American citizenship on marrying a German.
. . . When Germany was crushed in November 1918, Richard Oberwinder was still in Switzerland, where he saw much of an old friend, Matthias Erzberger. Negotiations were then under way for Erzberger to return to Berlin as Chancellor of the Reich. Richard Oberwinder tried earnestly to disuade his friend from going back, for he foresaw only a violent death awaiting the Socialist Erzberger.
“Germany needs me,” Erzberger replied, “I must go back, and so are you going back. You will be my ambassador to France.”
Richard Oberwinder would not go back to Germany. Matthias Erzberger went back, and was shot on the streets of Berlin on January 26, 1921.

Richard married Bernice Roche Metcalfe in Dresden while she was on tour. In 1919, after her return to the U.S. (in February 1914), Bernice divorced Richard. Richard didn’t know about the divorce until he emigrated to the U.S. in 1922.² They were never reunited.

Richard was enumerated in the 1930 federal census of Washington, D.C., as follows:³

Richard Oberwinder, boarder, male, white, 55, single, reads and writes, born Vienna - Austria, father born Germany, mother born Vienna - Austria, spoke German in home before immigration, immigrated 1923, alien, speaks English, lecturer and teacher at Catholic University, at work.

_______________
¹ Unpublished manuscript by John C. Metcalfe.
² http://www.ellisislandrecords.org/ read on 24 April 2001: Richard Oberwinder, male, married, age 49 years, German, residence Paris, France, arrived 27 December 1922 at Ellis Island aboard the La Savoie which departed Le Havre, Seine-Inferior, France.
³ Patrick [?] household, 1930 U.S. census, District of Columbia, population schedule, Washington Precinct 9, Block 4069, enumeration district 232, supervisor’s district 1, sheet [?], line 73 (Richard is entered on line 80), dwelling 321, family 388; National Archives micropublication T626, roll 298.

Images for Richard Maria Wilhelm Oberwinder:

Richard Maria Wilhelm Oberwinder at the time of his marriage, 1903, in Germany.

The ship “La Savoie” on which Richard Oberwinder immigrated to the United States from Le Havre, France, arriving on 27 December 1922 at Ellis Island.

95. ¹⁰John Rousseau Metcalfe, son of ⁹William Lyons Metcalfe [48] and Mary H. Roche. Born on 11 Sep. 1884 in Manhattan, New York County, New York. Baptized on 17 Jan. 1886 in Epiphany Church, Washington, District of Columbia when a year old. Died on 5 June 1946, 61 years old. Buried in Park Cemetery, Bridgeport, Fairfield County, Connecticut.

Married first Mae Louise Hamilton, dau. of Charles Wesley Hamilton (son of Isaac Hamilton and Lucy Ann Cline) and Mary Francis Murphy (dau. of John C. Murphy and Maria T. _____), on 1 June 1914 when 29 years old (Mae Louise was 38 years old). Divorced. Mae Louise Hamilton b. on 3 May 1876 in Omaha, Douglas County, Nebraska; d. in June 1968, 92 years old.

Married second Florence Lawlor, dau. of James S. Lawlor and Ellen A. Ward (dau. of Dennis Ward and Bridget _____), on 22 Aug. 1929 in London, England when 44 years old (Florence was 35 years old). Florence Lawlor b. on 2 July 1894 in Manhattan; d. on 29 Sep. 1970 in Manhattan, 76 years old; bur. in Park Cemetery; unm. partner of James Alexander Stillman (18 Aug. 1873 in Manhattan–12 Jan. 1944 in Manhattan), son of James Jewett Stillman (son of Charles Stillman and Elizabeth Pamela Goodrich) and Sarah E. Rumill (dau. of Alexander Rumill and Mary Alvord); issue (surname Metcalfe): Capt. John Ward (17 Sep. 1918 in Manhattan–6 Sep. 1994 in Manhattan).

Issue of John Rousseau Metcalfe and Florence Lawlor:
117 i. son ¹¹Jesse Carmichael Metcalfe b. on 4 Nov. 1932 in Manhattan.

Notes on John Rousseau Metcalfe:

John (Jack) Rousseau Metcalfe¹ was born on 11 September 1884 at 305 West 22nd Street in New York City. He was baptized on 17 January 1886 by Dr. Geisy of Epiphany Church in Washington, D.C., sponsored by Mrs. N. C. Baden, C. C. Baden and J. J. Veazur.

Jack was named Rousseau after his maternal grand uncle, Captain William Rousseau Cox Lyons, CSA, and the Captain’s uncle, William Rousseau Cox. For awhile, Jack took the surname Barber after the family of his stepfather, Lemuel J. Barber.

Jack (here Rousseau Barber) was enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Washington, D.C., in the household of his stepfather as follows:²

Jack grew up on his stepfather’s ranch in Texas and later served in the Third U.S. Infantry in the Philippines.³

Jack married first Mae Louise Hamilton (3 May 1876 Omaha, Nebraska–June 1968 buried in Washington, D.C.) on 1 June 1914. They were said to be living in or near Phoenix, Arizona, in the early 1920s, when he was supporting the education of his niece and nephews at Notre Dame, Indiana. A portrait of Stella (Hamilton) Stapleton (6 July 1872 Omaha, Nebraska–11 December 1965 buried at St. Mary’s Convent at Notre Dame), May Hamilton’s sister, hangs in St. Mary’s College at Notre Dame. (Both Mae and Stella attended St. Mary’s college.) Jack and Mae had no children and were divorced about 1928 . Mae was last known residing in Bethesda, Maryland, in the late 1960s.

Jack’s passport application No. 235166⁴ dated 4 December 1922 records:

Passport issued 5 December 1922.
John Rousseau Metcalfe Barber, accompanied by wife Mae Louise (married 1 June 1914).
Born 11 September 1884 in New York city.
Father Jas. R. Metcalfe Barber [sic, William L. Metcalfe] born Natchez, Mississippi, deceased.
Resided in Philippine Islands from 1910 to 1914.
Residing at Santa Barbara, California.
Occupation stock raising.
Last passport obtained from Gov. Genl. of Philipinne Islands Nov. 1914.
Intend to return within 2 years.
Intend to use passport for travel in British Isles, France, Italy, Spain, Norway, Denmark, Sweden, Germany, Austria, Switzerland, Belgium, Japan, India.
Intend to leave from port of New York on board the Majestic on 16 December 1922.
38 years old.
5 feet 10 inches.
Hign forehead.
Blue eyes.
Medium nose.
Medium mouth.
Oval chin.
Light hair.
Fair complexion.
Oval face.
Sworn to by George E. Hamilton, Lawyer, Union Trust Building, Washington, D.C.

Jack’s passport application No. 379586⁵ dated 19 February 1924 records:

Passport issued 15 March 1924.
J. Rousseau Metcalfe Barber, accompanied by wife Mae Louise. Uses stepfather’s name of Barber (his name was L. J. Barber).
Born 11 September 1884 in New York city.
Father was William James [sic, Lyons] Metcalfe born Natchez, Mississippi, deceased.
Bearer of passport issued about 6 December 1922.
Residing in Santa Barbara, California.
Temporary residence at c/o National City Bank of New York city.
Occupation stock raising.
Last left U.S. 16 December 1922, arriving France 23 December 1922, for purpose of studying French.v
Intend to return within 2 years.
Intend to use passport for temporary residence in France and travel in British Isles, Italy, Spain, Belgium, Holland, Switzerland, Greece, Egypt, Suez, Aden, Singapore, Straits Settlements, China, Japan, India.
39 years old.
5 feet 10-1/2 inches.
High forehead.
Blue eyes.
Regular nose.
Mustached mouth.
Regular chin.
Blonde hair.
Ruddy complexion.
Round face.
Sworn to by Col. Hercule Barre, native of Canada, 17, 19 Bd. des Capucines, Paris.

Attached is an affidavit:

John Rousseau Metcalfe Barber, being duly sworn, deposes and says:
I am a native born American citizen and was the bearer of a Departmental passport issued about December 6, 1-22, to me for travel in all countries.
I have lost that passport as follows:
In November, 1923, I desired to join the Inter-Allied Club at 33 Rue du Faubourg St. Honore, Paris, France, and I was asked to present my passport for my admission. I was proposed as a member of this club by The Honorable Myron T. Herrick, American Ambassador. My passport, while being held at the club was misplaced by the Secretary and they have not been able to located it since.
I need a new passport for continued temporary residence in Europe with my wife, Mae Louise.
/s/ John R. M. Barber
John Rousseau Metcalfe Barber,
National City Bank of New York, at 41
Boulevard Haussmann, Paris.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this 19th day of February, 1924.
/s/ Marc L. Severe
Marc L. Severe,
American Vice-Consul

Jack and Mae were recorded on the passenger list of the S.S. Santa Cecelia sailing from Guayaquil, Ecuador, on 14 August 1927 arriving at the Port of New York on 1 September 1927 as follows:⁶

Barber, John R. M. 43 years old; male; married; born Sep. 11th, 1884 in New York, N.Y.; address in U.S. Omaha National Bank, Omaha Neb.;
Barber, Mae Hamilton; 46 [sic, 51] years old; female; married; born May 3rd, 1881 [sic 1876] in Omaha, Neb.; address in U.S. Omaha National Bank, Omaha Neb.

Jack and Mae were divorced about 1928.

Jack married second Florence Lawlor (2 July 1894 Manhattan, New York–29 September 1970 Manhattan, New York) on 22 August 1929 in London, England. The New York Times on Tuesday,10 Septmember 1929, published an article on the marriage, headed “Florence Leeds Weds.” (Florence used the stage name of Florence Leeds when she was a dancer in the Ziegfield Follies.) The article stated that Florence, a former New York chorus girl, was the daughter of James S. Lawlor of 1205 Sixth Avenue, owner of a plumbing shop, that she married John Rousseau Metcalfe on 22 August at a London register’s office, and that John was President of the Compania Nacional de Esmeraldes which was developing a large tract of timber land in Ecuador.

Jack was recorded on the passenger list of the S.S. Santa Teresa sailing from Valparaiso, Chile, on 26 May 1930 arriving at the Port of New York on 18 June 1930 as follows:⁷

Embarked at Guayaquil, Ecuador, June 3, 1930.
Metcalfe, John R.; 45 years old; male; married, born Sept. 11, 1884 in New York, N.Y.; address in U.S. 125 E. 63rd St., N.Y.C.

Jack and Florence were recorded on the passenger list of the S.S. Bremen sailing from Cherbourg, France, on 14 August 1931 arriving at the Port of New York on 19 August 1931 as follows:⁸

Metcalfe, Florence; 34 [sic, 37] years old; female; married; born July 2, 1897 [sic, 1894] in New York, N.Y.; address in U.S. 125 East 63 St., New York, N.Y.
Metcalfe, John; 46 years old; male; married; born Sep. 11, 1884 in New York, N.Y.; address in U.S. 125 East 63 St., New York, N.Y.

Jack, Florence and Florence’s natural son (John J. Ward) by James Stillman were recorded on the passenger list of the S.S. Columbus sailing from Southampton, England, on 13 August 1932 arriving at the Port of New York on 19 August 1932 as follows:⁹

Ward, John J.; 14 years old; male; single; born Sep. 17th, 1884 in New York, N.Y.; address in U.S. 146 E. 48th St., New York, N.Y.
Metcalfe, John R.; 48 years old; male; married; born Sep. 11th, 1884 in New York, N.Y.; address in U.S. 146 E. 48th St., New York, N.Y.
Metcalfe, Florence; 34 [sic, 36] year old; born Jul. 2nd 1896 [sic, 1894] in New York, N.Y.; address in U.S. 146 E. 48th St., New York, N.Y.

John J. Ward was adopted by Jack and took the name John Ward Metcalfe. According to the Social Security Death Index, he died on 6 September 1994 in New York City: Social Security Death Index for John W. Metcalfe, SSN 130-12-1370, last residence 10128 New York, New York, New York, USA, born 17 September 1918, died 6 September 1994, SSN issued New York before 1951. (10128 is a zip code within New York City, no doubt in Manhattan.)

Jack was recorded on the passenger list of the S.S. General von Steuben sailing from Boulogne Sur Mer, France, on 15 September 1933 arriving at the Port of New York on 24 September 1933 as follows:¹⁰

Metcalfe, John R.; 49 years old; male, married, born Sept. 11, 1884 in New York, N.Y.; address in U.S. Hotel White, 37 & Lexington Ave, New York, N.Y.

Jack was recorded on the passenger list of the S.S. Henri Jaspar sailing from Antwerp, Belgium, on 28 February 1938 arriving at the Port of New York on 12 March 1938 as follows:¹¹

Metcalfe, John Rousseau; 53 years old; male, married; born Sept. 11, 1884 in New York, N.Y.; address in U.S. 231 Beach 127th St., Belle Harbor, N.Y.

Interestingly, Florence’s widowed mother, Helen A. (Ward) Lawlor, was living in Belle Harbor in 1938.

Jack registered for the draft on 26 April 1942.¹² On his draft card (no. 2283624) he recorded:

Rousseau Metcalfe
Residing Mark Twain Inn, Route 53, Redding, Fairfield County, Connecticut.
Mailing address same.
Telephone Redding 100.
58 years old, born Sept. 11, 1884, in Manhattan, New York.
Person who will always know my address: Mrs. Bernice Metcalfe [John’s sister], 9003 Sudbury [Road], [subdivision named] Gaynel Forest, Silver Springs [sic, Silver Spring], Maryland.
Employed by the United States Aluminum Co., 2190 Post Road, Fairfield, Fairfield County, Connecticut.
Signed Rousseau Metcalfe.
White; 5 feet 10 1/2 inches high; 180 pounds; blue eyes; gray hair; ruddy complexion; American flag tattooed on right forearm.
Signed Victor D’Amato, registrar for local board 21A, Btp., Conn., April 26, 1942.
Stamped “Local Board No. 24B, 105 Greenwood Ave., Bethel, Conn.”

Jack died on 5 June 1946, probably in Manhattan, New York. Florence died on 29 September 1970 in Manhattan. They were both buried in Park Cemetery, Bridgeport, Fairfield County, Connecticut, Jack in section X-3-B lot 848 and Florence in section 8-A lot 284.

_______________
¹ Personal discussions with Elizabeth Metcalfe (Sister Mary Noël, C.S.C.), the author’s aunt, in 1989. Also John C. Metcalfe’s address books. His birth and baptism appear in a handwritten note pasted in his sister’s scrapbook in the possession of the author.
² Lemuel J. Barber household, 1900 U.S. census, District of Columbia, population schedule, Washington, Wheeler Road, enumeration district 10, supervisor’s district 1, sheet 44A, line 16, dwelling 892, family 926; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 158.
³ Dated photographs of Jack: Texas 1908 and Jefferson Barracks, Philippines, June 1918.
⁴ Passport Applications, January 2, 1906-March 31, 1925; (National Archives Microfilm Publication M1490); General Records of the Department of State, Record Group 59; National Archives, Washington, D.C.
⁵ Ibid.
⁶ Passenger and Crew Lists of Vessels Arriving at New York, New York, 1897-1957; (National Archives Microfilm Publication T715, roll 4118); sheet 44, line 7; Records of the Immigration and Naturalization Service; National Archives, Washington, D.C.
⁷ Ibid., roll 4760, sheet 3, line 9.
⁸ Ibid., roll 5018, sheet 29, line 10.
⁹ Ibid., roll 5207, sheet 44, line 8.
¹⁰ Ibid., roll 5394, sheet 190, line 18.
¹¹ Ibid., roll 6125, sheet 78, line 1.
¹² Selective Service Registration Cards, World War II: Fourth Registration. This was the “old man’s registration” for men who were between 45 and 64 years old.

Images for John Rousseau Metcalfe:

John Rousseau Metcalfe, passport photo, 4 December 1922.

Notes on Mae Louise Hamilton:

Mae was enumerated in the 1880 federal census of Omaha, Douglas County, Nebraska, in the household of her parents as follows:¹

Charles Hamilton, white, male, 49, husband, married, banking and [?], born New York.
Mary Hamilton, white, female, 39, wife, married, keeping house, born Virginia, father born Ireland, mother born Virginia.
Thomas Hamilton, 15, son, single, at school, born Nebraska, father born New York, mother born Virginia.
Stella Hamilton, white, female, 8, daughter, single, at school, whooping cough, born Nebraska, father born New York, mother born Virginia.
May Hamilton, white, female, 4, daughter, single, born Nebraska, father born New York, mother born Virginia.
Fred Hamilton, white, male, 1, son, single, born Nebraska, father born New York, mother born Virginia.
Emila Sands, white, female, 18, servant, single, born Nebraska, father born Germany, mother born Germany.
Anna Niobe, white, female, 19, servant, single, born Bohemia, father born Bohemia, mother born Bohemia.

Mae was enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Omaha, Douglas County, Nebraska, in the household of her parents as follows:²

Mary F. Hamilton, head of household, white, female, born Apr. 1839, 60, widow, seven children, five living, born Virginia, father born Virginia, mother born Virginia, reads, writes, speaks English, owns home free of mortgage.
Mae L. [or Mac C.?] Hamilton, son [sic], white, male [sic], born May 1877, 23, single, born Nebraska, father born New York, mother born Virginia, clerk, reads, writes, speaks English.
Stella M. Hamilton, daughter, white, female, born July 1872, 27, single, born Nebraska, father born New York, mother born Virginia, reads, writes, speaks English.

Mae was enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Omaha, Douglas County, Nebraska, in the household of her brother as follows:³

Fred Hamilton, head of household, male, white, 31, married once for two years, born Nebraska, father born New York, mother born Virginia, speaks English, banker in bank, employee, reads, writes, owns home free of mortgage.
Ethel Hamilton, wife, female, white 22, married once for two years, no children, born Nebraska, father born Kentucky, mother born Kentucky, speaks English, reads, writes.
Stella M. Hamilton, sister, female, white, 37, single, born Nebraska, father born New York, mother born New York, speaks English, reads, writes.
Mae L. Hamilton, sister, female, white, 33, single, born Nebraska, father born New York, mother born New York, speaks English, reads, writes.
Margaret Cuming, mother-in-law, 75, widow, one child, one living, born Virginia, father born Virginia, mother born Virginia, speaks English, reads, writes.

(The mother-in-law in the 1920 federal census was listed as Martha L. Robertson, 62, born Illinois.)

Mae was enumerated in the 1930 federal census of Manhattan, New York County, New York, as follows:⁴

Mae L. Hamilton, head of household, rents for $379, radio set, female, white, 53, divorced, reads and writes, born Nebraska, father born New York, mother born Virginia.
Lee Park, servant, male, Korean, 30, single, reads and writes, born Korea, father born Korea, mother born Korea, immigrated in 1917, alien, reads and writes, servant in private familly, works for wages.

Mae was recorded on the passenger list of the S.S. Leviathan sailing from Cherbourg, France, on 10 September 1931 arriving at the Port of New York on 20 September 1931 as follows:⁵

Hamilton, Mae L.; 50 [sic, 54] years old; female, divorced; born May 3, 1876 in Omaha, Nebraska; address in U.S. Omaha National Bank Bldg Omaha Nebr.

Mae was recorded on the passenger list of the S.S. Queen Mary sailing from Cherbourg, France, on 14 September 1938 arriving at the Port of New York on 19 September 1938 as follows:⁶

Hamilton, Mae L.; 62 years old; female; single [sic, divorced]; born 3 May 1876 in Omaha, Nebraska; address in U.S. 2101 Connecticut Avenue, Washington, D.C.

Mae is listed in the Social Security Death Index as born 3 May 1876, her social security number 545-70-6486 was issued in 1963 in California and she died in July 1968.

This matches her age in the 1880 census (age 4 -- she seems to have lied about her age almost everywhere else) and the passenger lists. It’s possible she died in California since the card was issued there about five years before she died. However, she was not found in the California Death Index, 1940-1997, and she was reportedly buried in Washington, D.C.

_______________
¹ Charles Hamilton household, 1880 U.S. census, Douglas County, Nebraska, population schedule, Omaha, 21st Street, enumeration district 13, supervisor’s district [?], page 16, sheet 117D, line 14, dwelling 116, family 131; National Archives micropublication T9, roll 747.
² Mary F. Hamilton household, 1900 U.S. census, Douglas County, Nebraska, population schedule, Omaha Ward 4, 2102 [St. Marys Avenue?], enumeration district [48?], supervisor’s district 2, sheet 9B, line 86, dwelling 130, family 156; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 924.
³ Fred Hamilton household, 1910 U.S. census, Douglas County, Nebraska, population schedule, Omaha Ward 4, 2204 St. Marys Avenue, enumeration district 27, supervisor’s district 2, sheet 9A, line 39, dwelling 92, family 104; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 743.
⁴ Mae L. Hamilton household, 1930 U.S. census, New York County, New York, population schedule, Manhattan, 277 Park Avenue, enumeration district 276, supervisor’s district 21, page 31-276, sheet 5A, line 47, dwelling 1, family 38; National Archives micropublication T626, roll 1889.
⁵ Passenger and Crew Lists of Vessels Arriving at New York, New York, 1897-1957; (National Archives Microfilm Publication T715, roll 5042); sheet 11, line 20; Records of the Immigration and Naturalization Service; National Archives, Washington, D.C.
⁶ Ibid., roll 6220, sheet 35, line 10.

Images for Mae Louise Hamilton:

Mae Louise Hamilton, passport photo, 4 December 1922.

Notes on Florence Lawlor:

Florence used the stage name of Florence Leeds when she was a dancer in the Ziegfield Follies. She also used “Mrs. Florence H. Leeds” to hide her affair with James Alexander Stillman, who himself used Franklin Harold Leeds for the same purpose.

Her son by James, John J. Stillman (probably born John James Leeds), was known at times as Jay Leeds and John J. Ward (Ward being the maiden name of Florence’s mother).

Her husband, John Rousseau Metcalfe, was also known as John Rousseau Barber, using the surname of his stepfather Lemuel J. Barber. After his marriage to Florence he adopted Florence’s son by Stillman and from then on the son was known as John Ward Metcalfe.

Florence’s son by John Rousseau Metcalfe, Jesse Carmicheal Metcalfe, was generally known as Michael John Metcalfe.

Florence was enumerated in the 1900 federal census of Manhattan, New York County, New York, in her parents’ household as follows:¹

James S. Lawlor, head of household, white, male, born Jan. 1859, 41, married 24 years, born New York, father born Ireland, mother born England, tin smith, reads, writes, speaks English, rents flat.
Ellen Lawlor, wife, white, female, born Apr. 1859, 41, married 24 years, 14 children, 8 living, born Illinois, father born Ireland, mother born Ireland, reads, writes, speaks English.
Mary Lawlor, daughter, white, female, born Mar. 1880, 20, single, born New York, father born New York, mother born Illinois, reads, writes, speaks English.
Lillian Lawlor, daughter, white, female, born July 1883, 16, single, born New York, father born New York, mother born Illinois, dressmaker, reads, writes, speaks English.
Edward Lawlor, son, white, male, born Apr. 1887, 13, single, born New York, father born New York, mother born Illinois, at school, reads, attended school within the year, writes, speaks English.
Joseph Lawlor, son, white, male, born Mar. 1889, 11, single, born New York, father born New York, mother born Illinois, at school, reads, attended school within the year, writes, speaks English.
Arthur Lawlor, son, white, male, born No. 1890, single, born New York, father born New York, mother born Illinois, at school, reads, attended school within the year, writes, speaks English.
Francis Lawlor, son, white, male, born Mar. 1892, 8, single, born New York, father born New York, mother born Illinois, at school, reads, attended school within the year, writes, speaks English.
Florence Lawlor, daughter, white, female, born July 1894, 5, single, born New York, father born New York, mother born Illinois, reads, attended school within the year, writes, speaks English.
Walter Lawlor, son, white, male, born Mar. 1898, 2, single, born New York, father born New York, mother born Illinois.

Florence was enumerated in the 1910 federal census of Manhattan, New York County, New York, in her parents’ household as follows:²

James S. Lawlor, head of household, male, white, 51, married once for 33 years, born New York, father born Canada - English, mother born England - English, speaks English, plumber, own account, employer, reads, writes, rents home.
Helen A. Lawlor, wife, female, white, 50, married once for 33 years, 15 children, 8 living, born Illinois, father born Ireland - English, mother born Ireland - English, speaks English, reads, writes.
Mary Lawlor, daughter, female, white, 29, single, born New York, father born New York, mother born Illinois, speaks English, at home, reads, writes.
Edward Lawlor, son, male, white, 23, single, born New York, father born New York, mother born Illinois, speaks English, brick layer for house, works for wages, reads, writes.
Arthur Lawlor, son, male, white, 19, single, born New York, father born New York, mother born Illinois, speaks English, newspaper stand, own account, reads, writes.
Frank Lawlor, son, male, white, 18, single, born New York, father born New York, mother born Illinois, speaks English, apprentice plumber, works for wages, reads, writes.
Florence Lawlor, daughter, female, white, 15, single, born New York, father born New York, mother born Illinois, speaks English, reads, writes, attended school within the year.
Walter Lawlor, son, male, white, 12, single, born New York, father born New York, mother born Illinois, speaks English, reads, writes, attended school within the year.

Florence, her lover and their son were enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Manhattan, New York County, New York, as follows:³

Franklin H. [or M.] Leeds [sic, James A. Stillman], head of household, rents, male, white, 44 [sic, 48], married [sic, not married], reads, writes, born New York, father born New York, mother born New York, speaks English, agent for bankers [sic, banker], works for wages.
Florence Leeds [sic, Lawlor], wife [sic, mistress], female, white, 24 [sic, 25], married [sic, not married], reads, writes, born New York, father born New York, mother born New York, speaks English.
Jay Leeds [sic, Stillman], son, male, white, 1-3/12, single, reads [sic], writes [sic], born New York, father born New York, mother born New York.

The 1920 census was taken as of 1 January 1920, so Jay was born in September 1918.

Florence’s passport application⁴ recorded 19 March 1921, stamped 6919, records:

Application Dade County, Florida.
Passport issued 22 March 1921.
Florence H. Leeds [sic, Florence Lawlor].
Born 2 July 1895 [sic, 1894] in New York City, N.Y.
Husband Jay F. Leeds [sic, James A. Stillman, not married], born New York City, N.Y., residing Palm Beach.
Residing in New York City, N.Y.
Never had a passport before.
Intend to return within one year.
Intend to use passport to visit Cuba for recreation.
25 [sic, 26] years old.
5 feet 4 inches.
High forehead.
Hazel eyes.
Straight nose.
Medium mouth.
Round chin.
Auburn hair.
Fair complexion.
Round face.
Sworn to by Herbert B. Thrasher, photographer, Miami, Florida.

Attached is a note on stationary marked Office of the Solicitor, Department of State:

1/19/22
P.C.
Dear Mr. Brist:
1. How do we know that Florence H. Leeds is not the wife of Jay F. Leeds or that Jay F. was not born in NY. as alleged?
2. Please note that the witness to Florence’s appl’n is Herbert B. Thrasher. During the war a German spy obtained one of our ppts in the name of Thrasher, having procured a certificate of the latter’s birth in the US. from Thrasher’s wife. Is this the same Thrasher?
RWJ

Florence’s son by James Stillman, John Ward Metcalfe, born on 17 September 1918 in Manhattan, New York, died on 6 September 1994 in Manhattan and was buried on 9 September in Calverton National Cemetery, Calverton, Suffolk County, New York, in section 66 site 3836.⁵ He had been a Captain in World War II, enlisting on 10 January 1941.⁶

_______________
¹ James S. Lawlor household, 1900 U.S. census, New York County, New York, population schedule, Manhattan Ward 12, 1766 Amsterdam Avenue, enumeration district 634, supervisor’s district 1, sheet 5A (continued on the next sheet), line 47, dwelling 41, family 114; National Archives micropublication T623, roll 1109.
² James S. Lawlor household, 1910 U.S. census, New York County, New York, population schedule, Manhattan Ward 12, 1766 Amsterdam Avenue, enumeration district 698, supervisor’s district 1, sheet 14A, line 7, dwelling 39, family 328; National Archives micropublication T624, roll 1026.
³ Franklin H. Leeds household, 1920 U.S. census, New York County, New York, population schedule, Manhattan, 64/66 East 86 Street, enumeration district 1090, supervisor’s district 1, sheet 8B, line 87, dwelling 54, family 162; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 1213.
⁴ Passport Applications, January 2, 1906-March 31, 1925; (National Archives Microfilm Publication M1490); General Records of the Department of State, Record Group 59; National Archives, Washington, D.C.
⁵ National Cemetery Association, U.S. Veterans Gravesites, ca. 1775–2006.
⁶ Electronic Army Serial Number Merged File, 1938-1946 [Archival Database]; World War II Army Enlistment Records; Records of the National Archives and Records Administration, Record Group 64; National Archives at College Park, College Park, MD.

Images for Florence Lawlor:

Florence Lawlor (aka Florence Leeds), 1916 publicity photo, from the book “Ziegfeld Follies” by Marjorie Farnsworth.

Florence Lawlor (aka Florence Leeds), passport photo, 19 March 1921.

Issue of Maj. George Dilse Lawrence and ⁹Zuleika Rosalie Metcalfe [49] (⁸Oren Metcalfe [11], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1])

96. ¹⁰Zuleika Metcalfe Lawrence, dau. of Maj. George Dilse Lawrence and ⁹Zuleika Rosalie Metcalfe [49]. Born on 21 Sep. 1888 in Rome, Floyd County, Georgia. Died on 10 Nov. 1973 in Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi, 85 years old.

Married William Allen Adams, son of William Allen Adams and Elizabeth Dunbar (dau. of William C. Dunbar), on 18 May 1910 in Presbyterian Church, Natchez when 21 years old (William Allen was 36 years old). William Allen Adams b. on 11 Feb. 1874 in Nina Plantation, Point Coupee Parish, Louisiana; d. on 20 May 1953 in Ravenna Cottage, Natchez, 79 years old.

Issue of Zuleika Metcalfe Lawrence and William Allen Adams:
118   i. son ¹¹Col. William Allen Adams b. on 23 Jan. 1911 in Ravenna Cottage.
119   ii. son Maj. George Lawrence Adams b. on 10 Dec. 1913 in Ravenna Cottage.
      iii. dau. Zuleika Lawrence Adams b. about June 1915 in Ravenna Cottage; d. young.
120   iv. dau. Roane Fleming Adams b. on 23 July 1917 in Ravenna Cottage.

Notes on Zuleika Metcalfe Lawrence:

Zuleika (“Lalie”) Metcalfe Lawrence was born on 21 September 1888 in Rome, Georgia. On Lalie’s birth her grandfather Oren sent a telegram to her father George: “Count grandpa in rejoicings over little Zulie.” After her family moved back to Natchez in 1895, Lalie and her first cousin Mary Roane were raised at Ravenna like sisters, often dressing alike even when grown into young ladies. They were devoted to each other all of their lives which were spent with their families on the grounds of Ravenna.

Lalie married William Allen Adams on 18 May 1910 in the Presbyterian Church in Natchez. He was born on 11 February 1874 on Nina plantation in Point Coupee Parish, Louisiana, son of William Allen Adams and Elizabeth Dunbar. Lalie and William made their home at Ravenna Cottage along with Lalie’s mother Zulie. William was a druggist and for many years operated Adams Drug Store on Main Street in Natchez.

Lalie and her family were enumerated in the 1920 federal census of Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi, as follows:¹

The references to January relate to the census being taken “as of” 1 January 1920.

Lalie and her family were enumerated in the 1930 federal census of Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi, next door to her mother Zuleika, as follows:²

William died on 20 May 1953 at Ravenna Cottage and Lalie died on 10 November 1973 in Natchez. They had three surviving children.

_______________
¹ Will Adams household, 1920 U.S. census, Adams County, Mississippi, population schedule, Natchez Ward 4, 603 Ravenna Place, enumeration district 10, supervisor’s district 7, sheet 4A, line 4, dwelling 77, family 80; National Archives micropublication T625, roll 868.
² William A. Adams household, 1930 U.S. census, Adams County, Mississippi, population schedule, Natchez Ward 4, Beat 1, 601 Union, enumeration district 1-7, supervisor’s district 10, sheet 2B, line 70, dwelling 38, family 44; National Archives micropublication T626, roll 1137.

Issue of ⁹Richard Inge Metcalfe [51] (⁸Oren Metcalfe [11], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and Louise W. Leonard

97. ¹⁰Louise L. Metcalfe, dau. of ⁹Richard Inge Metcalfe [51] and Louise W. Leonard. Born on 9 March 1900 in Ravenna, Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi. Died on 31 Oct. 1993, 93 years old.

Married Albert D. Williams after 1930 when at least 30 years old.

Issue of Louise L. Metcalfe and Albert D. Williams:
i. dau. ¹¹(May be living) Williams
ii. son (May be living) Williams

Notes on Louise L. Metcalfe:

She inherited Ravenna from her parents.

Eleventh Generation

Issue of Wilford Ira Canfield and ¹⁰Juliet Randall [54] (⁹Eliza Smith [14], ⁸Sybil Metcalf [2], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1])

98. ¹¹Delos Wilford Canfield, son of Wilford Ira Canfield and ¹⁰Juliet Randall [54]. Born on 3 July 1875 in Ohio.

Married Mary Thompson on 2 Dec. 1901 when 26 years old.

Issue of Delos Wilford Canfield and Mary Thompson:
      i. son ¹²Delos Lincoln Canfield b. on 13 Dec. 1903.
      ii. son Randall Canfield b. on 22 Oct. 1905.
      iii. dau. Miriam Canfield b. on 19 Nov. 1907.
      iv. dau. (May be living) Canfield

Notes on Delos Wilford Canfield:

Delos Wilford Canfield:¹

son Ira Wilford & Juliet V. (Randall) Canfield, b. July 3, 1875.
m. Dec. 2, 1901, Mary Thompson.

_______________
¹ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. II: Eighth to Twelfth Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 2306.

99. ¹¹Florence Eliza Canfield, dau. of Wilford Ira Canfield and ¹⁰Juliet Randall [54]. Born on 27 Sep. 1885 in Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio.

Married Bert Dewey Presley on 31 Aug. 1907 in Chardon when 21 years old (Bert Dewey was 22 years old). Bert Dewey Presley b. on 30 May 1885.

Issue of Florence Eliza Canfield and Bert Dewey Presley:
i. son ¹²Marion Presley b. on 24 Sep. 1909.

Notes on Florence Eliza Canfield:

Florence Canfield:¹

dau. Ira Wilford & Juliet V. (Randall) Canfield, of Chardon, Ohio, b. Sept. 27, 1885, Chardon.
m. Aug. 31, 1907, Chardon, Bert Dewey Presley, b. May 30, 1885. [1 child.]

“Mrs. Florence Eliza Canfield Presley. Born in Chardon, Ohio. Wife of Bert D. Presley. . . . Daughter of Ira Wilford Canfield (1850–1909) and Juliette Randall (1852–1919), his wife, m. 1872. Granddaughter of Delos W. Canfield and Sophronia Allen, his wife; Leander Jason Randall (1817–69) and Eliza Smith (1820–86), his wife, m. 1846. Gr.-granddaughter of . . . Jason Randall (1787–1852) and Martha Thompson (1787–1856), his wife, m. 1807; . . . Gr-gr-granddaughter of . . . Nicholas Randall and Content Phillips (d. 1815), his wife, m. 1777; . . . ”²

_______________
¹ Gilbert Warren Chapin, compiler, The Chapin Book of Genealogical Data, Vol. II: Eighth to Twelfth Generations (Hartford: Chapin Family Association, 1924), 2306.
² DAR, Lineage Book, Vol. LXIII, 1907, 186–187, entry 62556.

Issue of Rear Adm. Charles Fremont Pond and ¹⁰Emma McHenry [59] (⁹Ellen Josephine Metcalfe [23], ⁸Dr. Asa Baldwin Metcalfe [6], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1])

100. ¹¹Charles McHenry Pond, son of Rear Adm. Charles Fremont Pond and ¹⁰Emma McHenry [59]. Born in 1882/3 in California. Died on 4 March 1947 in New York, New York, 64 years old. Buried on 25 March 1947 in Mountain View Cemetery, Piedmont, Alameda County, California.

Married Inez Henderson.

Issue of Charles McHenry Pond and Inez Henderson:
i. son ¹²Rev. Charles Pond .
ii. dau. Mary Virginia Pond m. Jack Culbertson.

Notes on Charles McHenry Pond:

Some information is from John Pond.

Charles died in the Prince George Hotel at 14 East 28th Street.

Notes on Inez Henderson:

The information is from John Pond.

101. ¹¹Cdr. John Enoch Pond, son of Rear Adm. Charles Fremont Pond and ¹⁰Emma McHenry [59]. Born on 10 May 1884 in Berkeley, Alameda County, California. Died on 25 Nov. 1941 in Berkeley, 57 years old. Buried in Golden Gate Cemetery, San Bruno, San Mateo County, California.

Married first Wynn Adele Martin on 15 April 1912 in San Francisco, San Francisco County, California when 27 years old (Wynn Adele was 20 years old). Wynn Adele Martin b. on 5 April 1892 in San Francisco; bap. on 23 July 1892 when three months old; d. on 24 March 1981 in San Francisco, 88 years old; bur. in Cypress Lawn Cemetery, Colma, San Mateo County, California.

Issue of Cdr. John Enoch Pond and Wynn Adele Martin:
      i. son ¹²Capt. John Enoch Pond b. on 3 July 1914 in San Francisco; bap. on 20 Sep. 1914 when two months old; m. (1) Anne Louise Langrall (25 Jan. 1919 in Maryland–6 March 1971 in San Francisco) on 5 July 1939 when 25 years old (Anne Louise was 20 years old); m. (2) Natalie B. Heck (8 July 1925 of Santa Rosa, Sonoma County, California–23 Oct. 1999 in Santa Rosa) in April 1974 when 59 years old (Natalie B. was 48 years old).
121   ii. son Col. William Martin Pond b. on 28 Aug. 1916 in Bremerton, Kitsap County, Washington.
122   iii. son Capt. Robert McHenry Pond b. on 14 Jan. 1921 in Treasure Island, San Francisco County, California.

Married second Wilmac Harrison. Wilmac Harrison d. on 27 April 1959 in Berkeley; bur. in Golden Gate Cemetery.

Notes on Cdr. John Enoch Pond:

The information is from Paula Stewart and John Pond

John notes he graduated from the U.S. Naval Academy in 1905.

Notes on Wynn Adele Martin:

The information is from John Pond.

Notes on Wilmac Harrison:

The information is from John Pond.

Issue of ¹⁰John McHenry [60] (⁹Ellen Josephine Metcalfe [23], ⁸Dr. Asa Baldwin Metcalfe [6], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and Frances Veronica Reynolds

102. ¹¹Frances Reynolds McHenry, dau. of ¹⁰John McHenry [60] and Frances Veronica Reynolds. Born on 11 Oct. 1898 in San Francisco, San Francisco County, California. Died on 21 April 1962 in Letterman Hospital, San Francisco, 63 years old. Buried in Mountain View Cemetery, Piedmont, Alameda County, California.

Married Capt. John Archer Stewart on 23 Sep. 1925 when 26 years old (Capt. John Archer was 27 years old). Capt. John Archer Stewart b. on 19 June 1898 in Concordia, Cloud County, Kansas; d. on 24 Nov. 1966 in Veteran’s Hospital, Long Beach, Los Angeles County, California, 68 years old.

Issue of Frances Reynolds McHenry and Capt. John Archer Stewart:
123 i. son ¹²John Reynolds Stewart b. on 25 Feb. 1929 in Colón, Colón Province, Panamá.

Notes on Frances Reynolds McHenry:

The information is from Paula Stewart and John Pond.

Notes on Capt. John Archer Stewart:

The information is from Paula Stewart and Joh Pond.

Issue of ¹⁰Asa Baldwin Metcalfe [62] (⁹George Edward Metcalfe [24], ⁸Dr. Asa Baldwin Metcalfe [6], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and Francis Lucinda Keller

103. ¹¹William Arthur Metcalfe, son of ¹⁰Asa Baldwin Metcalfe [62] and Francis Lucinda Keller. Born on 22 Feb. 1893 in Saint Joseph, Tensas County, Louisiana. Died on 4 March 1953, 60 years old. Buried in Lakewood Memorial Park, Jackson, Hinds County, Mississippi.

Married Lula Mae Saxon. Lula Mae Saxon b. on 12 Oct. 1893; d. on 21 Jan. 1966, 72 years old.

Issue of William Arthur Metcalfe and Lula Mae Saxon:
      i. dau. ¹²(May be living) Metcalfe
      ii. son (May be living) Metcalfe
      iii. dau. (May be living) Metcalfe
      iv. dau. (May be living) Metcalfe
      v. son (May be living) Metcalfe

Notes on William Arthur Metcalfe:

He may have been born in Vidalia,Concordia Parish,Louisiana.

Issue of ¹⁰Rev. Arthur Ludlow [73] (⁹Linnaeus Charles Ludlow [33], ⁸Harriet Metcalf [9], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and _____ _____

104. ¹¹Carroll G. Ludlow, son of ¹⁰Rev. Arthur Ludlow [73]. Born in June 1889 in Ohio.

Married Gertrude L. _____. Gertrude L. _____ b. in 1891/2 in Ohio.

Issue of Carroll G. Ludlow and Gertrude L. _____:
i. son ¹²Robert Ludlow b. in March 1916 in Ohio.

Issue of ¹⁰John B. Crall [81] (⁹Mary Eliza Metcalf [39], ⁸George A. Metcalf [10], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and Rose Eva _____

105. ¹¹Harry G. Crall, son of ¹⁰John B. Crall [81] and Rose Eva _____. Born in July 1887 in Iowa.

Married Marguerite _____. Marguerite _____ b. in 1888/9 in Wisconsin.

Issue of Harry G. Crall and Marguerite _____:
      i. son ¹²Charles Crall b. in 1910/1 in Washington.
      ii. son Chauncey John Crall b. in 1912/3 in Washington.
      iii. son Galen Crall b. in 1916 in Montana.
      iv. son (May be living) Crall
      v. dau. (May be living) Crall

106. ¹¹Donald J. Crall, son of ¹⁰John B. Crall [81] and Rose Eva _____. Born in June 1898 in Iowa.

Married Juanita Boyd on 24 June 1927 in Port Angeles, Clallam County, Washington when about 29 years old (Juanita was 19 years old). Juanita Boyd b. in 1907/8 in Washington; d. on 3 Aug. 1974, 66 years old.

Issue of Donald J. Crall and Juanita Boyd:
i. dau. ¹²(May be living) Crall
ii. dau. (May be living) Crall

Issue of ¹⁰Frank M. Haller [84] (⁹Mary Eliza Metcalf [39], ⁸George A. Metcalf [10], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and Pearl M. _____

107. ¹¹Helen F. Haller, dau. of ¹⁰Frank M. Haller [84] and Pearl M. _____. Born in 1902/3 in Ohio.

Married John C. Gilman in 1919/20 when about 17 years old (John C. was about 21 years old). Divorced. John C. Gilman b. in 1898/9 in Colorado.

Issue of Helen F. Haller and John C. Gilman:
i. son ¹²(May be living) Gilman

Issue of ¹⁰William Ludlow Metcalf [86] (⁹Gilbert A. Metcalf [41], ⁸George A. Metcalf [10], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and Eva C. Raymond

108. ¹¹Frank Raymond Metcalf, son of ¹⁰William Ludlow Metcalf [86] and Eva C. Raymond. Born on 24 Feb. 1887 in Attica, Seneca County, Ohio.

Married Hortense Bachman. Hortense Bachman b. in 1889/90 in Ohio.

Issue of Frank Raymond Metcalf and Hortense Bachman:
      i. dau. ¹²Carlan Metcalf b. in 1913 in Ohio.
      ii. dau. Lucile Metcalf b. in 1916 in Ohio.
      iii. son (May be living) Metcalf

109. ¹¹Arlington D. Metcalf, son of ¹⁰William Ludlow Metcalf [86] and Eva C. Raymond. Born in Sep. 1889 in Attica, Seneca County, Ohio.

Married Laura Hunt in 1910/1 when about 21 years old (Laura was about 19 years old). Laura Hunt b. in 1891 in Ohio.

Issue of Arlington D. Metcalf and Laura Hunt:
      i. dau. ¹²Garland R. Metcalf b. in 1913 in Ohio.
      ii. son Raymond A. Metcalf b. in Nov. 1918 in Ohio.
      iii. son (May be living) Metcalf

110. ¹¹Donald Colburn Metcalf, son of ¹⁰William Ludlow Metcalf [86] and Eva C. Raymond. Born in Oct. 1891 in Attica, Seneca County, Ohio. Died on 8 Jan. 1977 in Toledo, Lucas County, Ohio, 85 years old.

Married Maude Leora Chapman. Maude Leora Chapman b. in 1895/6 in Michigan.

Issue of Donald Colburn Metcalf and Maude Leora Chapman:
i. dau. ¹²Mildred A. Metcalf b. in May 1916 in Toledo.
ii. son Coburn Chapman Metcalf b. in Feb. 1918 in Toledo.

111. ¹¹Jesse Ladow Metcalf, son of ¹⁰William Ludlow Metcalf [86] and Eva C. Raymond. Born on 1 Feb. 1899 in Reed Township, Seneca County, Ohio.

Married Bertha F. Rossman. Bertha F. Rossman b. in 1894 in Ohio.

Issue of Jesse Ladow Metcalf and Bertha F. Rossman:
      i. dau. ¹²(May be living) Metcalf
      ii. son (May be living) Metcalf
      iii. son (May be living) Metcalf

112. ¹¹James Roland Metcalf, son of ¹⁰William Ludlow Metcalf [86] and Eva C. Raymond. Born on 16 Nov. 1904 in Reed Township, Seneca County, Ohio. Died on 2 Dec. 1986 in Toledo, Lucas County, Ohio, 82 years old.

Married Roberta Phillips, dau. of Thomas W. Phillips and Myrtle B. _____, in 1926 when 21 or 22 years old (Roberta was 21 years old). Roberta Phillips b. in 1904/5 in Ohio.

Issue of James Roland Metcalf and Roberta Phillips:
i. son ¹²(May be living) Metcalf
ii. son (May be living) Metcalf

Issue of ¹⁰Dell F. Harbaugh [89] (⁹Martha E. Metcalf [43], ⁸George A. Metcalf [10], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and Clara M. _____

113. ¹¹Joseph W. Harbaugh, son of ¹⁰Dell F. Harbaugh [89] and Clara M. _____. Born in June 1891 in Kansas. Died before 1920, at most 28 years old.

Married Goldie Billings. Goldie Billings b. in 1880 in Nebraska.

Issue of Joseph W. Harbaugh and Goldie Billings:
      i. son ¹²Joseph P. Harbaugh b. in 1911/2 in Nebraska.
      ii. son Robert W. Harbaugh b. in June 1915 in Nebraska.
      iii. son Dell Forest Harbaugh b. in Oct. 1918 in Missouri.

Issue of ¹⁰Thomas Oren Metcalfe [93] (⁹Lt. James Bard Metcalfe CSA [47], ⁸Oren Metcalfe [11], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and Helen Francis Smith

114. ¹¹Thomas Oren Metcalfe, son of ¹⁰Thomas Oren Metcalfe [93] and Helen Francis Smith. Born on 23 Dec. 1922 in Beaumont, Jefferson County, Texas. Died on 7 Nov. 1974 in Canton, Madison County, Mississippi, 51 years old.

Married Blanche Christine Furr on 4 Feb. 1950 in St. Peter’s Church, Jackson, Hinds County, Mississippi when 27 years old (Blanche Christine was 28 years old). Blanche Christine Furr b. on 4 Aug. 1921 in Picayune, Pearl River County, Mississippi.

Issue of Thomas Oren Metcalfe and Blanche Christine Furr:
      i. dau. ¹²(May be living) Metcalfe
      ii. dau. (May be living) Metcalfe
      iii. son (May be living) Metcalfe

Notes on Thomas Oren Metcalfe:

The information is from Margaret (Metcalfe) Hassin.

Notes on Blanche Christine Furr:

The information is from Margaret (Metcalfe) Hassin.

Blanche was born in the family home on Steele Avenue.

Issue of Richard Maria Wilhelm Oberwinder and ¹⁰Bernice Roche Metcalfe [94] (⁹William Lyons Metcalfe [48], ⁸Oren Metcalfe [11], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1])

115. ¹¹John Charles Metcalfe, son of Richard Maria Wilhelm Oberwinder and ¹⁰Bernice Roche Metcalfe [94]. Born on 2 Aug. 1904 in Berlin, Germany. Died on 29 June 1971 in San Antonio, Bexar County, Texas, 66 years old. Buried in San Fernando Cemetery, San Antonio.

Married Violet Emma Maria Hurtig, dau. of Carl Axel Hurtig (son of Axel Robert Hurtig and Emma Kristina Adamsdotter) and Esther Christina Nilsson (dau. of Olaf Peter Nilsson and Maria Jonsdotter), on 2 Jan. 1933 in Chicago, Cook County, Illinois when 28 years old (Violet Emma Maria was 25 years old). Violet Emma Maria Hurtig b. on 8 July 1907 in Chicago; d. on 1 May 1987 in Los Angeles, Los Angeles County, California, 79 years old; bur. in Beverly Cemetery, Blue Island, Cook County, Illinois; m. (1) Samuel Ångstrom on 6 Dec. 1924 in Chicago when 17 years old; divorced.

Issue of John Charles Metcalfe and Violet Emma Maria Hurtig:
i. son ¹²(May be living) Metcalfe
ii. dau. (May be living) Metcalfe

Notes on John Charles Metcalfe:

John’s birth name was Helmut Maria Siegfried Oberwinder (he spelled Helmut with a double-l). It was changed to John Charles Metcalfe after his emigration to the United States in 1914. Subsequently he was nicknamed “Jacie” (for his initials, J. C.). It is believed that he took his American given names from a maternal great-uncle, John Charles Roche. His early journeys from Germany to various places in the U.S. are noted under his mother.¹

Jacie and his brother James took their first communion and confirmation on 14 May 1916 at the University of Notre Dame.²

Jacie majored in Journalism at the University of Notre Dame Preparatory School from 1917 to 1922 and took additional courses in journalism at Englewood Night School in Chicago from 1923 to 1925. He became a reporter for the Associated Press in Chicago in 1925. He moved to report for the San Antonio Light in 1926. He returned to Chicago to become News Editor of the Southtown Economist in 1927–1932.

Jacie married Violet (Vi) Emma Maria Hurtig on 2 January 1933 in Chicago. His son, the author, was born on 23 November of that year.

At the bottom of the Great Depression, 1933–36, Jacie held a variety of jobs in Chicago. He was Public Relations Director of the Chicago Real Estate Board and Special Assistant to the National Association of Real Estate Boards. He was Assistant Editor of the magazine, Real Estate. And he was Public Relations Director of the Merchandise Mart.

In 1936–38 Jacie was a reporter for the Chicago Times. It was here that he got his “big story.” Prior to working for the Times, in 1933–35, he had assisted the FBI as a private citizen in investigations of German propaganda activities in the U.S., working with his brother Jim, the FBI agent, and reporting to Melvin Purvis. He was told by Agent Purvis, “We shall always deny having any connection with you!” Very comforting. Early in 1935 he was invited by Hitler, through the German Consul in Chicago, to come as Hitler’s guest to the Parteitag (Party Day) celebrations in Nuremburg, Germany. Agent Purvis wouldn’t permit the visit, saying “something could go wrong” and that it was too easy to arrange an “accident” if the Nazis had become suspicious of Jacie—reminding Jacie of his “deniability.”

Although a citizen of the United States by derivation (through his mother), Jacie was naturalized an American citizen (as was his brother Jim) on 19 August 1936³ on the recommendation of Agent Purvis—this to avoid any claim on him by Germany.

Now, in March 1937, Jacie became an undercover reporter for the Times. He joined the Amerikadeutscher Volksbund (the German-American Bund) as an active member, Storm Trooper and personal aide to Fritz Kuhn, the Führer of the Bund, using his fluency in German and his German name to great advantage. He spent six very dangerous months inside the Bund with his brother Jim and another Times reporter, William Mueller (who, unlike Jacie and Jim, couldn’t speak a word of German). The author, as a small child, remembers attending meetings with massed Nazi and American flags and storm troopers, wearing Sam Brown belts and jackboots, singing the Horst Wessel Lied (the Horst Wessel song—the Nazi Party anthem).

Jacie again was invited to Germany to enter a special propaganda school, there to be trained as a Nazi spy and saboteur in operations in the U.S. This invitation was also turned down, for the same reasons, although in both instances Jacie wanted to go. His brother, Andrew, told the author’s sister that Jacie always had a slightly mad bent for danger.

Finally, in September 1937, the Times went public with the story, which was front page material for weeks. Jacie then served for a year (1938) as Special Agent to Congress and was appointed Agent-in-Charge of Nazi-Fascist Investigations for the House Committee on Un-American Activities, the first agent appointed by that committee. He was subsequently retained by the Criminal Division of the Department of Justice in 1940–42.

In this period, Jacie received many threats, one recalled by the author as a young child—a threat on Jacie’s life wrapped around a block of wood and thrown through a closed window of a hall in which Jacie was lecturing on his experiences. Shortly thereafter, he was ambushed in his car by automatic weapons, but was able to escape without injury by fast driving—although the car was riddled.

Also in this period (1938–42), Jacie was a technical advisor to Columbia Pictures, Warner Brothers and Republic Pictures. Warner Brothers in particular was accused by congressmen of “war mongering” in June 1941. In testimony before a House Committee defending the movie “Confessions of a Nazi Spy,” Harry M. Warner, President of Warner Bros. Pictures, said “our script writers referred [particularly to] articles in the Chicago Daily News [sic] by John C. Metcalfe. Mr. Metcalfe was not writing hearsay. As a reporter for the Chicago Daily News [sic], Mr. Metcalfe joined the German-American Bund, in order that he might have first hand knowledge of the Bund’s operation.”⁴

In June 1939, Jacie and his family moved to Bethesda, Maryland, and in June 1941 to Silver Spring, Maryland. In 1943–45 he was Washington Diplomatic Correspondent for Time Magazine. In 1945–1947 he had the same title at the New York Herald Tribune and also was a War Correspondent. He reported from most Northern European countries and some in Latin America. In 1949–55 he contributed to the Worldwide Press Service as a Foreign Affairs Correspondent.

In 1948 Jacie started a lecture bureau, National Lecture Management, Inc., in Washington D.C., representing the Vice President of the U.S., Alben W. Barkley, and many Senators, Representatives, journalists and authors. He also represented some entertainers such as Hal Holbrook and Tarbell, the magician, as well as the adventurer, Thor Heyerdahl.

In 1960 Jacie closed the bureau (the impact of television being a significant factor) but continued lecturing on foreign affairs. In 1966 he was appointed Expert Consultant to the State Department’s Agency for International Development.

Jacie and Vi moved to St. Augustine, Florida, and then to 2609 Cincinnati Avenue in San Antonio, Texas, where he died of bladder cancer on Tuesday, 29 June 1971.⁵ Vi then moved to Los Angeles to be near their son, the author, where she died of circulatory failure on 1 May 1987.

In 1936 Jacie originated the Sun-Times syndicated column of poetry, “Portraits,” which his brother Jim continued in the 1940s and 1950s. After Jim’s death, Jacie continued the column for another few years for the Publishers-Hall Syndicate.

He was an active member of the National Press Club from 1943; the White House Correspondents Association and the State Department Correspondents Association from 1944; the Overseas Writers Club from 1945; and the Rotary Club from 1940. His awards included, among others, the National Headliners Club Medal of Honor for 1937 for Best Story of the Year (the Bund story, shared with his brother Jim and with William Mueller); the Chilean Legion of Merit decoration in 1945 for his United Nations coverage; and the St. Olav Medal of Norway in 1946 for coverage of the allied cause in World War II. In connection with the latter two awards he was made an honorary citizen of Chile and of Norway.

Jacie’s papers relating to his Bund investigation were deposited in the Hoover Institute at Stanford University and are open to researchers. They are described at:

http://texts.cdlib.org/view?docId=tf6w10052p&doc.view=entire_text

The abstract on that site reads: “Diary, correspondence, reports, notes, pamphlets, clippings, and printed matter, relating to the infiltration of the German-American Bund by J. C. Metcalfe as an investigative reporter in 1937, and to the activities of fascist organizations in the U.S.”

Jacie and Vi had two children.

_______________
¹ The information for this person is provided from the personal knowledge of the author. This is supplemented by information from the biography of John Metcalfe, the author’s father, as he wrote it for his lecturing brochure, in the possession of the author, and known by the author to be factual. His birth was recorded in the author’s birth certificate. Information was also available from a summary of a proposed book on his experiences, written in 1965, in the possession of the author, which was not published.
² Notre Dame Archives, http://archives1.archives.nd.edu/minims/o.htm, 15 May 1999:
“Oberwinder, Helmuth (Oberwinder, Helmuth A.) receives 1st comm, confirmation 1916/0514 St Edwards’ Hall Chronicles UNDR 18/7 p.18.”
“Oberwinder, Helmuth (Oberwinder, Helmuth A.) Chicago, Illinois 1916/1917 Address Book Entry ULDG: Address Book 1910-18 p. 211.”
“Oberwinder, Helmuth (Oberwinder, Helmuth A.) Chicago, Illinois 1917/1918 Address Book Entry ULDG: Address Book 1910-18 p. 212.”
³ U.S. District Court in Chicago, file number 4154734, petition number 144333.
⁴ Rudy Behlmer, Inside Warner Bros. (1935–1951), (New York: Simon & Schuster, Inc., no date), 190.
⁵ He was buried in Block 40, Lot 61, Space 385 in San Fernando Archdiocesan Cemetery #2 in San Antonio on Friday, 2 July 1971.

Images for John Charles Metcalfe:

John Charles Metcalfe (born Helmut Maria Siegfried Oberwinder) and Violet Emma Maria Hurtig, on their marriage day, 2 January 1933, in Chicago, Illinois.

Notes on Violet Emma Maria Hurtig:

Violet (Vi), older daughter of Carl Axel Hurtig, was born at home (850 Erickson Avenue in Roseland on the south side of Chicago) at 3 p.m. on 8 July 1907, attended by a midwife. She was baptized Lutheran in Chicago on 20 October 1907.¹

Vi attended Englewood Business School for two years (1921–2) and was a member of the Psi Delta Rita Sorority in 1923. She married first her apparent high school sweetheart, Samuel Ångstrom, a private detective, on 6 December 1924 at the Lutheran Evangelical Mission Church in Chicago when she was seventeen years old.² He had taken her to her first party a year earlier, on 20 October 1923, where they played “forfeits” and “post office,” danced and had what was described as a “wild time” ending at 3:30 a.m. However, the marriage lasted only for a short time. She worked as a secretary and assistant credit manager for the Telephone Maintenance Co. in Chicago from 1923 to 1928 and as a private secretary at Sears, Roebuck and Co. from 1931 to 1933.

Vi married second John Charles (“Jacie”) Metcalfe in Chicago on 2 January 1933. When Jacie had his lecture bureau, Vi worked with him for many years as general manager. She enjoyed attending embassy receptions and hosting parties for diplomats and journalists with Jacie.

She suffered a stroke in 1961, paralyzing her right arm and leg. She was mostly wheelchair-bound thereafter.³ After Jacie died in 1971 she moved to Los Angeles to be near her son, the author, and his wife, Iris, living in her home at 1134 North Hudson Avenue in Hollywood. She died at 6:20 a.m. on 1 May 1987 in Los Angeles, California, of general circulatory failure in her eightieth year.⁴ According to her wishes, Vi was buried on 6 May 1987 in lot 97, section 1, grave 3 east, in Beverly Cemetery near her sister (grave 2 east) and parents (lot 116).⁵

Vi and Jacie had two children.

_______________
¹ From her birth and baptismal certificates. Information not otherwise identified came from family letters in the possession of the author, as well as his personal knowledge.
² From their marriage certificate.
³ Interestingly, when asleep, she moved her paralyzed arm normally.
⁴ From her Los Angeles, California, death certificate.
⁵ From her Beverly Ridge Funeral Home Interment Record, Blue Island, Illinois.

116. ¹¹James Joseph Metcalfe, son of Richard Maria Wilhelm Oberwinder and ¹⁰Bernice Roche Metcalfe [94]. Born on 16 Sep. 1906 in Berlin, Germany. Died in March 1960 in Dallas, Dallas County, Texas, 53 years old.

Married Lillian Hammer, dau. of Kristoffer Hammer and Verda Louise Osmundsen (dau. of Kristen Osmundsen), in 1933 in Chicago, Cook County, Illinois when 26 or 27 years old (Lillian was 29 or 30 years old). Lillian Hammer b. in 1903 in Stavanger, Rogaland, Norway; d. in 1962, 58 or 59 years old.

Issue of James Joseph Metcalfe and Lillian Hammer:
124   i. son ¹²James Juan Metcalfe b. on 14 Nov. 1933 in Chicago.
      ii. son (May be living) Metcalfe
125   iii. dau. Kristina Maria Metcalfe b. on 18 Aug. 1943 in Dallas.

Notes on James Joseph Metcalfe:

Jim’s known birth name was James Joseph Oberwinder. It was changed to James Metcalfe after his emigration to the United States in February 1914, and he took the middle name of “Juan.” His full German birth name may have been James Maria Johannes Joseph Oberwinder.

Jim and his brother Helmut (John) took their first communion and confirmation together on 14 May 1916 at the University of Notre Dame.¹

Sometime after attending Notre Dame, Jim became a FBI agent, working directly for Melvin Purvis, the famed FBI man who directed the war against gangsterism in the Middle West. Jim was the first agent assigned to “get” John Dillinger, the notorious outlaw and killer. He was also one of the agents who participated in the ambush of Dillinger the night in 1934 when he was “fingered” by Anna Sage, the well-publicized “Lady in Red,” coming out of the Biograph, a small North Side Chicago movie theatre. In addition, he was the agent who located “Baby Face” Nelson and other gangsters of the Capone era, and he served on the Lindbergh kidnapping case.²

In 1937, after leaving the FBI, JIm spent six exciting but dangerous months as an undercover reporter for the Chicago Daily Times, joining the subversive Deutscher Volksbund as a Storm Trooper. He was joined by his brother John and another Times reporter, William Mueller (who, unlike Jim and John, couldn’t speak a word of German). Jim was awarded the National Headliners Club Medal of Honor in 1937 for Best Story of the Year (the Bund story, shared with his brother John and William Mueller). The following excerpt summarizes their adventure:³

NAZI ARMY IN U.S.
Secrets Told by TIMES Men Who Joined It
By William Mueller
The regimental tread of marching men under the flaming red swastika resounds from coast to coast in the United States today.
In uniforms strangely suggestive of those worn by Adolf Hitler’s nazi storm troops, a relatively small but rapidly growing army is preparing for the American counterpart of “Der Tag,” when it plans to seize control of the United States. “We are not plotting a revolution,” leaders tell their followers. “But we are going to be prepared to wrest control from the communist-Jews when they start their revolution. We will save America for white-Americans.”
The growing menace of an organization which outwardly professes to be 100 per cent American but which scorns democracy prompted the TIMES to undertake the first exhaustive investigation of American nazis.
Three reporters worked for months, both from within and outside the Amerikadeutscher Volksbund—German-American Bund—and its companion organization, the Deutscher Volksbund. They traveled from coast to coast and from Canada to the Gulf of Mexico to learn international secrets which the TIMES now presents exclusively to its readers. Months before Atty. Gen. Homer S. Cummings on Aug. 18 ordered G-men to make a “cursory” investigation of the Bund, two TIMES staff men—one a former G-man—were members of American nazi organizations. A third reporter, maintaining liaison with them, watched the Bund’s varied activities from the outside.
The three whose combined reports form this astounding series are James J. Metcalfe, former G-man, John C. Metcalfe and William A. Mueller.
Under the name of Oberwinder, the Metcalfe brothers months ago built themselves up as nazi sympathizers and were accepted as members of the organizations. John Metcalfe established himself in the predominantly German Yorkville section of New York City and later acted as a propagandist for the Amerikadeutscher Bund on a cross-country tour.
A month after John Metcalfe became a storm trooper in New York, his brother, James, was accepted as a member of the alien army operated by the Deutscher Volksbund in Chicago.
‘Get the Facts’
Ground work for the investigation was laid a year ago. It reached the definite build-up stage in February of this year when John Metcalfe and Mueller were sent to New York to “get the facts.”
The Metcalfe brothers were born in Germany and speak the language. Mueller was of German extraction. All are Americans. James Metcalfe was the first Federal Bureau of Investigation agent assigned to the John Dillinger hunt and was in on the Dillinger “kill.” He resigned a position with another federal investigation service to join the TIMES editorial staff.
The TIMES investigation found the German brand of fascism spreading its tentacles throughout the nation. Leaders of the movement say they will seize control of the United States, but not until “the communist revolution starts.”
The organization is an integral part of the Hitler movement in Germany. Leaders are in frequent communication with Berlin. Every method of modern propaganda is used to win converts to the cause.
Chief tenet of the German-American Bund is an intense hatred of Jews and all things Jewish. Other anti-semitic organizations are lining up with the Bund in what leaders plan will be a general fascist merger.

Jim was afterwards a journalist and a published poet (“Portraits,” a column which appeared in the Chicago Sun-Times syndicate in the 1940s and 1950s).

Jim married Lillian Hammer in early 1933. She was born in Stavanger, Norway, on 23 October 1903. She emigrated as a child to the U.S. in April 1908.⁴

Jim died in March 1960. Jim and Lillian had three children.

_______________
¹ Notre Dame Archives, http://archives1.archives.nd.edu/minims/o.htm, 15 May 1999:
“Oberwinder, James (Oberwinder, James J.) receives 1st communion & confirmation 1916/0514 St Edwards’ Hall Chronicles UNDR 18/7 p.18.”
“Oberwinder, James (Oberwinder, James J.) Notre Dame, Indiana 1919/1920 Address Book Entry ULDG: Address Book 1918-21 p. 150.”
² From a summary of a proposed book by the author’s father, written in 1965, in the possession of the author, which was not published.
³ Chicago Daily Times, Thursday, 9 September 1937, pp. 3-4. Reprinted with permission.
⁴ http://www.ellisislandrecords.org/ read on 25 April 2001 by Kristina Metcalfe: Lilly Hammer, female, single, age 4 years, Norwegian, residence Stavanger, Norway, arrived 22 April 1908 at Ellis Island aboard the Oscar II which departed Christiansand, Vest-Agder, Norway. Accompaning Lilly were her mother Verda, age 26 years, and brother Thorlief, age 2 years, 6 months. Lilly’s father arrived two years earlier on 10 March 1906, age 29 years, aboard the Lucania which departed from Liverpool, England.

Notes on Lillian Hammer:

Stavanger is a seaport located on a peninsula between the Norwegian Sea and an arm of the Boknafjorden. It was the seat of the bishopric from the twelfth century when the cathedral of St. Swithin was built. Current industries include fish processing, shipbuilding, shipping and oil refining.

Issue of ¹⁰John Rousseau Metcalfe [95] (⁹William Lyons Metcalfe [48], ⁸Oren Metcalfe [11], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and Florence Lawlor

117. ¹¹Jesse Carmichael Metcalfe, son of ¹⁰John Rousseau Metcalfe [95] and Florence Lawlor. Born on 4 Nov. 1932 in Manhattan, New York County, New York. Died on 24 Dec. 1992 in Duval County, Florida, 60 years old.

Married first Mary Jane _____.

Issue of Jesse Carmichael Metcalfe and Mary Jane _____:
i. son ¹²(May be living) Metcalfe
ii. son (May be living) Metcalfe

Unmarried partner of Diana Paul. Diana Paul b. on 26 June 1947.

Issue of Jesse Carmichael Metcalfe and Diana Paul:
iii. dau. ¹²(May be living) Metcalfe

Married second Belinda _____.

Issue of Jesse Carmichael Metcalfe and Belinda _____:
iv. dau. ¹²(May be living) Metcalfe

Notes on Jesse Carmichael Metcalfe:

Jesse Carmichael (aka Michael John) Metcalfe was noted as four and a half years old on 4 June 1937 and seven and a half years old on 17 May 1940 so he was born in November 1932.¹ He appears to have lived in Hammond, Indiana, in 1934/5 and on 12 September 1946.²

The Florida Death Index, 1877–1998, lists Michael John Metcalfe born 4 November 1932, white, died 24 December 1992 in Duval County, Florida, age 60. His daughter Melody Jean (Metcalfe) Tierney said he was a harness (horse) racer and that he died in a car accident on Christmas Eve, 1992.

_______________
¹ Dated photographs of Michael as a child. Another photo apparently taken when Michael was less than a year old was dated 4 August 1933.
² Photo as a child and as a young teenager noted as being taken in Hammond.

Issue of William Allen Adams and ¹⁰Zuleika Metcalfe Lawrence [96] (⁹Zuleika Rosalie Metcalfe [49], ⁸Oren Metcalfe [11], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1])

118. ¹¹Col. William Allen Adams, son of William Allen Adams and ¹⁰Zuleika Metcalfe Lawrence [96]. Born on 23 Jan. 1911 in Ravenna Cottage, Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi. Died on 31 Dec. 1981 in Natchez, 70 years old.

Married Isabel Peyton, dau. of Joseph Wharton Peyton and Birdie Vance. Isabel Peyton b. on 13 March 1914 in Shreveport, Caddo Parish, Louisiana; d. on 30 Dec. 1993 in Natchez, 79 years old.

Issue of Col. William Allen Adams and Isabel Peyton:
126 i. son ¹²William Allen Adams b. on 16 July 1941 in Shreveport.
ii. dau. (May be living) Adams

Notes on Col. William Allen Adams:

Colonel William Allen Adams (23 January 1911 Ravenna Cottage–31 December 1981 Natchez) married Isabel Peyton (13 March 1914 Shreveport, Louisiana–30 December 1993 Natchez), daughter of Joseph Wharton Peyton and Birdie Vance of Shreveport. William attended the University of Mississippi and then Louisiana State University where he graduated with a degree in engineering. He served in the Army Air Corps during World War II, making it a career and retiring in 1966 as a Colonel. He and Isabel then moved back to Natchez and built (in 1967) a home on the grounds of Ravenna on land given them by William’s first cousin once removed Louise (Metcalfe) Williams. William and Isabel had two children.

119. ¹¹Maj. George Lawrence Adams, son of William Allen Adams and ¹⁰Zuleika Metcalfe Lawrence [96]. Born on 10 Dec. 1913 in Ravenna Cottage, Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi. Died on 16 July 1994 in Oakland, Natchez, 80 years old.

Married Kate Doniphan Brandon, dau. of Gerard Hamilton Brandon and Kate Doniphan Prichard, on 20 July 1946 in Episcopal Church, Natchez when 32 years old. Kate Doniphan Brandon m. (2) John Taylor Green.

Issue of Maj. George Lawrence Adams and Kate Doniphan Brandon:
      i. dau. ¹²(May be living) Adams
      ii. dau. (May be living) Adams
      iii. son (May be living) Adams
      iv. son (May be living) Adams

Notes on Maj. George Lawrence Adams:

Major George Lawrence Adams I (10 December 1913 Ravenna Cottage–16 July 1994 Oakland, Natchez) married Kate Doniphan Brandon (3 December 1924 Natchez–)¹ on 20 July 1946 at Trinity Episcopal Church in Natchez. Kate is the daughter of Gerard Hamilton Brandon and Kate Doniphan Prichard. Lawrence graduated with a law degree from the University of Mississippi, served with the infantry in World War II, and ended his military career as a Major with the General Staff Corps. He returned to Natchez to practice law with his brother-in-law Brent, specializing in oil and gas matters. Lawrence also served as a Mississippi State Senator in 1948–60. Kate attended Stephens College and the University of Mississippi. In 1960 Lawrence and Kate purchased their antebellum home Oakland (built c. 1838) which is open every year on the Natchez Spring Pilgrimage. Lawrence inherited Ravennaside when his first cousin once removed Mary Roane Fleming died in 1970 and he sold it in 1972. Lawrence also inherited Roane’s plantation Beverly. Kate is the current genealogist of the family. Lawrence died in 1994 and Kate married second John Taylor Green. Kate and Lawrence had four children.

_______________
¹ Kate Don is the second-great granddaughter of Gerard Chittocque Brandon, first native-born governor of Mississippi.

120. ¹¹Roane Fleming Adams, dau. of William Allen Adams and ¹⁰Zuleika Metcalfe Lawrence [96]. Born on 23 July 1917 in Ravenna Cottage, Natchez, Adams County, Mississippi. Died on 22 May 1982 in Natchez, 64 years old.

Married Richard Brent Forman, son of Richard Brent Forman and Bernice Martin, on 15 Oct. 1942 in Presbyterian Church, Natchez when 25 years old (Richard Brent was 25 years old). Richard Brent Forman b. on 7 Oct. 1917 in Natchez; d. on 2 Feb. 1994 in Natchez, 76 years old.

Issue of Roane Fleming Adams and Richard Brent Forman:
      i. dau. ¹²(May be living) Forman
      ii. dau. (May be living) Forman
      iii. dau. (May be living) Forman

Notes on Roane Fleming Adams:

Roane attended Mississippi State College for Women and graduated from the University of Mississippi. Brent graduated from the University of Mississippi with a degree in law. He served as a Captain in the Army Air Corps during World War II. He practiced law in Natchez starting in 1946 and was President of the Natchez Municipal School District for twenty years. Brent was the genealogist of the family.

Twelfth Generation

Issue of ¹¹Cdr. John Enoch Pond [101] (¹⁰Emma McHenry [59], ⁹Ellen Josephine Metcalfe [23], ⁸Dr. Asa Baldwin Metcalfe [6], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and Wynn Adele Martin

121. ¹²Col. William Martin Pond, son of ¹¹Cdr. John Enoch Pond [101] and Wynn Adele Martin. Born on 28 Aug. 1916 in Bremerton, Kitsap County, Washington. Baptized on 15 April 1917 when seven months old. Died on 17 Nov. 1997 in Carmichael, Sacramento County, California, 81 years old.

Married Agnes Marie Finnegan on 24 Sep. 1954 in Anchorage, Alaska when 38 years old (Agnes Marie was 22 years old). Agnes Marie Finnegan b. on 12 July 1932 in Breckenridge, Wilkin County, Minnesota; d. on 7 Sep. 1997 in Salem, Marion County, Oregon, 65 years old; bur. on 30 Sep. 1997 in Cypress Lawn Cemetery, Colma, San Mateo County, California.

Issue of Col. William Martin Pond and Agnes Marie Finnegan:
i. son ¹³(May be living) Pond

Notes on Col. William Martin Pond:

The information is from John Pond.

John notes that William was also a real estate broker and gemologist. He was a graduate of UCLA and an Episcopalian.

Notes on Agnes Marie Finnegan:

The information is from John Pond.

She was called Angeline.

122. ¹²Capt. Robert McHenry Pond, son of ¹¹Cdr. John Enoch Pond [101] and Wynn Adele Martin. Born on 14 Jan. 1921 in Treasure Island, San Francisco County, California. Baptized on 17 April 1924 when three years old. Died on 17 April 1989 in Walnut Creek, Contra Costa County, California, 68 years old. Buried on 14 June 1989 at sea.

Married Kathleen Alice Kellar on 10 Feb. 1941 in San Francisco, San Francisco County, California when 20 years old (Kathleen Alice was 18 years old). Kathleen Alice Kellar b. on 1 June 1922 in Oakland, Alameda County, California.

Issue of Capt. Robert McHenry Pond and Kathleen Alice Kellar:
i. son ¹³(May be living) Pond

Notes on Capt. Robert McHenry Pond:

The information is from John Pond.

Robert had a bachelor’s degree in history, and was an Episcopalian.

Robert was buried at sea. A letter to his wife describes the burial:

Dear Mrs. Pond,
The cremated remains of your husband, the late Robert M. Pond, Captain, U.S. Navy, Retired, were buried at sea in accordance with your request. They were brought to the ship at the direction of Commander Combat Logistics Group ONE while the ship was in port at Naval Supply Center, Oakland, California. We departed Oakland to represent the Navy in the 1989 Portland Rose Festival and to provide refueling support to ships of the Pacific Fleet engaged in training exercises. Your husband had spent many years of loyal and dedicated service to our country. It was fitting that he be buried from the deck of a proud ship so employed.
The Burial at Sea ceremonies were conducted on the ship’s replenishment station seven on 14 June 1989 at 1300. The ship slowed for the ceremony and the national flag flown at half-mast. The afternoon was cool with a cloudy sky, slight wind and seas. With these favorable conditions, both the Religious and Military ceremonies were conducted with dignity and solemnity. The Executive Officer, Commander James B. Annis, U.S. Navy, was the Military Commander of the ceremony. Chaplain, Lieutenant James S. Twamley, U.S. Naval Reserve, performed the religious portions of the ceremony and the committal. An eight man rifle squad, two flag bearers, six urn bearers and a nine man Honor Platoon were formed from the crew of USS KANSAS CITY (AOR 3).
Pictures of the ceremony were taken and are presented to you along with a navigational chart showing the location the remains were committed, and two expended shell casings from the rifle volleys fired. It was our privilege to serve you, and if you have any further questions, please feel free to write to me. I wish to extend to you warm regards and sympathy.
Sincerely,
L.M. PIVONKA
Captain, U.S. Navy
Commanding Officer
USS KANSAS CITY (AOR 3)

Notes on Kathleen Alice Kellar:

The information is from John Pond.

She attended the University of California at Berkeley. She was an Episcopalian.

Issue of Capt. John Archer Stewart and ¹¹Frances Reynolds McHenry [102] (¹⁰John McHenry [60], ⁹Ellen Josephine Metcalfe [23], ⁸Dr. Asa Baldwin Metcalfe [6], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1])

123. ¹²John Reynolds Stewart, son of Capt. John Archer Stewart and ¹¹Frances Reynolds McHenry [102]. Born on 25 Feb. 1929 in Colón, Colón Province, Panamá. Died on 12 July 1996 in Alameda County, California, 67 years old.

Married Helen Meredith Walker. Helen Meredith Walker b. on 14 Jan. 1933 in San Francisco, San Francisco County, California; d. on 19 Nov. 1988 in San Jose, Santa Clara County, California, 55 years old.

Issue of John Reynolds Stewart and Helen Meredith Walker:
i. son ¹³(May be living) Stewart

Notes on John Reynolds Stewart:

The information is from Paula Stewart.

Notes on Helen Meredith Walker:

The information is from Paula Stewart.

Issue of ¹¹James Joseph Metcalfe [116] (¹⁰Bernice Roche Metcalfe [94], ⁹William Lyons Metcalfe [48], ⁸Oren Metcalfe [11], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and Lillian Hammer

124. ¹²James Juan Metcalfe, son of ¹¹James Joseph Metcalfe [116] and Lillian Hammer. Born on 14 Nov. 1933 in Chicago, Cook County, Illinois. Died on 10 Jan. 2007 in Lancaster, Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, 73 years old.

Married Beverly Ann Lineberry. Divorced. Beverly Ann Lineberry b. on 27 Oct. 1938 in Lancaster.

Issue of James Juan Metcalfe and Beverly Ann Lineberry:
i. son ¹³(May be living) Metcalfe
ii. dau. (May be living) Metcalfe

Notes on James Juan Metcalfe:

Jim graduated from Southern Methodist University with a Masters Degree in Accounting. He is now divorced and retired in Lancaster, Pennsylvania.

125. ¹²Kristina Maria Metcalfe, dau. of ¹¹James Joseph Metcalfe [116] and Lillian Hammer. Born on 18 Aug. 1943 in Dallas, Dallas County, Texas. Died in 2006, 62 or 63 years old.

Married Michael Lewis. Divorced.

Issue of Kristina Maria Metcalfe and Michael Lewis:
i. son ¹³(May be living) Lewis
ii. son (May be living) Lewis

Issue of ¹¹Col. William Allen Adams [118] (¹⁰Zuleika Metcalfe Lawrence [96], ⁹Zuleika Rosalie Metcalfe [49], ⁸Oren Metcalfe [11], ⁷Thomas Metcalf [1]) and Isabel Peyton

126. ¹²William Allen Adams, son of ¹¹Col. William Allen Adams [118] and Isabel Peyton. Born on 16 July 1941 in Shreveport, Caddo Parish, Louisiana. Deceased.

Married Linda Ainsworth on 15 Aug. 1964 in Houston, Harris County, Texas when 23 years old (Linda was 19 years old). Linda Ainsworth b. on 21 Dec. 1944 in Camden, Ouachita Parish, Louisiana.

Issue of William Allen Adams and Linda Ainsworth:
i. son ¹³(May be living) Adams
ii. son (May be living) Adams

Notes on William Allen Adams:

William Allen Adams (16 July 1941 Shreveport–)¹ married Linda Ainsworth (21 December 1944 Camden, Arkansas–) on 15 August 1964 in Houston, Texas. Bill graduated from Georgia Tech with a degree in engineering and was hired by DuPont where he worked in Wilmington, Delaware. He and Linda then moved to Helotes, Bexar County, Texas. Two sons.

_______________
¹ Bill’s father was known as William Jr. and Bill is known as William III (even though he is William IV).

2	i.	dau. ⁸Sybil Metcalf b. on 19 July 1789 in Enfield.
3	ii.	son Maj. Horace Metcalf b. on 23 March 1791 in Enfield.
	iii.	son Samuel Metcalf b. on 16 Jan. 1793 in Enfield.
	iv.	dau. Elizabeth Metcalf b. on 27 Jan. 1795 in Enfield; d. on 9 Feb. 1795 in Enfield, 13 days old.
4	v.	dau. Elizabeth Metcalf b. on 1 Jan. 1796 in Enfield.
5	vi.	son Thomas Metcalf b. on 10 Jan. 1798 in Enfield.
6	vii.	son Dr. Asa Baldwin Metcalfe b. on 9 March 1800 near Oakland, on Connecticut-Vermont road, Franklin County, Vermont.
7	viii.	son Ebenezer Metcalf b. on 27 Dec. 1801 in Enfield.
8	ix.	dau. Sidney Metcalf b. on 16 March 1804 in Enfield.
9	x.	dau. Harriet Metcalf b. on 23 Feb. 1806 in Enfield.
10	xi.	son George A. Metcalf b. on 26 Feb. 1808 in Enfield.
11	xii.	son Oren Metcalfe b. on 28 Jan. 1810 in Enfield.

12	i.	son ⁹Samuel Horton Smith b. on 20 Aug. 1811 in Enfield.
13	ii.	dau. Maria Smith b. on 19 June 1815 in Enfield.
14	iii.	dau. Eliza Smith b. on 26 Aug. 1818 in Ohio.
15	iv.	son George Kendall Smith b. about 1821, probably in Ohio.
	v.	dau. Harriet Smith b. on 20 April 1823, probably in Ohio; d. on 22 Oct. 1869 in Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio, 46 years old.
16	vi.	son Comfort Smith b. on 24 March 1825 in Ohio.

	i.	son ⁹Horace Metcalf b. on 4 March 1824 in Enfield; bap. on 25 Nov. 1832 in Enfield when eight years old.
	ii.	son James Metcalf b. in 1826/7 in Enfield; bap. on 25 Nov. 1832 in Enfield when five years old.
	iii.	dau. Sybil Cordelia Metcalf b. in 1829/30 in Enfield; bap. on 25 Nov. 1832 in Enfield when two years old.

17	i.	dau. ⁹Elizabeth Chandler b. on 13 May 1817 in Connecticut.
	ii.	son Horace Metcalf Chandler b. on 8 May 1820 in Connecticut.
	iii.	son Josephus Chandler b. on 13 May 1827 in Massachusetts.
18	iv.	son Henry Chandler b. on 12 Feb. 1830 in Massachusetts.
	v.	dau. Harriet Chandler b. on 7 March 1832 in Massachusetts; d. on 8 March 1858, 26 years old; m. S. W. Lemmon on 12 Jan. 1853 in Seneca County, Ohio when 20 years old.
19	vi.	son Francis M. Chandler b. on 31 March 1835 in Massachusetts.
	vii.	dau. Martha Clarissa Chandler b. on 8 May 1837 in New York; d. in April 1867, 29 years old; m. David Schuyler (1837/8 in New York–).

20	i.	son ⁹Horace Metcalf b. on 10 Aug. 1828 in Chardon.
	ii.	son Armstrong Metcalf b. on 12 Dec. 1830 in Chardon.
	iii.	son Alfred B. Metcalf b. on 25 Nov. 1832 in Chardon.
	iv.	dau. Harriet Metcalf b. in 1834/5 in Chardon; d. young.
	v.	dau. Lovira A. Metcalf b. on 8 Feb. 1837 in Chardon.
	vi.	son Henry H. Metcalf b. on 30 June 1840 in Chardon; m. Lydia _____ (1846/7 in Maryland–) possibly in Council Bluffs, Pottawattamie County, Iowa.
	vii.	son George Metcalf b. on 30 Sep. 1841 in Chardon.
21	viii.	son Thomas Metcalf b. on 22 June 1843 in Chardon.
	ix.	dau. Ellen S. Metcalf b. on 14 May 1846 in Chardon.
22	x.	son Frank Metcalf b. on 28 March 1848 in Chardon.
	xi.	dau. Sarah S. Metcalf b. on 15 Aug. 1850 in Chardon.
	xii.	dau. Kate Metcalf b. in 1853/4 in New York.

23	i.	dau. ⁹Ellen Josephine Metcalfe b. on 22 Nov. 1827 in Hiram, Portage County, Ohio.
24	ii.	son George Edward Metcalfe b. on 18 Feb. 1829 in Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio.
	iii.	son Henry Bascom Metcalfe b. on 6 July 1831 in Kingston, Adams County, Mississippi; d. in 1853 in Adams County, Mississippi, 21 or 22 years old.
	iv.	dau. Henrietta Metcalfe b. in Adams County.
	v.	son William Harris Metcalfe b. in Adams County.
	vi.	son John Metcalfe b. in Adams County.
	vii.	dau. Laura Metcalfe b. in Adams County.
25	viii.	dau. Emma Zuleika Metcalfe b. on 2 Dec. 1840 in Adams County.
	ix.	son Horace Metcalfe b. in Adams County.

	i.	dau. ⁹Eliza Dixon Metcalf b. on 28 Feb. 1828 in Enfield; bap. on 27 July 1828 in Enfield when four months old; d. on 18 May 1835 in Enfield, seven years old.
	ii.	son John Metcalf b. on 9 March 1830 in Enfield; bap. on 6 Sep. 1830 in Enfield when five months old; d. on 13 Oct. 1830 in Enfield, seven months old.
	iii.	son Henry Ebenezer Metcalf b. on 14 July 1831 in Enfield; bap. on 3 June 1832 in Enfield when ten months old; d. on 7 May 1835 in Enfield, three years old.

26	iv.	dau. ⁹Eliza Dixon Metcalf b. on 19 Feb. 1838 in Ohio.
	v.	son Charles Henry Metcalf b. on 18 March 1840 in Ohio; d. on 28 Feb. 1872, 31 years old.
27	vi.	dau. Isabella Linwood Metcalf b. on 15 Sep. 1842 in Ohio.
28	vii.	dau. Catharine Lovica Metcalf b. on 31 July 1845 in Ohio.
	viii.	dau. Theodore F. Metcalf b. on 17 May 1850 in Venice Township, Seneca County, Ohio; d. on 9 May 1851 in Venice Township, eleven months old.
29	ix.	son Willis Seymour Metcalf b. on 26 Oct. 1853 in Ohio.
	x.	dau. Louisa E. Metcalf b. on 13 Dec. 1858 in Chardon; d. on 13 March 1862, three years old.

30	i.	son ⁹Richard Evert Denton b. on 10 Sep. 1826 in Huntsburg.
	ii.	dau. Sybil Evert Denton b. in 1828/9 in Ohio.

31	iii.	son ⁹Julius Orrin Converse b. on 1 May 1834 in Chardon.
	iv.	dau. Mary E. Converse b. in 1847/8 in Chardon.

32	i.	dau. ⁹Marie Antoinette Ludlow b. on 9 Feb. 1828 in Chardon.
33	ii.	son Linnaeus Charles Ludlow b. on 2 Aug. 1831 in Newbury, Geauga County, Ohio.
34	iii.	son Benjamin Franklin Ludlow b. on 12 April 1833 in Newbury.
35	iv.	son Washington Irving Ludlow b. on 18 March 1835 in Newbury.
36	v.	son Lycurgus C. Ludlow b. on 17 May 1837 in Newbury.
	vi.	dau. Louisa Maria Ludlow b. on 8 Oct. 1842 in Auburn; d. on 29 June 1905, 62 years old.
37	vii.	dau. Harriet Ella Ludlow b. on 20 Oct. 1847 in Auburn.
38	viii.	son Oliver Ellis Ludlow b. on 23 Dec. 1849 in Auburn.

39	i.	dau. ⁹Mary Eliza Metcalf b. on 11 Jan. 1832 in Geauga County.
40	ii.	dau. Lucretia S. Metcalf b. on 10 Oct. 1833 in Seneca County.
41	iii.	son Gilbert A. Metcalf b. on 23 April 1835 in Seneca County.
42	iv.	son Orin E. Metcalf b. on 6 Jan. 1837 in Seneca County.
	v.	son Jude Metcalf b. on 19 May 1838 in Seneca County; d. on 13 Dec. 1838 in Seneca County, six months old.
43	vi.	dau. Martha E. Metcalf b. on 13 May 1840 in Seneca County.
44	vii.	dau. Harriet Augusta Metcalf b. on 17 Feb. 1842 in Seneca County.
45	viii.	son George M. Metcalf b. on 24 Jan. 1844 in Seneca County.
	ix.	dau. Maria Antoinette Metcalf b. on 19 Oct. 1846 in Seneca County; d. in 1875, 28 or 29 years old; m. James Smapsel on 25 Oct. 1866 in Richland County when 20 years old.
46	x.	dau. Clara Pauline Metcalf b. in Jan. 1849 in Seneca County.

	i.	son ⁹Joseph Albert Metcalfe b. on 12 Nov. 1839 in Natchez; d. on 9 June 1840 in Natchez, six months old; bur. in City Cemetery.
	ii.	son Cpl. John Thomas Winn Metcalfe CSA b. on 20 May 1841 in Natchez; bap. on 12 Dec. 1841 in Natchez when six months old; d. on 10 July 1863 near Funkstown, Washington County, Maryland, 22 years old.
	iii.	son Pvt. Julius Oren Metcalfe CSA b. on 12 April 1843 in Natchez; bap. on 12 May 1844 in Natchez when a year old; d. on 29 Nov. 1880 in Natchez, 37 years old; bur. in City Cemetery.
47	iv.	son Lt. James Bard Metcalfe CSA b. on 15 Jan. 1846 in Natchez.
	v.	son Charles Metcalfe b. on 28 Sep. 1848 in Natchez; d. on 6 Aug. 1849 in Natchez, ten months old.
48	vi.	son William Lyons Metcalfe b. on 30 Sep. 1849 in Natchez.
	vii.	son John Inge Metcalfe b. on 12 Nov. 1853 in Natchez; bap. on 4 June 1854 in Natchez when six months old; d. on 7 Aug. 1863 in Natchez, nine years old; bur. in City Cemetery.
49	viii.	dau. Zuleika Rosalie Metcalfe b. on 15 March 1855 in Natchez.
	ix.	dau. Medora Metcalfe b. on 8 Jan. 1858 in Natchez; bap. on 25 July 1858 in Natchez when six months old; d. on 5 Sep. 1867 in Natchez, nine years old; bur. in City Cemetery.
50	x.	dau. Anna Metcalfe b. on 8 July 1861 in Natchez.
	xi.	dau. Belle Metcalfe b. on 1 Oct. 1864 in Natchez; d. on 22 June 1865 in Natchez, eight months old; bur. in City Cemetery.
51	xii.	son Richard Inge Metcalfe b. on 29 May 1866 in Natchez.

	i.	dau. ¹⁰Harriet Smith b. in 1833/4 in Ohio.
	ii.	dau. Laura Smith b. in 1835/6 in Ohio.
52	iii.	dau. Sybil Smith b. in 1838/9 in Ohio.
	iv.	son Samuel H. Smith b. in 1841 in Ohio.
	v.	dau. Eliza Smith b. in 1843 in Ohio.
	vi.	son G. Roland Smith b. in 1846 in Ohio.

53	i.	son ¹⁰Lawrence S. Faulk b. in 1833 in Ohio.
	ii.	son Horton H. Faulk b. in 1835 in Ohio.
	iii.	dau. Sybil Faulk b. in 1844 in Ohio.

	i.	dau. ¹⁰Sybil Randall b. in Feb. 1848; d. on 7 April 1848, about two months old.
	ii.	dau. Lucinda Randall b. in Sep. 1849 in Ohio; d. on 12 March 1856, six years old.
54	iii.	dau. Juliet Randall b. on 12 June 1852 in Ohio.
	iv.	dau. Florence Randall b. in April 1855; d. on 1 Oct. 1856, a year old.

	i.	son ¹⁰George B. Smith b. in 1850/1 in Ohio.
	ii.	son Frank E. Smith b. in 1852/3 in Ohio.

	i.	dau. ¹⁰Sybil Baker b. in 1844/5 in Ohio.
	ii.	son Frank Baker b. in 1846/7 in Ohio.
	iii.	dau. Ella Baker b. in 1849 in Ohio.
	iv.	dau. Nettie Baker b. in 1852/3 in Ohio.
	v.	son William C. Baker b. in 1854/5 in Ohio; m. Fannie C. _____ (1861/2 in West Virginia–).

	i.	dau. ¹⁰Nellie Martha Chandler b. in 1867/8 in New York.
	ii.	dau. Margaret Chandler b. in 1870 in New York.
	iii.	dau. Sarah B. Chandler b. in 1873/4 in New York.

	i.	son ¹⁰Thomas Metcalf b. in Nov. 1871 in Council Bluffs, Pottawattamie County, Iowa; m. Elsie M. _____ (May 1876 in Iowa–) in 1898/9 when about 27 years old (Elsie M. was about 22 years old).
56	ii.	son Dr. Frank A. Metcalf b. in 1873 in Council Bluffs.
57	iii.	dau. Delia Paulina Metcalf b. in June 1884 in Council Bluffs.

	i.	son ¹⁰Frank H. Metcalf b. on 6 Aug. 1879 in Pennsylvania.
58	ii.	son Truman Henry Metcalf b. on 17 July 1881 in Pennsylvania.

	i.	dau. ¹⁰Elizabeth Harris McHenry b. on 4 Jan. 1850 in Algiers, Orleans Parish, Louisiana; d. on 9 July 1907 in Berkeley, 57 years old; bur. on 7 Aug. 1907 in Mountain View Cemetery; m. Prof. Emanuel Benjamin Lamare (April 1848 in France–6 Sep. 1916 in Berkeley), son of _____ Lamare and Caroline Goddefroy, in 1886 when 35 or 36 years old (Prof. Emanuel Benjamin was 37 or 38 years old).
	ii.	son John McHenry b. in 1852; d. in 1852, an infant; bur. in Mountain View Cemetery.
	iii.	dau. Mary McHenry b. on 20 Nov. 1855 in Temescal Rancho, Alameda County, California; d. on 13 Oct. 1947 in Berkeley, 91 years old; bur. in Mountain View Cemetery; m. William Keith (21 Nov. 1839 in Oldmeldrum, Aberdeenshire, Scotland–13 April 1911 in Berkeley) on 2 June 1883 when 27 years old (William was 43 years old).
59	iv.	dau. Emma McHenry b. on 3 Feb. 1857 in Temescal Rancho.
60	v.	son John McHenry b. on 28 Nov. 1858 in San Francisco.

	i.	son ¹⁰Wade Metcalfe b. in 1854/5 in Wilkinson County; d. young.
	ii.	son Lamar Metcalfe b. in 1856/7 in Wilkinson County; d. young.
61	iii.	son Jefferson Davis Metcalfe b. on 12 Jan. 1858 in Wilkinson County.
62	iv.	son Asa Baldwin Metcalfe b. on 13 March 1860 in Wilkinson County.
	v.	dau. Mary Emma Metcalfe b. in 1861/2 in Wilkinson County.
	vi.	dau. Mary Elizabeth Metcalfe b. on 31 May 1864 in Wilkinson County; d. on 24 Feb. 1941, 76 years old.
	vii.	son John Franklin Metcalfe b. in 1867/8 in Wilkinson County.
	viii.	dau. Eliza Metcalfe b. in 1870/1 in Wilkinson County.
63	ix.	son George W. Metcalfe b. on 12 July 1873 in Wilkinson County.
64	x.	son Orin L. Metcalfe b. in Jan. 1877 in Wilkinson County.

	i.	son ¹⁰William Gilbert Hay b. in May 1867 in Santa Cruz, Santa Cruz County, California; d. before 1910 in San Francisco, at most 42 years old.
	ii.	dau. Emily Parkins Babcock Hay b. in 1868/9 in Santa Cruz; d. on 14 July 1937 in Burlingame, 68 years old; bur. in Mountain View Cemetery.

65	i.	son ¹⁰Norman Charles Pomeroy b. on 4 June 1866 in Toledo.
66	ii.	son William Metcalf Pomeroy b. on 13 Sep. 1868 in Toledo.
	iii.	son Fred Pomeroy b. in Jan. 1870 in Toledo; d. on 13 April 1871 in Toledo, a year old.

68	i.	son ¹⁰Franklin Evert Denton b. on 22 Nov. 1859 in Huntsburg.
69	ii.	son Richard Linwood Denton b. on 17 July 1864 in Huntsburg.
	iii.	son Harold Pomeroy Denton b. on 19 Sep. 1866 in Huntsburg; m. Eliza Russell Peachy (1872–).
70	iv.	son George Metcalf Denton b. on 1 March 1871 in Huntsburg.

	i.	dau. ¹⁰Zuleika Hodges b. in 1861 in Ohio.
	ii.	dau. Stella Hodges b. in 1862/3 in Ohio.
71	iii.	son William Hodges b. in June 1866 in Ohio.
	iv.	dau. Helen Hodges b. in 1868/9 in Ohio.

72	i.	son ¹⁰William Wallace Ludlow b. in April 1858 in Ohio.
73	ii.	son Rev. Arthur Ludlow b. in June 1861 in Ohio.
	iii.	dau. Mary L. Ludlow b. in 1867/8 in Ohio.
74	iv.	son Linnaeus Charles Ludlow b. in May 1873 in Ohio.
	v.	son Dr. Alfred Irving Ludlow b. in Nov. 1875 in Ohio.
	vi.	dau. Helen L. Ludlow b. in 1877/8 in Ohio.
75	vii.	son Harold Stafford Ludlow b. on 22 April 1886 in Ohio.

	i.	dau. ¹⁰Louise Evaline Ludlow b. in 1866 in Ohio.
	ii.	son Clement O. Ludlow b. in 1870/1 in Ohio.
	iii.	son Oliver L. Ludlow b. in Dec. 1872 in Ohio.

76	i.	dau. ¹⁰Lou Ella Reed b. on 30 March 1869 in South Newbury, Geauga County, Ohio.
	ii.	dau. Minnie Tryphena Reed b. on 8 May 1873 in Burton; d. on 2 July 1914, 41 years old.
77	iii.	son Henry Hayes Reed b. on 12 June 1876 in Burton.
78	iv.	son Ernest Waring Reed b. on 8 Nov. 1881 in Burton.
	v.	dau. Florence Adele Reed b. on 3 May 1884 in Burton.